Best of 13 pizza places in Midtown NYC

Discover our curated list of top-ranked pizza places in Midtown NYC, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Don Antonio, Uncle Paul's Pizza NY, Best Pizza, Fresh Pizza, Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza. Let's explore together!

Toc

1. Little Italy Pizza

Family-owned and operated for over 30 years, Fresh ingredients, Delicious homemade sauce

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (3585 Review by google)
  • Address:

    2 E 33rd St, New York, NY 10016, United States

  • Pros:

    Central location in Manhattan, Wide variety of pizza options, Fast and friendly service
  • Cons:

    Limited seating, Can be crowded during peak hours, Some dishes may be greasy
  • Popular Menu:

    New York-style pizza, Calzones, Garlic knots
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website
Indulge in the best pizza you'll ever taste in New York - it even surpasses the offerings of Rome, Italy! The secret lies in the expertly crafted crust, which boasts a delightful crunch that elevates the entire slice-eating experience. Each ingredient in this culinary masterpiece has been carefully selected by George himself, ensuring a symphony of flavors that will leave you truly satisfied. But don't just take my word for it - come and try it for yourself! Our menu offers a wide range of options to cater to every taste, and our friendly staff will make sure your dining experience is nothing short of exceptional. From classic pepperoni to more adventurous combinations like pepperoni and jalapenos, we have something for everyone. And don't forget to try our mouthwatering garlic knots too! You won't regret it.

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Happy Hours
  • Late Night

2. Uncle Paul's Pizza NY

Serving the community for over 20 years

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (2176 Review by google)
  • Address:

    70 Vanderbilt Ave, New York, NY 10017, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of pizzas, friendly service, delivery and takeout options
  • Cons:

    Prices slightly higher than average, limited seating, can be busy during peak hours
  • Popular Menu:

    New York-style pizza, specialty pies, calzones
  • Price Range:

    $15-$30
Phone Directions Website
Experience the taste of New York City right here at Uncle Paul's Pizza NY. Every bite of our perfectly chewy, chewy crust topped with creative and delicious toppings will transport you to the streets of the Big Apple. Indulge in the ultimate pizza experience, where quality and flavor are never compromised. Come and join us for a slice of pizza that will leave you craving more. Don't miss out on the chance to taste the authentic flavors of New York City at Uncle Paul's Pizza NY.
Step into a world of pizza perfection at Uncle Paul's Pizza NY, conveniently located near Grand Central. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite before catching a train or in need of a delicious meal, our great little pizza place is the go-to spot. Prepare to be blown away by how good our pizza is. From the amazing crust to the mouthwatering toppings, each bite is a heavenly experience. When you're in the city center, Uncle Paul's Pizza NY is the place to be. Come and discover why we have quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Cheap Eats

3. Don Antonio

Authentic New York-style pizzeria with a lively atmosphere

  • Time:

    11:30 AM to 10 PM

  • Rating: 4.6/5 (1018 Review by google)
  • Address:

    309 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/donantoniopizza
  • Pros:

    Central location, Wide variety of pizzas, Generous serving sizes
  • Cons:

    Some pizzas may be too greasy for some, Service can be slow during peak hours, Limited vegan/vegetarian options
  • Popular Menu:

    Margherita pizza, Pepperoni pizza, Fried calamari
  • Price Range:

    $15 - $30
Phone Directions Website
Experience the tantalizing flavors of Don Antonio, where wood-fired pizzas take center stage. Indulge in the truffle burrata and classic Margherita varieties, expertly crafted to perfection. As you savor every bite, immerse yourself in the vibrant atmosphere, surrounded by locals and savvy tourists who have discovered this hidden gem. Enhance your dining experience with a selection of Italian beers and handcrafted cocktails that set Don Antonio apart from your regular slice shop. With its irresistible combination of flavors and inviting ambiance, Don Antonio is sure to leave a lasting impression.
Prepare to be blown away as you step into Don Antonio, the ultimate destination for pizza enthusiasts. Immerse yourself in the narrow theater district and step inside this brick oven pizzeria that exudes authenticity. Though the space may be cozy, it's filled with the aroma of freshly baked 12-inch pizzas that captivate your senses. Sink your teeth into the Neapolitan sausage Margherita and peppers pizza, bursting with savory flavors. Complement your meal with a delectable salad featuring beet and orange dressing, expertly prepared by our culinary experts. The friendly staff ensures prompt service, delivering your culinary delights with a smile. Don't miss out on this gastronomic haven - make your way to Don Antonio and prepare to be wowed!

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Pasta restaurants in Midtown NYC

4. Angelo's Pizza

Open late, Classic pizzeria atmosphere, Hand-tossed dough

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (2012 Review by google)
  • Address:

    1697 Broadway, New York, NY 10019, United States

  • Pros:

    Central location, Wide variety of pizzas, Friendly staff
  • Cons:

    Can get crowded, Limited seating, No delivery service
  • Popular Menu:

    New York-style pizza, Specialty slices, Garlic knots
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website
Angelo's Pizza truly exceeded our expectations! From the moment we stepped in, we were greeted with a beautifully decorated space that resembled a high-end Italian restaurant. Despite the fancy ambiance, we were pleasantly surprised by the speed of service. The square pizza topped with meatballs and onions was absolutely divine - the best brick oven pizza we've ever had! And that's not all, the thin round pizza with pineapple and ham was a delightful combination of flavors. We also couldn't resist trying the Insalata di Arugula, which turned out to be an absolute winner. The whole dining experience at Angelo's Pizza was nothing short of magnificent, with impeccable service adding to the overall satisfaction.

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Mid-Range

Relate link

BYOB restaurants in Midtown NYC

5. Vezzo NYC Thin Crust Pizza

Authentic NY-style pizza, made fresh daily

  • Time:

    11:30 AM to 9:30 PM

  • Rating: 4.5/5 (1603 Review by google)
  • Address:

    178 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/nycthincrust/
  • Pros:

    Thin crust pizza, fast delivery, friendly service
  • Cons:

    Limited seating, can be crowded, cash-only
  • Popular Menu:

    Margherita pizza, pepperoni pizza, veggie pizza
  • Price Range:

    $10-$30
Phone Directions Website
During our trip to New York, the children were craving thin crust pizza, and I decided to give Vezzo NYC a try for lunch. As we settled in and sipped on our drinks, the waiter provided us with a detailed explanation of the various options available. Not only did the ambiance exude a pleasant vibe, but they also had a stylish bar area to match.
I opted for their lasagna, which turned out to be an absolute delight. The service was top-notch, and to top it all off, the restaurant is located in a charming neighborhood with the option for relaxing window or outside seating. It truly offers a cozy and rustic ambiance, making it feel like a home away from home.

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots
  • Dinner

Relate link

happy hours in Midtown NYC

6. My Pie Pizzeria Romana

Voted one of the best pizza places in New York

  • Time:

    10:30 AM to 8:30 PM

  • Rating: 4.7/5 (1289 Review by google)
  • Address:

    690 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10022, United States

  • Pros:

    Lively atmosphere, authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, extensive wine list
  • Cons:

    Limited seating, can get crowded during peak hours, expensive for the location
  • Popular Menu:

    Margherita pizza, Prosciutto e Arugula pizza, Bianca pizza
  • Price Range:

    $15 - $30
Phone Directions Website
My Pie Pizzeria Romana offers fast and friendly service, serving delicious pizza at fair prices. The highlight of their menu is the Roma-style square pizza, which boasts a crispy bottom and a chewy, yet not doughy, top. It is truly a must-try! This pizzeria stands out as the best in the area, with an amazing crust, flavorful sauce, and a wide range of options at reasonable prices. Despite its small size, the place is always bustling with customers, thanks to its efficient and quick service. I personally tried the sun-dried tomato slice and found it to be absolutely delicious. With so many enticing choices available, it's hard to decide which one to try next!

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

bread pudding in Midtown NYC

7. Joe G Pizza & Restaurant

Authentic New York-style pizza and Italian cuisine in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (512 Review by google)
  • Address:

    244 W 56th St, New York, NY 10019, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of pizzas and Italian dishes, convenient location in Midtown Manhattan, offers both indoor and outdoor seating
  • Cons:

    Prices can be on the higher side, service can be slow during peak hours, some dishes may be too greasy for some customers
  • Popular Menu:

    Margherita pizza, lasagna, chicken parmigiana
  • Price Range:

    $20-$40 per person
Phone Directions Website
Joe G Pizza & Restaurant offers a truly unique dining experience that stands out in a crowded market. As soon as you step foot inside, you're met with a warm and inviting atmosphere that effortlessly blends comfort with sophistication. The moment you walk through the door, you'll know you're in for something special.
Oh my goodness, this place is absolutely incredible! The food is simply divine, bursting with freshness and authenticity. And the service? It's truly top-notch, the best I've ever experienced in New York. The restaurant itself is charming and cozy, making it the perfect spot for a memorable meal. Trust me, you won't want to miss out on this gem. I'm already planning my return visit for tomorrow.

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots
  • Dinner

8. Fresh Pizza

Family-owned pizzeria since 1987

  • Time:

    10 AM to 4 AM

  • Rating: 4.0/5 (465 Review by google)
  • Address:

    1032 6th Ave, New York, NY 10018, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of pizzas, Friendly service, Convenient location in Manhattan
  • Cons:

    Prices slightly higher than average, Limited seating, Parking can be difficult
  • Popular Menu:

    Margherita Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Sicilian Pizza
  • Price Range:

    $15 - $30
Phone Directions Website

71 2nd Avenue - East Village As the Walmart of dollar pizza slices, you won't go here for the atmosphere or an unforgettable slice of cheese pizza. However, it's perfect when you're in a pinch and craving some basic sauce, dough, and mozzarella to satisfy that grumpy stomach. Look for the big red signs in the West Village, Hell's Kitchen, Midtown East and more.


TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots

9. Best Pizza

Handcrafted, locally-sourced ingredients

  • Time:

    10 AM to 10:45 PM

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (189 Review by google)
  • Address:

    1038 1st Ave., New York, NY 10022, United States

  • Pros:

    Delicious pizza varieties, cozy atmosphere, excellent service
  • Cons:

    Limited seating, can get crowded, expensive for the area
  • Popular Menu:

    Margherita pizza, pepperoni pizza, caprese salad
  • Price Range:

    $20-$30 per person
Phone Directions Website

With the addition of Best Pizza, Williamsburg finally got what it was missing: a pizzeria considered one of the best in New York City. Although the pizzeria is fairly new, it looks like your mom and dad used to frequent it. But then when you see the hipsters, the kale, and hear the music, you'll realize that Best Pizza is as hip as it gets. There's a loving feeling here that will grab you and make your mushroom, caramelized onion, and extra cheese pizza feel like the comfort food you've always been missing. Just as the name suggests, Best Pizza will be one of the best you've ever had! Where: 33 Havemeyer Street, Brooklyn (Williamsburg) View this post on Instagram A post shared by Prince St. Pizza NYC (@psp_nyc)


TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots

10. New Times Square Pizza LLC

Established in 1994, known for its classic New York-style pizza

  • Time:

    9:30 AM to 3 AM

  • Rating: 4.1/5 (217 Review by google)
  • Address:

    236 W 40th St, New York, NY 10018, United States

  • Pros:

    Central location in Times Square, Late-night delivery available, Generous slices and toppings
  • Cons:

    Can be crowded, Limited seating available, Prices slightly higher than some competitors
  • Popular Menu:

    New York-style pizza, Specialty slices such aswhite spinach and Margherita, Salads and calzones
  • Price Range:

    $3-$5 for a slice, $20-$30 for a large pie
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots
  • Cheap Eats

Relate link

fast food restaurants in Midtown NYC

11. USA Brooklyn Delicatessen

Long-standing NYC institution for deli fare

  • Time:

    7 AM to 8 PM

  • Rating: 4.1/5 (174 Review by google)
  • Address:

    200 W 57th St, New York, NY 10019, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/brooklyndelicatessen/
  • Pros:

    Wide variety of classic deli sandwiches, Competitive prices for high-quality ingredients, Convenient midtown location
  • Cons:

    Small seating area, Can get crowded during peak hours, Limited vegetarian options
  • Popular Menu:

    Pastrami on rye, Corned beef sandwich, Matzo ball soup
  • Price Range:

    $10-$20
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Budget-Friendly Eats

Relate link

egg sandwich in Midtown NYC

12. NYC Pizza

Phone Directions

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots
  • Dinner

Relate link

Tuna restaurants in Midtown NYC