Best of 11 Philly cheesesteaks in Buffalo
Discover our curated list of top-ranked Philly cheesesteaks in Buffalo, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Shys Original Steak House, Jim's Steakout, Jim's Steakout, Mike's Steak House, Jim's SteakOut. Let's explore together!
Toc
1. Shys Original Steak House
Family-owned steakhouse serving high-quality cuts since 1973
Shy's Original Steak House stands as a unique culinary gem, offering a delightful dining experience unlike any other. While drawing comparisons to Scotty's, it exudes a charm and character that captivate its patrons. Indulge in a delicious sub that promises to tantalize your taste buds, though reaching them by phone may prove challenging - stepping inside is a journey worth taking for a savory meal.
Impeccably renowned for serving the finest meat hoagies known to mankind, Shy's Original Steak House boasts a menu selection that is both quick and diverse. Amidst the vintage ambiance that could benefit from a modern touch, the real star of the show remains the sloppy yet scrumptious hoagies that leave a lasting impression. With a dedicated staff and delectable food offerings, Shy's effortlessly creates a culinary experience that exceeds expectations on every visit.
Impeccably renowned for serving the finest meat hoagies known to mankind, Shy's Original Steak House boasts a menu selection that is both quick and diverse. Amidst the vintage ambiance that could benefit from a modern touch, the real star of the show remains the sloppy yet scrumptious hoagies that leave a lasting impression. With a dedicated staff and delectable food offerings, Shy's effortlessly creates a culinary experience that exceeds expectations on every visit.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Dinner
Relate link
2. Jim's Steakout
Well-known for late-night eats and hearty sandwiches
From the captivating commercials on Buffalo Fox 29 to the mouthwatering subs, our visit to Jim's Steakout in Buffalo was nothing short of extraordinary. Traveling from Toronto for an event, we stumbled upon this gem and were blown away by the impeccable service and delectable sandwiches. A must-visit spot that has now become a highlight of our Buffalo trips, we are eagerly looking forward to our return in the summer.
Having been acquainted with the hype surrounding Jim's Steakout for years, finally experiencing it firsthand was truly a culinary delight. Opting for the classic beef sub left me speechless with its savory goodness, while my wife's choice of the beef and chicken sandwich was equally satisfying. This iconic establishment has undoubtedly won us over, and we are already planning our next indulgent visit to savor more of their delicious offerings.
Having been acquainted with the hype surrounding Jim's Steakout for years, finally experiencing it firsthand was truly a culinary delight. Opting for the classic beef sub left me speechless with its savory goodness, while my wife's choice of the beef and chicken sandwich was equally satisfying. This iconic establishment has undoubtedly won us over, and we are already planning our next indulgent visit to savor more of their delicious offerings.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
3. Jim's Steakout
A popular spot for late-night eats in Buffalo
Indulge in the flavorful delights of Jim's Steakout, a late-night haven for hearty eats. Despite the modest soda selection, the star of the show is undoubtedly the mouthwatering steak sandwich. Generously sized at 8 inches, it is a savory delight that satisfies any late-night craving.
While the menu offers a variety of options like the Philly steak, deluxe steak, and stinger hoagie, it's hard to overlook the occasional hiccup like tough gristle in the deluxe steak hoagie. A minor flaw in an otherwise delicious experience, Jim's Steakout remains a must-visit for those seeking a delectable bite in the wee hours of the night.
While the menu offers a variety of options like the Philly steak, deluxe steak, and stinger hoagie, it's hard to overlook the occasional hiccup like tough gristle in the deluxe steak hoagie. A minor flaw in an otherwise delicious experience, Jim's Steakout remains a must-visit for those seeking a delectable bite in the wee hours of the night.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Social Gatherings
- Budget-Friendly Eats
Relate link
4. Mike's Steak House
Family-owned and operated since 1965, extensive wine list
Indulge in the delectable offerings at Mike's Steak House, where exceptional cuisine and top-notch service are served at affordable prices. From savory dishes to mouthwatering sandwiches, this urban eatery has it all. Conveniently, they also provide delivery through Skip The Dishes, perfect for when you crave their food but can't make it to pick up an order. The ambience is cozy, the food is top-tier, and the staff are absolute treasures. A true gem in the dining scene, Mike's Steak House never fails to impress.
Immerse yourself in a culinary delight at Mike's Steak House, where every dish is a masterpiece and service is unparalleled, all at a pocket-friendly price point. Whether you're craving a sumptuous meal or a satisfying sandwich, this urban hotspot has something for everyone. Their delivery option through Skip The Dishes adds an extra layer of convenience, ensuring you can enjoy their delectable offerings wherever you are. The inviting atmosphere, coupled with the exceptional food quality and stellar service, makes every visit to Mike's Steak House a memorable experience.
Immerse yourself in a culinary delight at Mike's Steak House, where every dish is a masterpiece and service is unparalleled, all at a pocket-friendly price point. Whether you're craving a sumptuous meal or a satisfying sandwich, this urban hotspot has something for everyone. Their delivery option through Skip The Dishes adds an extra layer of convenience, ensuring you can enjoy their delectable offerings wherever you are. The inviting atmosphere, coupled with the exceptional food quality and stellar service, makes every visit to Mike's Steak House a memorable experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
Relate link
5. Jim's SteakOut
Family-owned and operated for over 25 years
During our journey home, we made a pit stop at Jim's SteakOut. Intrigued by their renowned Chicken Finger Sub, I opted for the full works: blue cheese, tomato, lettuce, cheese, oil, and vinegar. While it was decent, it failed to captivate my taste buds. The service was commendably prompt and effective. Jim's SteakOut is undeniably a hotspot worth checking out, especially if you're a visitor in the vicinity. Despite not venturing towards the combo of steak and chicken, the experience was still a flavorsome adventure.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
6. The Hoagie Stop
Family-owned business with a focus on fresh ingredients and local products
Upon stepping into The Hoagie Stop, I was greeted by an explosion of flavors that transported me back to the streets of Philly. Offering a true taste of authenticity, this spot outshines any imitators in town. The impeccable customer service further elevated my experience, leaving me not only satisfied but craving more. Indulging in their charcuterie steak and fries was a divine experience that I urge all food enthusiasts to embark on. Trust me, this culinary journey is one you do not want to miss.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
Relate link
7. Jim's Steakout
Well-known local establishment with a wide variety of options
In January 2022, I indulged in the irresistible Jim's Steakout hoagie, a quintessential delicacy for those touring Buffalo, New York. Opting for the frenchy brimming with tender steak and a medley of fillings, the flavors were divine. Additionally, I savored the Hoagie Deluxe Bomber and delectable Mac and Cheese Bites - a feast for the senses at such affordable prices. Who can resist the allure of a perfectly crafted Philly cheesesteak, especially from a renowned spot like Jim's Steakout?
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
8. Jim's SteakOut
Family-owned restaurant known for high-quality meat
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
Relate link
9. Down The Way Chop Steak Shop inside of Jami Chop Steak
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
Relate link
10. Teague's steak subs & more
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
- Late Night
Relate link
11. RICK'S STEAKHOUSE 2
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
