Best of 10 bagels in Ithaca
Discover our curated list of top-ranked bagels in Ithaca, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Collegetown Bagels, Ithaca Bakery, Shortstop Deli, Gimme! Coffee, Dunkin'. Let's explore together!
Toc
1. Collegetown Bagels
Local favorite for over 30 years
Indulge in the delightful world of Collegetown Bagels, where each bite is a taste of perfection. The extensive bagel menu invites you to explore a myriad of flavors, while the customizable smoothies offer a refreshing twist tailored to your preferences. Although the shakes may fall slightly short on boldness, the classic bagels never fail to impress with their time-honored appeal.
Beyond its name lies a culinary haven waiting to be discovered. A treasure trove of fresh and flavorful offerings awaits at Collegetown Bagels, where friendly service and efficiency ensure a seamless dining experience. Whether you're a local regular or a first-time visitor, each visit promises a culinary journey filled with tantalizing surprises.
Beyond its name lies a culinary haven waiting to be discovered. A treasure trove of fresh and flavorful offerings awaits at Collegetown Bagels, where friendly service and efficiency ensure a seamless dining experience. Whether you're a local regular or a first-time visitor, each visit promises a culinary journey filled with tantalizing surprises.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
2. Ithaca Bakery
Strong community involvement and support
Indulge in a delectable experience at Ithaca Bakery, where you can savor a variety of sandwiches, drinks, and sweets that cater to every craving. Their signature New Yorker sandwich is a must-try, and don't miss out on their delightful chocolate milk. With a friendly and efficient service, the bakery ensures a delightful culinary journey that you simply cannot miss when in Ithaca.
Experience the charm of Ithaca Bakery, a true gem that combines the essence of a bakery, coffee shop, and bar all under one roof. From fresh and mouthwatering daily specials to a unique happy hour from 4 to 6, this place offers a culinary adventure like no other. With its irresistible offerings and inviting ambiance, Ithaca Bakery is a beloved destination that promises a delightful escape for food enthusiasts.
Experience the charm of Ithaca Bakery, a true gem that combines the essence of a bakery, coffee shop, and bar all under one roof. From fresh and mouthwatering daily specials to a unique happy hour from 4 to 6, this place offers a culinary adventure like no other. With its irresistible offerings and inviting ambiance, Ithaca Bakery is a beloved destination that promises a delightful escape for food enthusiasts.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Happy Hours
- Breakfast
3. Shortstop Deli
Known for their unique and delicious sandwich combinations
Step into the bustling enclave of Shortstop Deli, a culinary gem that beckons both locals and visitors alike. Brace yourself for a taste sensation as you sink your teeth into their exquisite bagels, a culinary masterpiece that leaves a lasting impression. The luscious sandwiches are a feast for the eyes and a delight for the taste buds, drawing rave reviews from patrons far and wide. While there may not be seating indoors, the speedy and amiable service ensures a seamless experience whether you choose to dine in or grab your meal to go.
Indulge in a cornucopia of flavors at Shortstop Deli, a haven for those seeking a quick and satisfying meal. Upon our weary arrival from Toronto, we were greeted with a hearty spread that included a delectable double BBQ pulled pork sandwich, accompanied by a steaming bowl of soup and a refreshing soda. The pièce de résistance was the gracious host behind the counter, who graciously shared the secret to the tantalizing BBQ pork recipe. Immerse yourself in the vibrant tapestry of tastes at Shortstop Deli, where every bite tells a story of culinary craftsmanship and hospitality.
Indulge in a cornucopia of flavors at Shortstop Deli, a haven for those seeking a quick and satisfying meal. Upon our weary arrival from Toronto, we were greeted with a hearty spread that included a delectable double BBQ pulled pork sandwich, accompanied by a steaming bowl of soup and a refreshing soda. The pièce de résistance was the gracious host behind the counter, who graciously shared the secret to the tantalizing BBQ pork recipe. Immerse yourself in the vibrant tapestry of tastes at Shortstop Deli, where every bite tells a story of culinary craftsmanship and hospitality.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Lunch
- Dinner
4. Gimme! Coffee
Sustainable and socially responsible business practices
Nestled just a brief stroll away from Hilton Garden Inn is Gimme! Coffee, where a skilled barista expertly crafted a flawless Americano. The array of tempting cakes was a delightful surprise, beckoning with their delectable allure. With both indoor and outdoor seating options, Dame! Coffee comes highly recommended for its impeccable service and inviting ambiance.
Impeccably attentive staff members, chic decor, and charming outdoor seating make Gimme! Coffee a standout spot. Their frozen Americano is unparalleled and has set a new standard for coffee aficionados like me. The brew itself is a delightfully smooth concoction that warrants praise - don’t just take my word for it, experience it firsthand with a steaming cup of your own.
Impeccably attentive staff members, chic decor, and charming outdoor seating make Gimme! Coffee a standout spot. Their frozen Americano is unparalleled and has set a new standard for coffee aficionados like me. The brew itself is a delightfully smooth concoction that warrants praise - don’t just take my word for it, experience it firsthand with a steaming cup of your own.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- Breakfast
- Vegetarian Options
5. Dunkin'
Quick service and convenient for on-the-go customers
Nestled in Ithaca, the Dunkin' Coffee Shop exudes a warm ambiance, attracting visitors seeking top-notch coffee, delectable bagels, and fresh pastries. This location shines for its stellar customer service, notably courtesy of the affable Donyell M., a true asset to the establishment. With a delightful mix of superb offerings and friendly staff, this spot is indeed a gem in the heart of Ithaca.
Stepping into this vibrant eatery, I was met with a scene of diligent staff honing their craft. Despite the training session, the service I received was nothing short of impeccable. A young man at the window stood out for his exceptional politeness and attentiveness, making my dining experience truly memorable.
Stepping into this vibrant eatery, I was met with a scene of diligent staff honing their craft. Despite the training session, the service I received was nothing short of impeccable. A young man at the window stood out for his exceptional politeness and attentiveness, making my dining experience truly memorable.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Breakfast
- Dinner
6. Collegetown Bagels
Iconic local business since 1977
Collegetown Bagels offers an enticing selection of bagel sandwiches, such as the Bronx Bagel with zaatar bagel, chicken sausage, pepper jack, and avocado. The Mediterranean flair of the Za'atar adds a delightful touch, reminiscent of the manakeesh I enjoyed in Buffalo. Don't miss out on this unique flavor experience! The speedy service ensures you get to savor the delicious bagels promptly, though do take note that food and drinks need to be ordered separately at different counters. Be sure to prioritize your food order to kickstart your enjoyable dining experience at this establishment.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
7. Panera Bread
Popular for breakfast, lunch, and dinner
Panera Bread, a renowned chain, offers an indulgent treat amidst rising costs. Despite a bustling Sunday crowd and occasional out-of-stock items, its ambiance and staff win me over. Indecisiveness strikes when faced with a dilemma between healthful options like apples and soul-satisfying choices such as their creamy macaroni and cheese with warm bread, but the friendly and patient team always makes my visit an enjoyable one.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
8. Ooy's Cafe & Deli
TOPICS
- Gluten-Free
- Vegetarian Options
- Asian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
9. Dunkin'
Well-known brand, drive-thru available
TOPICS
- Cheap Eats
- Breakfast
- Downtown Spots
10. Bus Stop Bagels
