Best of 15 sushi restaurants in Sheepshead Bay NYC
Sheepshead Bay in NYC is a foodie's paradise, particularly for sushi lovers. The area is home to a variety of exceptional sushi restaurants, each offering unique and authentic Japanese cuisine. From traditional nigiri and sashimi to creative rolls and specialty dishes, sushi restaurants in Sheepshead Bay NYC cater to all palates and preferences. Whether you're a local or a tourist, be sure to indulge in the fresh and mouthwatering sushi that these restaurants have to offer.
1. Masuta Japanese Fusion
Fusion of traditional Japanese flavors with modern twists

Masuta, a Japanese restaurant in Brooklyn, offers an exquisite dining experience with its fresh and delicious food. The restaurant prides itself on using only the freshest ingredients, particularly when it comes to their selection of seafood. Their sushi and sashimi are highly recommended, as they practically melt in your mouth with their rich and delicate flavors.
In addition to their sushi and sashimi, Masuta also offers a variety of other Japanese dishes that are sure to satisfy. Their Oyster Shots are a must-try, as they are not only delicious but also unique. The atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy and inviting, making it the perfect place to relax and enjoy a meal. With its attentive service, impressive menu, and comfortable ambiance, Masuta has established itself as a top-notch Japanese restaurant in NYC.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Fusion Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Celebrations
2. Omakase sushi by hiro in Sheepshead Bay
A culinary journey that delights the senses

A memorable anniversary was spent at a charming omakase restaurant, where the chef/owner and assistant chef provided exceptional service. Despite a small slip-up by the assistant chef, the owner graciously offered a complimentary dinner, showcasing their generosity and understanding.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- High-End
- Downtown Spots
3. Masakari
Traditional Japanese techniques with modern flavors.

Sushi lovers in the Sheepshead Bay area should not miss the opportunity to try the delectable offerings at this sushi restaurant. The freshness and taste of their sushi are unparalleled in the area, making it a standout destination for sushi enthusiasts.
The fish served at this establishment is always fresh and expertly prepared, resulting in a melt-in-your-mouth experience. The cucumber wraps are expertly made, thin and tight, providing the perfect contrast to the succulent fish. Many other sushi restaurants fail to achieve this level of precision and care, making this restaurant a must-visit.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Fusion Cuisine
- Dinner
- Lunch
4. Shinjuku Japanese Fusion

TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Asian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
5. E Sushi II
Unlimited sushi and sashimi for a great price

E Sushi II is a highly-regarded all-you-can-eat sushi restaurant, distinguished for its offering of fresh and flavorful sushi dishes. The restaurant boasts an extensive variety of sushi options, as well as dessert offerings to satisfy every guest's preferences.
The staff at E Sushi II is frequently commended for their friendly and efficient service, ensuring guests receive their orders in a timely manner. Although some patrons report occasional slow service, the general consensus is that the staff is courteous and prompt, adding to a positive dining experience.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
6. Kosan Asian Fusion
Innovative Asian fusion with a sushi focus.

Crispy Sushi offers top-notch sushi and exceptional service, making it an ideal dining destination. The restaurant's fish quality surpasses that of its competitors, providing a more satisfying dining experience. Notably, the rock shrimp dish stands out due to its generous portion size and delicious taste, which could easily be mistaken for jumbo rock shrimp.
The staff at Crispy Sushi demonstrates remarkable attentiveness and friendliness, contributing to the overall positive atmosphere. The service provided by Jesse, in particular, was exceptional. As a result, Crispy Sushi has earned a reputation as a reliable establishment worth returning to, delivering excellent sushi and memorable experiences to its patrons.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
7. East Sushi Bistro
Delicious sushi presented as beautiful works of art.

This small restaurant offers a fantastic dining experience, primarily geared towards take-out and delivery orders. They provide seating for a small number of patrons, with just three tables for four and two spots at the sushi counter. Despite the limited seating, the restaurant more than makes up for it with their impressive menu. The reasonably priced offerings, which include an assortment of sushi, sashimi, and homemade rolls, guarantee a delightful and filling meal for groups of 4-8 people, especially when ordering their value-packed party trays and king or queen sizes.
The presentation of the food is not only delicious but also visually stunning. Each dish showcases the raw fish as a work of art, ensuring a memorable dining experience for sushi lovers. Prices are extremely competitive, considering the high-quality food offered. You can expect to enjoy a satisfying meal at a cost of around $15-20 per person when ordering their combination platters, making it an attractive option for those looking for a budget-friendly meal without compromising on quality and taste.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
8. Osaka
Discover the exquisite flavors of Japan.

Sushi at this establishment is highly regarded for its freshness and delightful taste, with many considering it the top choice for sushi in the local area. The reasonable pricing of this sushi only adds to its appeal, making it a popular option for sushi lovers.
Teriyaki chicken is another well-liked menu item, praised by some guests for its exquisite flavor. However, there have been reports of the teriyaki sauce and salmon teriyaki having an overly salty taste, which may not appeal to all palates. Despite this, the chicken teriyaki remains a popular choice for many guests.
TOPICS
- Chinese Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Affordable Nightlife
- Hidden Gems
9. Omiya Sushi in Sheepshead Bay
Innovative sushi with a friendly atmosphere.

A warm and welcoming atmosphere is created by the staff at this establishment, who go above and beyond to offer deals and provide excellent customer service. Their quick and polite delivery adds to the positive dining experience.
The sushi served at this establishment is highly regarded for its quality, with fresh and delicious options available. The affordability of their sushi is enhanced by special deals, making it a popular choice among customers.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
10. Mitoushi
Best Japanese Cuisine in Brooklyn.

This establishment offers delicious food at reasonable prices, making it a great choice for anyone looking for a satisfying meal. The ramen dishes are particularly noteworthy, with rich and flavorful broths that are sure to impress. In addition to the ramen, the sushi is also a standout, with fresh and expertly prepared rolls that are full of flavor.
The service at this restaurant is another highlight, with staff who are friendly, attentive, and dedicated to providing an excellent dining experience. They go out of their way to make customers feel welcome and accommodate any requests or dietary restrictions. The restaurant has a comfortable and inviting atmosphere, making it a great place to hang out and enjoy a meal with friends or family. Whether you're a fan of ramen, sushi, or just great food in general, this restaurant is definitely worth checking out.
TOPICS
- Gluten-Free
- Asian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
11. Chikurin
Modern sushi with a touch of tradition.

Sushi at this establishment is widely regarded for its exceptional quality and diverse offerings. The freshness of the fish, combined with the expert preparation of the sushi chefs, results in a truly delightful dining experience. Customers consistently rave about the delicious taste and high-quality ingredients used in each dish.
However, there have been some conflicting opinions about the food. While many customers have praised the sushi for its freshness and flavor, others have found it to be inconsistent. Some have reported instances of poor quality and unappetizing dishes. This discrepancy may be due to variations in ingredients or preparation, making for a less satisfying dining experience for some customers. Despite these occasional complaints, the overall impression of the sushi is one of freshness, quality, and variety.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
12. Sushi MiKasa in Sheepshead Bay
Exclusively sushi, nigiri, and sashimi.

Sushi MiKasa, nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, offers a dining experience that is nothing short of exceptional. The sushi at this establishment is of the highest quality, with each piece crafted with care and precision. The fish is always fresh, and the rice has the perfect balance of vinegar and sweetness. The service at Sushi MiKasa is also noteworthy, with staff who are friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu.
For those seeking a truly memorable sushi experience, the chef's selection is highly recommended. This assortment of the chef's favorite dishes showcases the best of what Sushi MiKasa has to offer, from classic rolls to innovative creations. The intimate and cozy atmosphere of the restaurant adds to the overall experience, making it easy to forget that you're in bustling New York City. If you're a sushi lover, Sushi MiKasa should not be missed. It's truly one of the best sushi spots in town.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
13. Poke Sushi
Fresh, flavorful sushi and poke bowls.

Sushi of exceptional quality and diverse selection awaits at this establishment. The sushi offerings are highly regarded, with a plethora of options to choose from that cater to various preferences. The freshness of the ingredients is evident in every bite, providing a satisfying and delicious dining experience.
The service at this establishment is commendable. The staff members are known for their friendliness and courtesy, making guests feel welcome and well taken care of. The speed at which they serve is also impressive, ensuring wait times are minimal. Overall, impeccable service adds to the enjoyable dining experience at this establishment.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Fusion Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
14. Asian Bay
Quality sushi and Asian cuisine in Sheepshead Bay

For sushi enthusiasts, this establishment is a must-visit. They offer an impressive variety of sushi rolls that cater to diverse tastes, with the Summer Roll being a standout choice for its exceptional flavor. Each piece is carefully crafted, showcasing the chef's expertise in creating delectable and visually appealing dishes.
In addition to the dine-in experience, the establishment also offers a fast and reliable delivery service. Even when enjoyed at home, the sushi maintains its high quality, making it a perfect option for those who prefer to dine in the comfort of their own homes. The Alaska Roll, in particular, is a highly recommended choice, boasting delightful flavors and fresh ingredients that will not disappoint.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
15. Umi Sushi
Fresh sushi made to order with diverse options.

Sushi in this establishment is consistently fresh and flavorful, with a wide selection of rolls and exceptional quality of fish. The dedication to providing top-notch sushi is evident in the offerings, which are sure to satisfy any sushi aficionado. Along with the delicious food, the service is commendable - friendly and prompt, adding to the overall positive dining experience.
For those who prefer to enjoy their sushi in the comfort of their own home, the restaurant also offers reliable delivery services. The sushi arrives promptly and in the correct order, ensuring that the quality and freshness of the food are preserved. Overall, the consistency and reliability of the sushi offered here make it an excellent choice for sushi lovers seeking a satisfying and delicious meal.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link