Best of 12 calzones in Sheepshead Bay NYC
Discover our curated list of top-ranked calzones in Sheepshead Bay NYC, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Di Fara Pizza, Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay, Delmar Pizzeria, Lucia Pizza Of Avenue X, V & S. Let's explore together!
1. Di Fara Pizza
Famous for using whole milk mozzarella and fresh basil

Finally, after years of anticipation, I embarked on a pilgrimage to Di Fara in Brooklyn. Although I was disappointed not to be greeted by Maggie, the staff was incredibly warm and welcoming. The restaurant itself is a testament to classic simplicity, exuding an old-school charm that is difficult to find in this modern age. Eager to sample the renowned offerings, I indulged in two pizzas: one traditional and one Detroit-style. Of the two, the traditional pizza stood out, surpassing my expectations with its impeccable flavors and textures. While there may be other establishments that specialize in Detroit-style pizza, Di Fara truly excels in the craft of traditional pies. The crust of the slice I savored was decent, but what truly stole the show was the exquisite tomato sauce that enveloped every bite. Should I find myself in the neighborhood again, I would not hesitate to return to Di Fara, eager to indulge in their timeless creations.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- High-End
- Hidden Gems
2. Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay
Family-owned Italian restaurant with a focus on fresh seafood

Indulge in the mouthwatering cuisine offered at Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay, where every bite is a tantalizing homage to Italian flavors. The portions are generous, leaving you feeling completely satisfied. Whether it's a plate of delectable pasta or a sumptuous main course, each dish is sure to leave a lasting impression. The service is unmatched, with waitstaff who exude fun and friendliness, adding to the overall enjoyment of your dining experience. Come and discover the true taste of Italy at Patrizia's Of Sheepshead Bay, where quality, quantity, and exceptional service are always on the menu.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
- Dinner
3. Delmar Pizzeria
Family-owned business since 1965, using original recipes

Paragraph 2: As someone who lived just a door down from Delmar Pizzeria, it's safe to say that their pizza holds a special place in my heart. They have faithfully kept the same recipe for decades, ensuring that every slice is a taste of nostalgia. But they haven't stopped there – Delmar Pizzeria is also known for their Alfredo portion, which is nothing short of outstanding. It's probably the best Alfredo pizza I've had anywhere, and the option to order half regular and half Alfredo is a delicious twist. Whether you're a long-time neighborhood resident or just passing through, Delmar Pizzeria is a must-visit for all pizza enthusiasts.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Dinner
Relate link
4. Lucia Pizza Of Avenue X
Family-owned pizzeria serving Brooklyn since 1959

I must say, this is hands down the best pizza I've had in a long time. The crust is perfection itself, with the dough, sauce, and cheese harmoniously balanced. We tried the vodka pizza and grandma's pizza, both of which were exceptional. Every bite is a burst of flavors that will leave you craving for more. Don't miss out on this extraordinary pizza experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
5. V & S
Fresh seafood flown in daily, Waterfront dining with stunning views

TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
6. La Casa Mia
Authentic Italian cuisine in a family-owned trattoria

This pizzeria is more than just amazing; it is a culinary experience that showcases the freshest and most delicious flavors. Whenever I visit New York, I make sure to grab a vodka pizza pie from La Casa Mia, freeze it, and take it back home to Dallas. I can't help but think that Dallas is missing out on this incredible pizzeria, and I sincerely hope they expand their reach to Texas soon.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
7. N & D Pizza East 29
Long-standing family-owned business with a loyal customer base

Now, let's talk about their specialty pizza slices. Worth every penny, these slices are a culinary delight. Even when reheated the next day, they maintain their flavor and tastiness. My secret tip is to place them in a resealable bag overnight to preserve their freshness. Trust me, you won't be disappointed. N & D Pizza East 29 is a must-visit for all pizza lovers out there.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
8. Sofia Pizza
Family-owned business since 1973, known for their thin-crust pizza

TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
9. Luigi's Pizzeria
Serving Brooklyn since 1977 with authentic Italian-style pizzas

TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
10. J&M Pizza II
Family-owned pizzeria serving Brooklyn for over 20 years

TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
11. Backyard Pizza Cafe

TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
12. Papa Johns Pizza
Offers loyalty program and special discounts for online orders

TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Dinner
- Social Gatherings