Best of 12 bodegas in Carroll Gardens NYC
Bodegas in Carroll Gardens, NYC, are a vital part of the neighborhood's vibrant culture. These small, independently owned convenience stores offer a unique blend of local products, fresh produce, and everyday essentials, creating a distinct shopping experience for residents. As gathering places, bodegas serve as hubs for community interaction, fostering relationships and contributing to the area's welcoming atmosphere. Explore the charm and significance of bodegas in Carroll Gardens, NYC.
1. Scotto's Wine Cellar in Carroll Gardens

Scotto's Wine Cellar is a must-visit destination for any wine enthusiast. The establishment boasts an extensive variety of wines from diverse bodegas, providing a wide range of options to suit every palate. The knowledgeable and friendly staff are always on hand to offer their expertise, ensuring that customers can find the perfect bottle to suit their tastes and budget.
The customer service at Scotto's Wine Cellar is truly outstanding. The staff go above and beyond to ensure that every customer feels welcome and valued. Their attentive and personalized approach creates a warm and inviting atmosphere, making Scotto's Wine Cellar a truly special place to visit. Whether you're a seasoned wine connoisseur or a casual drinker, you're sure to have a fantastic experience at this wonderful wine cellar.
2. Frankies 457 Spuntino
Warm, rustic ambiance with a garden seating

Frankies 457 Spuntino has a warm and welcoming atmosphere, reminiscent of the traditional bodegas found in Spain. This charm is further complemented by exquisite food, with a particular standout being their pasta dishes, which are simply divine.
At Frankies 4
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Social Gatherings
- Celebrations
3. Vinny's

Vinny's, located in Carroll Gardens, offers a unique dining experience with its old-school bodega atmosphere and mouth-watering Italian cuisine. The establishment is a well-kept secret, serving up classic dishes like lasagna and meatballs that are sure to impress.
The charm of a local bodega combined with the warmth of Italian hospitality makes Vinny's a standout destination. Expect to be greeted with friendly service and heaping helpings of Italian favorites, with the baked ziti being a particularly noteworthy dish. Vinny's is a must-visit for anyone looking for an authentic and satisfying taste of Italy in the heart of Carroll Gardens.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Mid-Range
4. Black Mountain Wine House
A popular spot for wine lovers

A cozy and inviting atmosphere can be found at BMWH, particularly during the colder months with the warmth of a fireplace. The truffle mac n cheese and cod topped artichoke are standout dishes, making it an excellent choice for a date night or a casual dinner. The ambiance is not overly crowded or noisy, creating a perfect setting for intimate conversations.
The crostini at BMWH is also worth trying, with three large pieces featuring warm goat cheese center and a crunchy Parmesan crisp. The restaurant maintains a charming and unpretentious ambiance, making it an ideal spot for a relaxed meal with friends or family. Overall, the food and atmosphere make it a worthy dining option for anyone looking for a cozy and enjoyable experience.
5. Gersi
Experience the taste of Italy in Brooklyn

Gersi, a restaurant nestled in Brooklyn, offers a unique and delightful dining experience. Its atmosphere is reminiscent of a cozy bodega, but with an elegant twist that makes it a standout. The food at Gersi is always fresh and skillfully prepared, ensuring a memorable meal for all who visit.
The restaurant's intimate setting and friendly staff create a warm and inviting ambiance. Gersi is the perfect place to enjoy a casual yet refined meal. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely dinner, Gersi is sure to exceed your expectations. The bodega-like charm of the restaurant adds to its appeal, making it a must-visit destination for food lovers in Brooklyn.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
6. Enoteca
Homemade Italian cuisine with a brick oven flavor

Enoteca on Court provides a charming and intimate atmosphere, reminiscent of traditional Italian wine bars. The knowledgeable staff is eager to guide customers through the extensive wine list, offering suggestions and insights to enhance the experience. The food menu features a variety of dishes that pair beautifully with the wines, making it an ideal spot for both wine enthusiasts and foodies.
The wine selection at Enoteca on Court is outstanding, featuring a diverse range of wines from Italy and beyond. The ambiance is warm and inviting, with dim lighting and comfortable seating, creating an ideal setting for a romantic evening or a relaxed night out with friends. Whether you're a seasoned wine drinker or simply looking to expand your palate, Enoteca on Court offers an exceptional wine-tasting experience.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
7. Franks Wine Bar
Remarkable wine list in an idyllic tavern setting

Frank's Wine Bar perfectly captures the essence of a bodega while offering a sophisticated selection of wines and delectable small plates. This establishment has become a must-visit destination in Brooklyn, appealing to both casual drinkers and wine connoisseurs alike. Its welcoming and unpretentious atmosphere makes it an ideal place for visitors and locals seeking a laid-back and enjoyable experience.
At Frank's Wine Bar, the staff members are not only friendly but also incredibly knowledgeable about the extensive wine list. Their expertise enhances visitors' appreciation of the subtleties and complexities within each glass. Whether customers are looking for a full-bodied red or a crisp white, the well-curated wine selection ensures that there is something for every palate. Paired with the enticing array of small plates, Frank's Wine Bar achieves the perfect balance between approachable simplicity and refined elegance.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Hidden Gems
- Dinner
8. Fragole
Homemade food made everyday from scratch

Fragole offers an intimate and cozy setting that is reminiscent of the bodegas found in Italy. The homemade Italian dishes are a standout feature of this establishment, with the gnocchi being a highly recommended dish. Authenticity and quality are at the forefront of Fragole's offerings, making it a go-to spot for anyone seeking a true Italian culinary experience.
The ambiance at Fragole is warm and inviting, evoking memories of quaint Italian bodegas. The staff is attentive and provides excellent service, adding to the overall positive dining experience. The authenticity of the food is unmatched, with each dish skillfully prepared to bring out the true flavors of Italy.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Hidden Gems
- Mid-Range
9. Carroll Gardens Greenmarket

Indulge in the fantastic array of fresh vegetables and all things produce-related at Carroll Gardens Greenmarket. It's the perfect spot to bring the whole family for some quality time in the park. On sun-soaked Sundays, keep an eye out for a vendor offering stylish cotton masks that will keep your loved ones safe. Join the green movement and make Carroll Gardens your destination.
10. Carroll Gardens Wines & Liquor in Carroll Gardens

11. Smith & Vine
Top-notch wine shop with a focus on rare finds

This local wine shop is a true gem for anyone who appreciates a good glass of wine. It offers an impressive selection of wines from smaller producers, providing a unique and diverse range of options. The staff is extremely knowledgeable about the wines they carry and are always eager to share their expertise.
Whether you're a seasoned wine enthusiast or just starting to explore the world of wine, this shop is the perfect place to discover new favorites. The staff were able to help me find wines that met my specific requests and price points with ease, making for a wonderfully curated selection. I was able to walk away with several bottles that I was excited to try, and I can't wait to go back and discover more.
12. Henry Street Wines & Liquors

This wine shop is an ideal location for Italian wine lovers, with a knowledgeable and friendly staff dedicated to providing excellent service. Many customers seem to discover the shop while making reservations at Lucali, as it is a BYOB establishment. On one visit, the staff's assistance was particularly appreciated when selecting two bottles of red wine, perfect for a meal at Lucali.
The employee's product knowledge and eagerness to help made the wine-purchasing experience enjoyable and informative. They offered recommendations based on personal preferences and the type of food to be consumed, ensuring that the selected wines would complement the meal perfectly. Overall, this wine shop is an excellent choice for those looking to enhance their dining experience with top-quality Italian wines and knowledgeable recommendations.