Best of 11 Sandwiches restaurants in Prospect-Lefferts Gardens NYC
Discover the top-notch "Sandwiches restaurants in Prospect-Lefferts Gardens NYC," where artisanal bread, fresh ingredients, and creative flavor combinations reign. These local gems offer a tantalizing variety of sandwiches, from classic deli-style to globally inspired, making them a must-visit for sandwich connoisseurs and casual diners alike in Prospect-Lefferts Gardens, NYC.
- 1. Moe's Pastrami & Burger
- 2. Habib1deli
- 3. NOSTRAND FOOD CORP
- 4. Bonafini in Prospect-Lefferts Gardens
- 5. Prospect Deli and smokeshop
- 6. Edie Jo’s
- 7. PLG Coffee House and Tavern
- 8. Defonte's Sandwich Shop
- 9. Ix Restaurant
- 10. Mama Louisa's Hero Shoppe in Prospect-Lefferts Gardens
- 11. Prospect Gardens Deli & Grill Corp
1. Moe's Pastrami & Burger
Authentic deli experience with a modern twist.

The pastrami at this establishment is truly exceptional. It is described as delicious, with a perfect balance of seasoning and flavor. The pastrami is also consistently juicy and succulent, making it a true standout among other dishes on the menu. The restaurant offers a pastrami sandwich that is highly recommended, with the option to have it served on toasted rye bread for added texture and flavor.
In addition to the pastrami sandwich, the restaurant's sandwich selection is solid and varied. The chicken sandwich is also highly rated, with a great balance of flavors and ingredients. The sandwiches are consistently tasty and well-made, making this a great spot for sandwich lovers looking for a satisfying meal. Whether you're in the mood for pastrami or something else, this restaurant is sure to have a sandwich that will hit the spot.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
2. Habib1deli
Delicious sandwiches and smoothies for a healthy start!

A sandwich from Habib 1 Deli was thoroughly enjoyed today. The establishment was clean and welcoming, and the staff members behind the counter were friendly and professional. They prioritized safety by insisting on mask-wearing, even asking a customer to leave for failing to comply. It's surprising that after living in the area for many years, this deli was overlooked, but it has now earned a spot as a top contender for favorite local bodega.
With a rating of 4.3 and 415 reviews, Habib 1 Deli has proven its quality. Customers rave about the tasty food and timely delivery. Impressively, 96% of orders are delivered on schedule, and 90% of orders are correct, which demonstrates remarkable attention to detail and efficiency. Sandwiches from this deli are truly a hidden gem in the neighborhood, and it's no wonder they've gained such a positive reputation among locals.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
3. NOSTRAND FOOD CORP

The past year may have been challenging, but Nostrand Food Corp has been a constant source of comfort and sustenance for many. The consistent quality of their food and the exceptional service provided by their hardworking staff have made this place a cherished spot for locals. It's more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a place that has become a second home for many. As you indulge in their delicious offerings, take a moment to appreciate the grill guy, whose dedication adds that special touch. And if you find yourself needing cash, there's an ATM conveniently available. The cellar cat, with its playful presence, adds to the charm of this place. While alcohol is not served, they now offer cigarettes and vaporizers for those looking for a different kind of indulgence. So whether you choose to call ahead or simply show up and wait, Nostrand Food Corp is ready to serve you with open arms.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
- Dinner
4. Bonafini in Prospect-Lefferts Gardens
Brick oven pizzas, extensive wine list

A delightful and satisfying breakfast experience is highly recommended. The pancake stood out with its fluffy and tender texture, perfectly golden brown, and served with a generous amount of syrup. The breakfast sandwich, another impressive dish, featured fresh and perfectly cooked ingredients. The bread was toasted to perfection, while the egg was cooked just right, and the savory taste of the meat and cheese complemented each other well.
The food presentation was visually appealing, with a harmonious arrangement of colors and textures. The service was attentive and efficient, with the staff regularly checking on guests and ensuring they had a pleasant dining experience. The ambiance was cozy and welcoming, making it an ideal place for a relaxing breakfast. Whether you're in the mood for a sweet or savory breakfast, this establishment has you covered, delivering nothing but top-notch dishes that are sure to satisfy your cravings.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
5. Prospect Deli and smokeshop

At Prospect Deli and Smokeshop, they aim to create a comfortable and judgment-free environment. So, whether you're searching for smoking accessories or other paraphernalia, you'll find it all here. This place raises a thought-provoking question: do we need to evolve the way we talk about these items? Can we have open conversations about our needs without fear of judgment or miscommunication? Visit Prospect Deli and Smokeshop and discover a space where you can find what you need and explore these intriguing thoughts.
TOPICS
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Late Night
6. Edie Jo’s
Neighborhood bar and café with a cozy ambiance.

For food enthusiasts seeking a delectable and satisfying meal, the fried chicken sandwich with fries is highly recommended. The chicken is expertly prepared, resulting in a delightful combination of crispy exterior and juicy interior that leaves taste buds craving more. The fries are equally impressive, featuring a perfect balance of seasoning that enhances their flavor without overpowering the palate.
Alternatively, the bacon egg & cheese sandwich with a side salad is an excellent choice for those seeking a hearty yet nutritious meal. The sandwich boasts a satisfying combination of flavors and textures, with the savory taste of bacon complementing the creamy texture of the egg and cheese. The side salad is equally impressive, featuring fresh and crisp greens that serve as the perfect accompaniment to the sandwich. Overall, this establishment is an excellent spot for a quick and delicious bite to eat.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
7. PLG Coffee House and Tavern
A cozy spot with organic, locally-sourced ingredients.

PLG Coffee House and Tavern has made a name for itself with its top-notch sandwiches. From The Club to The Farm System, each option is consistently delicious and has become a favorite among locals. The sandwich menu offers a wide range of options catering to various tastes and preferences, ensuring there is something for everyone.
Anyone who has visited PLG Coffee House and Tavern can attest to the quality of their sandwiches. For instance, the Turkey Avocado is a phenomenal choice, bursting with fresh and wholesome flavors with every bite. It's unsurprising that patrons keep coming back for more – the remarkable quality of the food speaks for itself.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
8. Defonte's Sandwich Shop
Iconic deli sandwiches since 1922.

The long-awaited family reunion finally took place, and to our delight, we were greeted with delicious sandwiches from Defonte's. We couldn't have been happier with their selection - the corned beef special with hot chilies was a standout, perfectly seasoned and with a delightful kick. The eggplant and roast beef sandwiches were also exceptional, bursting with flavor and sure to satisfy any appetite. It's clear that Defonte's takes pride in their homemade ingredients and attention to detail.
In stark contrast to the many trendy eateries that have popped up across Brooklyn, Defonte's is a rare gem that harkens back to a simpler time. It's not interested in following the latest culinary fads or catering to niche diets - instead, it focuses on serving up hearty sandwiches made with high-quality ingredients. With its old-school charm and commitment to excellence, Defonte's has earned its reputation as a beloved neighborhood institution. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Italian hero or something a little more adventurous, Defonte's is sure to deliver a memorable meal.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
Relate link
9. Ix Restaurant
Authentic Guatemalan flavors with a gourmet twist.

Ix Restaurant offers a distinctive dining experience, with generous and fulfilling options that include delectable hot figs and an assortment of soups. Among their offerings are the Green Eggs and Cheese Sandwich and the Cubano Sandwich, both of which are highly favored by patrons.
The Belleza Sandwich, featuring pork belly, kimchi, sesame, arugula and Sriracha mayo on ciabatta, is a mouthwatering combination of flavors and textures. It arrives accompanied by a fresh salad. Another standout option is the Number 1 Sandwich, showcasing turkey, bacon, avocado, arugula and rocoto aioli on sourdough, also served with a crisp salad.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Affordable Nightlife
10. Mama Louisa's Hero Shoppe in Prospect-Lefferts Gardens
Beloved neighborhood gem with impressive 3ft hoagies.

The Chicken Parmigiana Hero and Italian Combo Hero at this establishment have garnered a strong following among customers. The freshness of the ingredients is consistently praised, as is the warm and welcoming service provided by the staff. These heroes are frequently commended for their delicious taste and satisfying portion size, making them a popular choice for regulars and newcomers alike.
One reviewer went so far as to describe the Artichoke Parm sandwich as 'life-changing', citing the exquisite balance of flavors and textures as a standout feature. The quality of the ingredients and the care taken in crafting each sandwich is evident in the rave reviews this dish consistently receives. Whether you're a fan of classic favorites or adventurous flavor combinations, this establishment has a hero sandwich that is sure to delight.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
11. Prospect Gardens Deli & Grill Corp

TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Asian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Dinner