Best of 10 shops for birthday cupcakes in Williamsburg NYC
Looking for the perfect birthday treat? Check out the various shops for birthday cupcakes in Williamsburg, NYC. From classic flavors to unique and gourmet options, these bakeries have it all. Whether you're looking for a small batch for an intimate gathering or a larger order for a big celebration, these shops have you covered. Experience the deliciousness of custom cupcakes for your next birthday bash in Williamsburg.
1. Brooklyn Cupcake
Experience the flavor of Brooklyn.

A variety pack of cupcakes was ordered for a birthday party, and they were a big hit among the guests. The cupcakes were fresh and had a rich, full flavor that was enjoyed by all. The diversity of flavors catered to various preferences, satisfying everyone's sweet tooth.
The cupcake pack proved to be an excellent value, considering the quality of the dessert and the number of servings. These delightful treats would be a tremendous addition to any birthday celebration, leaving your guests delighted and satisfied. Based on the reviews received, it is highly recommended to include them at your next birthday party.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
2. Kaffs Bakery
Famous for their crunchy fried lox bagel

Kaffs Bakery is renowned for offering some of the finest birthday cupcakes in Brooklyn. These delightful treats are always fresh and baked to perfection, ensuring a burst of flavor with every bite. The bakery's commitment to quality and dedication to creating delicious cupcakes make it an ideal choice for any birthday celebration.
The cupcakes at Kaffs Bakery are truly outstanding, making it the perfect destination for birthday festivities. With a wide variety of flavors and designs, there is guaranteed to be something for everyone. The knowledgeable and friendly staff are happy to help customers make the right selection, and the cozy atmosphere creates a welcoming environment for all to enjoy the bakery's delightful creations. Without a doubt, Kaffs Bakery is highly recommended for those seeking a memorable birthday cupcake experience.
3. Martha's Country Bakery
Warm, inviting atmosphere with classic American treats

Martha's Country Bakery is known for their impressive baked goods, and the birthday cupcakes are no exception. For a recent celebration, ordered cupcakes were not only fresh and moist but also beautifully decorated, adding a special touch to the festivities. Each cupcake was a delight to behold, revealing a colorful and thoughtfully crafted design within. The taste was equally pleasing, with a perfect balance of sweetness and flavor.
Without a doubt, Martha's Country Bakery continues to demonstrate their expertise in the realm of baked goods. Their birthday cupcakes are consistently well-received, praised for their variety and uncompromising quality. Whether it's a classic flavor or something more adventurous, the bakery delivers delicious and visually appealing treats that leave a lasting impression. They truly capture the celebratory spirit of a birthday, making them an ideal choice for any special occasion.
4. Sander's Bakery
Best chocolate croissants and cinnamon rolls in NY

A delightful aroma wafts through the air, leading passersby to the welcoming doors of Sander's Bakery in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. The establishment's impressive array of baked goods includes delectable variations of kippelech, rugelach, and pastry danishes. These items are truly noteworthy; they were found to be the most delicious examples of their respective kinds among all bakeries visited. Even several days after purchase, the quality remained exceptional, demonstrating the freshness and care taken in their preparation.
A local favorite, Sander's Bakery attracts patrons with its delectable cakes, bulk pastas at $12 per pound, and cheese pastas at $10. The friendly and attentive staff consistently receive commendations from customers, contributing to the bakery's positive reputation. Sander's Bakery stands out as a high recommendation among local establishments, making it an ideal stop for both tourists and residents of Williamsburg seeking a satisfying baked goods experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Kosher Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
5. La Bicyclette Bakery
Artisan French bakery with organic ingredients

La Bicyclette Bakery's cupcakes are truly a delight. A recent order for a dozen cupcakes for a birthday celebration were a big success. The unique flavors and expertly prepared frosting make these cupcakes stand out.
When it comes to birthday cupcakes, La Bicyclette Bakery is a reliable choice. With a wide variety of options and consistently high-quality product, it's no wonder they are a popular choice. The cupcakes were a hit at the birthday party, with guests praising their delicious taste.
6. byPensa in Williamsburg

7. Bakeri in Williamsburg
Cozy cafe with a tranquil, European-inspired atmosphere

A charming bakery and coffee shop, reminiscent of a Wes Anderson film set, offers a delightful escape with its charming atmosphere and delicious offerings. The staff, clad in uniform blue, add to the overall aesthetic with their friendly and efficient service. The display case is filled with a variety of fresh pastries that go beyond the typical croissant, providing a delightful selection for any palate.
This bakery, situated just two blocks from a hotel, quickly became a favorite spot for its exquisite offerings. The quality of the pastries was consistently high, making it difficult to resist the temptation to visit every day. Among the many delicious options, the savory tart stands out as a particularly exceptional choice, leaving a lasting impression on those who are fortunate enough to try it. It is highly recommended to include this bakery as a must-visit destination for any traveler or local looking to indulge in a delectable pastry experience.
8. Northside Bakery
The best artisan bakery in New York City

Upon ordering an 8-inch custom birthday cake from this establishment, the design exceeded expectations, accompanied by a reasonable price. The bakery boasts an in-house pastry chef who also happens to be the owner, enabling the creation of fresh cakes in as little as one hour.
Northside Bakery is a Polish bakery that provides a distinctive experience to its clientele. The bakery offers an assortment of traditional Polish dishes, such as paczki, krokiety with spinach and cheese, and perogies. The hot food bar features daily specials that consist of sausage, meatballs, and potatoes. Additionally, the bakery provides a selection of baked goods, including prune donuts and coconut donuts. Conveying an authentic Polish ambiance and staffed by friendly personnel, Northside Bakery presents a unique and appetizing experience to all visitors.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Kosher Options
- Downtown Spots
- Breakfast
9. Bake Shop
Wholesome traditional American desserts with sustainable ingredients

The cupcakes on offer are truly impressive, providing a delightful experience for anyone lucky enough to taste them. A recent order of a dozen for a daughter's birthday party was met with great enthusiasm from the guests. The array of unique and delectable flavors on display was a definite crowd-pleaser.
This establishment excels in catering to various dietary preferences, including those of the vegan variety. During a recent birthday celebration, the availability of vegan cupcake options was greatly appreciated, ensuring that everyone could partake in the sweet festivities. The bakery's commitment to diversity in their offerings is commendable, making it an ideal choice for any gathering.
10. Ovenly Greenpoint
Award-winning bakery blending savory and sweet treats

Ovenly Greenpoint is highly recommended for anyone in search of delicious cupcakes, particularly for special occasions. Their Brooklyn Blackout cupcakes are a popular choice, known for their rich chocolate flavor and moist texture. The staff at the bakery consistently demonstrate a friendly and helpful demeanor, making the experience of ordering a pleasure.
For a recent birthday party, Ovenly's cupcakes were ordered and proved to be a huge hit among the guests. The standout variety was the salted chocolate chip cupcakes, which provided a delightful contrast between the sweetness of the frosting and the slight saltiness of the cake. Whether it's for a birthday or another celebration, Ovenly is a reliable source for high-quality and delicious cupcakes.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Happy Hours