Best of 5 caprese sandwich in Fishtown
Discover the deliciousness of a caprese sandwich in Fishtown, a Philadelphia neighborhood known for its vibrant food scene. This Italian-inspired sandwich, featuring fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil, is a popular choice among locals and visitors alike. Enjoy a caprese sandwich at one of Fishtown's top spots, including Johnny Brenda's, Front Street Cafe, Wm. Mulherin’s Sons, Murph's Bar, and Sulimay's Restaurant.
1. Johnny Brenda's
Live music venue, rooftop bar, locally sourced ingredients

Johnny Brenda's caprese sandwich is a standout option for any sandwich lover. The freshness and balance of flavors in this sandwich make it a delicious choice. The key ingredients, mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil, come together in a perfect harmony, resulting in a satisfying and savory experience.
The combination of fresh and flavorful ingredients in Johnny Brenda's caprese sandwich is what makes it shine. The mozzarella is creamy and mild, the tomatoes are ripe and juicy, and the basil is fresh and aromatic. This expertly crafted sandwich is sure to leave a lasting impression on anyone who tries it. Food enthusiasts and casual diners alike should not miss out on the opportunity to savor this delectable caprese sandwich.
TOPICS
- Affordable Nightlife
- Hidden Gems
- Vegetarian Options
- Personal Celebrations
2. Wm. Mulherin’s Sons
Rustic Italian cuisine in a historic building with a hidden speakeasy

The caprese sandwich I enjoyed was exceptional, offering a combination of fresh ingredients and perfectly toasted bread. The standout components of the sandwich were the fresh mozzarella and tomatoes, which were perfectly complemented by basil and a tasty balsamic glaze.
This sandwich was truly delicious, offering a perfect balance of flavors and textures. The freshness of the ingredients, including the high-quality mozzarella and tomatoes, elevated the overall taste. The inclusion of basil and a balsamic glaze further enhanced the sandwich, making it one of the best I've ever had.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
Relate link
3. Milkcrate Cafe in Fishtown
Cozy atmosphere, local art displays, communal seating

The Caprese sandwich is a delightful dish, featuring fresh and high-quality ingredients. The combination of ripe tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and aromatic basil creates a well-balanced and flavorful experience. What sets this sandwich apart is the addition of balsamic glaze, which gives it a tangy and sweet kick. The glaze not only enhances the taste but also adds a visually appealing touch to the dish.
Overall, the Caprese sandwich is a perfect blend of freshness and flavor. Each ingredient complements the other, resulting in a delightful culinary experience. The sandwich contains the right amount of basil and mozzarella, ensuring that neither flavor overpowers the other. The freshness of the ingredients is evident in every bite, making it a satisfying and enjoyable meal. Whether enjoyed as a quick lunch or a leisurely snack, the Caprese sandwich is sure to impress.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
4. Fishtown Market
Friendly service in a casual, counter-serve environment

Fishtown Market offers a spectacular caprese sandwich that should not be missed. The sandwich is well-known for its high-quality, fresh ingredients and well-balanced flavors. The combination of ripe tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and fresh basil leaves is a delightful treat for the taste buds.
I highly recommend trying the caprese sandwich at Fishtown Market. Its consistent deliciousness and satisfying nature make it an excellent choice for any meal. Whether you're a fan of caprese salads or just looking to try something new, this sandwich is sure to impress. With its fresh and flavorful ingredients, it's no wonder that this sandwich is a crowd favorite.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Gluten-Free
5. Castellino's Italian Market
Family-owned Italian market with a wide variety of authentic Italian products

Castellino's hoagies on Palmer Street in Fishtown are truly exceptional. The bread, in particular, is outstanding, and the freshness and quality of the other ingredients used in each hoagie are top-notch. The Franklin, Caprese, and Gabagool are just a few of the delicious options available. Even several hours after being made, the hoagies maintain their structural integrity and don't become soggy.
In summary, Castellino's in Fishtown serves outstanding hoagies with high-quality ingredients and excellent bread. The hoagies retain their freshness and structure for hours after being made. Specifically, the Franklin, Caprese, and Gabagool are standout choices.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems