Best of 8 milkshakes in East Harlem NYC

Discover our curated list of top-ranked milkshakes in East Harlem NYC, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like White Castle, East Harlem Bottling Co., CakeBurgers, Harlem Baking Co., Sugar Hill Creamery. Let's explore together!

Toc

1. White Castle

Over 100 years of history, Unique square-shaped burgers

  • Time:

    Open 24 hours

  • Rating: 3.8/5 (2215 Review by google)
  • Address:

    351 E 103rd St, New York, NY 10029, United States

  • Pros:

    Iconic burger chain, Slim Jims and chicken rings are popular, Affordable prices
  • Cons:

    Limited vegetarian options, Some locations can be crowded, Small portions
  • Popular Menu:

    Sliders, Slim Jims, Chicken Rings
  • Price Range:

    $1-$6
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots
  • Late Night

2. East Harlem Bottling Co.

Specialized craft beer store and bar

  • Rating: 4.6/5 (708 Review by google)
  • Address:

    1711 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10029, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/eastharlembottlingco
  • Pros:

    Wide selection of craft beers, friendly staff, offers delivery and pick-up services
  • Cons:

    Limited food options, some menu items may be pricey, cash-only policy
  • Popular Menu:

    IPAs, stouts, sour beers
  • Price Range:

    $8 - $15 per draft beer
Phone Directions Website
Looking for a burger that will blow your mind? Look no further than East Harlem Bottling Co. Indulge in their mouthwatering burger that will leave you craving for more. Pair it with their incredible fried chicken sandwiches that are bursting with flavor. And let's not forget about their impressive selection of beers on tap, guaranteed to quench your thirst and complement your meal perfectly. However, I must admit that the cheese curds are a bit overpriced and not quite up to the level of excellence found in Wisconsin and Minnesota. But don't let that deter you from experiencing a culinary adventure at East Harlem Bottling Co.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Happy Hours
  • Hidden Gems

3. CakeBurgers

Unique fusion of cake and burgers, offers a one-of-a-kind dining experience

  • Time:

    10 AM to 9 PM

  • Rating: 4.9/5 (155 Review by google)
  • Address:

    400 E 120th St, New York, NY 10035, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of creative cake burgers, located in a vibrant neighborhood, offers vegetarian and vegan options
  • Cons:

    Some customers may find the prices slightly high, limited seating available, may have long wait times during peak hours
  • Popular Menu:

    Red Velvet Cake Burger, Classic Cheeseburger Cake, Vegan Chickpea Burger
  • Price Range:

    $15 - $25
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots
  • Dinner

Relate link

late night restaurants in East Harlem NYC

4. Harlem Baking Co.

Phone Directions Website
Discover the heavenly delights of Harlem Baking Co, a true culinary gem that I have been a loyal customer of for years. Prepare to be captivated by their irresistible array of desserts, each one more tantalizing than the last. Let me start by singing praises of their divine key lime pie - a slice of absolute heaven that transports you to a tropical oasis with its tangy yet creamy perfection. But don't just stop there, for Harlem Baking Co. offers a myriad of other confections that will have your taste buds rejoicing. From the velvety cheesecake to the comforting apple crumble and the indulgent carrot cake, every bite is a blissful symphony of flavor. Treat yourself and your loved ones to a delightful experience by ordering from this culinary haven. Whether it's a special occasion or just a craving for something delicious, Harlem Baking Co. will never disappoint.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Cheap Eats
  • Hidden Gems

5. Sugar Hill Creamery

Phone Directions Website
Experience the delectable flavors of Sugar Hill Creamery at their newest location! With their latest creation, First Day Out, you'll be taken on a tantalizing journey of taste. The herbaceous undertones of jalapenos meld seamlessly with the sweet and tangy blackberries, creating a harmonious symphony on your palate. And that's just the beginning. Step into their charming yet spacious setting, nestled between their Lennox Avenue and Broadway locations. While smaller than their Lennox Avenue spot, it offers more room to indulge in their irresistible offerings. Get ready to be amazed by their unique and inventive flavors that will leave your tastebuds begging for more.
While the prices may reflect the top-notch quality, the friendly staff and mouthwatering ice cream make every penny worth it. And if you need any more reasons to visit, just take a look at the mouthwatering photo featuring the enticing flavors of "hello new world" and "brown bomb." Prepare your taste buds for an unforgettable experience at Sugar Hill Creamery.

TOPICS

  • Mexican Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Downtown Spots

6. Baskin-Robbins

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

delis in East Harlem NYC

7. Baskin-Robbins

Phone Directions Website
As a local resident, I finally decided to give Baskin-Robbins a try today, and to my surprise, their donuts were incredibly fresh. My kids absolutely loved their ice cream, and that made the experience even better. However, we did encounter a slight disappointment when it came to the latte and iced coffee. Unfortunately, they had an unusual taste that didn't quite live up to our expectations. Nevertheless, overall it was still a positive experience.

TOPICS

  • Personal Celebrations
  • Cheap Eats
  • Lunch

8. Baskin-Robbins

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Personal Celebrations
  • Gluten-Free
  • American Cuisine