Best of 9 Mexican restaurants in Prospect Heights NYC
Mexican restaurants in Prospect Heights, NYC, are a foodie's delight, offering a wide range of authentic Mexican cuisine. From traditional tacos and burritos to mouth-watering mole and tamales, these restaurants showcase the rich and diverse flavors of Mexico. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Mexican restaurants in Prospect Heights, NYC, have something for everyone. Come and indulge in the vibrant culinary scene that this neighborhood has to offer!
1. Burrito Bar & Kitchen in Prospect Heights
The party never ends at Burrito Bar & Kitchen!

The drinks at this establishment have received much acclaim for their robust strength, refreshing qualities, and delightful taste. Among the most popular choices are the margaritas and cocktails, which guests have raved about for their exquisite preparation and presentation. There is a wide range of drink options available, catering to various preferences, all of which have been highly commended for their quality and flavor.
The burritos at this establishment are generously sized and stuffed with a variety of ingredients, such as rice, beans, tomato, and steak, with guacamole served as a side. While many guests have expressed their satisfaction with the burritos' sheer size and the abundance of ingredients, some have noted a slight lack of flavor. Nonetheless, the burritos remain a popular choice among patrons, reflecting the establishment's commitment to providing a wide range of delicious food options.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
2. Maya Taqueria - Vanderbilt Avenue
Authentic Mission-style Mexican food in Brooklyn.

The Mexican cuisine offered at this establishment is highly impressive, with the fish tacos being a particular standout. The fish is expertly seasoned and cooked to perfection, resulting in a tender and flavorful dish. The chipotle sauce that accompanies the tacos is also noteworthy, with a delicious and unique flavor that complements the fish perfectly.
This restaurant is a top choice for those craving Mexican food. The food is consistently delicious and is always delivered in a timely manner. For a better experience, it is recommended to use the restaurant's own app for ordering, rather than using third-party delivery services like GrubHub or Seamless. This ensures that more of the money goes directly to the restaurant, and also provides a wider range of choices. Overall, this establishment is highly recommended for anyone looking for delicious and authentic Mexican food.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
3. Tiny's Cantina
Innovative Mexican cuisine with impeccable ingredients.

This establishment is truly a hidden gem, offering a wide variety of delicious Mexican dishes. The tacos and enchiladas were standouts, packed with flavor and leaving a lasting impression. The 'green sauce' that accompanied the enchiladas added a spicy kick that was both enjoyable and satisfying. The house nachos were also a highlight, with black beans and sauce creating a delightful balance of crispy and soft textures.
Despite its small size and tendency to be loud, the restaurant's cozy atmosphere makes it an inviting place to dine. Seating may be limited, but customers are quickly accommodated by the efficient and friendly staff. The guacamole is exceptional and should not be overlooked. The tacos Al pastor were delicious, but the birria tacos truly stole the show with their incredible flavor. Diners should not hesitate to indulge in the side dishes as well, as they are equally impressive. The churros make for a satisfying dessert, adding a sweet finish to a meal that is sure to leave a lasting impression.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Mexican Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
4. Yummy Taco in Prospect Heights
Delicious Mexican cuisine with fast delivery.

Upon receiving the order, the rapid delivery was commendable, and the food arrived piping hot. The burritos, priced affordably, are generously sized but flavor is occasionally lacking.
For a more satisfying option, the grilled chicken chimichangas are highly recommended. These menu items offer impressive portion sizes and unbeatable flavor profiles, making them a top choice for any meal.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Lunch
- Vegetarian Options
5. Chela
Modern Mexican cuisine with a creative twist.

The service at this establishment is consistently commended for its friendliness, efficiency, and welcoming atmosphere. Patrons feel at ease and well taken care of due to the staff's attentiveness and responsiveness to their needs.
The drink options offered have received high praise from guests, who describe them as refreshing, delicious, and perfectly balanced in terms of alcohol content. The beverages stand out as a highlight of the experience, consistently exceeding customers' expectations.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
6. Claro
Oaxaca on the Gowanus

Claro is an excellent choice for those seeking authentic Oaxacan cuisine. The mole negro and mole rojo are two notable dishes, and the churros are a delightful dessert option. The ambiance of the restaurant is warm and inviting, making it suitable for a special occasion.
Unfortunately, many 'Mexican' restaurants fail to meet expectations, offering only basic dishes like guacamole and tacos. However, Claro stands out as one of the exceptional establishments that celebrate its Mexican heritage with fine cuisine. They offer a four-course prix fixe menu with four choices for each course, ensuring that every dish is exceptional. In addition to the menu, they also have an extensive Mezcal list and thoughtfully crafted cocktails. The service is impressive, and the atmosphere is quiet and contemplative, making Claro a true gem.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mexican Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Downtown Spots
7. Antojitos del Patron
Experience the heart of Mexico in every bite

The offerings at this establishment are varied and authentic, with a focus on tacos that are sure to please any palate. The quality of the food is consistently high, and the prices are reasonable, making it an excellent choice for a casual meal.
The service at this location is fast, efficient, and kind. The staff members are always quick to assist customers and the inside counter has plexiglass serving as a barrier between the front and back of house, ensuring a safe and comfortable dining experience. This level of attention to detail and concern for customer well-being is truly commendable.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Personal Celebrations
8. Xochitl Taqueria
Authentic Mexican cuisine in the heart of Brooklyn.

This Mexican restaurant may be located off the beaten path, in a less fashionable area, but it certainly does not disappoint when it comes to the quality of its food. The shrimp fajitas, in particular, are a standout dish - fresh, flavorful, and generously portioned. The homey atmosphere and peaceful interior of the restaurant, despite the presence of three large televisions (all conveniently silenced), make it an ideal spot for a relaxing meal.
The restaurant's offerings also translate well to takeout, as evidenced by a recent order that included the Franklin Burrito and half BBQ chicken. The portions were once again large and the flavors were just as delicious as they would have been in the restaurant itself. The reviewer is already looking forward to a future visit to the restaurant to enjoy even more of its high-quality Mexican cuisine.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
9. L.A. Burrito
Delicious Mexican food with a variety of veggie options.

Burritos at this establishment are a popular and affordable choice, well-regarded for their use of fresh ingredients and delicious flavor. The wraps are generously filled with a variety of ingredients, all of which are consistently fresh and contribute to the overall taste. The burritos offer excellent value for money, making them a reliable option for a casual meal.
The food at this establishment is not only tasty but also well-seasoned, with a variety of options available at reasonable prices. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty burrito or something lighter, there's something for everyone. The quality of the food is consistently high, making it a dependable option for those who value flavor and affordability. Whether dining in or taking out, the food is sure to impress and satisfy.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots