Best of 19 consignment shops in Rochester
Discover our curated list of top-ranked consignment shops in Rochester, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Goodwill, The Op Shop, Estate Sale Store, Aaron's Alley, Little Button Craft. Let's explore together!
Toc
- 1. Goodwill
- 2. The Op Shop
- 3. Estate Sale Store
- 4. Aaron's Alley
- 5. Little Button Craft
- 6. Scarlet Bridal Boutique
- 7. Xquisite Boutique
- 8. Warehouse127 | Curated Home
- 9. The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center
- 10. South Avenue Treasures
- 11. MidCentury585
- 12. Victoria Clare Vintage
- 13. Staple Vintage
- 14. Pendulum Finds & Keeps
- 15. Little Shop of Hoarders
- 16. Matthew’s Closet
- 17. FOMO
- 18. Jonzey’s Closet
- 19. Rochester Greenovation
1. Goodwill
Proceeds benefit local programs and services

Discover an oasis of treasures at Goodwill, where every visit promises exciting finds. Seamlessly blending affordability with quality, this recently reorganized haven boasts a vast selection of shoes and clothing that cater to every style and size. As you browse through the aisles, keep an eye out for hidden gems in the book section and indulge in some delicious snacks while you shop. Despite its compact size, Goodwill never fails to impress with its warm atmosphere and excellent customer service, ensuring a memorable shopping experience every time.
Step into a world of endless possibilities at Goodwill, where the thrill of scoring great deals is a reality. Embrace the hustle and bustle of this shopper's paradise, where the staff's efficiency shines through even during peak hours. From fashionable finds to must-have essentials, Goodwill offers a diverse range of items that cater to all tastes and preferences. Treat yourself to some new shoes or clothing, and don't forget to explore their selection of snacks to keep you fueled during your shopping spree. With its unbeatable charm and unbeatable prices, Goodwill stands as a beacon of affordable luxury for savvy shoppers everywhere.
Step into a world of endless possibilities at Goodwill, where the thrill of scoring great deals is a reality. Embrace the hustle and bustle of this shopper's paradise, where the staff's efficiency shines through even during peak hours. From fashionable finds to must-have essentials, Goodwill offers a diverse range of items that cater to all tastes and preferences. Treat yourself to some new shoes or clothing, and don't forget to explore their selection of snacks to keep you fueled during your shopping spree. With its unbeatable charm and unbeatable prices, Goodwill stands as a beacon of affordable luxury for savvy shoppers everywhere.
2. The Op Shop

Experience the charm of The Op Shop, where hidden treasures await to enchant you. Step inside and immerse yourself in the allure of vintage fashion with a touch of Italian elegance. The attentive staff will guide you through a curated collection, ensuring you find the perfect piece to ignite your inner beauty and evoke a sense of warmth in your heart. With its organized layout and inclusive atmosphere, this gem of a showcase promises a delightful shopping experience that will keep you coming back for more.
Discover the magic of The Op Shop in the heart of Rochester, a delightful haven for vintage enthusiasts. Lose yourself in a world of exquisite finds, meticulously selected to captivate your senses. From high-quality garments to unique accessories, every corner exudes Joanna's passion for timeless style. Immerse yourself in the treasure trove of this boutique, where each item has a story to tell and each visit promises a new delight. Joanna's warm presence adds a personal touch to your shopping experience, making The Op Shop a must-visit destination for fashion aficionados.
Discover the magic of The Op Shop in the heart of Rochester, a delightful haven for vintage enthusiasts. Lose yourself in a world of exquisite finds, meticulously selected to captivate your senses. From high-quality garments to unique accessories, every corner exudes Joanna's passion for timeless style. Immerse yourself in the treasure trove of this boutique, where each item has a story to tell and each visit promises a new delight. Joanna's warm presence adds a personal touch to your shopping experience, making The Op Shop a must-visit destination for fashion aficionados.
3. Estate Sale Store
Unique and rare items available

Discover a treasure trove of possibilities at the Estate Sale Store. Revel in the abundance of furniture and decor, a haven for interior design enthusiasts. Journey through the aisles stocked with crockery, utensils, and even coffee makers on the main floor. Venture downstairs to unearth tools, man cave essentials, and perhaps even fishing tackle. Each corner is a delightful surprise, waiting to be explored.
Step into a world where aesthetics meet functionality at this exquisitely curated store. The tasteful presentation of items is unparalleled, enhancing the shopping experience. Remarkably, there is a noticeable absence of the musty odors often associated with such establishments. Immerse yourself in a shopping adventure where every item tells a story and adds character to your space.
Step into a world where aesthetics meet functionality at this exquisitely curated store. The tasteful presentation of items is unparalleled, enhancing the shopping experience. Remarkably, there is a noticeable absence of the musty odors often associated with such establishments. Immerse yourself in a shopping adventure where every item tells a story and adds character to your space.
4. Aaron's Alley
Rent-to-own options available

Explore Aaron's Alley, a charming gift shop situated on Monroe Ave in Rochester, New York. Delight in their eclectic array of Tie-dye and Dead memorabilia, as well as concert tickets for intimate local venues. A must-visit spot for unique gifts, especially for your bohemian pals.
Step into this treasure trove offering vintage attire, exclusive Greatful Dead pieces, handcrafted gemstone jewelry, and more. Discover a plethora of items like crystal skulls, tapestries, and sterling silver rings that cater to diverse tastes, making it a haven for enthusiasts of alternative fashion and accessories.
Step into this treasure trove offering vintage attire, exclusive Greatful Dead pieces, handcrafted gemstone jewelry, and more. Discover a plethora of items like crystal skulls, tapestries, and sterling silver rings that cater to diverse tastes, making it a haven for enthusiasts of alternative fashion and accessories.
5. Little Button Craft

Little Button Craft is a treasure trove of unique local finds, where the friendly staff make you feel right at home. Each visit is a delightful adventure, discovering ever-changing collections that beckon you to explore further. It's the perfect place to find special gifts or indulge yourself in something truly one-of-a-kind. Don't miss out on this charming gem in the heart of Roc!
Venturing into Little Button Craft is like stepping into a wonderland of adorable gifts and trinkets that will enchant everyone in your family. This store is a true hidden gem that deserves to be shared with all. You'll find yourself immersed in a world of creativity and charm, making it a must-visit for anyone in the area. So grab your camera and get ready to capture the magic for yourself!
Venturing into Little Button Craft is like stepping into a wonderland of adorable gifts and trinkets that will enchant everyone in your family. This store is a true hidden gem that deserves to be shared with all. You'll find yourself immersed in a world of creativity and charm, making it a must-visit for anyone in the area. So grab your camera and get ready to capture the magic for yourself!
6. Scarlet Bridal Boutique

Scarlet Bridal Boutique stood out as a sanctuary of warmth and elegance after a disappointing experience at another boutique. Sharon's swift response and accommodating nature secured an appointment, unveiling a meticulously clean and inviting space. Yet, while Sharon's amiable demeanor was a breath of fresh air, the intricacies of the dress fell short. The promise of tailored perfection clashed with the reality of limitations, leaving me disheartened as the envisioned sleeves seemed unattainable.
7. Xquisite Boutique

Xquisite Boutique is a gem for last-minute outfit inspo. The welcoming staff has kept me coming back for years, as they always go above and beyond to help. From prom suits to party shoes, they have us covered for all occasions, making us loyal customers and ensuring we never shop elsewhere.
8. Warehouse127 | Curated Home

9. The Salvation Army Thrift Store & Donation Center

10. South Avenue Treasures

11. MidCentury585

12. Victoria Clare Vintage

13. Staple Vintage

14. Pendulum Finds & Keeps

15. Little Shop of Hoarders

16. Matthew’s Closet

17. FOMO

18. Jonzey’s Closet

19. Rochester Greenovation
