Best of 14 bars in City Island NYC
City Island, NYC, is a quaint seaside destination offering a unique blend of small-town charm and urban sophistication. Among the various attractions, "bars in City Island NYC" are popular hotspots for both locals and tourists alike. These establishments provide a welcoming atmosphere, diverse drink selections, and frequently host live music events, making them a must-visit for any itinerary. Whether you're seeking a relaxed evening or a lively night out, "bars in City Island NYC" cater to a wide range of tastes and preferences.
Toc
- 1. The Snug
- 2. Fella's Bar & Grill
- 3. Archie's Tap & Table
- 4. City Island Lobster House in City Island
- 5. Tony's Pier
- 6. The Black Whale
- 7. Man Overboard Bar
- 8. Paddy's On The Island
- 9. Johnny's Reef
- 10. Sammy's Fish Box
- 11. Sea Shore Restaurant
- 12. Vistamar
- 13. Portofino Restaurant in City Island
- 14. The Ice Rotisserie and Kitchens and Rooms in City Island
1. The Snug
Friendly service and laid-back vibes, perfect local hangout.
__NEW TEXT__
The Snug, a local bar on City Island, is a wonderful spot to spend an evening. The welcoming atmosphere, created by the friendly staff and owners, ensures that all guests feel at home. It's a great place to socialize, meet new people, and enjoy a variety of sporting events. Many visitors, including those with university-aged children in New York, find themselves returning to The Snug for dinner or drinks during their stay.
Upon entering The Snug, one is immediately struck by the cozy environment and extensive selection of spirits and local beers. The knowledgeable and sociable staff engage patrons in conversations about the local community and even compare life on City Island to other coastal towns, creating a warm and connected atmosphere for all to enjoy. Whether you're looking for a place to unwind with a drink or seeking a new favorite local watering hole, The Snug is sure to please.
The Snug, a local bar on City Island, is a wonderful spot to spend an evening. The welcoming atmosphere, created by the friendly staff and owners, ensures that all guests feel at home. It's a great place to socialize, meet new people, and enjoy a variety of sporting events. Many visitors, including those with university-aged children in New York, find themselves returning to The Snug for dinner or drinks during their stay.
Upon entering The Snug, one is immediately struck by the cozy environment and extensive selection of spirits and local beers. The knowledgeable and sociable staff engage patrons in conversations about the local community and even compare life on City Island to other coastal towns, creating a warm and connected atmosphere for all to enjoy. Whether you're looking for a place to unwind with a drink or seeking a new favorite local watering hole, The Snug is sure to please.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Waterfront
- Happy Hours
- Late Night
2. Fella's Bar & Grill
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Waterfront
Relate link
3. Archie's Tap & Table
Community restaurant with fresh seafood and gourmet dishes
__NEW TEXT__
Archie's, a new addition to City Island, offers a fresh and exciting dining experience that the area has been lacking. One-of-a-kind on the island, Archie's boasts an upscale New York City vibe with a relaxed atmosphere that allows the delicious food to take center stage. During both brunch and dinner services, the staff is attentive, and the tap selection showcases an impressive variety of beers.
Archie's has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike, thanks to its unique ambiance and mouthwatering menu options. The restaurant's atmosphere is laid-back yet welcoming, with an attractive interior design that enhances the dining experience. Guests can enjoy a selection of excellent beers on tap while savoring the truly delicious food. The knowledgeable and friendly server adds to the overall positive experience.
Archie's, a new addition to City Island, offers a fresh and exciting dining experience that the area has been lacking. One-of-a-kind on the island, Archie's boasts an upscale New York City vibe with a relaxed atmosphere that allows the delicious food to take center stage. During both brunch and dinner services, the staff is attentive, and the tap selection showcases an impressive variety of beers.
Archie's has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike, thanks to its unique ambiance and mouthwatering menu options. The restaurant's atmosphere is laid-back yet welcoming, with an attractive interior design that enhances the dining experience. Guests can enjoy a selection of excellent beers on tap while savoring the truly delicious food. The knowledgeable and friendly server adds to the overall positive experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
4. City Island Lobster House in City Island
Famous for fresh seafood and waterfront views.
__NEW TEXT__
A visit to the ocean's edge, sipping on a premier martini, and indulging in fresh seafood create an unbeatable experience. The atmosphere is serene and inviting, perfect for a relaxing evening.
The service at this establishment is commendable, with staff who are attentive and friendly. The food offerings are top-notch, especially the seafood dishes, which are a highlight of the menu. This City Island location is a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable dining experience.
A visit to the ocean's edge, sipping on a premier martini, and indulging in fresh seafood create an unbeatable experience. The atmosphere is serene and inviting, perfect for a relaxing evening.
The service at this establishment is commendable, with staff who are attentive and friendly. The food offerings are top-notch, especially the seafood dishes, which are a highlight of the menu. This City Island location is a must-visit for anyone seeking a memorable dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Waterfront
- Mid-Range
Relate link
5. Tony's Pier
Seafood with a view, just a stone's throw from water.
__NEW TEXT__
This establishment provides an affordable range of pina coladas, making it an excellent choice for those seeking a refreshing beverage during the summer season. Its location, near the water, adds to the overall ambiance of the establishment.
The bar is a great place to unwind with friends, offering a diverse selection of drinks that cater to different tastes and preferences. Furthermore, the seafood served here is fresh and of good quality, enhancing the overall dining experience.
This establishment provides an affordable range of pina coladas, making it an excellent choice for those seeking a refreshing beverage during the summer season. Its location, near the water, adds to the overall ambiance of the establishment.
The bar is a great place to unwind with friends, offering a diverse selection of drinks that cater to different tastes and preferences. Furthermore, the seafood served here is fresh and of good quality, enhancing the overall dining experience.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- American Cuisine
Relate link
6. The Black Whale
A gem on City Island with impeccable service
__NEW TEXT__
The Black Whale, located on City Island, is a restaurant that offers a great dining experience. The bar at The Black Whale is a standout feature, with a wide range of creative and tasty cocktails that are sure to please. It's a great spot to relax and enjoy a drink, whether you're waiting for your table or just looking to unwind.
The bar area at The Black Whale is warm and inviting, making it an ideal place to spend time. The knowledgeable and friendly staff are happy to help you find the perfect drink and are eager to answer any questions you may have. The bar is well-stocked with a variety of options, ensuring that there is something for everyone. Whether you're a cocktail connoisseur or just looking for a good glass of wine, The Black Whale is the place to be.
The Black Whale, located on City Island, is a restaurant that offers a great dining experience. The bar at The Black Whale is a standout feature, with a wide range of creative and tasty cocktails that are sure to please. It's a great spot to relax and enjoy a drink, whether you're waiting for your table or just looking to unwind.
The bar area at The Black Whale is warm and inviting, making it an ideal place to spend time. The knowledgeable and friendly staff are happy to help you find the perfect drink and are eager to answer any questions you may have. The bar is well-stocked with a variety of options, ensuring that there is something for everyone. Whether you're a cocktail connoisseur or just looking for a good glass of wine, The Black Whale is the place to be.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
7. Man Overboard Bar
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
8. Paddy's On The Island
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Affordable Nightlife
- Downtown Spots
9. Johnny's Reef
Serving fresh, delicious seafood for over 60 years.
__NEW TEXT__
Frozen drinks are a popular choice at Johnny's Reef, providing a refreshing and satisfying beverage option for customers. The sauce bar is an added bonus, offering a variety of condiments such as tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, hot sauce, and ketchup for customers to personalize their meals.
Johnny's Reef serves delicious and reasonably priced drinks that are sure to satisfy. It's an ideal spot for those craving a simple yet satisfying meal, with options to suit every taste preference. The combination of affordability and quality makes it a standout among other dining establishments.
Frozen drinks are a popular choice at Johnny's Reef, providing a refreshing and satisfying beverage option for customers. The sauce bar is an added bonus, offering a variety of condiments such as tartar sauce, cocktail sauce, hot sauce, and ketchup for customers to personalize their meals.
Johnny's Reef serves delicious and reasonably priced drinks that are sure to satisfy. It's an ideal spot for those craving a simple yet satisfying meal, with options to suit every taste preference. The combination of affordability and quality makes it a standout among other dining establishments.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Waterfront
- Dinner
10. Sammy's Fish Box
World-famous seafood since 1966, serving the freshest dishes.
__NEW TEXT__
The drinks at this establishment are notably robust and high in quality, justifying the slightly elevated pricing. A select group of patrons have expressed concern over the cost of the beverages, but the majority find the prices to be commensurate with the quality.
In addition to the regular drink offerings, Sammy's also features exceptional frozen specialty drinks and sangria. These unique offerings have proven to be incredibly popular with customers, adding to the overall enjoyment of their visit and making for a delightful drinking experience.
The drinks at this establishment are notably robust and high in quality, justifying the slightly elevated pricing. A select group of patrons have expressed concern over the cost of the beverages, but the majority find the prices to be commensurate with the quality.
In addition to the regular drink offerings, Sammy's also features exceptional frozen specialty drinks and sangria. These unique offerings have proven to be incredibly popular with customers, adding to the overall enjoyment of their visit and making for a delightful drinking experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Waterfront
- Gluten-Free
11. Sea Shore Restaurant
Premier waterfront dining with fresh seafood specialties.
__NEW TEXT__
The bar area at this establishment is truly exceptional, offering a vast selection of creative cocktails that are sure to please any palate. Adding to the ambiance is a stunning view of the water, making it an ideal location for a relaxed and enjoyable evening.
The outdoor deck bar is particularly noteworthy. With a refreshing drink menu and a lively atmosphere, it's the perfect place to spend a summer night. The outdoor setting provides a welcome breath of fresh air, making it a popular spot for patrons looking to unwind and soak up the atmosphere.
The bar area at this establishment is truly exceptional, offering a vast selection of creative cocktails that are sure to please any palate. Adding to the ambiance is a stunning view of the water, making it an ideal location for a relaxed and enjoyable evening.
The outdoor deck bar is particularly noteworthy. With a refreshing drink menu and a lively atmosphere, it's the perfect place to spend a summer night. The outdoor setting provides a welcome breath of fresh air, making it a popular spot for patrons looking to unwind and soak up the atmosphere.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- High-End
- Waterfront
12. Vistamar
Unparalleled Latin-fusion cuisine with live shows.
__NEW TEXT__
Dining at this Latin restaurant offers a feast for the senses, with beautiful views of the harbor complementing a diverse menu and expertly crafted cocktails. The restaurant's elegant atmosphere is matched by the caliber of its cuisine, which showcases the vibrant flavors and techniques of Latin American cooking. From fresh ceviches to rich stews, every dish is made with care and attention to detail, resulting in a dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable.
The bar at Vistamar is the perfect spot to enjoy a pre-dinner drink or a nightcap, with a lively atmosphere, attentive service, and a creative cocktail menu that draws inspiration from Latin America's rich cocktail culture. Sipping on a perfectly balanced mojito or a smoky mezcal cocktail while taking in the stunning views of the harbor is a truly unforgettable experience. Whether you're looking for a romantic evening out or a fun night with friends, Vistamar's bar and restaurant are the perfect destination.
Dining at this Latin restaurant offers a feast for the senses, with beautiful views of the harbor complementing a diverse menu and expertly crafted cocktails. The restaurant's elegant atmosphere is matched by the caliber of its cuisine, which showcases the vibrant flavors and techniques of Latin American cooking. From fresh ceviches to rich stews, every dish is made with care and attention to detail, resulting in a dining experience that is both satisfying and memorable.
The bar at Vistamar is the perfect spot to enjoy a pre-dinner drink or a nightcap, with a lively atmosphere, attentive service, and a creative cocktail menu that draws inspiration from Latin America's rich cocktail culture. Sipping on a perfectly balanced mojito or a smoky mezcal cocktail while taking in the stunning views of the harbor is a truly unforgettable experience. Whether you're looking for a romantic evening out or a fun night with friends, Vistamar's bar and restaurant are the perfect destination.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Waterfront
- Dinner
Relate link
13. Portofino Restaurant in City Island
Delightful dining experience with amazing food and friendly staff.
__NEW TEXT__
The bar at Portofino offers a pleasant atmosphere for patrons, featuring a stunning waterfront view that adds to its appeal. The cocktails served are skillfully crafted, using high-quality ingredients to create well-balanced and delicious drinks. The staff members are attentive and efficient, ensuring that guests are promptly served and well taken care of throughout their visit.
Visiting the bar at Portofino is an excellent way to unwind and kick off an evening. The welcoming ambiance makes it an ideal location to gather with friends or coworkers and enjoy a drink before dinner. The bar boasts an extensive menu of beverages, providing a wide range of options to suit every taste. The knowledgeable and approachable staff are happy to help customers make informed choices and are dedicated to providing excellent service. Overall, a visit to Portofino's bar promises a memorable and satisfying experience.
The bar at Portofino offers a pleasant atmosphere for patrons, featuring a stunning waterfront view that adds to its appeal. The cocktails served are skillfully crafted, using high-quality ingredients to create well-balanced and delicious drinks. The staff members are attentive and efficient, ensuring that guests are promptly served and well taken care of throughout their visit.
Visiting the bar at Portofino is an excellent way to unwind and kick off an evening. The welcoming ambiance makes it an ideal location to gather with friends or coworkers and enjoy a drink before dinner. The bar boasts an extensive menu of beverages, providing a wide range of options to suit every taste. The knowledgeable and approachable staff are happy to help customers make informed choices and are dedicated to providing excellent service. Overall, a visit to Portofino's bar promises a memorable and satisfying experience.
TOPICS
- Waterfront
- Italian Cuisine
- Asian Cuisine
- Dinner
14. The Ice Rotisserie and Kitchens and Rooms in City Island
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Asian Cuisine
- Waterfront