Best of 11 caprese sandwich in City Island NYC
Discover our curated list of top-ranked caprese sandwich in City Island NYC, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Tony's Pier, The Original Crab Shanty, Johnny's Reef, Sea Shore Restaurant, Seafood Kingz 2 Inc. Let's explore together!
Toc
1. Tony's Pier
Family-owned seafood restaurant with a relaxed atmosphere and beautiful views
Located at Tony's Pier, the dining experience is nothing short of exceptional. Indulge in their signature fried lobster tails paired with crispy fries and succulent shrimp, all cooked to perfection. The well-crafted drinks complement the exquisite meal, making it a true delight for the taste buds. With reasonable prices, a touch of humor from the friendly staff, and efficient service from the dedicated waiters, Tony's Pier offers a memorable culinary experience that will keep you coming back for more.
For years, Tony's Pier has been a go-to spot for those craving a reliable combination of fast food and fresh seafood. The quick service, even outside regular business hours, ensures a satisfying dining experience every time. While weekends may see a bustling crowd, the restaurant's popularity is a testament to its delectable offerings. Despite occasional price increases, Tony's Pier remains a top recommendation for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful meal that hits all the right notes.
For years, Tony's Pier has been a go-to spot for those craving a reliable combination of fast food and fresh seafood. The quick service, even outside regular business hours, ensures a satisfying dining experience every time. While weekends may see a bustling crowd, the restaurant's popularity is a testament to its delectable offerings. Despite occasional price increases, Tony's Pier remains a top recommendation for food enthusiasts seeking a delightful meal that hits all the right notes.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- American Cuisine
Relate link
2. The Original Crab Shanty
Waterfront dining with stunning views
Indulge in the ultimate seafood extravaganza at The Original Crab Shanty, where every bite is a symphony of flavor. Feast on plump lobster and colossal crab legs that practically burst with freshness and succulence. Each piece is a treasure trove waiting to be discovered as you savor the generous portions that promise to leave you completely satisfied.
Immerse yourself in a dining experience like no other, where impeccable service and potent drinks perfectly complement the mouthwatering dishes. The friendly staff adds a welcoming touch to an already stellar meal, ensuring that every visit is met with warmth and hospitality. Dive into a feast for the senses, where tender crab legs melt in your mouth, creating moments of pure culinary bliss that will keep you coming back for more.
Immerse yourself in a dining experience like no other, where impeccable service and potent drinks perfectly complement the mouthwatering dishes. The friendly staff adds a welcoming touch to an already stellar meal, ensuring that every visit is met with warmth and hospitality. Dive into a feast for the senses, where tender crab legs melt in your mouth, creating moments of pure culinary bliss that will keep you coming back for more.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
3. Johnny's Reef
Waterfront dining with beautiful views of the city
Experience the charm of Johnny's Reef, where you'll find a perfect fusion of a prime location, affordable prices, and delectable cuisine. The well-organized setup ensures a seamless dining experience in a lively atmosphere. Indulge in their array of offerings, from refreshing drinks to mouthwatering dishes, complete with all the necessary accompaniments, including a selection of alcoholic beverages.
Having visited Johnny's Reef twice this year, I can attest to the exceptional quality of their food. The fried shrimp with fries, paired with their homemade tartar sauce, was an absolute delight. Generous portions of freshly prepared dishes at such reasonable prices make it a must-visit spot. Rest assured, the restaurant strictly adheres to all safety measures, allowing you to savor your meal with peace of mind.
Having visited Johnny's Reef twice this year, I can attest to the exceptional quality of their food. The fried shrimp with fries, paired with their homemade tartar sauce, was an absolute delight. Generous portions of freshly prepared dishes at such reasonable prices make it a must-visit spot. Rest assured, the restaurant strictly adheres to all safety measures, allowing you to savor your meal with peace of mind.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mexican Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Hidden Gems
4. Sea Shore Restaurant
Fresh seafood, welcoming ambiance, attentive service
Seaside Dining Delight Indulge in delectable dishes at this charming restaurant with attentive staff. A slight discomfort arose over tipping when a waiter, dissatisfied with his gratuity, expressed his unhappiness - insisting on a 15% or 20% benchmark. Despite this, the culinary experience remains unforgettable.
Oceanfront Oasis This place is a true gem! The food is exceptional, the drinks are top-notch, but what truly sets it apart is the impeccable service. From the moment we stepped in until the final farewell, we were treated to unparalleled hospitality that left us beaming with satisfaction.
Oceanfront Oasis This place is a true gem! The food is exceptional, the drinks are top-notch, but what truly sets it apart is the impeccable service. From the moment we stepped in until the final farewell, we were treated to unparalleled hospitality that left us beaming with satisfaction.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- High-End
- Waterfront
5. Seafood Kingz 2 Inc
Fresh seafood and lively ambiance
Seafood Kingz 2 Inc delights with their crispy yet juicy dishes, prompting an exhilarating happy dance upon the first bite. The experience is beyond words, instantly lifting spirits and banishing any hint of melancholy. The warm, inviting ambience and friendly service make every visit a joyous occasion, complemented by flavorful drinks and delectable cuisine that leaves a lasting impression.
TOPICS
- Waterfront
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Happy Hours
- Dinner
6. Archie's Tap & Table
Located in the charming City Island with a great view
Indulge in delightful dishes like the flavorsome chicken and waffles, with highlights such as the exquisite salted avocado. Families with avocado enthusiasts should consider ordering extra, as it is sure to tantalize taste buds and leave everyone wanting more.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
7. Augie's City Island Deli
Iconic deli with a long history on City Island
Augie's City Island Deli is a beloved local institution on City Island offering a diverse menu for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. With fast, friendly service, it's a go-to spot for locals, fishermen, and workers. Although dining in space is limited, the welcoming atmosphere and top-notch food make it well worth a visit. Here, generations of customers have savored the delicious meals and embraced the community spirit, creating unforgettable memories and a strong sense of belonging. Whether you're a newcomer or a regular, Augie's Deli promises a delightful experience that keeps you coming back for more.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Italian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
8. City Island Diner
Long-standing family-owned diner with a nostalgic feel
TOPICS
- Waterfront
- Breakfast
9. Scavello's On The Island
Family-owned Italian seafood restaurant
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
10. Sea Breeze Deli Corp
TOPICS
- Waterfront
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
11. A Taste of Italy Italian Deli
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings