15 Best Ice Cream restaurants in Buffalo
"Ice Cream restaurants in Buffalo" are a sweet escape for locals and tourists alike. Satisfy your cravings with a wide variety of flavors and styles, from classic scoops to artisanal, handcrafted creations. These establishments not only offer delicious treats but also contribute to Buffalo's vibrant food scene, making them a must-visit for ice cream enthusiasts. Experience the joy of "Ice Cream restaurants in Buffalo" and create memorable moments one lick at a time.
Toc
- 1. Lake Effect Ice Cream
- 2. Churn Soft Serve & Coffee
- 3. Hertel Avenue Poutine and Cream
- 4. Cookies & Cream
- 5. Custard Corner & Grill
- 6. Anderson's Frozen Custard
- 7. Golden Hour Treats & Things
- 8. Sweet Jenny's Chocolates & Ice Cream
- 9. Hanna's Frosty Treats
- 10. Pam's Custard Corner
- 11. Cookies & Cream On Elmwood
- 12. King Condrell's Candy and Ice Cream
- 13. Romeo & Juliet's Cafeé & Bakery
- 14. Dairy Queen (Treat)
- 15. Bryce's Ice Cream
1. Lake Effect Ice Cream
Artisan ice cream with a Buffalo twist
__NEW TEXT__
The array of ice cream flavors on offer is absolutely stunning, each one showcasing a perfect blend of ingredients. From the classic vanilla and chocolate to the more adventurous options like lavender honey or spicy mango, every flavor delivers on taste. It would take months of daily visits to try them all, but the journey would be more than worth it.
This ice cream is some of the best tasted, period. The creativity and imagination behind each flavor is truly impressive, resulting in a unique and unforgettable experience for the taste buds. And it's not just the flavors that make this place special – the staff are friendly, welcoming, and quick to serve, ensuring that customers are well taken care of. Overall, this ice cream shop goes above and beyond in every way and is definitely worth a visit.
The array of ice cream flavors on offer is absolutely stunning, each one showcasing a perfect blend of ingredients. From the classic vanilla and chocolate to the more adventurous options like lavender honey or spicy mango, every flavor delivers on taste. It would take months of daily visits to try them all, but the journey would be more than worth it.
This ice cream is some of the best tasted, period. The creativity and imagination behind each flavor is truly impressive, resulting in a unique and unforgettable experience for the taste buds. And it's not just the flavors that make this place special – the staff are friendly, welcoming, and quick to serve, ensuring that customers are well taken care of. Overall, this ice cream shop goes above and beyond in every way and is definitely worth a visit.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
2. Churn Soft Serve & Coffee
Natural, grass-fed soft serve with unique flavors and toppings.
__NEW TEXT__
Churn Soft Serve & Coffee is known for its speedy and amiable service, leaving customers satisfied and well-cared for. The establishment's customer service representatives are knowledgeable and attentive, ensuring a positive experience for all who visit.
Their dessert offerings, particularly the coconut soft serve ice cream and fresh churros, have received high praise. These treats are an excellent choice for those looking to satisfy their sweet tooth after a meal. The combination of delicious flavors and fresh ingredients make for a memorable post-dinner treat.
Churn Soft Serve & Coffee is known for its speedy and amiable service, leaving customers satisfied and well-cared for. The establishment's customer service representatives are knowledgeable and attentive, ensuring a positive experience for all who visit.
Their dessert offerings, particularly the coconut soft serve ice cream and fresh churros, have received high praise. These treats are an excellent choice for those looking to satisfy their sweet tooth after a meal. The combination of delicious flavors and fresh ingredients make for a memorable post-dinner treat.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Breakfast
- Dinner
3. Hertel Avenue Poutine and Cream
Buffalo's best poutine paired with fresh homemade ice cream
__NEW TEXT__
The service at this establishment is commonly described as friendly and quick, providing guests with an enjoyable dining experience. However, some guests have noted that the service can be slow due to staffing shortages, which may affect overall satisfaction.
The dessert menu is a highlight, featuring bold freak shakes and rich, creamy ice cream. These unique milkshakes, known as 'freak shakes,' offer a playful and indulgent treat. For those who prefer a more traditional dessert, the restaurant also offers their house-made ice cream in scoops, cones, and pints. Additionally, there are limited vegan and gluten-free options available, accommodating guests with dietary restrictions. The menu even boasts alcoholic desserts, adding a fun twist to the offerings. A must-try is the combination of Buffalo's best poutine with fresh, homemade ice cream, creating a delightful fusion of flavors.
The service at this establishment is commonly described as friendly and quick, providing guests with an enjoyable dining experience. However, some guests have noted that the service can be slow due to staffing shortages, which may affect overall satisfaction.
The dessert menu is a highlight, featuring bold freak shakes and rich, creamy ice cream. These unique milkshakes, known as 'freak shakes,' offer a playful and indulgent treat. For those who prefer a more traditional dessert, the restaurant also offers their house-made ice cream in scoops, cones, and pints. Additionally, there are limited vegan and gluten-free options available, accommodating guests with dietary restrictions. The menu even boasts alcoholic desserts, adding a fun twist to the offerings. A must-try is the combination of Buffalo's best poutine with fresh, homemade ice cream, creating a delightful fusion of flavors.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Cheap Eats
4. Cookies & Cream
Nostalgic ice cream parlor with freshly baked cookies.
__NEW TEXT__
The giant ice cream sandwich at Cookies & Cream is a must-try for any sweet tooth. An impressive variety of cookies, ice creams, and toppings are available to create the perfect sandwich. In addition to the ice cream, Cookies & Cream also offers a range of delicious drinks. The store is known for its old-style atmosphere, making it a great spot for a casual outing or a special treat.
The staff at Cookies & Cream go above and beyond to ensure a positive experience for all customers. They are friendly, helpful, and work hard to fill orders accurately and efficiently. Even during busy periods, they maintain a high level of service. The ice cream itself is top-notch, with a rich and creamy texture that is sure to delight. The store is kept clean and tidy, making it a pleasant place to enjoy a treat. It can be busy at times, but the wait is worth it for the delicious food and excellent service. Consider ordering ahead to avoid any potential delays.
The giant ice cream sandwich at Cookies & Cream is a must-try for any sweet tooth. An impressive variety of cookies, ice creams, and toppings are available to create the perfect sandwich. In addition to the ice cream, Cookies & Cream also offers a range of delicious drinks. The store is known for its old-style atmosphere, making it a great spot for a casual outing or a special treat.
The staff at Cookies & Cream go above and beyond to ensure a positive experience for all customers. They are friendly, helpful, and work hard to fill orders accurately and efficiently. Even during busy periods, they maintain a high level of service. The ice cream itself is top-notch, with a rich and creamy texture that is sure to delight. The store is kept clean and tidy, making it a pleasant place to enjoy a treat. It can be busy at times, but the wait is worth it for the delicious food and excellent service. Consider ordering ahead to avoid any potential delays.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
5. Custard Corner & Grill
Family-friendly spot for tasty treats and grilled favorites.
__NEW TEXT__
Custard Corner & Grill is a popular destination on the West Side, offering a quintessential summer experience with their delicious ice cream and outdoor picnic tables. Among their most requested flavors are the rich Butter Pecan and the vibrant Northern Lights, which keep locals and visitors coming back for more.
This beloved West Side establishment, Custard Corner, is an ideal spot to enjoy ice cream and soak up the summer sun at their picnic tables. Their menu features mouth-watering options such as the nutty Butter Pecan and the captivating Northern Lights, making it a go-to destination for countless ice cream enthusiasts.
Custard Corner & Grill is a popular destination on the West Side, offering a quintessential summer experience with their delicious ice cream and outdoor picnic tables. Among their most requested flavors are the rich Butter Pecan and the vibrant Northern Lights, which keep locals and visitors coming back for more.
This beloved West Side establishment, Custard Corner, is an ideal spot to enjoy ice cream and soak up the summer sun at their picnic tables. Their menu features mouth-watering options such as the nutty Butter Pecan and the captivating Northern Lights, making it a go-to destination for countless ice cream enthusiasts.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
- Budget-Friendly Eats
6. Anderson's Frozen Custard
Signature Frozen Custard & All Natural Roast Beef on Weck!
__NEW TEXT__
The establishment has been a long-standing local favorite for many years, with a reputation for serving delicious food and ice cream. However, there seems to be a recurring issue that affects the dining experience for some patrons.
One customer, who has been visiting for several decades, including since they learned to drive, notes the consistent quality of the food and ice cream. However, they also bring up the lack of acknowledgement for tips. Despite being a generous tipper and having visited the establishment countless times, they have only received a thank you for their tip once or twice throughout their many visits. This oversight contributes to an unsatisfactory end to what is otherwise a pleasant dining experience.
The establishment has been a long-standing local favorite for many years, with a reputation for serving delicious food and ice cream. However, there seems to be a recurring issue that affects the dining experience for some patrons.
One customer, who has been visiting for several decades, including since they learned to drive, notes the consistent quality of the food and ice cream. However, they also bring up the lack of acknowledgement for tips. Despite being a generous tipper and having visited the establishment countless times, they have only received a thank you for their tip once or twice throughout their many visits. This oversight contributes to an unsatisfactory end to what is otherwise a pleasant dining experience.
7. Golden Hour Treats & Things
Your go-to spot for unique and delightful treats!
__NEW TEXT__
The bubble tea served at this establishment is nothing short of extraordinary. Its exquisite taste and high-quality ingredients make it the best the reviewer has ever had. The crepes are equally impressive, with their generous size and delicious flavor. One crepe is enough to satisfy even the heartiest of appetites, making it a great option for a meal or a shared treat with a friend.
The desserts at this location are truly a treat for the senses. The presentation is beautiful, and the variety is vast, ensuring that there is something for everyone. The high praise for the quality of the desserts is well deserved. This is certainly a place worth visiting, whether you're looking for a decadent dessert or a satisfying meal. The reviewer cannot emphasize enough how much this place is recommended for anyone with a sweet tooth or a love for delicious food.
The bubble tea served at this establishment is nothing short of extraordinary. Its exquisite taste and high-quality ingredients make it the best the reviewer has ever had. The crepes are equally impressive, with their generous size and delicious flavor. One crepe is enough to satisfy even the heartiest of appetites, making it a great option for a meal or a shared treat with a friend.
The desserts at this location are truly a treat for the senses. The presentation is beautiful, and the variety is vast, ensuring that there is something for everyone. The high praise for the quality of the desserts is well deserved. This is certainly a place worth visiting, whether you're looking for a decadent dessert or a satisfying meal. The reviewer cannot emphasize enough how much this place is recommended for anyone with a sweet tooth or a love for delicious food.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
8. Sweet Jenny's Chocolates & Ice Cream
Handcrafted treats made fresh daily in a historic mill.
__NEW TEXT__
Sweet Jenny's is renowned for their exquisite ice cream, particularly their Orange Chocolate flavor. The creamy texture and fresh taste of the chocolate and orange create a heavenly combination that is sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. Their Orange Chocolate Ice Cream stands out for its high-quality ingredients and exceptional flavors, making it a must-try for all ice cream lovers.
Sweet Jenny's commitment to quality extends to all their ice cream offerings, with an impressive range of flavors available to choose from. Each scoop of ice cream is a testament to their dedication to providing customers with a memorable dessert experience. Whether you're in the mood for fruity, chocolatey, or something in between, Sweet Jenny's has got you covered with their consistently excellent ice cream.
Sweet Jenny's is renowned for their exquisite ice cream, particularly their Orange Chocolate flavor. The creamy texture and fresh taste of the chocolate and orange create a heavenly combination that is sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. Their Orange Chocolate Ice Cream stands out for its high-quality ingredients and exceptional flavors, making it a must-try for all ice cream lovers.
Sweet Jenny's commitment to quality extends to all their ice cream offerings, with an impressive range of flavors available to choose from. Each scoop of ice cream is a testament to their dedication to providing customers with a memorable dessert experience. Whether you're in the mood for fruity, chocolatey, or something in between, Sweet Jenny's has got you covered with their consistently excellent ice cream.
9. Hanna's Frosty Treats
Serving Buffalo's favorite soft serve and novelties!
__NEW TEXT__
This ice cream parlor is a true hidden treasure. Their soft serve is a delight, and the extra thought they put into touches like branded Hannah's baseball hat bowls, as well as fresh Italian Ice, and even free mini cones for canine friends, make for an exceptional and memorable experience.
The custard served here is fantastic, with a luxurious thick and creamy texture. They offer a variety of flavored dips, which proved to be a popular hit. This establishment has undoubtedly mastered the art of creating delicious and enjoyable ice cream treats, making it a must-visit destination for ice cream enthusiasts.
This ice cream parlor is a true hidden treasure. Their soft serve is a delight, and the extra thought they put into touches like branded Hannah's baseball hat bowls, as well as fresh Italian Ice, and even free mini cones for canine friends, make for an exceptional and memorable experience.
The custard served here is fantastic, with a luxurious thick and creamy texture. They offer a variety of flavored dips, which proved to be a popular hit. This establishment has undoubtedly mastered the art of creating delicious and enjoyable ice cream treats, making it a must-visit destination for ice cream enthusiasts.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Breakfast
10. Pam's Custard Corner
Best custard in Buffalo with unique toppings!
__NEW TEXT__
Pam's Custard Corner, located in South Buffalo, is a highly recommended destination for anyone with a sweet tooth. Although the prices may be slightly higher than other establishments, the exceptional quality and diverse selection of treats, such as their famous frozen chocolate covered bananas with peanuts, make it a worthwhile investment.
The menu at Pam's Custard Corner boasts a wide variety of velvety custard flavors, with an extensive range of unique toppings, including birthday cake and cotton candy. The staff members are not only friendly and welcoming but also efficient, consistently delivering top-notch service. Customers have consistently raved about their delectable parfaits and frozen custards, which are considered among the best in Buffalo.
Pam's Custard Corner, located in South Buffalo, is a highly recommended destination for anyone with a sweet tooth. Although the prices may be slightly higher than other establishments, the exceptional quality and diverse selection of treats, such as their famous frozen chocolate covered bananas with peanuts, make it a worthwhile investment.
The menu at Pam's Custard Corner boasts a wide variety of velvety custard flavors, with an extensive range of unique toppings, including birthday cake and cotton candy. The staff members are not only friendly and welcoming but also efficient, consistently delivering top-notch service. Customers have consistently raved about their delectable parfaits and frozen custards, which are considered among the best in Buffalo.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Breakfast
11. Cookies & Cream On Elmwood
A sweet spot for ice cream lovers on Elmwood!
__NEW TEXT__
A charming and old-fashioned bakery awaits visitors with a cozy and inviting ambiance, ideal for relaxation and indulging in delicious sweets. The atmosphere harks back to a simpler time, making it a perfect spot to enjoy a well-deserved break.
The bakery offers a delightful range of tasty cookies and an impressive selection of ice cream, making it an excellent destination for those seeking a sweet treat. The high-quality offerings and welcoming environment are sure to leave a lasting impression on patrons looking for a place to satisfy their cravings.
A charming and old-fashioned bakery awaits visitors with a cozy and inviting ambiance, ideal for relaxation and indulging in delicious sweets. The atmosphere harks back to a simpler time, making it a perfect spot to enjoy a well-deserved break.
The bakery offers a delightful range of tasty cookies and an impressive selection of ice cream, making it an excellent destination for those seeking a sweet treat. The high-quality offerings and welcoming environment are sure to leave a lasting impression on patrons looking for a place to satisfy their cravings.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Gluten-Free
12. King Condrell's Candy and Ice Cream
Old-fashioned treats made with love since 1966
__NEW TEXT__
The ice cream shop offers excellent service, with a wide variety of options to choose from at reasonable prices. Knowledgeable staff members guide customers in making a selection, and they were particularly helpful in assisting with the choice of a peanut butter flavored ice cream. The choc PB banana milkshake turned out to be a fantastic option for enjoying a delicious treat while on the go.
A visit to the ice cream and candy shop is always a delightful experience, transporting customers back to a simpler time. Fans of nostalgia will appreciate the traditional offerings and inviting atmosphere. Whether looking for a sweet indulgence or a trip down memory lane, this shop is sure to satisfy.
The ice cream shop offers excellent service, with a wide variety of options to choose from at reasonable prices. Knowledgeable staff members guide customers in making a selection, and they were particularly helpful in assisting with the choice of a peanut butter flavored ice cream. The choc PB banana milkshake turned out to be a fantastic option for enjoying a delicious treat while on the go.
A visit to the ice cream and candy shop is always a delightful experience, transporting customers back to a simpler time. Fans of nostalgia will appreciate the traditional offerings and inviting atmosphere. Whether looking for a sweet indulgence or a trip down memory lane, this shop is sure to satisfy.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
13. Romeo & Juliet's Cafeé & Bakery
Experience Italy in Buffalo with our authentic flavors
__NEW TEXT__
The dessert options at this establishment are truly exceptional, with the ice cream standing out as a highlight. Food enthusiasts should not miss the opportunity to try it.
The ice cream served is nothing short of fantastic. Its delightful taste and creamy texture make it an excellent choice for those with a sweet tooth. Whether you're a casual diner or a dessert connoisseur, you'll find the ice cream to be a satisfying treat.
The dessert options at this establishment are truly exceptional, with the ice cream standing out as a highlight. Food enthusiasts should not miss the opportunity to try it.
The ice cream served is nothing short of fantastic. Its delightful taste and creamy texture make it an excellent choice for those with a sweet tooth. Whether you're a casual diner or a dessert connoisseur, you'll find the ice cream to be a satisfying treat.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Breakfast
- Mid-Range
14. Dairy Queen (Treat)
Classic frozen treats with a smile.
__NEW TEXT__
This establishment is renowned for its delicious and exciting ice cream blizzard, offering a wide variety of candy and cookie combinations to suit every taste preference. The customer service is consistently top-notch, and the parking lot is spacious, making it a convenient and enjoyable experience for all visitors. Despite the indulgent treats, prices remain reasonable, making it an affordable option for families and individuals alike.
The ice cream blizzard's delightful taste and texture, combined with the sentimental value of fond memories, make this a must-visit destination for all ice cream lovers. The springtime opening anticipation is shared among many, signaling the arrival of a refreshing and mouthwatering delight. Whether visiting with family, friends, or simply passing by, this ice cream destination guarantees a satisfying and enjoyable experience, with exceptional customer service and a welcoming atmosphere.
This establishment is renowned for its delicious and exciting ice cream blizzard, offering a wide variety of candy and cookie combinations to suit every taste preference. The customer service is consistently top-notch, and the parking lot is spacious, making it a convenient and enjoyable experience for all visitors. Despite the indulgent treats, prices remain reasonable, making it an affordable option for families and individuals alike.
The ice cream blizzard's delightful taste and texture, combined with the sentimental value of fond memories, make this a must-visit destination for all ice cream lovers. The springtime opening anticipation is shared among many, signaling the arrival of a refreshing and mouthwatering delight. Whether visiting with family, friends, or simply passing by, this ice cream destination guarantees a satisfying and enjoyable experience, with exceptional customer service and a welcoming atmosphere.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Lunch
15. Bryce's Ice Cream
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Waterfront
- Budget-Friendly Eats