Best of 22 consignment shops in Chicago
Consignment shops in Chicago offer a unique shopping experience, providing a platform for local residents to sell their gently used items while giving buyers the opportunity to discover hidden gems at a fraction of the retail price. These shops specialize in a variety of items, from clothing and accessories to furniture and home decor, and contribute to the city's vibrant thrifting culture. Environmentally friendly and budget-conscious, consignment shops in Chicago are the perfect place to find one-of-a-kind treasures while supporting the local community.
- 1. McShane's Exchange Consignment
- 2. Elliott Consignment
- 3. Cynthia's Consignments
- 4. Mr. & Mrs. DIGZ
- 5. My Sister's Closet Resale
- 6. North Shore Exchange
- 7. Elliott Consignment
- 8. Three Stars Vintage/Furniture Store
- 9. Galore Consignment
- 10. Mercy Beaucoup Resale Boutique
- 11. Born Again Consignment Parlor
- 12. Crossroads Trading
- 13. Mount Sinai Resale Shop
- 14. Root Consignment Company
- 15. A Lotta Goodstuff Upscale Resale Furniture & More
- 16. Buffalo Exchange
- 17. Crossroads Trading
- 18. Sophie's Closet Inc.
- 19. C&J Collections Chicago
- 20. Solé Resale Boutique
- 21. Nice Twice Resale Shop
- 22. A Secret Closet
1. McShane's Exchange Consignment
Unique consignment shop in Chicago

McShane's Exchange Consignment offers a range of products, including luxury brand names, in their store. However, I noticed that some of their items seemed to be mispriced. While they attempt to make up for this by offering a 20% discount for leaving a Google review, I view this as a questionable business practice. It seems like a sneaky way to build their SEO and generate positive online reviews, rather than offering fair prices for their merchandise. As a result, I am not likely to return to the store.
McShane's Exchange Consignment boasts a diverse selection of products for customers to choose from. The store carries everything from clothing and accessories to home decor and furniture. This makes it a great destination for shoppers looking for unique, one-of-a-kind items that reflect their personal style and taste. Whether you're looking for a new outfit, a piece of art, or a cozy piece of furniture to add to your home, you're sure to find something you'll love at McShane's Exchange Consignment.
2. Elliott Consignment
Sustainable shopping with consignment prices

I had a frustrating experience with the owner of a clothing store, who I believe is a bald man with a beard. He is not friendly and never greets, smiles, or acknowledges customers. Despite this, I have brought high-end clothing labels like Gucci and Alexander McQueen to him over the years, and he has sold most of them. However, there were a few instances where clothes were not sold and were nowhere to be seen in the shop. When I brought this up, he did not appreciate being questioned and denied any knowledge of the missing items. In the end, the owner rejected all the clothes I brought him, stating that they did not have commercial value, even though they were in excellent condition and hardly worn. I am disappointed with this experience and will not bring any more clothes to him. I have made my peace with the situation by writing about it.
In summary, my experience with the owner of a clothing store was negative due to his lack of friendliness and unwillingness to address customer concerns. Despite selling most of the high-end clothing labels I brought him, there were a few instances where clothes were not sold and went missing. When I questioned him about it, he did not appreciate being questioned and rejected all future clothes I brought him. I am disappointed with this experience but have made my peace with it by sharing my story.
3. Cynthia's Consignments

4. Mr. & Mrs. DIGZ

5. My Sister's Closet Resale
Sustainable shopping in a trendy, welcoming environment

Three generations of a family have found high-quality selections and reasonable prices at the same store, with helpful staff providing honest feedback on clothing choices. Joy F., an enthusiastic second-hand shopper, has been shopping at this store for over 25 years and considers it an all-in-one experience, reminiscent of shopping at 200 different stores. She particularly values the honesty and helpfulness of the staff who provide frank feedback on her clothing choices.
This store's long-standing reputation for quality and outstanding customer service has been built up over generations, with the staff's honest and helpful feedback being a consistent highlight. Shoppers can enjoy a wide variety of second-hand items, making for a unique and satisfying shopping experience. The store offers the convenience of multiple stores in one, with a friendly and approachable staff that is always eager to help. It's no wonder that shoppers like Joy F. have been loyal customers for over 25 years, and continue to come back for more.
6. North Shore Exchange

7. Elliott Consignment

8. Three Stars Vintage/Furniture Store
Knowledgeable and friendly staff, spacious showroom

Three Stars Resale Shop is a top-rated consignment store located in the Chicagoland area, known for its excellent selection of vintage and mid-century modern furniture. The store offers high-quality used furniture and home decor at affordable prices, making it a popular choice for those looking to add unique and stylish pieces to their homes.
The premier consignment store in Chicago, IL, Three Stars Resale Shop provides a wide variety of pre-owned furniture and decor items, all carefully selected to ensure their quality and condition. With a focus on mid-century modern and vintage pieces, the store offers a one-of-a-kind shopping experience for those looking to add some character to their living space. In addition to their great selection and affordable prices, Three Stars Resale Shop also offers a consignment service for those looking to sell their own used furniture.
9. Galore Consignment

10. Mercy Beaucoup Resale Boutique

11. Born Again Consignment Parlor

12. Crossroads Trading
Sell or consign your items for cash or store credit

The store in a busy city location has the advantage of attracting many customers, but it also poses a challenge for inventory management. Despite carrying current trendy items, there may not be enough space for additional products. A visitor to the store in Chicago was left feeling disappointed, despite having positive experiences at a different location in Seattle.
The Chicago store had a wide selection of clothing, but the visitor noted a lack of high-end or designer items. The abundance of clothing did not make up for the absence of these higher-quality pieces. This customer's experience highlights the importance of maintaining a consistently impressive inventory, regardless of the store's location or size.
13. Mount Sinai Resale Shop
Proceeds benefit Mount Sinai Hospital

The store in question offers a range of products, from CDs and DVDs to higher-end items. While the prices for CDs and DVDs are reasonable, the cost of more expensive items can vary greatly and may seem overpriced. The pricing lacks consistency, with prices appearing to increase without warning.
The branded clothing section is a highlight of the store, featuring a variety of unique and interesting finds. Although the prices for some of these items may be higher than other stores, it is important to note that the store supports a good cause. The store is consistently busy, reflecting the popularity and quality of the products available.
14. Root Consignment Company
Long-standing history and reputation in the community

This store offers a unique selection of vintage clothes, shoes, and furniture that recently drew the attention of a first-time visitor. The customer was impressed by the variety of items and their fair pricing, making it likely that they will return in the future. The store's location in the Beverley area is also noteworthy, as the community is fortunate to have such a unique business in its midst.
The first-time visitor was thrilled to discover this store, which carries a wide variety of vintage clothing, shoes, and furniture. They found the prices to be reasonable and will likely visit again. The store's presence in the Beverley area provides a valuable addition to the community, with many unique items to offer.
15. A Lotta Goodstuff Upscale Resale Furniture & More

16. Buffalo Exchange
Sustainable fashion, trade-in program

While on my way home from the grocery store, I noticed a Crossroads thrift store and decided to stop in, hoping to trade some of my unwanted clothes for Halloween costumes. The staff at Crossroads declined to take my clothes, so I headed over to Buffalo Exchange instead. The experience at Buffalo Exchange was much more positive - the staff was friendly and complimented me on my good taste as they sorted through my items. I received a store credit and used it to purchase a pair of domestic-cat ears that matched perfectly with a cropped faux fur jacket I found later.
Buffalo Exchange is a standout thrift store with friendly and helpful staff and a great selection of clothes. I recently visited the store in search of summer clothes and, while the selection of shorts was limited, the rest of the store did not disappoint. The store had a wide range of stylish and unique items, making it a great place to shop for thrifted clothing.
17. Crossroads Trading
Sustainable fashion, buy-sell-trade model

The Crossroads store in Wicker Park, one of Chicago's hippest neighborhoods, is a bustling hub of buying and selling, operating every day of the week. The store specializes in contemporary fashion for women and men, purchasing gently used clothing, shoes, and accessories from the public in exchange for immediate cash. For high-end items, Crossroads offers a consignment option, allowing customers to earn more cash in return.
Wicker Park is known for its vibrant music scene, eclectic record shops, diverse dining establishments, and shopping options, and Crossroads is located right in the heart of it all. The store is open for drop-off selling from Monday to Thursday, making it easy and convenient for customers to sell their items and receive cash on the spot. Whether you're looking to update your wardrobe with trendy fashion pieces or sell your gently used items, Crossroads in Wicker Park is the perfect destination.
18. Sophie's Closet Inc.

19. C&J Collections Chicago

20. Solé Resale Boutique

21. Nice Twice Resale Shop

22. A Secret Closet
Cozy and welcoming atmosphere

A charming shop, owned and operated by what appears to be a mother-daughter duo, is a must-visit for its friendliness and excellent selection. The small business exudes a sense of warmth and approachability, making it a perfect spot for those who appreciate a more personal shopping experience.
The owners are particularly commendable for their hard work and dedication to their business. The shop boasts a collection that is both stylish and well-curated, showcasing a range of products that are sure to appeal to a wide variety of customers. Overall, the shop is a shining example of the positive impact that small businesses can have on their communities.