Best of 11 bread pudding in New Dorp NYC
Bread pudding takes on a delectable twist in New Dorp, NYC. This time-honored dessert is prepared with a unique blend of ingredients, creating a distinctive flavor that delights locals and visitors alike. From classic recipes to innovative twists, bread pudding in New Dorp NYC offers a memorable dessert experience that keeps foodies coming back for more.
1. Piece-A-Cake
Family-owned bakery since 1987, serving a variety of desserts

The bread pudding at this location is truly delicious, earning high praise from my taste buds. Its texture stands out for being just right, avoiding the common pitfalls of being either too soggy or too dry. The sweetness level is also commendable, as it is not overly saccharine, which can often be a issue with many bread pudding recipes.
Overall, the bread pudding offers a rich and creamy experience with a perfect balance of sweetness, making it a standout dessert. For those with a sweet tooth, this dessert is a must-try and is sure to leave a lasting impression. The quality of the bread pudding speaks for itself and is certainly worth recommending to others who are looking for an exceptional dessert experience.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Mid-Range
2. Cookie Jar
Cozy and relaxed atmosphere, perfect for families and friends

The bread pudding at Cookie Jar is a must-try dessert. Its texture is perfect, with just the right amount of moisture. The flavors are well-balanced, making each bite a delight. Whether you have a sweet tooth or not, you are sure to enjoy this dessert.
If you're looking for a delicious bread pudding, Cookie Jar is the place to go. Their bread pudding is moist, flavorful, and has the perfect amount of sweetness. It is a crowd-pleaser, suitable for people who enjoy sweets and those who prefer less sugary treats. You will not be disappointed with this dessert option.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Fusion Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
3. Cafe Con Pan
Cozy atmosphere, friendly service, and a variety of coffee and tea options

Cafe Con Pan offers a remarkable bread pudding that stands out for its exceptional flavors and texture. The balance of sweetness and other tastes in this dessert is expertly executed, making for a truly satisfying dining experience.
The bread pudding at Cafe Con Pan is a standout dish, known for its moist and flavorful consistency. The level of sweetness is perfectly balanced, making it a must-try treat for anyone visiting the restaurant.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
4. Mango Mango Dessert Staten Island
Exotic ingredients, creative presentations, and fun atmosphere

Mango Mango Dessert offers a delicious bread pudding that should not be missed. The dessert is known for its moist and flavorful consistency, making it the perfect way to end a meal. The bread pudding is highly recommended for anyone who visits the establishment.
The bread pudding at Mango Mango Dessert is characterized by its rich and creamy texture, as well as its perfect balance of sweetness. It is a delightful treat that is sure to satisfy anyone with a sweet tooth. Overall, the bread pudding is a standout dish at the dessert shop.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Fusion Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
5. Brioso in New Dorp
Handcrafted pastries baked fresh daily

The bread pudding served was a delightful dessert that provided a satisfying end to a meal. Its delicious taste and satisfying warmth made it a standout choice. The bread pudding is highly recommended for anyone looking for a tasty dessert option.
The bread pudding was warm and full of flavor. Its texture was perfect, offering a satisfying experience with every bite. This dessert is a must-try for anyone who appreciates a well-made bread pudding, as its combination of warmth, taste, and texture make it a truly exceptional dish.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Italian Cuisine
- Lunch
- Dinner
6. Something Sweet Homemade
Homemade desserts using high-quality ingredients

The bread pudding in question received mixed reviews, with one person finding it overly sweet while another thought it was expertly prepared and delightfully sweet. Both parties agreed on the generous portion size and the high-quality preparation of the dish.
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Hidden Gems
7. Prince Tea House New Dorp
Cozy atmosphere, with a vintage decor and comfortable seating, perfect for a relaxing afternoon.

The bread pudding at Prince Tea House is widely regarded as exceptional. Its rich and decadent flavor makes it an ideal choice for those seeking a satisfying sweet treat. The dish's popularity is due in part to its perfect balance of sweetness and warmth, making it a comforting and delicious dessert option.
Visitors to Prince Tea House consistently rave about the establishment's bread pudding. Its warm and inviting nature, coupled with a carefully calibrated level of sweetness, has earned it a loyal following among sweet-toothed patrons. Whether enjoyed as a standalone dessert or as a complement to one of the tea house's many tea offerings, the bread pudding is a standout menu item.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
- Breakfast
8. Fig & Vine
Warm and inviting restaurant with outdoor seating

The meal consisted of several delicious items, including an order of meatballs, pasta, zetchinia salad, filet mignon with vegetables and roasted sweet potato, and bread pudding with a cappuccino to finish. The filet mignon, salad, and bread pudding were particularly enjoyed and stood out as the highlights of the meal.
Eating establishment provided a variety of options, incorporating both meat and vegetable dishes as well as a tasty dessert. The filet mignon came with a serving of vegetables and roasted sweet potato, and the zucchini salad offered a lighter, healthier option. The bread pudding satisfied any sweet cravings, and the cappuccino finished the meal off with a nice touch of flavor and energy. Overall, the meal was diverse and enjoyable, with specific praise given to the filet, salad, and pudding.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
9. Fresh Twist in New Dorp
Cozy atmosphere and friendly service

Fresh Twist's bread pudding stands out with its exceptional moistness and rich flavor, making it one of the best versions I've ever tasted. This dessert is a standout dish that should not be missed for anyone visiting Fresh Twist.
Fresh Twist offers an amazing bread pudding, which is incredibly moist and full of flavor. If you decide to dine at Fresh Twist, this bread pudding is a highly recommended dish to try and enjoy.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
10. Sammi Sweetz

TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
11. New Dorp Deli

TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch