Best of 18 lobster rolls in Buffalo

Discover our curated list of top-ranked lobster rolls in Buffalo, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Cole's, Allen Burger Venture, Liberty Hound, The Place, Charlie's Boat Yard. Let's explore together!

Toc

1. Cole's

Over 50 beers on tap, rotating selections

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (1114 Review by google)
  • Address:

    1104 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/colesbuffalo/
  • Pros:

    Wide selection of beer, friendly staff, cozy atmosphere
  • Cons:

    Can get crowded, limited food menu, hit-or-miss service
  • Popular Menu:

    Beef on Weck, Mac and Cheese, Cole's Classic Burger
  • Price Range:

    $-$$
Phone Directions Website
Experience the delectable delights at Cole's, where the food tantalizes the taste buds and the service surpasses expectations. Despite a brief oversight that had us waiting for attention, the flavorsome dishes made up for the delay. Don't let a minor hiccup deter you, as Cole's promises a culinary journey worth savoring. Your next favorite dining spot awaits!
Embark on a flavorful adventure along the Buffalo Wing Trail and make a pitstop at Cole's - a haven for wing enthusiasts. Indulge in some of the finest wings in town, served in a vibrant and inviting atmosphere that beckons you to unwind and socialize with friends. Cole's encapsulates the essence of good food, good company, and good times, making it a must-visit destination for wing aficionados.

TOPICS

  • Corporate Events
  • American Cuisine
  • Mid-Range
  • Dinner

Relate link

restaurants for large groups in Buffalo

2. Allen Burger Venture

Known for their unique and high-quality ingredients

  • Time:

    11:30 AM to 12 AM

  • Rating: 4.6/5 (1918 Review by google)
  • Address:

    175 Allen St, Buffalo, NY 14201, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allenburgerventure/
  • Pros:

    Wide selection of creative burgers, friendly service, popular craft beer list
  • Cons:

    Can get crowded, limited seating, may have long wait times during peak hours
  • Popular Menu:

    The Farmhouse Burger, The Mac Attack, Truffle Fries
  • Price Range:

    $10-$20
Phone Directions Website
Indulge in a truly unforgettable experience at Allen Burger Venture, where every bite will leave you craving more. The innovative selection of burgers offers a playful twist on a classic favorite, enticing you to explore each enticing option. While the prices may be a bit higher, the delicious flavors and generous portions more than make up for it, ensuring a satisfying and fulfilling meal. Despite a slight delay in service, the attentive waitress guarantees a pleasant dining experience, leaving you eager to return for another round of culinary delights at Allen Burger Venture.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Beer Bars in Buffalo

3. Liberty Hound

Features a nautical theme and historic photographs of Buffalo

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (962 Review by google)
  • Address:

    1 Naval Park Cove, Buffalo, NY 14202, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/libertyhoundbuffalo/
  • Pros:

    Outdoor seating with harbor views, locally sourced ingredients, extensive beer selection, dog-friendly, live music events
  • Cons:

    Pricey for the portion size, limited parking, can get crowded during events
  • Popular Menu:

    Lobster Roll, Fish and Chips, Beef on Weck
  • Price Range:

    $15 - $30
Phone Directions Website
Nestled by the waterfront, Liberty Hound beckons with a tantalizing seafood-centric menu that also offers tempting non-seafood options. From succulent pork chop to perfectly roasted asparagus, each dish is a delight for the taste buds, promising a culinary journey like no other. The ambiance is vibrant, making it an ideal spot to gather with friends for an unforgettable dining experience.
At Liberty Hound, excellence is not just a promise but a guarantee. The black grouper reigns supreme, embodying the pinnacle of seafood perfection. Our server, Riley, elevated the dining experience with impeccable service, ensuring every need was met with a smile. As a local favorite, Liberty Hound delivers a symphony of flavors that captivate the palate and leave a lasting impression. Indulge in a feast for the senses and savor the magic that defines this gem by the water.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Waterfront
  • Dinner

4. The Place

Family-owned and operated since 1976, unique local favorite

  • Time:

    11:30 AM to 10 PM

  • Rating: 4.5/5 (752 Review by google)
  • Address:

    229 Lexington Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theplacebuffalo/
  • Pros:

    Wide variety of menu options, friendly staff, offers catering services
  • Cons:

    Some reviewers mention long wait times, hit-or-miss food quality, cash-only policy
  • Popular Menu:

    Chicken finger subs, beef on weck, pizza logs
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website
Referred to The Place, we were thrilled with the experience. The banana pepper sauce was a standout, ample to share. Our main dishes did not disappoint either, and the crème brûlée finale was exquisite. Anticipating a return with family, my companions and I savored a variety of dishes, from the beef sandwich and buffalo chicken sandwich with crispy potatoes to a gluten-free option.

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • Celebrations
  • American Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

late night restaurants in Buffalo

5. Charlie's Boat Yard

Waterfront dining with a laid-back atmosphere

  • Rating: 4.1/5 (955 Review by google)
  • Address:

    1111 Fuhrmann Boulevard, Buffalo, NY 14203, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/charliesboatyard
  • Pros:

    Great views of the lake, Friendly and knowledgeable staff, Wide selection of food and drinks
  • Cons:

    Limited indoor seating, Cash only payments, Hit or miss food quality
  • Popular Menu:

    Lobster Rolls, Fish Fry, Clam Chowder
  • Price Range:

    $15 - $30
Phone Directions Website
During a bike ride along the Outer Harbor Trail, we stumbled upon Charlie's Boat Yard. The friendly staff and delectable food, especially the exceptional calamari, left us eagerly anticipating our next visit. With magnificent views, delicious dishes like the fish tacos, and a relaxed atmosphere perfect for the more mature crowd, this waterfront gem is a must-visit stop both for bikers and boat enthusiasts alike.

TOPICS

  • Waterfront
  • Lunch
  • Dinner

6. Founding Fathers Pub

Historic building with a variety of craft beers

Phone Directions
Founding Fathers Pub is a captivating tavern that pays homage to our Presidents and Nation without being overtly political. Featuring a modest selection of beers on tap and a menu focused on sandwiches and chips, the establishment offers a pleasant experience. Steeped in history, the pub's ambiance is enhanced by intriguing decor, making it a popular local hangout. As seen on "50 Things You Didn't Know About Buffalo," the tavern's unique concept invites patrons to immerse themselves in American history through engaging visuals and a lively atmosphere, complete with bar trivia for added fun.

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Karaoke Bars in Buffalo

7. Bailey Seafood

Friendly atmosphere with a focus on seafood excellence

  • Time:

    3 to 7 PM

  • Rating: 4.0/5 (921 Review by google)
  • Address:

    3316 Bailey Ave, Buffalo, NY 14215, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/baileyseafood/
  • Pros:

    Wide variety of seafood options, Fresh and high-quality ingredients, Generous portion sizes
  • Cons:

    Prices slightly above average, Limited vegetarian options, Inconsistent service
  • Popular Menu:

    Crab legs, Lobster tails, Shrimp scampi
  • Price Range:

    $30-$60 per person
Phone Directions Website
Bailey Seafood offers exceptional dishes, like the flavorful Skillet Chicken and Shrimp, perfect for sharing. Despite some issues with the pick-up service causing occasional delays and confusion, the food itself is undeniably delicious. From the mouthwatering sprouts to the tangy tartar sauce, each bite is a burst of spice and flavor. While the proteins are expertly fried, maintaining the intended crispiness can be a challenge during delivery, often a limitation of the third-party app handling the orders.

TOPICS

  • Mexican Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots
  • Dinner

Relate link

roasted chicken in Buffalo

8. The Terrace at Delaware Park

Beautiful setting in Delaware Park, Popular spot for events and gatherings

  • Rating: 4.3/5 (715 Review by google)
  • Address:

    199 Lincoln Pkwy, Buffalo, NY 14222, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/terracebuffalo/
  • Pros:

    Offers stunning views of Delaware Park, Great selection of beer and wine, Live music and events
  • Cons:

    Limited food options, Service can be slow, Outdoor seating only
  • Popular Menu:

    Burgers, Salads, Flatbreads
  • Price Range:

    $15-$30
Phone Directions Website
I attended a 5-course vegan wine dinner here with chef Scott Bogucki and it was fabulous!We sat family style at large round tables on the lower level by the water for an indoor/outdoor experience.

TOPICS

  • Mediterranean Cuisine
  • Waterfront
  • Social Gatherings
  • Vegetarian Options

9. The Crabman

Fresh seafood flown in daily

  • Time:

    4 to 9 PM

  • Rating: 4.1/5 (151 Review by google)
  • Address:

    341 Franklin St, Buffalo, NY 14202, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thecrabmanbuffalo/
  • Pros:

    Wide selection of seafood, Generous portion sizes, Friendly service
  • Cons:

    Limited vegetarian options, Inconsistent food quality, Noisey atmosphere
  • Popular Menu:

    Crab legs, Shrimp scampi, Lobster bisque
  • Price Range:

    $30-$60
Phone Directions Website
I reviewed this new seafood place in town and I must say I was a little disappointed.This is mainly due to poor menu naming for a couple of items (re: the catfish dinner isn't catfish and the gumbo soup isn't really gumbo).…

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

romantic restaurants in Buffalo

10. The Flaming Fish

Fresh seafood sourced daily from the Finger Lakes region

  • Rating: 4.6/5 (158 Review by google)
  • Address:

    535 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14203, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theflamingfishbuffalo/
  • Pros:

    Wide variety of seafood options, friendly service, offers catering and delivery
  • Cons:

    Some reviews mention long wait times, limited parking, and prices on the higher side
  • Popular Menu:

    lobster rolls, fish tacos, clam chowder
  • Price Range:

    $15 - $30
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots
  • Dinner

Relate link

family restaurants in Buffalo

11. Allen St Hardware Cafe

Local favorite with a laid-back vibe

  • Time:

    5 PM to 2 AM

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (423 Review by google)
  • Address:

    245 Allen St, Buffalo, NY 14201, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/allensthardware/
  • Pros:

    Wide selection of drinks and food, cozy atmosphere, friendly staff
  • Cons:

    Limited seating, can get crowded during peak hours, some menu items may be overpriced
  • Popular Menu:

    Craft beers, sandwiches, all-day breakfast
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots
  • Affordable Nightlife

Relate link

nightclubs in Buffalo

12. Falley Allen

Cozy atmosphere with eclectic decor

  • Rating: 4.1/5 (390 Review by google)
  • Address:

    204 Allen St, Buffalo, NY 14201, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/falleyallenbuffalo/
  • Pros:

    Offers brunch, dinner, and happy hour menus; pet-friendly patio; accommodates large groups
  • Cons:

    Limited parking; some menu items can be hit or miss; service can be slow during peak hours
  • Popular Menu:

    Chicken and waffles, avocado toast, bloody mary
  • Price Range:

    $10-$30
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots
  • Dinner

Relate link

cocktail bar in Buffalo

13. Teton Kitchen Elmwood . Asian Tapas , Bar & Sushi

Uniquely fuses Asian and western cuisine with a modern twist

  • Time:

    4 to 11 PM

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (390 Review by google)
  • Address:

    153 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14201, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/tetonkitchen/
  • Pros:

    Wide variety of Asian dishes, Creative cocktails, Friendly and attentive staff, Cozy atmosphere, Good for groups and date night
  • Cons:

    Limited vegetarian options, Some dishes may be too spicy for some, Parking can be challenging
  • Popular Menu:

    Pork belly bao buns, Spicy tuna roll, Drunken noodles
  • Price Range:

    $$$
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Asian Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Seafood restaurants in Buffalo

14. Rolack Seafood

Fresh seafood flown in daily, cozy and intimate atmosphere

  • Time:

    11 AM to 6 PM

  • Rating: 4.5/5 (196 Review by google)
  • Address:

    571 William St, Buffalo, NY 14206, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of seafood options, positive customer reviews, offers catering services
  • Cons:

    Limited vegetarian options, some complaints about slow service, a few customers find it overpriced
  • Popular Menu:

    Lobster roll, crab cakes, shrimp and grits
  • Price Range:

    $30-$60
Directions

TOPICS

  • Asian Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots
  • Dinner

Relate link

congee in Buffalo

15. Fresh Catch Poke and The Galley Lounge

Sustainable and locally sourced seafood

  • Time:

    11 AM to 8 PM

  • Rating: 4.6/5 (160 Review by google)
  • Address:

    305 Franklin St, Buffalo, NY 14202, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/freshcatchpoke/
  • Pros:

    Wide selection of fresh seafood, Friendly and attentive staff, Modern and clean atmosphere
  • Cons:

    Limited parking options, Higher price point compared to some competitors, Some customers find the portions small
  • Popular Menu:

    Poke bowls, Fish tacos, Craft beers
  • Price Range:

    $15 - $30
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Breakfast
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

pancakes in Buffalo

16. Man-aung Sushi

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Fusion Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots
  • Mid-Range

Relate link

lamb in Buffalo

17. Luxor Steak & Lobster

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Personal Celebrations
  • American Cuisine
  • High-End

18. Ballyhoo

Fresh seafood flown in daily, Upscale dining experience

  • Rating: 4.5/5 (1000 Review by google)
  • Address:

    211 South Park Ave, Buffalo, NY 14204, United States

  • Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ballyhoobuffalo/
  • Pros:

    Offers a variety of seafood options, Nice atmosphere and decor, Friendly and attentive staff
  • Cons:

    Prices can be on the higher side, Limited vegetarian options, Parking can be challenging
  • Popular Menu:

    Lobster rolls, Fish and chips, Clam chowder
  • Price Range:

    $30-$60
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots
  • Dinner

Relate link

oysters in Buffalo