Best of 9 restaurants in East Harlem NYC
Discover the vibrant culinary scene of restaurants in East Harlem, NYC. This neighborhood, also known as "El Barrio," offers a rich cultural experience with its diverse mix of eateries. From classic Italian-American cuisine to authentic Mexican dishes, restaurants in East Harlem NYC showcase a variety of flavors to satisfy any palate. Don't miss out on the unique culinary journey that awaits you in this bustling NYC community.
1. Bistro Casa Azul
Elevated Mexican cuisine with a unique twist.

Exquisite meals and unique twists on traditional favorites are the hallmark of this dining establishment. The guacamole, in particular, stands out for its delicious and authentic taste, made from fresh, high-quality ingredients. Each dish is a delightful burst of flavor, featuring a perfect balance of spices and seasonings that is sure to impress even the most discerning of palates.
The service at this establishment is nothing short of outstanding. From the moment you enter, you are greeted by friendly and attentive staff who go above and beyond to ensure that your dining experience is enjoyable and memorable. They are knowledgeable about the menu and can offer excellent recommendations based on your preferences. The staff's commitment to impeccable service and customer satisfaction is truly top-notch, making this a must-visit destination for anyone in search of a exceptional dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
Relate link
2. Nocciola Ristorante in East Harlem
Rustic charm with a modern twist.

This Italian restaurant is truly a gem! The dishes are impeccably crafted, with a perfect pizza that has a perfectly crispy crust and an exquisite taste. The pasta is also exceptional, with rich and flavorful sauces that elevate each dish. Even the cheesecake is heavenly, with a creamy and smooth texture that is simply irresistible. This restaurant is a must-visit for any Italian food lover.
Nocciola never fails to deliver delicious and high-quality food. From their brunch offerings to their dinner plates, every dish is carefully prepared and presented with elegance. Standout dishes include the classic pizza Margherita, tender and flavorful ravioli with squash, and the indulgent tiramisu. The prices are also very reasonable, making this restaurant a great value for the exceptional food and service. East Harlem is lucky to have such a fantastic Italian restaurant, and it is not to be missed.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Hidden Gems
3. Cascalote
Family-owned Latin bistro with a homely vibe.

This establishment is known for its cozy seating and warm atmosphere, making a reservation is highly recommended to ensure a comfortable dining experience. The culinary delights on offer are sure to satisfy, with the steak fajitas being a particular standout. The classic margarita is also a popular choice, providing a refreshing accompaniment to the rich and flavorful dishes.
The music selection is diverse and energetic, creating a lively ambiance that enhances the overall dining experience. The guacamole and chuletas are must-try dishes, bursting with fresh and vibrant flavors. The service is top-notch, with friendly and attentive servers like Walker going the extra mile to make sure every guest feels welcome and satisfied. Overall, this restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike, offering a memorable dining experience that is sure to delight.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
4. Au Jus Harlem
Authentic Oklahoma BBQ in the heart of NYC

For those who enjoy animal-derived dishes, Au Jus’s Oklahoma BBQ sampler tray is worth exploring. While it may not offer the most exceptional barbecue in terms of flavor, the sheer quantity of smoked pork and beef makes it a worthwhile choice. This option is particularly attractive for those looking to get a lot of meat for their money, as the portion size is quite generous.
Au Jus in Harlem is a great spot for barbecue lovers, offering a variety of options in a casual and friendly setting. Among the most popular dishes are the short ribs, which are tender and flavorful. The baked beans and Mac and cheese side dishes are also highly regarded, providing a well-rounded and satisfying meal. The service at Au Jus is another highlight, with staff who are attentive and helpful, making for a positive dining experience.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Asian Cuisine
- Dinner
- Late Night
5. Amor Cubano in East Harlem
Experience the golden age of Cuba with live music and dance.

Amor Cubano offers a transportive dining experience, taking guests on a journey to 1950s Havana while serving up delectable Cuban cuisine. The atmosphere is a lively blend of classic elegance and contemporary energy, complete with dancing, singing, and performance art. The restaurant's commitment to authenticity and quality has not wavered even amidst the challenges of the pandemic.
A recent visit confirmed that Amor Cubano continues to deliver on its exceptional reputation. The food, staff, and music all remained top-notch, creating a truly enjoyable dining experience. Whether you're a returning patron or a newcomer, Amor Cubano is a must-visit destination for anyone seeking to savor the flavors and ambiance of Cuba in a welcoming and engaging environment.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
6. East Harlem Bottling Co.
Craft Beer. Craftier Food. El Barrio.

The restaurant's menu offers a variety of dishes, such as the crowd-pleasing fish and chips and the hearty black bean burger, all of which have received positive feedback. The menu also features creative dishes like nachos and steak sandwiches, providing something for everyone's taste. To complement the meal, the restaurant offers a unique selection of drinks, including the popular Neruda mocktail.
The ambiance of the restaurant is relaxed and cozy, making it the perfect place to unwind and enjoy a meal. The reviewer's experience with the grandma's chili and weary traveler mini salad was overwhelmingly positive, praising their great taste and generous portions. The salad, when customized with chicken, added an extra layer of flavor and satisfaction to the meal. Overall, the dishes were impressive and satisfying, leaving the reviewer with a positive impression of the restaurant.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Happy Hours
- Hidden Gems
7. Ponty Bistro
Creative French and African cuisine since 2008.

A woman and her sister-in-law visited the restaurant around 2 pm and had an exceptional dining experience. The grilled salmon and mussels were the chosen dishes, both of which were incredibly flavorful. The salmon was particularly impressive, with a delicious tarragon sauce that enhanced its taste. The cocktail selection was also noteworthy, as the Little Africa cocktail turned out to be a delightful drink.
The food at this establishment is undoubtedly delicious, and the service was reportedly top-notch. A large group of diners was present during the visit, and everyone seemed to be impressed by the offerings. The servers were attentive and catered to the guests' needs, adding to the overall positive experience. This reviewer cannot recommend the restaurant highly enough, as it was an all-around excellent lunchtime excursion.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Affordable Nightlife
8. El Paso
Experience traditional Mexican flavors in East Harlem

A recent dining experience at this establishment proved to be a delightful surprise. The menu offered a variety of delicious food options, with each dish skillfully prepared and beautifully presented. The space was immaculate and tastefully decorated, providing a comfortable and enjoyable atmosphere. The service was exceptional, with attentive staff who were friendly and quick to respond to any needs or questions.
It is clear that a lot of care and attention goes into every aspect of this restaurant, from the food to the service and the ambiance. It's no surprise that diners have had such positive experiences and would highly recommend it to others. The rave reviews speak for themselves - the food is truly exceptional and the overall experience is not to be missed. Whether you're looking for a romantic night out or a place to gather with friends, this restaurant is sure to impress.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
Relate link
9. Maxwell's Central Park
Neighborhood gem with a fun, welcoming vibe.

Some customers have reported being delighted with the food offerings, praising the delicious and well-prepared dishes. However, others have had a vastly different experience, finding their meals to be dry and lacking in flavor, with inconsistent service to match.
On the other hand, the drinks at this establishment have garnered nearly universally positive reviews. Customers appreciate the refreshing and always-available options, making it a popular choice for those looking for a great drink to accompany their meal.
TOPICS
- Holiday Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options