Best of 14 pizza places in Upper West Side NYC
Pizza places in Upper West Side NYC offer a wide variety of delicious pies for any palate. From classic cheese and pepperoni to more unique options like truffle and artichoke, these pizza places have it all. With cozy atmospheres and friendly service, they provide a welcoming dining experience for both locals and tourists alike. Whether you're looking for a quick slice or a sit-down meal, pizza places in Upper West Side NYC are sure to satisfy.
Toc
- 1. Made In New York Pizza
- 2. Patsy's Pizzeria
- 3. Made in New York Pizza
- 4. Marinara Pizza Upper West in Upper West Side
- 5. Sal and Carmine Pizza
- 6. Freddie & Pepper's
- 7. UNO Pizzeria & Grill
- 8. Peperino West Side
- 9. Mama's TOO!
- 10. Motorino in Upper West Side
- 11. Marinara Pizza - Broadway
- 12. Bravo West Pizza
- 13. La Traviata Pizzeria
- 14. Pizza Collective in Upper West Side
1. Made In New York Pizza
The quintessential New York pizza experience.
__NEW TEXT__
Made in New York Pizza is an excellent choice for affordable and delicious pizza in New York City. With a wide variety of pizza slices to choose from, customers can find something to suit their taste. Once an order is placed, the pizza slices are warmed up in a large pizza oven, ensuring they are served hot and fresh. The staff is efficient, and the pizza is both delicious and reasonably priced.
Located on New York City's Upper West Side, Made in New York Pizza is a reliable option for pizza lovers. The restaurant is a frequent stop for both tourists and locals alike, and it is a particular favorite of their son. During their most recent visit to NYC, they stopped by the restaurant twice and enjoyed a selection of slices, including mushroom, vodka, Sicilian, Margherita, and cheese. Each slice was served hot and flavorful, making for a satisfying meal.
Made in New York Pizza is an excellent choice for affordable and delicious pizza in New York City. With a wide variety of pizza slices to choose from, customers can find something to suit their taste. Once an order is placed, the pizza slices are warmed up in a large pizza oven, ensuring they are served hot and fresh. The staff is efficient, and the pizza is both delicious and reasonably priced.
Located on New York City's Upper West Side, Made in New York Pizza is a reliable option for pizza lovers. The restaurant is a frequent stop for both tourists and locals alike, and it is a particular favorite of their son. During their most recent visit to NYC, they stopped by the restaurant twice and enjoyed a selection of slices, including mushroom, vodka, Sicilian, Margherita, and cheese. Each slice was served hot and flavorful, making for a satisfying meal.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mexican Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Dinner
2. Patsy's Pizzeria
Premier pizza dynasty in New York
__NEW TEXT__
The cheese pizza on offer boasts a non-greasy, authentic American-style cheese that is delicious. The crust is not only easy to chew but also has crisp edges and a light charring in places, adding to its appeal. The salad options are equally impressive, providing a refreshing contrast to the rich and buttery cheese.
Moving on to the toppings, the pepperoni is exceptionally peppery, providing a spicy kick that complements the rest of the ingredients well. The red and green roasted peppers are a significant addition, contributing a vegetable presence that is both flavorful and visually appealing. Overall, the combination of the perfectly cooked crust, high-quality cheese, and generous toppings make for a truly satisfying dining experience.
The cheese pizza on offer boasts a non-greasy, authentic American-style cheese that is delicious. The crust is not only easy to chew but also has crisp edges and a light charring in places, adding to its appeal. The salad options are equally impressive, providing a refreshing contrast to the rich and buttery cheese.
Moving on to the toppings, the pepperoni is exceptionally peppery, providing a spicy kick that complements the rest of the ingredients well. The red and green roasted peppers are a significant addition, contributing a vegetable presence that is both flavorful and visually appealing. Overall, the combination of the perfectly cooked crust, high-quality cheese, and generous toppings make for a truly satisfying dining experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Mid-Range
Relate link
3. Made in New York Pizza
Experience the quintessential New York taste.
__NEW TEXT__
Made in New York Pizza is a popular choice for pizza lovers on the Upper West Side of NYC. With a wide variety of options, it's a great spot for families and groups with different tastes. During a recent visit, this reviewer enjoyed a range of slices including mushroom, vodka, Sicilian, Margherita, and cheese.
The pizzas at Made in New York Pizza consistently receive high marks for quality, punctuality and accuracy. Overall, the food is excellent, arriving in a timely manner and in the correct order. The pizza slices were fresh, hot and flavorful, making for a satisfying meal on both occasions that this reviewer visited.
Made in New York Pizza is a popular choice for pizza lovers on the Upper West Side of NYC. With a wide variety of options, it's a great spot for families and groups with different tastes. During a recent visit, this reviewer enjoyed a range of slices including mushroom, vodka, Sicilian, Margherita, and cheese.
The pizzas at Made in New York Pizza consistently receive high marks for quality, punctuality and accuracy. Overall, the food is excellent, arriving in a timely manner and in the correct order. The pizza slices were fresh, hot and flavorful, making for a satisfying meal on both occasions that this reviewer visited.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
4. Marinara Pizza Upper West in Upper West Side
Passion for quality ingredients and hospitality.
__NEW TEXT__
This pizza establishment offers fresh and delicious pizzas that will surely satisfy your cravings. The cheese and margherita slices are made to order, ensuring each bite is hot and flavorful. The quality of the ingredients used is evident in the taste and texture of the pizza, providing a satisfying dining experience.
The BBQ chicken pizza is a standout option, always cooked to perfection with a well-balanced blend of sweet and savory flavors. The staff members are not only friendly but also attentive, providing excellent customer service and contributing to the restaurant's welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're a regular or a first-time customer, the consistently great pizza and warm hospitality make this a go-to spot for pizza lovers.
This pizza establishment offers fresh and delicious pizzas that will surely satisfy your cravings. The cheese and margherita slices are made to order, ensuring each bite is hot and flavorful. The quality of the ingredients used is evident in the taste and texture of the pizza, providing a satisfying dining experience.
The BBQ chicken pizza is a standout option, always cooked to perfection with a well-balanced blend of sweet and savory flavors. The staff members are not only friendly but also attentive, providing excellent customer service and contributing to the restaurant's welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're a regular or a first-time customer, the consistently great pizza and warm hospitality make this a go-to spot for pizza lovers.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
5. Sal and Carmine Pizza
Serving New York's best pizza since 1957.
__NEW TEXT__
Sal & Carmine's is a well-known pizza destination in the Upper West Side, with a long-standing reputation for serving high-quality pizzas. Whether you're in the mood for a quick slice or a whole pie for the family, Sal & Carmine's is an excellent choice. Their crust and toppings are renowned for their exceptional taste and quality, making every bite a memorable experience.
This legendary pizzeria has received acclaim from many reputable sources, including The New York Times, which named it one of the top five slices in the city. Several other comparisons and rankings have also reached the same conclusion, attesting to the consistently outstanding pizza that Sal & Carmine's offers. Whether you're a local resident or a tourist, a visit to Sal & Carmine's is a must for any pizza lover.
Sal & Carmine's is a well-known pizza destination in the Upper West Side, with a long-standing reputation for serving high-quality pizzas. Whether you're in the mood for a quick slice or a whole pie for the family, Sal & Carmine's is an excellent choice. Their crust and toppings are renowned for their exceptional taste and quality, making every bite a memorable experience.
This legendary pizzeria has received acclaim from many reputable sources, including The New York Times, which named it one of the top five slices in the city. Several other comparisons and rankings have also reached the same conclusion, attesting to the consistently outstanding pizza that Sal & Carmine's offers. Whether you're a local resident or a tourist, a visit to Sal & Carmine's is a must for any pizza lover.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
6. Freddie & Pepper's
Delicious pizza with a friendly atmosphere.
__NEW TEXT__
This pizza place in New York is a must-visit, particularly for take-out. Upon entering, one immediately notices the pizza kitchen, with only a few tables available for dining in. A single slice is quite filling, and the assortment of pizzas available changes regularly, depending on the time and what remains. On a recent visit, a large pizza was ordered, which was so large that it barely fit through the hotel room door. The pizza provided several meals' worth of food and was an excellent value.
During the Thanksgiving parade in Manhattan's Upper West Side, a friend and I stumbled upon Freddy's Pizza. Before watching the parade, we shared a slice. The pesto goat cheese slice was unlike any I had ever seen before, and it was incredible. My friend, a private chef, tried the ranch chicken pizza and declared it one of the best slices he had in years. Freddy's Pizza is an exceptional pizzeria, and their unique and delicious offerings should not be missed.
This pizza place in New York is a must-visit, particularly for take-out. Upon entering, one immediately notices the pizza kitchen, with only a few tables available for dining in. A single slice is quite filling, and the assortment of pizzas available changes regularly, depending on the time and what remains. On a recent visit, a large pizza was ordered, which was so large that it barely fit through the hotel room door. The pizza provided several meals' worth of food and was an excellent value.
During the Thanksgiving parade in Manhattan's Upper West Side, a friend and I stumbled upon Freddy's Pizza. Before watching the parade, we shared a slice. The pesto goat cheese slice was unlike any I had ever seen before, and it was incredible. My friend, a private chef, tried the ranch chicken pizza and declared it one of the best slices he had in years. Freddy's Pizza is an exceptional pizzeria, and their unique and delicious offerings should not be missed.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
7. UNO Pizzeria & Grill
Home of the original Chicago deep dish pizza.
__NEW TEXT__
UNO Pizzeria & Grill is known for its diverse pizza offerings, ranging from customizable options to deep dish pizzas with various meat toppings, thin crust Blanco Roses, and even Hawaiian-style pies. However, opinions about the pizza's quality differ, with some customers praising it as the best deep-pan pizza in New York while others express disappointment due to undercooked or cold centers.
In addition to their pizza options, UNO Pizzeria & Grill also offers affordable lunch specials. For under $8.99, customers can enjoy a meal that includes a soup or salad, making it an excellent choice for budget-conscious diners seeking a satisfying lunch option.
UNO Pizzeria & Grill is known for its diverse pizza offerings, ranging from customizable options to deep dish pizzas with various meat toppings, thin crust Blanco Roses, and even Hawaiian-style pies. However, opinions about the pizza's quality differ, with some customers praising it as the best deep-pan pizza in New York while others express disappointment due to undercooked or cold centers.
In addition to their pizza options, UNO Pizzeria & Grill also offers affordable lunch specials. For under $8.99, customers can enjoy a meal that includes a soup or salad, making it an excellent choice for budget-conscious diners seeking a satisfying lunch option.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
8. Peperino West Side
A local pizzeria with a community feel.
__NEW TEXT__
Peperino West Side offers a variety of Italian-American dishes, including their NY-style pizza, pasta, salads, wings, soup, and appetizers. The restaurant has a welcoming and family-friendly atmosphere, making it a great spot for a casual meal. While the pizza may not always meet expectations, children seem to enjoy it, making it a good option for families with young kids.
The BBQ chicken wings are one of the highlights of the menu, and the staff is known for being kind and helpful. However, some may find the prices a bit steep, especially when ordering a slice of pizza and a beer. Despite this, Peperino West Side remains a popular choice for those looking for a taste of New York-style pizza in a relaxed setting.
Peperino West Side offers a variety of Italian-American dishes, including their NY-style pizza, pasta, salads, wings, soup, and appetizers. The restaurant has a welcoming and family-friendly atmosphere, making it a great spot for a casual meal. While the pizza may not always meet expectations, children seem to enjoy it, making it a good option for families with young kids.
The BBQ chicken wings are one of the highlights of the menu, and the staff is known for being kind and helpful. However, some may find the prices a bit steep, especially when ordering a slice of pizza and a beer. Despite this, Peperino West Side remains a popular choice for those looking for a taste of New York-style pizza in a relaxed setting.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Affordable Nightlife
- Dinner
9. Mama's TOO!
Big taste in a small spot.
__NEW TEXT__
The pizza establishment is a small, unassuming venue with minimal interior seating and a straightforward ordering process. Customers are expected to order their pizza, wait in a designated area, and claim their order once their name is called out.
Despite the lackluster customer service, the pizza is truly exceptional. The crust is crunchy and offers a satisfying texture, while the sauce is bursting with flavor. In fact, it is arguably the best pizza available in all of New York City. During a recent trip to NYC for the marathon, this pizza joint was a top priority for a post-race meal, and it did not disappoint. With an extensive menu filled with flavorful options, it's no wonder that this pizzeria has gained a loyal following.
The pizza establishment is a small, unassuming venue with minimal interior seating and a straightforward ordering process. Customers are expected to order their pizza, wait in a designated area, and claim their order once their name is called out.
Despite the lackluster customer service, the pizza is truly exceptional. The crust is crunchy and offers a satisfying texture, while the sauce is bursting with flavor. In fact, it is arguably the best pizza available in all of New York City. During a recent trip to NYC for the marathon, this pizza joint was a top priority for a post-race meal, and it did not disappoint. With an extensive menu filled with flavorful options, it's no wonder that this pizzeria has gained a loyal following.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
- Budget-Friendly Eats
10. Motorino in Upper West Side
Authentic Neapolitan pizza with a modern twist.
__NEW TEXT__
Motorino is a delightful pizza restaurant that offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere with exceptional service. Their menu boasts delicious options like the clam and prosciutto pizzas, which are sure to satisfy any pizza lover's cravings. Additionally, their wings are packed with flavor and served at just the right temperature. The crust of their pizzas has a fantastic texture – soft and chewy with a crispy edge that adds a satisfying crunch to every bite.
A different pizza variety, the picante, failed to impress as much, but the spread used for the salad was exceptional. Unfortunately, the diner forgot to ask the waiter about its name, but the unique taste still left a lasting impression. This spread's deliciousness highlights the restaurant's attention to detail in crafting high-quality dishes, elevating their offerings beyond just pizza and wings. Motorino's commitment to flavor and quality is evident in every dish, making it a worthwhile choice for any food lover.
Motorino is a delightful pizza restaurant that offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere with exceptional service. Their menu boasts delicious options like the clam and prosciutto pizzas, which are sure to satisfy any pizza lover's cravings. Additionally, their wings are packed with flavor and served at just the right temperature. The crust of their pizzas has a fantastic texture – soft and chewy with a crispy edge that adds a satisfying crunch to every bite.
A different pizza variety, the picante, failed to impress as much, but the spread used for the salad was exceptional. Unfortunately, the diner forgot to ask the waiter about its name, but the unique taste still left a lasting impression. This spread's deliciousness highlights the restaurant's attention to detail in crafting high-quality dishes, elevating their offerings beyond just pizza and wings. Motorino's commitment to flavor and quality is evident in every dish, making it a worthwhile choice for any food lover.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Downtown Spots
11. Marinara Pizza - Broadway
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Celebrations
12. Bravo West Pizza
Delicious pizza with a friendly neighborhood vibe.
__NEW TEXT__
Bravo West Pizza, located on W 86th Street in NYC, offers some of the finest pizza in the area, including a $4.00 pepperoni slice that is unmatched in both price and quality. The tangy tomato sauce, plentiful cheese, and soft, thick crust create a delicious combination. While the crust is not crispy, it is well-liked by those who prefer a softer base for their pizza.
The staff at Bravo West Pizza are known for their friendliness and kindness, with no reports of rudeness or poor service. Furthermore, their delivery service has received high praise for its speed and accuracy, making it a convenient option for pizza lovers looking for great taste and convenience. Overall, Bravo West Pizza offers an exceptional experience for pizza lovers seeking quality, affordability, and top-notch service.
Bravo West Pizza, located on W 86th Street in NYC, offers some of the finest pizza in the area, including a $4.00 pepperoni slice that is unmatched in both price and quality. The tangy tomato sauce, plentiful cheese, and soft, thick crust create a delicious combination. While the crust is not crispy, it is well-liked by those who prefer a softer base for their pizza.
The staff at Bravo West Pizza are known for their friendliness and kindness, with no reports of rudeness or poor service. Furthermore, their delivery service has received high praise for its speed and accuracy, making it a convenient option for pizza lovers looking for great taste and convenience. Overall, Bravo West Pizza offers an exceptional experience for pizza lovers seeking quality, affordability, and top-notch service.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
13. La Traviata Pizzeria
Traditional Italian-style pizzas in the heart of NYC.
__NEW TEXT__
The pizza's crispy crust and distinct Italian spices make for an enjoyable dining experience. However, a more even distribution of sauce and cheese would enhance the flavor. Despite the imbalance, the delicious crust and seasoning make it easy to overlook the issue and still rate it highly.
Guests have expressed mixed opinions on the pizza, with some particularly appreciating the cheese-focused options. However, concerns about customer service and hidden fees when using cards for payment have been raised. While these issues may not affect the taste of the pizza, they can impact overall satisfaction with the dining experience.
The pizza's crispy crust and distinct Italian spices make for an enjoyable dining experience. However, a more even distribution of sauce and cheese would enhance the flavor. Despite the imbalance, the delicious crust and seasoning make it easy to overlook the issue and still rate it highly.
Guests have expressed mixed opinions on the pizza, with some particularly appreciating the cheese-focused options. However, concerns about customer service and hidden fees when using cards for payment have been raised. While these issues may not affect the taste of the pizza, they can impact overall satisfaction with the dining experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
14. Pizza Collective in Upper West Side
Experience the best pizza in town!
__NEW TEXT__
A margarita, perfectly crafted with just the right amount of tart and sweet, provides a refreshing escape for the taste buds. The establishment offers an impressive variety of pizzas, each slice generously square and bursting with flavor.
The buffalo chicken pizza, in particular, stands out for its delightful blend of spicy buffalo sauce and tender chicken atop a crispy crust. Overall, it's a must-try destination for pizza lovers, with numerous options catering to various palates.
A margarita, perfectly crafted with just the right amount of tart and sweet, provides a refreshing escape for the taste buds. The establishment offers an impressive variety of pizzas, each slice generously square and bursting with flavor.
The buffalo chicken pizza, in particular, stands out for its delightful blend of spicy buffalo sauce and tender chicken atop a crispy crust. Overall, it's a must-try destination for pizza lovers, with numerous options catering to various palates.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots