Best of 15 Italian restaurants in Syracuse New York City
When it comes to dining, Italian restaurants in Syracuse, NY offer a delicious and authentic experience. These establishments bring the warm and inviting atmosphere of Italy right to your table, serving up classic dishes like pasta, pizza, and risotto. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner spot or a family-friendly eatery, Italian restaurants in Syracuse, NY are sure to satisfy. Indulge in mouth-watering flavors and traditional recipes at these top-rated culinary destinations.
- 1. Pastabilities
- 2. Francesca's Cucina
- 3. Delmonico's Syracuse
- 4. Strada Mia 313
- 5. Attilio's
- 6. Abbiocco by A Mano
- 7. Spaghetti Warehouse Syracuse
- 8. Angotti's Family Restaurant
- 9. Apizza Regionale
- 10. Twin Trees Restaurant
- 11. Mona Lisas Ristorante
- 12. Pavone's Pizza
- 13. Joey's Italian Restaurant and Pronto Joeys
- 14. Nick's Tomato Pie
- 15. Franco's Pizzeria and Deli
1. Pastabilities
Heart and soul in every dish for 40 years.

At a popular Italian eatery in downtown Syracuse, diners are treated to a complimentary Spicy Hot Tomato Oil and stretch bread while they await their meals. The pasta options are diverse and satisfying, with each dish expertly prepared and bursting with flavor.
The atmosphere at this establishment is lively and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a Friday night out. The food and presentation are both impressive, with a focus on fresh ingredients and bold flavors. Many dishes feature a delightful garlic kick, adding an extra layer of depth and complexity to each bite. Overall, the restaurant offers a top-notch Italian dining experience that is not to be missed.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Dinner
2. Francesca's Cucina
Family-owned gem in Syracuse's Little Italy

Francesca's has established a strong reputation over the years, and it's easy to see why. The restaurant offers a delightful dining experience, with delicious food, a charming atmosphere, and a beautiful outdoor grotto that provides a unique and romantic setting. Whether it's a special occasion or just a night out, Francesca's never fails to impress.
During a recent visit, we had the pleasure of trying several of the restaurant's signature dishes. The Chicken Riggies, which were spicy and flavorful, were a standout, as was the Lobster Ravioli, which was rich and creamy. The Fettuccine was cooked to perfection, and the stuffed Salmon with crab risotto was a hit with my wife. All of the dishes were delicious, and the portions were generous. Overall, the food at Francesca's is consistently excellent, making it a go-to spot for Italian cuisine in downtown Syracuse.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Celebrations
- Downtown Spots
3. Delmonico's Syracuse
A fusion of casual steakhouse and fine Italian dining

TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
- Weekend Dining
4. Strada Mia 313
We provide our best for you, as you are our family.

This establishment is a delightful dining option, particularly for those who enjoy outdoor seating and special occasions. The menu features several standout dishes, including the succulent prime rib and the rich and flavorful chicken Riggies. Diners are certain to be pleased with the quality and presentation of these dishes.
The service at this restaurant is typically described as good, with a team of friendly and attentive staff members. However, some reviewers have noted that service can be slower during peak dining hours. Despite this occasional delay, the overall dining experience is generally positive and well-regarded by patrons.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
5. Attilio's
Authentic Italian flavors made from scratch daily.

A memorable dining experience was had on a Saturday evening in June. The meal began with a generous serving of warm, crusty Italian bread that was truly delightful. Starting the meal with such high-quality bread speaks volumes about a restaurant's dedication to providing an excellent dining experience. Both our fresh and crisp salads were exceptional, setting a promising tone for the rest of the meal.
The main courses continued to impress. I had the Shrimp and Scallops over Linguine, which were cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor. My dining partner's Eggplant Parmesan was equally impressive, as the eggplant was breaded and not fried, resulting in a lighter and tastier dish. To end the meal, we shared a homemade Turtle Cheesecake, which was a indulgent and satisfying conclusion. Our waitress Jessica provided excellent service, while Samantha the bartender added to the friendly atmosphere. With drinks, main courses, dessert, and tip, the total cost was $100, which was quite reasonable given the quality and quantity of the food.
During our initial visit, we had reservations for 5 pm and were promptly seated. Our party of four was attended to eagerly, and we ordered a selection of drinks, including a Birthday Martini for one. As we waited, we received bread and oil with garlic and crushed red pepper, which perfectly complemented the two delicious appetizers we ordered: Fried Meatballs and Hot Peppers. The appetizers were delivered in a timely manner and were so generous that we almost filled up before our entrees arrived. We indulged in a variety of dishes, including Salmon, Chicken Parmigiana, Haddock, and Seafood Medley over Angel Hair. The food was remarkable, with the Haddock and Meatballs being particularly noteworthy for their generous portions and bold flavors.
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
6. Abbiocco by A Mano
Rustic Italian fare with a modern twist.

Abbiocco is truly one of the top restaurants in Syracuse, boasting delicious homemade pastas, pizzas, and side dishes. The meals are so extraordinary that they often leave diners in awe, leading to descriptions of the meal to others long after. The complimentary homemade bread and butter service is a standout way to start any meal and sets the tone for the quality of food to come. The restaurant focuses on using simple, high-quality ingredients that allow each ingredient and flavor to shine.
The ownership adds a personal touch to the dining experience, often talking to customers at their tables and adding special touches that make the meal and night even more memorable. It's the perfect spot for a glass of wine and wood-fired pizza at the bar or a full meal. The menu emphasizes seasonality and local produce, resulting in dishes that are not only delicious but also fresh and timely. From the fire-roasted delicata squash with burrata to the seafood entree on special and signature dessert, each dish is meticulously crafted and full of flavor.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
7. Spaghetti Warehouse Syracuse
A fun dining experience with generous portions and great service.

Customers consistently give high marks for the level of service provided, often highlighting the quality of the staff and servers. Warm and gracious interactions with customers are frequently cited as a standout aspect of the service.
Regarding the culinary offerings, many reviewers describe the food as flavorful and plentiful, yet a small subset of diners note a greasy or oversalted quality to some dishes. The presentation of the meals is visually appealing, and the restaurant's atmosphere is commended for its cleanliness and hygiene. Overall, the establishment provides a positive dining experience, with great service and food quality being the primary strengths.
8. Angotti's Family Restaurant
Best red sauce in Syracuse, family-friendly atmosphere.

Angotti's Family Restaurant is currently offering take-out services due to the ongoing situation. A recent catering order for 85 people was placed, and the experience was exceptional. The baked ziti was a hit, with such positive feedback that a second order was necessary. The salad was also a success, filled with a variety of fresh vegetables and olives. The bread received high praise, resulting in an increased order as well.
Angotti's is well-known in Syracuse for its authentic Italian cuisine. The pasta dishes are particularly noteworthy, including options like pasta and beans, pasta and meatballs, or sausage. The pasta is always cooked to perfection, and the red sauce is a customer favorite, often considered the best in town. Whether you're looking for a casual take-out meal or catering for a large event, Angotti's is an excellent choice.
9. Apizza Regionale
Authentic Neapolitan and New York style pizzas in a cozy setting.

Apizza Regionale is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Syracuse. The restaurant prides itself on sourcing ingredients from regional growers and producers in NY State and surrounding areas, resulting in a high-quality product that is both delicious and fresh. Cooked in a large custom oven imported from Italy, the wood-fired pizza is a standout dish that is worth the trip alone.
Service at Apizza Regionale is attentive and efficient, ensuring that guests have a pleasant dining experience. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it a great spot for families, friends, and couples. In addition to their excellent pizza, Apizza Regionale also boasts a impressive cocktail menu, featuring hand-crafted drinks made with top-shelf spirits. The Negroni, in particular, is a crowd favorite. The restaurant can get busy, especially during peak hours, so it is recommended to arrive early or try them for lunch to beat the crowds. Overall, Apizza Regionale is a top-notch pizza destination in Syracuse that should not be missed.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
10. Twin Trees Restaurant
A longstanding Italian gem with a cozy charm.

Twin Trees Restaurant on Avery Avenue is a well-established Italian eatery that has gained a reputation for serving excellent pizza and wings at an unbeatable price. Their pizza is made with high-quality ingredients and features a perfect balance of crispy crust and flavorful toppings. The wings are equally delightful, with a choice of sauces that will satisfy any palate.
Apart from their outstanding pizza and wings, Twin Trees Restaurant offers a range of mouth-watering dishes. Their fried ravioli and pasta fugli are popular choices, and the chicken riggies are a must-try for meat lovers. The restaurant's vodka sauce is also highly acclaimed, adding a unique touch to their pasta dishes. The comfortable atmosphere and friendly service make Twin Trees Restaurant an ideal spot for a family dinner, a night out with friends, or a quick bite to eat.
11. Mona Lisas Ristorante
Authentic Italian cuisine with a touch of old-world charm.

The establishment offers a dining experience that continually improves with each visit. Two standout dishes are the hot and creamy chicken Riggies and the delectable hot pizza. The chicken Riggies feature tender chicken in a rich and creamy sauce, while the pizza boasts a perfect crust and an ample topping selection.
The food at this establishment is not only consistently delicious but also generously portioned, providing great value for the price. The sauces used in the dishes have received particular praise for their depth of flavor and quality. The kitchen takes care to ensure every dish meets the highest standards, resulting in a dining experience that is sure to please.
12. Pavone's Pizza
Always Best, Always Fresh!

Pizza at this establishment is held in high regard for its authentic and classic nature, featuring top-quality ingredients that contribute to its delicious taste. The chewy crust is often reminiscent of the iconic pizzerias in Little Italy, New York City.
Upon moving to the area and visiting the pizzeria, one cannot help but notice the exceptionally friendly and helpful staff. Their welcoming demeanor creates a warm and inviting atmosphere, making customers feel right at home. While their cheese pizza is a satisfactory option, it does not quite reach the level of being spectacular. However, the sauce and cheese are both reliable and flavorful, and their calzones come highly recommended. The crust, though, is a touch too thick for those seeking a traditional New York-style slice.
13. Joey's Italian Restaurant and Pronto Joeys
Two great restaurants under one roof!

A lovely and romantic atmosphere welcomes guests to this upscale establishment. The atmosphere is sure to impress, with impeccable service that makes every guest feel like royalty. The menu features a wide variety of dishes, all made with high-quality ingredients and prepared with great care.
Customers rave about the taste and quality of the food, with many praising the chicken marsala, meatball, pasta primavera, and steak as standout dishes. The presentation of the food is just as impressive as the flavors, making every meal a visual feast as well as a culinary one. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner spot or a place to enjoy a night out with friends, this restaurant is sure to impress.
14. Nick's Tomato Pie
Serving Syracuse's best pizza since 1995!

A fantastic location for a satisfying and swift meal is this establishment, where the Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza is a standout selection. The staff is welcoming and the ambiance is comfortable, making it a great spot for a relaxed dining experience.
Syracuse's finest Italian cuisine can be found at this establishment, where the lasagna is an absolute must-try. Furthermore, the garlic knots are a perfect complement and add to the delightful dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
15. Franco's Pizzeria and Deli
A Slice of Italy in the Heart of Syracuse!

Franco's is an excellent choice for those seeking quick and reliable food delivery. The meals consistently arrive hot and at the peak of freshness, which is vital when ordering Italian cuisine. Among the standout options on the menu are the Italian subs, which have garnered a reputation for their exceptional taste and quality.
The pizza at Franco's is another highlight, featuring a perfectly crispy crust that serves as an ideal foundation for the generous toppings. The freshness of the ingredients truly sets this pizza apart, making it a must-try for any pizza lover. All things considered, Franco's is undoubtedly one of the top Italian restaurants in Syracuse.