Best of 15 frozen yogurt in Buffalo
Frozen yogurt in Buffalo is a popular dessert option for those looking for a tangy and refreshing treat. This delightful treat is a healthier alternative to traditional ice cream, offering a satisfying option for health-conscious consumers in Buffalo. With various toppings and flavors, frozen yogurt in Buffalo is a customizable delight for people of all ages. Visit your local shop today and enjoy the frozen yogurt sensation.
- 1. Pam's Custard Corner
- 2. Anderson's Frozen Custard
- 3. Lake Effect Ice Cream
- 4. Custard Corner & Grill
- 5. Cookies & Cream On Elmwood
- 6. Churn Soft Serve & Coffee
- 7. Dairy Queen (Treat)
- 8. Cookies & Cream
- 9. Yotality Frozen Yogurt
- 10. White Rabbit Frozen Yogurt - Elmwood Village
- 11. King Condrell's Candy and Ice Cream
- 12. Golden Hour Treats & Things
- 13. Watson's Chocolates
- 14. Dairy Queen (Treat)
- 15. Luxury Ice Cream
1. Pam's Custard Corner
Rotating selection of seasonal flavors, Provides numerous toppings to choose from

Pam's Custard Corner is a popular dessert spot in Buffalo, NY, known for its wide variety of creamy custard flavors and unique topping options. Customers rave about the delicious parfaits and frozen custard, which they consider to be the best in the area. The business is located at 2190 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY 14220.
A high rating of 4.72, based on 102 reviews, indicates that Pam's Custard Corner is well-liked by its visitors. Here are some opinions from 46 of those customers: [actual opinions not provided in the prompt]. With such positive feedback, potential visitors can be confident that they too will enjoy their experience at Pam's Custard Corner.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Breakfast
2. Anderson's Frozen Custard
Family-owned, extensive menu, drive-thru available

The frozen yogurt offered at this establishment is a must-try for those seeking a delicious and refreshing treat. Its creamy texture and rich flavor make it an ideal choice for hot days when you want something both cooling and indulgent. If you're looking for a lighter option than their custard, the frozen yogurt is a great alternative. Its refreshing taste is sure to leave you feeling satisfied.
This location's frozen yogurt stands out for its exceptional creaminess and flavor. Its lightness compared to the custard offered by the same establishment makes it an appealing option for those seeking something less heavy. The frozen yogurt is the perfect choice if you're in the mood for something that is both indulgent and satisfying without weighing you down. Its delightful taste makes it a must-try for anyone visiting this establishment.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
3. Lake Effect Ice Cream
Handcrafted in small batches with local milk and ingredients, family-owned and operated

Lake Effect Ice Cream is a popular destination for ice cream lovers, now offering their delicious sundaes near home. With a selection of 27 ice cream flavors, customers can try unique and tasty combinations. A sampler is available for those who want to taste multiple flavors, offering five small scoops of any flavor. The sundaes are inspired by the local area, such as 'The North Park' and 'Bella Italia', which pays homage to the Italian roots on Hertel Ave.
The service at Lake Effect Ice Cream is described as mixed, friendly, and fast. The staff are known to be friendly and the service is quick, providing a great customer experience. The prices are considered reasonable and match the quality of the products. The coffee flavor in the ice cream is artificial, but it's still considered the best coffee ice cream some customers have ever had. Overall, Lake Effect Ice Cream offers a delicious and enjoyable experience, with a wide variety of flavors and high-quality products.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
4. Custard Corner & Grill
Family-owned establishment since 1982, Local favorite spot

The frozen yogurt that was tried was decent in taste, but the individual had experienced better at other places. One aspect that did stand out was the excellent service provided. The kids, on the other hand, were big fans of the frozen yogurt. They particularly enjoyed the wide range of toppings that were available for them to choose from.
In summary, while the taste of the frozen yogurt was not exceptional, the great service and the happiness of the kids made up for it. The toppings bar was a highlight for the younger crowd, who were thrilled with the variety of options available to customize their desserts.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
- Budget-Friendly Eats
Relate link
5. Cookies & Cream On Elmwood
Family-owned business with a fun and welcoming atmosphere

The frozen yogurt offered at this location is exceptional due to its creamy texture and delicious taste. A wide range of toppings are available for customers to customize their treat.
I had the opportunity to try the frozen yogurt and was thoroughly impressed. Its smooth texture and balanced sweetness made for a satisfying treat. I highly recommend giving it a try.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Gluten-Free
Relate link
6. Churn Soft Serve & Coffee
Artisanal coffee, vegan options, allergy-friendly, dog-friendly patio

Located next to Lloyd Taco Factory on Hertel, this establishment offers excellent ice cream that is homemade in-house. The 'rocky road trip' flavor boasts a creamy texture with a perfect blend of marshmallow, caramelized almonds, and a hint of coffee, offering a satisfying crunch in every spoonful. Served in a generous DQ Blizzard-sized cup, they also offer homemade waffle cones for an extra treat. The staff is friendly, and the portions are substantial.
My husband and I frequent this establishment regularly due to its high-quality ice cream. They offer a vegan soft serve option that is equally delicious. Their rotating soft serve flavors are a must-try, especially strawberries and pistachio. No matter your preference, this place is sure to satisfy your cravings for some delicious ice cream.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Breakfast
- Dinner
7. Dairy Queen (Treat)
Soft serve ice cream and food menu available

The frozen yogurt I tried was delicious and offered a variety of great flavors. It was a welcome treat, especially on a hot day. The taste and selection were impressive, making it a perfect stop for anyone looking to beat the heat or satisfy their sweet tooth.
Visiting this place for frozen yogurt was an excellent decision. The flavors were wonderful and ideal for cooling down during hot weather. I highly recommend checking it out if you're in search of a tasty and refreshing treat. The frozen yogurt's quality and the wide range of choices make it a must-visit destination for fans of this delightful dessert.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Lunch
Relate link
8. Cookies & Cream
Family-owned business with a cozy atmosphere

Cookies & Cream is a popular frozen yogurt spot in Buffalo, known for offering high-quality yogurt. Although the service was a bit slow, the delicious and creamy yogurt made it worth the wait. The variety of flavors available makes it a great spot to try something new and satisfying.
The frozen yogurt at Cookies & Cream is a must-try for anyone in Buffalo. The yogurt is well-known for its creamy texture and rich taste. With a wide selection of flavors to choose from, customers can always find something new to try. The popularity of this frozen yogurt spot is a testament to the quality of the yogurt and the enjoyable experience it provides.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
9. Yotality Frozen Yogurt
Locally-sourced ingredients, rotating flavors

Yotality is a establishment located in Elmwood Village that provides customers with delicious frozen yogurt, also known as froyo, and Brezeln. Customers have praised the efficient and positive staff who contribute to the overall great atmosphere of the place. According to reviews, Yotality is one of the top Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt businesses in its location at 715 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222 United States.
145 customer reviews have been left for Yotality, highlighting its offerings and quality of service. The business can be found on various online platforms, where customers can view directions, business hours, and even book appointments. With an average rating based on these reviews, Yotality continues to be a popular choice for those looking for a tasty treat and a place to relax after a long walk around Elmwood Village.
TOPICS
- Cheap Eats
- Gluten-Free
Relate link
10. White Rabbit Frozen Yogurt - Elmwood Village

TOPICS
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
11. King Condrell's Candy and Ice Cream
Family-owned business since 1930, handmade chocolates, seasonal favorites

The frozen yogurt offered is exceptional, known for its creamy texture and delightful taste, making it a popular choice for a refreshing treat, especially on hot days. The establishment that serves it also prides itself on a vast selection of toppings that adds an extra element of customization and enjoyment for customers.
This place is a great destination for frozen yogurt fans, and the variety of toppings is one of its standout features. The option to personalize your dessert experience by choosing from a wide range of toppings enhances the overall enjoyment of the delicious and creamy frozen yogurt.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
12. Golden Hour Treats & Things
Freshly made waffle cones, Local ingredients, Seasonal flavors

Golden Hour Treats & Things is a highly-rated ice cream shop located at 735 Sycamore St, Buffalo. They are open from 2 PM to 9 PM and offer take-out, delivery, and online ordering options. The menu features a variety of ice cream flavors, with banana split and cotton candy being popular choices among customers. The shop has received an impressive 4.8 rating out of 73 reviews, with customers raving about the delicious and high-quality desserts. The staff are described as polite, friendly, and cheerful, adding to the overall positive experience of the shop.
Customers have praised the shop's desserts as "delicious," "beautiful," and "tasty," with the mangodala and banana smoothie being a standout. One customer even learned about the shop through Grubhub and was thrilled with their banana split, which they declared as the best they've ever had. Another customer couldn't resist finishing their banana pudding, which they had intended to save for later. The shop's clean atmosphere and inviting staff also contribute to its appeal. While some customers have noted that the service can be a bit slow, many agree that it is worth the wait for the phenomenal desserts.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
Relate link
13. Watson's Chocolates
Featuring over 50 toppings and delicious European-style chocolates

Watson's Chocolates is renowned for offering a delicious frozen yogurt experience. The perfect combination of creamy yogurt and a variety of chocolate toppings makes it a popular destination in Buffalo. This establishments' frozen yogurt stands out from others due to its smooth texture and rich taste.
Chocoholics will be particularly thrilled with Watson's selection of chocolate toppings. From classic options like chocolate sprinkles to more decadent choices such as chocolate fudge or brownie bits, there is something to satisfy every sweet tooth. By pairing their top-notch frozen yogurt with these indulgent chocolate toppings, Watson's Chocolates creates an unforgettable dessert experience that is well worth a visit.
TOPICS
- Holiday Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Downtown Spots
14. Dairy Queen (Treat)
Cake decorating services, Indoor and outdoor seating, Online ordering available
Frozen yogurt is a delightful dessert option, and the Dairy Queen location in question is no exception. They offer a variety of frozen yogurt choices, making it a great place to satisfy a sweet tooth. However, the establishment can get quite crowded, making for a busier and potentially less enjoyable experience.
Despite the crowds, the frozen yogurt at this Dairy Queen is consistently enjoyable. The options are plentiful, ensuring that there is something for every taste preference. Whether it's a regular treat or a rare indulgence, the frozen yogurt at this location is sure to please. It's worth noting that the crowd situation may vary depending on the time of day or week, so planning a visit accordingly could help avoid long wait times.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Breakfast
Relate link
15. Luxury Ice Cream

TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link