Best of 19 grocery stores in Upper West Side NYC
Grocery stores in Upper West Side NYC are a vital part of the community, providing residents with access to fresh produce, meat, and other essentials. These stores range from large chains to small, family-owned businesses, each offering unique products and services. With a focus on quality and convenience, these grocery stores cater to the diverse needs of Upper West Side residents, making them a essential destination for locals and visitors alike.
- 1. Fairway Market of 74th Street
- 2. Whole Foods Market
- 3. Westside Market NYC
- 4. Trader Joe's
- 5. Key Food Supermarkets
- 6. Key Food Supermarkets
- 7. Pioneer Supermarket
- 8. Brooklyn Fare
- 9. Mani Market Place in Upper West Side
- 10. Garden of Eden Marketplace
- 11. Zingone Brothers
- 12. Gristedes
- 13. Broadway Farm
- 14. D'Agostino at 91st Street
- 15. Space Market
- 16. Simply Gourmet Market Place in Upper West Side
- 17. Morton Williams Supermarkets
- 18. West 82 Grocery Inc in Upper West Side
1. Fairway Market of 74th Street
Knowledgeable and helpful staff

The first poster raves about their positive experience at the restaurant, recently opened again after being closed. They praise the quality of the food and service, stating that the prices are reasonable and even less expensive than some diners. The reviewer also notes the availability of good cappuccino and considers the restaurant a hidden gem.
The second reviewer shares a very different experience, stating that their recent visit was dramatically different from their pre-pandemic visits. While the reviewer does not provide specific details about what has changed, they imply that the quality of the food or service has declined. Despite this, the poster does not mention any major issues and does not discourage others from visiting the restaurant.
2. Whole Foods Market
Known for its environmentally friendly practices

Whole Foods in Union Square is a favorite shopping destination, known for its fresh bakery items. Upon entering the store, one is immediately greeted by an abundance of flowers, creating a positive atmosphere. The bakery and cheese section, located near the entrance, are particularly noteworthy.
Despite the appealing selection of non-fresh bakery items, the author has never been tempted to purchase anything but the fresh offerings from the bakery. The appeal of the fresh bakery items, with their high quality and delicious taste, outweighs any interest in the pre-packaged options.
3. Westside Market NYC
Knowledgeable staff, extensive selection, and community atmosphere

This grocery store stands out for its impressive selection of fresh produce and specialty items. The staff is known for being friendly and helpful, which contributes to a positive shopping experience. The store is a valuable asset in the community, as it is clean, well-organized, and offers a wide variety of products.
If you're looking for a great grocery store, this one is highly recommended. It's not only a convenient option for fresh produce and essential items, but also offers a variety of specialty items. The friendly and helpful staff enhance the shopping experience, making it easy to find what you need. Overall, the store's cleanliness, organization, and product variety make it a true gem in the neighborhood.
4. Trader Joe's
Friendly staff, unique products, no artificial colors

Trader Joe's is known for its well-organized layout, friendly staff, and great prices. The store is easy to navigate, making shopping a breeze. Even when the store is crowded, the staff works efficiently to ensure lines move quickly. However, if you're looking to avoid the crowds, it's best to avoid Fridays right after work.
Trader Joe's is an excellent choice for smart shoppers. While it can get crowded, especially on Fridays after work, the store effectively manages long lines. Its affordable prices and helpful staff make it a popular destination for many shoppers. If you plan your visit carefully, you can take advantage of the store's many benefits without feeling overwhelmed by the crowds.
5. Key Food Supermarkets
Friendly service, well-organized store layout, and convenient location

Key Food Supermarkets, located near the 96th Street (Broadway - Seventh Avenue Line) Metro Station, is a great place to shop for food and beverages, farm products, fish and seafood, and deli meats. The store's knowledgeable staff is available to assist customers in navigating the product range and finding exactly what they need. Overall, Key Food Supermarkets is a convenient and reliable option for anyone looking to do their grocery shopping in the area.
Key Foods is a grocery store chain with a strong presence in New York, NY, offering a wide variety of food products and household essentials to customers. With multiple locations throughout the city, Key Foods aims to make shopping easy and convenient for individuals and families in the local community. Whether you're looking for fresh produce, pantry staples, or specialty items, Key Foods has everything you need to stock your kitchen and keep your household running smoothly.
6. Key Food Supermarkets
In-store bakery and deli, knowledgeable staff, convenient location

Key Food is a local grocery store known for its varied selection and reasonable prices, making it an ideal choice for shoppers seeking both quality and affordability. For those living in the surrounding neighborhood, Key Food was likely a go-to option for everyday grocery needs.
During a visit to Key Food, customers can expect to find a wide variety of products, ensuring they can locate their desired foods. The store's freezer section boasts a diverse assortment of options, catering to a range of culinary preferences. However, the selection of prepared meals and pizzas may be less extensive, so those seeking convenience may want to look elsewhere for quick meal solutions.
7. Pioneer Supermarket
Knowledgeable and helpful staff, catering services

If you're looking to save money on groceries, the cheapest supermarket in town is the place to go. Despite its dated appearance, Pioneer stocks a wide selection of products and offers better prices than other, more modern grocery stores in the area.
While some may be put off by the store's outdated decor, those who are focused on saving money will appreciate the value they find at Pioneer. With a huge selection of products and lower prices than its competitors, it's no wonder that budget-conscious shoppers are flocking to this store. Despite its lower rating, Pioneer remains a popular choice for those looking to save money on their grocery bills.
8. Brooklyn Fare
Intimate shopping experience, focused on quality

The specialty grocery store is slightly on the pricier side, but the high quality of its products, particularly those from the bakery section, makes it worth the extra cost. The store offers a wide variety of organic products, providing customers with a wide range of choices to select from.
The location of the store is convenient and easy to access. Inside, the store is kept clean and well-organized, making shopping a pleasant experience. The combination of these factors, along with the high-quality products available, makes this grocery store a great option for those looking for organic and specialty items.
9. Mani Market Place in Upper West Side
Long-standing establishment, cultural experience

Taso and Taki's market is a full-service grocery store that offers a wide selection of fresh produce, dairy, and bakery items. Customers can find both local and imported produce, a fantastic cheese selection, bulk whole coffee beans, fresh bakery bread, and various organic foods. In addition to their great product offerings, the market also features a deli bar and freshly brewed coffee.
The market is highly regarded for its selection, delicious sandwiches, and excellent service. The fresh roast turkey sandwiches are a customer favorite. Taso and Taki have created a welcoming and friendly shopping experience for their customers, making it a popular local grocery store.
10. Garden of Eden Marketplace
Sustainable and eco-friendly marketplace

The speaker has one complaint regarding their bakery experience. They noticed that the slices of cake are not easily accessible, and they believe this is because there is no employee in the bakery area. The speaker can understand why whole cakes are not on display, but they think it would be more convenient if individual slices were placed in a more accessible location.
In addition to this complaint, the speaker highlights a positive aspect of their visit. They mention a 50% discount on the salad bar at 8 pm, which they found to be a great deal. This suggests that despite their issue with the bakery, they still found value in other parts of the dining experience.
11. Zingone Brothers
Family-owned since 1924 with old-world charm

Zingone Brothers is a rare gem in the form of a family-owned and operated store that still exists today. This market offers high-quality produce at affordable prices, making it a great alternative to larger, corporate-owned grocery stores. For those living in the Upper West Side (UWS), Zingone Brothers is a welcome alternative to the nearby Gristedes, which may not offer the same freshness and quality in its produce section.
The move to a new neighborhood can be stressful, especially when it comes to finding reliable and high-quality grocery options. Those who have recently moved to the UWS can take comfort in the fact that Zingone Brothers provides fresh and affordable produce, making it a much better option than the nearby Gristedes. This family-owned store offers a level of care and attention that is often missing from larger chain stores, providing peace of mind for those looking for a convenient and trustworthy place to shop for their groceries.
12. Gristedes
Convenient location with friendly service

A local grocery store is a convenient option for quick stops, but it may not be the best choice for a full grocery run. The store takes pride in its cleanliness and organization, making it a pleasant place to shop. However, shoppers should be prepared to pay higher prices for items compared to other grocery stores in the surrounding area.
While the store has a decent selection of products, shoppers may not be able to find everything they need. Items may be out of stock or not carried at all. Despite this, the store remains a popular choice for those looking for a quick and convenient shopping experience. However, those on a budget may want to consider other options to save money on their grocery bill.
13. Broadway Farm
Committed to sustainable and local sourcing

Broadway Farm is a bustling retail food store located in New York, specifically at 2341 Broadway, NY 10024. It is licensed by the Division of Food Safety & Inspection of the NYS Department of Agriculture and Markets, ensuring that it meets strict quality and safety standards. The store offers a wide variety of products, including fresh produce, meats, cheese, household items, and a comprehensive fish department, making it a one-stop-shop for all grocery needs. The high volume of customers and frequent turnover of products ensures that the food is always fresh.
In addition to being a licensed retail food store, Broadway Farm also serves as a neighborhood destination for local residents. Its central location in the county of New York makes it easily accessible to those in the area. The store's bustling atmosphere and wide selection of products make it a popular destination for shoppers looking for high-quality, fresh food options. Whether you're in need of groceries for the week or just stopping by for a few items, Broadway Farm is the perfect place to stock up on all your food and household needs.
14. D'Agostino at 91st Street
Family-owned and operated for over 40 years

This local grocery store stands out for its great selection of fresh produce and friendly staff. The store is conveniently located, making it a perfect spot for quick shopping trips. Although prices are slightly higher compared to other stores, the excellent quality of the products makes up for it.
The well-stocked grocery store offers a wide variety of items, ensuring customers can find what they need. The knowledgeable and approachable staff create a welcoming atmosphere, helping customers and answering questions. While the cost of goods is a bit above average, the assurance of high-quality produce and goods makes it a preferred choice for many. Ultimately, the convenience, selection, and welcoming environment make this local grocery store a popular shopping destination.
15. Space Market

16. Simply Gourmet Market Place in Upper West Side

1138 ratings Convenience • Open now 92% Food was good 93% Delivery was on time 90% Order was correct Go to menu "Always a great experience! " David • 6 days ago "Excellent service, food was excellent! " David • 1 week ago "The French toast was very good. The cut fruit had too much watermelon, I would like more oranges and grapes!" Venkat • 3 weeks ago 3
17. Morton Williams Supermarkets
Knowledgeable and friendly staff

Trader Joe's is known for being a bit more expensive than other grocery stores, but the quality of their products justifies the cost. The store offers a wide variety of items, including both fresh produce and packaged goods. In addition to the high-quality products, Trader Joe's is also known for their friendly and helpful staff. The convenience of the store's location is an added bonus for many shoppers.
Trader Joe's stands out for its focus on high-quality products, even if the prices are a bit higher than at other grocery stores. The store's wide selection of items ensures that shoppers can find everything they need in one place. The staff's friendly and helpful attitude makes for a pleasant shopping experience. The convenient location of most Trader Joe's stores is the cherry on top, making it a great option for grocery shopping.
18. West 82 Grocery Inc in Upper West Side
