Best of 10 Seafood restaurants in Theater District NYC
Discover our curated list of top-ranked Seafood restaurants in Theater District NYC, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Grand Central Oyster Bar, Bubba Gump Shrimp Co., Red Lobster, Sea Fire Grill, Oceana. Let's explore together!
Toc
1. Grand Central Oyster Bar
Historical site operating since 1913 with beautiful tiled arches
Established in 1913, Part of the Grand Central Terminal landmark
Indulge in the culinary delights of Grand Central Oyster Bar, where the gazpacho with lobster stands out as a true gem. The rich flavors of the soup are elevated by the addition of succulent lobster, creating a truly special dining experience. While the seafood offerings are reliably good, it's the gazpacho that steals the show, making it a worthwhile splurge for a memorable seafood feast. The selection of oysters, particularly the ones from British Columbia's Fanny Bay, left us craving for more with their exquisite taste and freshness. However, the dining experience was somewhat dampened by lackluster service from unwelcoming waitstaff.
Savor the exquisite flavors of the iconic Grand Central Oyster Bar, where the gazpacho with lobster reigns supreme as a must-try dish. Each spoonful of the soup delights the palate with its harmonious blend of flavors, accentuated by the luxurious addition of tender lobster meat. While the overall seafood offerings are solid, it's the gazpacho that truly shines as a star attraction, making it a worthwhile investment for a special seafood dining experience. The British Columbia oysters, especially those from Fanny Bay, captivated our taste buds with their exceptional quality and variety. However, the dining experience was marred by subpar service marked by unfriendly and inattentive waiters, detracting slightly from an otherwise memorable meal.
Savor the exquisite flavors of the iconic Grand Central Oyster Bar, where the gazpacho with lobster reigns supreme as a must-try dish. Each spoonful of the soup delights the palate with its harmonious blend of flavors, accentuated by the luxurious addition of tender lobster meat. While the overall seafood offerings are solid, it's the gazpacho that truly shines as a star attraction, making it a worthwhile investment for a special seafood dining experience. The British Columbia oysters, especially those from Fanny Bay, captivated our taste buds with their exceptional quality and variety. However, the dining experience was marred by subpar service marked by unfriendly and inattentive waiters, detracting slightly from an otherwise memorable meal.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
2. Bubba Gump Shrimp Co.
Themed after the movie Forrest Gump, outdoor seating with views of Broadway
Themed after the popular movie Forrest Gump, outdoor seating with views of Times Square
Dive into an unforgettable journey of flavor and nostalgia at Bubba Gump Shrimp Co., nestled in the vibrant City Walk. From the moment you step inside, you are transported back to the iconic movie, enveloped in a wave of familiar charm. Indulge in an array of delectable dishes crafted with precision and care, each bite a symphony of flavors that will tantalize your taste buds. The impeccable service adds a touch of elegance to your dining experience, leaving you pampered and satisfied. When visiting Universal, a stop at Bubba Gump's is a must-do, offering not just a meal, but a culinary adventure that will linger in your memory.
Immerse yourself in the heartwarming ambiance of Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. at City Walk, an experience that promises to captivate your senses from start to finish. The essence of the beloved movie comes alive as you savor the exceptional cuisine and embrace the nostalgia that fills the air. With a menu that boasts excellence in every dish and a team dedicated to delivering top-notch service, every moment spent here is a celebration of good food and great memories. For a culinary escapade like no other, head straight to Bubba Gump's when at Universal, where every meal is a testament to the joy of discovery and the delight of sharing delicious moments.
Immerse yourself in the heartwarming ambiance of Bubba Gump Shrimp Co. at City Walk, an experience that promises to captivate your senses from start to finish. The essence of the beloved movie comes alive as you savor the exceptional cuisine and embrace the nostalgia that fills the air. With a menu that boasts excellence in every dish and a team dedicated to delivering top-notch service, every moment spent here is a celebration of good food and great memories. For a culinary escapade like no other, head straight to Bubba Gump's when at Universal, where every meal is a testament to the joy of discovery and the delight of sharing delicious moments.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Vegetarian Options
3. Red Lobster
Famous for their seafood selection and biscuits
Famous for their delicious and fresh seafood
Red Lobster offers an exceptional dining experience with a welcoming atmosphere that sets the stage for a memorable meal. From the warm greeting at the door to the attentive service from the friendly waitress, every detail contributes to a delightful visit. The menu impresses with flavorful dishes, such as the tantalizing crunchy dragon fruit, and generous portions that leave diners fully satisfied. Don't miss out on their delicious cocktails that perfectly complement the meal, adding an extra touch of indulgence to the overall dining experience.
Temple, our dedicated server at Red Lobster, truly goes above and beyond with his professionalism and attentiveness, making him a standout member of the team. His exceptional service adds to the restaurant's charm, creating a welcoming environment that keeps guests coming back for more. The quality of the food perfectly matches the prices, offering great value for a top-notch dining experience. And let's not forget the phenomenal atmosphere at Red Lobster, located in the heart of Times Square, adding a touch of excitement and energy to an already outstanding dining experience.
Temple, our dedicated server at Red Lobster, truly goes above and beyond with his professionalism and attentiveness, making him a standout member of the team. His exceptional service adds to the restaurant's charm, creating a welcoming environment that keeps guests coming back for more. The quality of the food perfectly matches the prices, offering great value for a top-notch dining experience. And let's not forget the phenomenal atmosphere at Red Lobster, located in the heart of Times Square, adding a touch of excitement and energy to an already outstanding dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
4. Sea Fire Grill
Upscale atmosphere with an extensive raw bar
Upscale seafood dining experience with a lively atmosphere
Located at 158 E 48th St, New York, Sea Fire Grill boasts a delectable menu featuring highlights such as Jumbo Crab Cake, Lobster Bisque, and Alaskan King Crab Legs. The restaurant, a venture from the team behind Benjamin Steakhouse, offers a chic and lively ambiance where they focus on simplicity to showcase top-notch ingredients. The Raw Bar sets the tone with offerings like cold whole lobsters and a variety of oysters, while the "fresh catch" section features seasonal treasures like the whole Maine lobster stuffed with crab.
Our go-to spot for seafood in New York, Sea Fire Grill stands out not only for its elegant dining room and impeccable service but most notably for its exceptional cuisine. On a recent visit with friends to sample the weekly menu, we were promptly seated and treated to a selection of menus to peruse, including the enticing array of dishes on offer.
Our go-to spot for seafood in New York, Sea Fire Grill stands out not only for its elegant dining room and impeccable service but most notably for its exceptional cuisine. On a recent visit with friends to sample the weekly menu, we were promptly seated and treated to a selection of menus to peruse, including the enticing array of dishes on offer.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- High-End
5. Oceana
Sustainable seafood options, stylish nautical-themed decor
Sustainable seafood, extensive wine list
Oceana, located in New York, is a seafood enthusiast's utopia, celebrated for its premium fresh ingredients and top-notch hospitality. The seafood tower is a spectacle to behold, brimming with lustrous oysters and juicy shrimp—a true feast for the senses. For those seeking exceptional dining experiences in the bustling culinary scene of New York, Oceana strikes the ideal balance of elegance and approachability, making it a stellar choice for indulging in exquisite seafood fare.
TOPICS
- Corporate Events
- Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Mediterranean Cuisine
6. Ocean Prime
High-end dining experience with a focus on fresh seafood
Sophisticated dining experience with live music
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Affordable Nightlife
- Social Gatherings
7. Burger & Lobster Bryant Park
Fresh seafood flown in daily, unique dining experience
Fresh seafood flown in daily, unique dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
8. Blue Fin
Stunning views of Times Square, Fresh and high-quality seafood
Fresh seafood flown in daily, located in Times Square
After many strolls past Blue Fin, we finally dined there and were delighted by the delicious offerings. Our waiter, Adrian, impressed us with his attentive service and fascinating backstory, adding to the exceptional experience. The 5-star tuna sashimi was a standout dish, and despite our late arrival, we were warmly welcomed and well taken care of. We highly recommend a visit to Blue Fin, especially to enjoy Adrian's outstanding hospitality.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- High-End
9. Hunt & Fish Club
Live music on select nights, Vintage decor and ambiance, Exclusive location in the heart of Times Square
Upscale dining experience with a focus on fresh ingredients and exceptional service
Hunt & Fish Club exudes graceful elegance, with its dimly lit interiors creating a sophisticated ambiance. On a delightful dinner outing with friends, we indulged in a wine tasting at the bar before relishing the impeccable service and exquisite menu. Though prices are on the higher end, the exceptional quality justifies the expense. The friendly and engaging waitress added to our wonderful experience, despite the somewhat subdued atmosphere for a Friday evening.
Hunt & Fish Club captures a refined charm through its elegant decor and intimate setting. Our dinner soirée with friends was heightened by a delightful wine tasting experience at the inviting bar. The attentive waitstaff complemented the curated wine selection perfectly. While the upscale pricing may deter some, the impeccable service and delectable dishes make it a worthwhile indulgence. The lively and jovial waitress enhanced our evening, adding a touch of warmth to the slightly quiet Friday night ambiance.
Hunt & Fish Club captures a refined charm through its elegant decor and intimate setting. Our dinner soirée with friends was heightened by a delightful wine tasting experience at the inviting bar. The attentive waitstaff complemented the curated wine selection perfectly. While the upscale pricing may deter some, the impeccable service and delectable dishes make it a worthwhile indulgence. The lively and jovial waitress enhanced our evening, adding a touch of warmth to the slightly quiet Friday night ambiance.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mexican Cuisine
- High-End
- Downtown Spots
10. Mermaid Oyster Bar Times Square
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots