Best of 11 romantic bars in Edgemere NYC
Discover our curated list of top-ranked romantic bars in Edgemere NYC, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like McGee's Pub, The Bonnie, The Long Island Bar, Garfunkel's, White Oak Tavern. Let's explore together!
Toc
1. McGee's Pub
Extensive selection of Irish whiskey and beer
Experience the charm of McGee's Pub, a hidden gem in New York City that encapsulates the essence of hospitality with its unassuming ambiance. Step into this cozy establishment and be greeted by the affable Donilo, a master mixologist who elevates your drinking experience to a whole new level. The pub exudes a unique allure for fans of "How I Met Your Mother," serving as the real-life embodiment of the show's iconic setting. Indulge in meticulously crafted cocktails inspired by the series, such as the tantalizing Robin Sparkle featuring Crown Royal, apple pucker, and cranberry juice. For a non-tequila option, savor the intriguingly named "Don't Drink Tequila" concoction. McGee's Pub promises not just a meal, but an unforgettable journey through delectable flavors and nostalgic television-inspired delights.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
2. The Bonnie
Wide selection of craft beers and big-screen TVs for watching games
Nestled in the heart of Astoria, The Bonnie exudes a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like stepping into your favorite TV show hangout. With a diverse selection of craft cocktails and delectable bites ranging from upscale nibbles to classic comfort dishes, this gastropub is perfect for any occasion. Whether you're perched at the bar chatting with the friendly staff, lounging at a table, or basking in the sunshine on the back patio, The Bonnie offers a welcoming space to gather with friends or make new ones.
From the moment my perfectly cooked medium rare steak melted in my mouth, I knew The Bonnie was a culinary gem. The attentive service, quality drinks, and vibrant ambiance create an unforgettable dining experience. Despite a minor hiccup with the door staff, the overall visit was a delightful one, leaving me eager to return with friends in tow. Shoutout to Marie and Jonathan for adding an extra layer of fun to our evening – their exceptional service truly elevated the already fantastic food, music, and atmosphere at The Bonnie.
From the moment my perfectly cooked medium rare steak melted in my mouth, I knew The Bonnie was a culinary gem. The attentive service, quality drinks, and vibrant ambiance create an unforgettable dining experience. Despite a minor hiccup with the door staff, the overall visit was a delightful one, leaving me eager to return with friends in tow. Shoutout to Marie and Jonathan for adding an extra layer of fun to our evening – their exceptional service truly elevated the already fantastic food, music, and atmosphere at The Bonnie.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
3. The Long Island Bar
Historic location, extensive drink selection, and a commitment to quality
Immerse yourself in the vibrant atmosphere of Long Island Bar, nestled in the charming Cobble Hill neighborhood. This hidden gem is a haven for cocktail enthusiasts and food aficionados alike. While their skillfully crafted gimlets and martinis are a must-try, the real star of the show is the delectable burger. Made with two juicy dry-aged patties, gooey cheese, and tangy pickles, encased in a soft bun, it's a true delight for the taste buds. Whether you opt for outdoor dining or takeout, Long Island Bar promises a memorable dining experience that will leave you craving for more.
Indulge in the irresistible bar food offerings at Long Island Bar, where each bite is a burst of flavor that delights the senses. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, with the option to dine al fresco on the sidewalk, adding a touch of urban charm to your meal. While the perfectly crafted burger steals the show, don't miss out on the intriguing panisse, with its fascinating blend of seasonings. From impeccable service to superb drinks, Long Island Bar ticks all the boxes for a perfect dining outing. Be sure to plan your visit accordingly, as this popular spot tends to get bustling. A return trip to Long Island Bar is not just an option - it's a necessity for anyone seeking a culinary experience that lingers long after the last bite.
Indulge in the irresistible bar food offerings at Long Island Bar, where each bite is a burst of flavor that delights the senses. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, with the option to dine al fresco on the sidewalk, adding a touch of urban charm to your meal. While the perfectly crafted burger steals the show, don't miss out on the intriguing panisse, with its fascinating blend of seasonings. From impeccable service to superb drinks, Long Island Bar ticks all the boxes for a perfect dining outing. Be sure to plan your visit accordingly, as this popular spot tends to get bustling. A return trip to Long Island Bar is not just an option - it's a necessity for anyone seeking a culinary experience that lingers long after the last bite.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
4. Garfunkel's
Renowned for classic American fare and excellent service
Garfunkel's is not just a trendy bar; it boasts some of the finest cocktails you'll find in any NYC speakeasy. I particularly recommend trying the Upmann the Banker, made with a unique cigar-infused scotch base that's impossible to replicate at home, no matter how hard you try.
Located on the first floor of a building in East Village, this hidden gem of a speakeasy offers a truly memorable experience. Accessible through a crafty front entrance disguised as a regular bar, once you step inside, you'll be transported through a faux vault door that adds to the allure. Arriving late at night? Don't worry—just ring the bell outside for an unforgettable nightcap.
Located on the first floor of a building in East Village, this hidden gem of a speakeasy offers a truly memorable experience. Accessible through a crafty front entrance disguised as a regular bar, once you step inside, you'll be transported through a faux vault door that adds to the allure. Arriving late at night? Don't worry—just ring the bell outside for an unforgettable nightcap.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
5. White Oak Tavern
Seasonal and locally sourced ingredients, extensive wine list, and craft cocktails
White Oak Tavern offers a delightful dining experience with its scrumptious fish and chips and mouth-watering burgers. Though slightly on the pricey side, the quality of the food justifies the cost. The service strikes the perfect balance of friendliness without being intrusive, making for a pleasant meal out. The cozy atmosphere adds to the overall charm of the place, making it a great choice for a leisurely lunch. While I typically lean towards casual or dive bars, White Oak Tavern has won me over with its consistently enjoyable offerings. Each visit has been a memorable one, and I can't help but appreciate the above-average quality of the food and drinks. If you're willing to splurge a bit, this spot is well worth a visit for a fantastic dining experience.
TOPICS
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- American Cuisine
6. Overstory
Exclusive access to panoramic views of New York City
The trio of upscale venues at 70 Pine Street, Crown Shy, Saga, and Overstory, showcase the remarkable talent of Overstory One team. Overstory, perched on the 64th floor of the building, offers cocktails at $24 each, a true reflection of its lofty setting. However, the real sticker shock comes from the restaurant below, making the drinks at Overstory seem like a steal.
Ranked among the top rooftop bars in the city, Overstory provides an unparalleled experience. Securing a table can be a challenge, but the effort is well worth it for a chance to enjoy the breathtaking views and exceptional service. With a bit of patience and advance planning, a reservation at this iconic spot is well within reach.
Ranked among the top rooftop bars in the city, Overstory provides an unparalleled experience. Securing a table can be a challenge, but the effort is well worth it for a chance to enjoy the breathtaking views and exceptional service. With a bit of patience and advance planning, a reservation at this iconic spot is well within reach.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
7. Banzarbar
Nestled in the heart of LES, Level 1 is a cocktail bar par excellence. Set in Freeman Alley, above Freeman Restaurant, its charming boat-themed ambiance sets the stage for an exceptional experience. The skilled bartenders craft a menu of eclectic drinks with precision, while also whipping up custom creations. Without a doubt, this gem ranks high on the list of New York's finest cocktail bars.
Embark on a gastronomic journey at Banzarbar, a unique locale blending whimsy with elegance. An experience unlike any other awaits, where impeccable service and unforgettable moments converge. Leave behind the ordinary and opt for the extraordinary - venture down the enchanting Road to Kerala.
Embark on a gastronomic journey at Banzarbar, a unique locale blending whimsy with elegance. An experience unlike any other awaits, where impeccable service and unforgettable moments converge. Leave behind the ordinary and opt for the extraordinary - venture down the enchanting Road to Kerala.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
8. Peachy's
Known for their Southern comfort food and prohibition-era speakeasy vibe
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
9. J.Bespoke
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Corporate Events
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
10. The Red Stache
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
11. Joyface
Cozy backyard seating, creative cocktails, weekend brunch
Save to a List Website Phone Directions East Village $ $ $ $ Perfect for: First/Early Game Dates Earn 3 points with your Sapphire Card What happens when you place a waterbed in a bar and then complete the setting with a disco ball and a bunch of strangely soft furniture that was probably found at a garage sale in 1983? You get Joyface. When it's Saturday night and you absolutely need to walk in the dark and feel the flickering lights of a disco ball in your face before settling into a decades-old couch, this place should be your number one choice. It's fun. But if you come before 11 p.m. m., you may be the only one here. photo: Briana Balducci
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Happy Hours