8 Best Italian restaurants in Bayside New York City
Italian restaurants in Bayside, NYC, are a food lover's delight, offering a wide range of delicious and authentic Italian cuisine. From mouth-watering pasta dishes to flavorful pizzas and delectable desserts, these restaurants showcase the rich and diverse culinary traditions of Italy. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Italian restaurants in Bayside, NYC, are sure to impress.
1. Trattoria 35
Experience the flavors of Italy in a welcoming setting

The veal marsala and tiramisu at this establishment are truly exceptional. The veal is tender and cooked to perfection, while the tangy marsala wine sauce provides a delightful contrast in flavor. The tiramisu is a masterful combination of coffee-soaked ladyfingers, rich mascarpone cheese, and cocoa powder that simply melts in your mouth.
The ambiance of this restaurant is warm and inviting, creating a perfect setting for a romantic dinner. The soft music playing in the background adds to the cozy atmosphere. The chicken capriccioso is another impressive dish, with juicy chicken breast, flavorful mushrooms, and a delectable sauce that leaves you craving more.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
2. Jimmy's Trattoria
Homemade Italian fare with a touch of elegance.

Jimmy's Trattoria is an exceptional Italian restaurant located in the heart of Bayside. The establishment is known for its exceptional service and delicious cuisine, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere for all to enjoy. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pasta dish or something a little more adventurous, Jimmy's Trattoria has something for everyone.
In addition to its dine-in options, Jimmy's Trattoria also boasts a full bar and offers catering services for private events. Whether you're hosting a wedding, corporate event, or family gathering, the restaurant's team of experienced professionals will work with you to create a customized menu that is sure to impress. With a focus on quality and attention to detail, Jimmy's Trattoria is the perfect choice for any celebration.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
3. Papazzio Restaurant & Caterer
Bayside's best-kept secret for Italian cuisine.

This Italian restaurant, conveniently located in the middle of Bell Blvd's bustling nightlife, offers an excellent dining experience. The portions are generous, making it a satisfying meal for most customers. Among the menu options, the pasta dishes are particularly noteworthy and have garnered positive feedback.
The service at this establishment excels in graciousness and attentiveness, adding to the overall positive experience of diners. From the greeting at the entrance to the timely refills of drinks, the staff effectively cater to the needs of their patrons, thus ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The combination of delicious food and exceptional service makes this Italian restaurant a standout choice for those in search of quality cuisine in the area.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Celebrations
4. L'Italiano Trattoria
Experience Italy in the heart of Queens

The culinary experience at this establishment is a delight. The chicken francaise stands out, with the chicken skillfully pounded thin and bursting with flavor. The dish is cooked to perfection, resulting in a meal that is both appetizing and satisfying.
The appetizers are equally impressive. Diners can choose from a range of options, all made with fresh ingredients. The mixed seafood oreganata is a seafood lover's dream, with a generous serving of shrimp, scallops, and clams. The cheese and cold cut platter is a perfect starter for a group, with a variety of meats and cheeses that are sure to please. The fried and grilled calamari are also noteworthy, cooked just right and served with zesty dipping sauces.
5. Villa Rustica
Authentic Italian flavors in the heart of Queens

This restaurant offers a mix of dishes at reasonable prices, providing a dining experience that is worth the cost for some customers, while others may find the portions' sizes do not quite meet their expectations. The establishment is known for its delicious and fresh food, with the pizza being a particular standout. The pizza boasts a crispy crust and generous toppings, making it a favorite among patrons.
The dishes are not only tasty but also made with fresh ingredients, resulting in a truly satisfying meal. While there may be some debate over the pricing, the portions are reportedly adequate, and the food's quality is consistently high. This is a fantastic option for pizza lovers, thanks to the crispy crust and carefully selected toppings that make for an enjoyable dining experience. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a place to enjoy a meal with friends and family, this restaurant is definitely worth considering.
6. FINO French Bistro
Experience exquisite French dining in the heart of Queens.

FINO French Bistro is a superb dining destination that excellently combines French and Italian culinary traditions. The pasta dishes are one of the highlights of their menu, with each item demonstrating the same level of care and attention to detail that one would expect from a traditional French bistro.
The ambiance at FINO is warm and inviting, providing the perfect setting for a romantic dinner or a night out with friends. The knowledgeable and attentive staff are dedicated to ensuring that every guest has a wonderful dining experience. From the delicious food to the cozy atmosphere, FINO French Bistro is a must-visit for anyone seeking a taste of European cuisine in a setting that is both elegant and approachable.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
7. Valdari NYC
Indulge in a mouthwatering 3-course experience

Valdari NYC, located in Queens, offers an exquisite dining experience with its authentic Italian dishes. The menu boasts a variety of options, all made with great care and attention to detail. The use of high-quality imported and locally sourced ingredients ensures that each dish is packed with rich flavors. From the pasta to the sauces, every component of the meal is made fresh in-house, elevating the dining experience.
The ambiance at Valdari adds to the overall enjoyment of the meal. The lighting is soft, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The tables are well-spaced, allowing for intimate conversations without feeling cramped. Whether it's a romantic dinner for two or a gathering with friends and family, Valdari NYC provides the perfect setting for any occasion. The exceptional food and welcoming environment make it a must-visit for Italian cuisine lovers.
8. Vivo
Experience fine dining in a historic mansion with beautiful gardens.

The quality of the drinks at this establishment is highly regarded by guests, with many praising the skills of the bartender. In one notable instance, the manager went above and beyond to source a specific whiskey for a guest, demonstrating a high level of attentiveness and care.
As for the dining experience, this elegant eatery offers seasonal Italian cuisine in a beautiful converted mansion setting. The ambiance is ideal for special occasions, with patio dining and gardens available for those who wish to enjoy their meal in an outdoor setting. Overall, the combination of excellent drinks, skilled service, and delicious food make this a standout dining destination.