Best of 15 breadsticks in City Island NYC
Breadsticks in City Island NYC are a must-try for any food lover. This small island in the Bronx is home to some of the best Italian-American cuisine in the city, and the breadsticks are no exception. These long, thin loaves of bread are perfect for snacking on their own or enjoying with a bowl of delicious marinara sauce. Made with high-quality ingredients and baked to perfection, the breadsticks in City Island NYC are a true culinary delight.
Toc
- 1. City Island Lobster House
- 2. Tony's Pier
- 3. Sammy's Shrimp Box
- 4. The Original Crab Shanty
- 5. Seafood City
- 6. Sammy's Fish Box in City Island
- 7. Sea Shore Restaurant
- 8. Artie's Steak and Seafood Restaurant
- 9. Portofino Restaurant
- 10. Archie's Tap & Table in City Island
- 11. Augie's City Island Deli
- 12. City Island Diner in City Island
- 13. Scavello's On The Island
- 14. City Island Pizza Company
- 15. A Taste of Italy Italian Deli
1. City Island Lobster House
Waterfront dining with stunning views of City Island
__NEW TEXT__
The meal began with complimentary garlic bread and either marinated olives or mushrooms. The garlic bread was a hit, described as outrageous in a positive way. The olives and mushrooms were marinated and also well-received as a starting course.
The pre-fix price included a variety of offerings. Soup and salad were served first, followed by a whole lobster with pasta. After the main course, an antipasto plate was presented. In addition to the garlic bread, guests were treated to blueberry bread. The meal was concluded with a delicious slice of chocolate cake.
The meal began with complimentary garlic bread and either marinated olives or mushrooms. The garlic bread was a hit, described as outrageous in a positive way. The olives and mushrooms were marinated and also well-received as a starting course.
The pre-fix price included a variety of offerings. Soup and salad were served first, followed by a whole lobster with pasta. After the main course, an antipasto plate was presented. In addition to the garlic bread, guests were treated to blueberry bread. The meal was concluded with a delicious slice of chocolate cake.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Waterfront
- Mid-Range
Relate link
2. Tony's Pier
Family-owned restaurant with a relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, offering stunning views of the Long Island Sound.
__NEW TEXT__
The breadsticks served before the meal were a standout, warm and fresh to kick off the dinner. However, the lobster tails were the true star of the evening. The view of the water was another highlight of the experience, adding to the overall ambiance of the meal.
Before the meal, the breadsticks were a pleasant beginning to the dinner, but they were quickly overshadowed by the delicious lobster tails. The water view provided a lovely backdrop to the meal, making for an enjoyable and memorable dining experience.
The breadsticks served before the meal were a standout, warm and fresh to kick off the dinner. However, the lobster tails were the true star of the evening. The view of the water was another highlight of the experience, adding to the overall ambiance of the meal.
Before the meal, the breadsticks were a pleasant beginning to the dinner, but they were quickly overshadowed by the delicious lobster tails. The water view provided a lovely backdrop to the meal, making for an enjoyable and memorable dining experience.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- American Cuisine
Relate link
3. Sammy's Shrimp Box
Seafood market on-site, live music on weekends, waterfront dining
__NEW TEXT__
The breadsticks served at the beginning of our meal were warm and enjoyable. They provided a good starting point for the meal and had a delicious flavor. However, some people at the table thought that the breadsticks were a bit too salty.
Despite the slight excess of salt, the breadsticks were well-received. Their warmth and delicious taste made for a positive start to the meal. Even though not everyone found the level of salt to be ideal, the breadsticks still contributed to an enjoyable dining experience.
The breadsticks served at the beginning of our meal were warm and enjoyable. They provided a good starting point for the meal and had a delicious flavor. However, some people at the table thought that the breadsticks were a bit too salty.
Despite the slight excess of salt, the breadsticks were well-received. Their warmth and delicious taste made for a positive start to the meal. Even though not everyone found the level of salt to be ideal, the breadsticks still contributed to an enjoyable dining experience.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Waterfront
4. The Original Crab Shanty
Seafood market and catering service available
__NEW TEXT__
If you're a garlic bread enthusiast, this establishment definitely caters to your tastes. One of the standout elements of our meal was the breadsticks, which were served warm, generously coated in butter, and with a well-balanced garlic flavor that was not overpowering.
Overall, the breadsticks were a delightful and satisfying part of our lunch. Their warmth, butteriness, and mild garlic taste made them a memorable and enjoyable culinary experience.
If you're a garlic bread enthusiast, this establishment definitely caters to your tastes. One of the standout elements of our meal was the breadsticks, which were served warm, generously coated in butter, and with a well-balanced garlic flavor that was not overpowering.
Overall, the breadsticks were a delightful and satisfying part of our lunch. Their warmth, butteriness, and mild garlic taste made them a memorable and enjoyable culinary experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
5. Seafood City
Offers a wide variety of fresh seafood imported daily
__NEW TEXT__
The breadsticks were a notable feature of the meal, with their warm temperature and well-seasoned flavor providing a good beginning to the dining experience. However, there was a difference in opinion regarding the texture of the breadsticks, as some found them to be a bit too hard.
The breadsticks were a notable feature of the meal, with their warm temperature and well-seasoned flavor providing a good beginning to the dining experience. However, there was a difference in opinion regarding the texture of the breadsticks, as some found them to be a bit too hard.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Social Gatherings
6. Sammy's Fish Box in City Island
Waterfront dining with stunning views of the Long Island Sound
__NEW TEXT__
The breadsticks served during our gathering received mixed reviews. Some individuals found them to be overly salty, while others, including myself, enjoyed them immensely. The divisive factor seemed to be the level of saltiness, but there was agreement on the satisfying hot temperature and adequacy of the breadsticks.
On a positive note, the garlic-infused breadsticks were a standout favorite for many. Their delicious flavor and hot serving temperature were commendable aspects. These breadsticks can be considered a must-try for those who appreciate garlic-enhanced baked goods.
The breadsticks served during our gathering received mixed reviews. Some individuals found them to be overly salty, while others, including myself, enjoyed them immensely. The divisive factor seemed to be the level of saltiness, but there was agreement on the satisfying hot temperature and adequacy of the breadsticks.
On a positive note, the garlic-infused breadsticks were a standout favorite for many. Their delicious flavor and hot serving temperature were commendable aspects. These breadsticks can be considered a must-try for those who appreciate garlic-enhanced baked goods.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Waterfront
- Gluten-Free
7. Sea Shore Restaurant
Scenic waterfront views, family-friendly atmosphere, and a varied seafood menu.
__NEW TEXT__
Enjoy a luxurious and comfortable seafaring experience, featuring fresh seafood specialties, a sushi bar, and an extensive wine list. The lounge and outdoor deck bar offer a range of cocktails, mixed drinks, and tropical frozen delights. For a group of eight, the "feasts for two" and a snow crabs/ribs combo were ordered, priced at $75 and $28 respectively.
The mixed seafood appetizer, priced at $20, was a great value with a generous amount of seafood. The fried scallops were well-prepared. The "feasts for two" are highly recommended, priced at $75 and feeding three to four people. Two feasts and one additional dish were not finished by eight people, indicating substantial portion sizes. This restaurant is a great choice for seafood on City Island.
Enjoy a luxurious and comfortable seafaring experience, featuring fresh seafood specialties, a sushi bar, and an extensive wine list. The lounge and outdoor deck bar offer a range of cocktails, mixed drinks, and tropical frozen delights. For a group of eight, the "feasts for two" and a snow crabs/ribs combo were ordered, priced at $75 and $28 respectively.
The mixed seafood appetizer, priced at $20, was a great value with a generous amount of seafood. The fried scallops were well-prepared. The "feasts for two" are highly recommended, priced at $75 and feeding three to four people. Two feasts and one additional dish were not finished by eight people, indicating substantial portion sizes. This restaurant is a great choice for seafood on City Island.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- High-End
- Waterfront
8. Artie's Steak and Seafood Restaurant
Offers waterfront dining with stunning views of the Long Island Sound
__NEW TEXT__
The breadsticks served at this establishment are truly noteworthy. They arrive at the table hot and are incredibly delicious, providing a delightful start to the dining experience. The warmth of the breadsticks adds to their appeal, as they are fresh and tantalizing.
These breadsticks are a standout aspect of the meal, serving as the perfect opening act. They come out freshly baked and steaming, with a taste that is simply irresistible. The warmth of the breadsticks is inviting, setting a positive tone for the rest of the meal.
The breadsticks served at this establishment are truly noteworthy. They arrive at the table hot and are incredibly delicious, providing a delightful start to the dining experience. The warmth of the breadsticks adds to their appeal, as they are fresh and tantalizing.
These breadsticks are a standout aspect of the meal, serving as the perfect opening act. They come out freshly baked and steaming, with a taste that is simply irresistible. The warmth of the breadsticks is inviting, setting a positive tone for the rest of the meal.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Asian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
9. Portofino Restaurant
Family-owned restaurant offering waterfront dining
__NEW TEXT__
The breadsticks were a popular choice as a starter. They stood out for their freshness, making for a satisfying bite. The breadsticks were served with an olive oil dip, which complemented their flavor well.
However, there were differing opinions regarding the saltiness of the breadsticks. While some found the level of saltiness to be just right, others, including the speaker, thought they were a touch too salty. Nonetheless, the breadsticks were a topic of enjoyment among the group, with most of the friends relishing them.
The breadsticks were a popular choice as a starter. They stood out for their freshness, making for a satisfying bite. The breadsticks were served with an olive oil dip, which complemented their flavor well.
However, there were differing opinions regarding the saltiness of the breadsticks. While some found the level of saltiness to be just right, others, including the speaker, thought they were a touch too salty. Nonetheless, the breadsticks were a topic of enjoyment among the group, with most of the friends relishing them.
TOPICS
- Waterfront
- Italian Cuisine
- Asian Cuisine
- Dinner
10. Archie's Tap & Table in City Island
Waterfront dining with stunning city views
__NEW TEXT__
Archie's Tap & Table offers delicious breadsticks that are sure to delight. Served warm, these breadsticks provide a satisfying crunch on the outside, while remaining soft and tender on the inside. The result is a perfectly balanced texture that is highly enjoyable.
These breadsticks are enhanced by a complementary dipping sauce, making for a tasty and satisfying appetizer. Food enthusiasts would do well to give Archie's breadsticks a try, as they are sure to leave a lasting impression with their exceptional quality and flavor. As a must-try item on the menu, the breadsticks at Archie's Tap & Table are not to be missed.
Archie's Tap & Table offers delicious breadsticks that are sure to delight. Served warm, these breadsticks provide a satisfying crunch on the outside, while remaining soft and tender on the inside. The result is a perfectly balanced texture that is highly enjoyable.
These breadsticks are enhanced by a complementary dipping sauce, making for a tasty and satisfying appetizer. Food enthusiasts would do well to give Archie's breadsticks a try, as they are sure to leave a lasting impression with their exceptional quality and flavor. As a must-try item on the menu, the breadsticks at Archie's Tap & Table are not to be missed.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
11. Augie's City Island Deli
Hand-rolled breadsticks made fresh daily
__NEW TEXT__
Augie's City Island Deli is known for its delicious breadsticks. Crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, they make for a perfect snack or accompaniment to a meal. Many customers rave about their exceptional quality and flavor.
Freshness and delicious taste are consistently associated with the breadsticks at Augie's. They are a popular menu item and a great addition to any meal. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or sitting down for a full meal, be sure to try these amazing breadsticks.
Augie's City Island Deli is known for its delicious breadsticks. Crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, they make for a perfect snack or accompaniment to a meal. Many customers rave about their exceptional quality and flavor.
Freshness and delicious taste are consistently associated with the breadsticks at Augie's. They are a popular menu item and a great addition to any meal. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or sitting down for a full meal, be sure to try these amazing breadsticks.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Italian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
12. City Island Diner in City Island
Family-owned and operated, serving classic American and Italian cuisine in a cozy and inviting atmosphere.
__NEW TEXT__
The breadsticks served at the beginning of the meal were a delightful addition. They were warm, fresh, and well-seasoned, providing a great start to the dining experience. The breadsticks were enjoyed by all, and their quality was highly praised.
It was mentioned that the breadsticks were a pleasant surprise, and they were specifically loved for their freshness. The marinara sauce that accompanied them was also a hit, as it complemented the breadsticks well. Overall, the breadsticks were a memorable and enjoyable part of the meal.
The breadsticks served at the beginning of the meal were a delightful addition. They were warm, fresh, and well-seasoned, providing a great start to the dining experience. The breadsticks were enjoyed by all, and their quality was highly praised.
It was mentioned that the breadsticks were a pleasant surprise, and they were specifically loved for their freshness. The marinara sauce that accompanied them was also a hit, as it complemented the breadsticks well. Overall, the breadsticks were a memorable and enjoyable part of the meal.
TOPICS
- Waterfront
- Breakfast
13. Scavello's On The Island
Family-owned and operated for over 30 years, Scavello's offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere with homemade Italian cuisine.
__NEW TEXT__
The breadsticks at the dining establishment were a standout aspect of the meal. They were warm, freshly baked, and seasoned well, providing a delicious start to the meal. Both visitors agreed that the breadsticks were a highlight of their dining experience.
The garlic flavor of the breadsticks at Scavello's was particularly noteworthy. They were clearly made with fresh garlic and were well-seasoned, making them a tasty and enjoyable beginning to the meal. Both parties agreed that the garlic breadsticks were a must-try for any visitor.
The breadsticks at the dining establishment were a standout aspect of the meal. They were warm, freshly baked, and seasoned well, providing a delicious start to the meal. Both visitors agreed that the breadsticks were a highlight of their dining experience.
The garlic flavor of the breadsticks at Scavello's was particularly noteworthy. They were clearly made with fresh garlic and were well-seasoned, making them a tasty and enjoyable beginning to the meal. Both parties agreed that the garlic breadsticks were a must-try for any visitor.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
14. City Island Pizza Company
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
15. A Taste of Italy Italian Deli
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings