Best of 12 themed bars in Randall's Island NYC
Discover our curated list of top-ranked themed bars in Randall's Island NYC, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Connolly's, Bathtub Gin, Jimmy's Corner, Surf Bar, Rao's. Let's explore together!
Toc
1. Connolly's
Historic building with a rich past
Indulge your senses at Connolly's, where a tantalizing array of global flavors awaits beyond the Irish-inspired name. From mouthwatering dishes to flavorful drinks, this gem caters to diverse palates with its eclectic menu. Ascend to the charming rooftop space, offering a cozy ambiance despite its limited street view. Our repeated visits during our nearby stay were a testament to the delightful experience – a harmonious blend of great food and a vibrant atmosphere that kept us coming back for more.
TOPICS
- Corporate Events
- Celebrations
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
2. Bathtub Gin
Hidden behind a coffee shop facade, unique gin selection
Immerse yourself in the allure of Bathtub Gin, a sophisticated speakeasy where tradition meets innovation. Step into a bygone era, where a copper bathtub takes center stage amidst the intimate ambiance. Delight your palate with meticulously crafted cocktails by rising stars in the mixology scene, boasting unique concoctions like the refreshing West Side and the indulgent Jazz Age. As you sip on these liquid works of art, savor the delectable comfort food offerings that complement the experience perfectly.
Tucked away behind the facade of a store lies a hidden gem that transports you to the roaring '20s. With an ambiance steeped in nostalgia and waitstaff dressed to the nines, this speakeasy exudes charm and sophistication. Explore their extensive gin collection hailing from around the globe, with gems like the exquisite Blue Gin from Austria waiting to be savored. While the old-fashioned s'mores make for a sweet treat, it's the impeccable service and expertly curated drinks that truly steal the show, offering a memorable experience for aficionados and novices alike.
Tucked away behind the facade of a store lies a hidden gem that transports you to the roaring '20s. With an ambiance steeped in nostalgia and waitstaff dressed to the nines, this speakeasy exudes charm and sophistication. Explore their extensive gin collection hailing from around the globe, with gems like the exquisite Blue Gin from Austria waiting to be savored. While the old-fashioned s'mores make for a sweet treat, it's the impeccable service and expertly curated drinks that truly steal the show, offering a memorable experience for aficionados and novices alike.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
3. Jimmy's Corner
Cash-only policy and no frills atmosphere
Nestled just a stone's throw away from the hustle and bustle of Times Square, Jimmy's Corner exudes an irresistible charm that transports visitors to a bygone era of historic New York. Managed by the iconic Jimmy and Swannie, the bar doubles as a living tribute to Jimmy's illustrious career as a boxing trainer, adorned with memorabilia that paints a vivid picture of yesteryear. Regulars and newcomers alike are drawn to the magnetic allure of this hidden gem, immersing themselves in the nostalgia of a simpler time.
Renowned as Manhattan's ultimate dive bar, Jimmy's Corner stands out as a beacon of authenticity and character in a city teeming with trendy alternatives. Garnering acclaim from even the most discerning of critics, this establishment has carved out a reputation that precedes it. Step inside to experience a slice of unadulterated Americana, where the prices are refreshingly down-to-earth, beckoning patrons to unwind, relax, and revel in the unassuming allure of this quintessential New York watering hole.
Renowned as Manhattan's ultimate dive bar, Jimmy's Corner stands out as a beacon of authenticity and character in a city teeming with trendy alternatives. Garnering acclaim from even the most discerning of critics, this establishment has carved out a reputation that precedes it. Step inside to experience a slice of unadulterated Americana, where the prices are refreshingly down-to-earth, beckoning patrons to unwind, relax, and revel in the unassuming allure of this quintessential New York watering hole.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Cheap Eats
4. Surf Bar
Unique atmosphere with a rooftop bar and lively events
Tucked away in Brooklyn is a delightful surprise - a surf bar that transports you to a tropical paradise. Despite the cold outside, the warm and fun atmosphere inside makes you feel right at home, with sand under your feet! While some may find the portions a tad small for the price tag, the eclectic menu with dishes like crab cakes, ceviche, and tuna tartare cooked to perfection more than make up for it. The friendly host and outdoor seating on the patio at the rear add to the charm of this beach-like haven.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mexican Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
5. Rao's
Family-owned, famous for generations-old recipes
Rao's is a legendary Italian restaurant, notorious for its exclusivity and elusive reservations. Tucked away in East Harlem, this culinary gem caters to a select group of A-list patrons. Stepping inside is like entering a culinary time capsule, with cherished family recipes and star-studded memories adorning the walls. Securing a coveted table at this cozy establishment is a near-impossible feat, unless you have a well-placed connection or stumble upon a stroke of luck.
Dining at Rao's is a privilege that few are fortunate enough to experience, making each visit a truly unforgettable affair. From the tantalizing Meatball to the exquisite Fish Salad, every dish is a testament to the restaurant's unparalleled culinary prowess. With Rao's, it's not just about making a reservation; it's about gaining access to an exclusive dining club, where the food is as exceptional as the company.
Dining at Rao's is a privilege that few are fortunate enough to experience, making each visit a truly unforgettable affair. From the tantalizing Meatball to the exquisite Fish Salad, every dish is a testament to the restaurant's unparalleled culinary prowess. With Rao's, it's not just about making a reservation; it's about gaining access to an exclusive dining club, where the food is as exceptional as the company.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- High-End
- Downtown Spots
6. Garfunkel's
Spacious outdoor seating with great city views
Garfunkel's in the Lower East Side offers a captivating experience with live jazz, top-notch whiskey, and a speakeasy vibe. Uncover this hidden gem in East Village, where you enter through a normal bar before being led to the secret back entrance. Accessible through a Vault door on Burgary Street, this speakeasy intrigues visitors with its late-night entry process that involves ringing a bell outside.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
7. Trailer Park Lounge
Unique dining experience with a quirky atmosphere
Trailer Park Lounge is a delightfully quirky gem for a fun night out. The friendly staff, amazing drinks, and delicious food create a unique charm. The limited menu adds to the appeal, making it a must-visit spot for a late-night snack.
With its adorably kitschy vibe, Trailer Park Lounge is the perfect place to unwind with drinks and tasty treats. The chiquitines loaded with chili were a crunchy, meaty delight that perfectly complemented the refreshing PBRs. This hidden gem is a must-visit for those seeking a one-of-a-kind experience in the city.
With its adorably kitschy vibe, Trailer Park Lounge is the perfect place to unwind with drinks and tasty treats. The chiquitines loaded with chili were a crunchy, meaty delight that perfectly complemented the refreshing PBRs. This hidden gem is a must-visit for those seeking a one-of-a-kind experience in the city.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Dinner
- Late Night
8. Full Circle Bar
Rotating craft beers, unique decor, live music events
Looking for a unique bar experience in Brooklyn, NY? Look no further than Full Circle Bar on Grand St. With over 40 varieties of beer, including national league skeeball competitions, this spot offers a fun and lively atmosphere for both day and evening crowds. Enjoy the simplicity of their well-executed bar menu, along with the option to control your own drinks selection via their website. And the best part? Free delicious hot dogs with your drinks! Don't miss out on their happy hour specials Monday through Thursday from 4 to 7 p.m.
Full Circle Bar in Brooklyn is not your average watering hole—it's a hotspot for beer enthusiasts and skeeball aficionados alike. You'll love the friendly bartenders who whip up everything from classic cocktails to innovative concoctions. With clean bathrooms, good prices, and a laid-back vibe, it's the perfect place to unwind with friends. Challenge each other to a round of skeeball at one of their four stations, and enjoy the cheap drinks while you're at it. Whether you're flying solo or with a group, Full Circle Bar promises a memorable night out.
Full Circle Bar in Brooklyn is not your average watering hole—it's a hotspot for beer enthusiasts and skeeball aficionados alike. You'll love the friendly bartenders who whip up everything from classic cocktails to innovative concoctions. With clean bathrooms, good prices, and a laid-back vibe, it's the perfect place to unwind with friends. Challenge each other to a round of skeeball at one of their four stations, and enjoy the cheap drinks while you're at it. Whether you're flying solo or with a group, Full Circle Bar promises a memorable night out.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Corporate Events
- American Cuisine
- Dinner
9. La Caverna
Extensive wine list and unique atmosphere
La Caverna is an absolute gem, exuding a unique atmosphere that truly transports you into a mystical cave-like setting. With a diverse selection of delicious food options to choose from, it's a culinary adventure waiting to be explored. The standout, though, is undeniably their exceptional coffee, a true delight for any coffee enthusiast. A return visit is not just a possibility but a certainty, beckoning with the promise of another unforgettable experience.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Chinese Cuisine
- High-End
- Dinner
10. Boobie Trap
Quirky decor and entertaining theme nights
Step into the Boobie Trap and get ready for a unique atmosphere that is truly one-of-a-kind. Immerse yourself in a world of old school board games, complemented by a selection of reasonably priced drinks that will keep you going all night long. The clever and comical signs scattered throughout the venue add an extra element of fun to your experience, making every moment a memorable one.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
11. Bar SixtyFive at Rainbow Room
Historic Art Deco setting, unforgettable Rockefeller Center location
Bar SixtyFive at Rainbow Room is an affordable option to admire the New York Skyline. With views of Central Park and downtown landmarks like the Empire State Building and One World Trade Center, it offers a unique perspective that won't break the bank.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Rooftop
- Happy Hours
12. La Noxe
Offers a unique fusion of French and Japanese cuisine
Introducing the latest sensation in New York City's speakeasy world - La Noxe. Despite being a newcomer, this hidden gem has quickly gained a reputation for its exclusivity and mystery. Tucked away inside the 28th Street subway station, finding this covert hotspot requires navigating through a series of secret passages. However, with a lengthy queue of eager patrons, gaining entry may prove to be a challenging feat in the near future.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
- Corporate Events