Best of 24 milkshakes in Ithaca

Discover our curated list of top-ranked milkshakes in Ithaca, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Collegetown Bagels, The State Diner, Five Guys, Ithaca Ale House, Shortstop Deli. Let's explore together!

Toc

1. Collegetown Bagels

Local favorite for over 40 years

  • Rating: 4.3/5 (1200 Review by google)
  • Address:

    420 College Ave, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of bagel options, cozy atmosphere, popular student hangout
  • Cons:

    Can get crowded during peak hours, limited seating, hit-or-miss service
  • Popular Menu:

    Everything bagel with cream cheese, lox bagel, iced coffee
  • Price Range:

    $2-$10
Phone Directions Website
Located on College Ave in Ithaca, NY, Collegetown Bagels is a gem that tantalizes the taste buds of locals and visitors alike. As you peruse the extensive bagel menu, each option beckons with mouthwatering possibilities. Whether you opt for a classic favorite or dive into an innovative creation, the delicious rolls will leave you craving more. The customizable smoothies offer a fun twist, allowing you to tailor your drink with an array of fresh fruits. While the shakes could use a bit more flavor, the overall experience is buoyed by the welcoming ambiance and efficient service.
A hidden culinary oasis in a college town, Collegetown Bagels surprises and delights with its diverse offerings. Beyond the tantalizing bagels, this establishment boasts a menu that caters to various tastes and preferences. Fresh and flavorful options abound, ensuring that every craving is met with satisfaction. From hearty sandwiches to refreshing drinks, each item reflects a commitment to quality and taste. The friendly staff further enhance the dining experience, creating a welcoming atmosphere that beckons patrons to return time and time again.

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • Mexican Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Pasta restaurants in Ithaca

2. The State Diner

Iconic diner serving classic American comfort food since 1955

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (1272 Review by google)
  • Address:

    428 W State St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Open 24/7, free parking, offers vegetarian and vegan options
  • Cons:

    Can get crowded, hit-or-miss service, cash-only
  • Popular Menu:

    Buttermilk pancakes, Reuben sandwich, veggie burger
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website
Experience a delightful culinary journey at The State Diner located in the heart of Ithaca, New York. Indulge in a diverse menu offering American classics, including mouthwatering burgers, savory sandwiches, and delectable breakfast options available all day long. Whether you're craving a hearty dinner entrée or a stack of fluffy pancakes, this diner has something to satisfy every craving.
Immerse yourself in the lively ambiance of The State Diner as you savor their top-notch service and relish in the exquisite flavors of their signature dishes. From the crispy home fries to the generously filled meat lovers omelet, each bite is a testament to the diner's dedication to quality and taste. Conveniently located on West State Street, the diner offers quick bites for those on the go and ensures a memorable dining experience with every visit.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

pumpkin desserts in Ithaca

3. Five Guys

Peanuts available for customers to snack on while waiting

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (1048 Review by google)
  • Address:

    222 Elmira Rd Unit A, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of toppings, fresh ingredients, made-to-order burgers and fries
  • Cons:

    No vegetarian or vegan burger options, prices can add up quickly, limited seating
  • Popular Menu:

    Hamburger, Cheeseburger, Bacon Cheeseburger
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website
After a brief closure for renovation, Five Guys Burgers & Fries in Ithaca is set to make a grand return on May 6th. Anticipation builds as loyal fans eagerly await the reopening, reassured that their favorite fast-food spot will be back better than ever. With its promise of delicious burgers loaded with flavorful toppings and generous servings of freshly-cut fries, Five Guys never fails to impress.
Stepping into Five Guys is like entering a haven for burger enthusiasts - a clean and inviting space where you can indulge in juicy, mouthwatering burgers that rival homemade creations. The friendly staff and vibrant ambiance create a welcoming experience, while the irresistibly tasty fries and refreshing smoothies add to the overall appeal. Though a bit pricier than typical fast food joints, the quality and freshness of the food make every penny worth it, ensuring a satisfying and enjoyable dining experience.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats

Relate link

fast food restaurants in Ithaca

4. Ithaca Ale House

Over 60 craft beers on tap, locally sourced ingredients

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (1716 Review by google)
  • Address:

    301 E State St Suite 1, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide selection of beers, friendly staff, cozy atmosphere
  • Cons:

    Prices slightly high, limited vegetarian options, small space
  • Popular Menu:

    Burgers, wings, mac and cheese
  • Price Range:

    $15-$30
Phone Directions Website
Situated in the heart of Ithaca, the Ale House offers a vibrant atmosphere for enjoying locally brewed beer and scrumptious comfort food. Nestled on the bustling "Streatery," this gem stands out with its extensive menu featuring must-try dishes like French Onion Soup and Buffalo Egg Rolls. Whether you opt for a juicy burger, fresh salad, or a sizzling pizza, each bite promises to be delectable and satisfying. And don't miss out on Mrs. O'Leary's cookies – they are simply divine. Address: 301 E State St Suite 1, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States.
During my recent visit to Ithaca Ale House, the attentive service and impressive beer selection left a lasting impression. The cozy ambiance was perfect for a quick stopover and the appetizers were top-notch. I can't wait to return for a full meal next time. It also proved to be a great spot for a group lunch, with prompt seating and a wallet-friendly menu making it a hit with my companions.

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Spanish restaurants in Ithaca

5. Shortstop Deli

Unique and delicious sandwich combinations using high-quality ingredients

  • Time:

    7 AM to 8 PM

  • Rating: 4.5/5 (1125 Review by google)
  • Address:

    200 W Seneca St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of sandwiches, friendly service, central location in Ithaca
  • Cons:

    Limited seating, can get crowded during peak hours, cash-only
  • Popular Menu:

    The Ithaca Melt, The Godfather, The VegHead
  • Price Range:

    $5-$10
Phone Directions Website
Nestled in the heart of town, Shortstop Deli is a culinary gem where bagel aficionados flock. The mouthwatering sandwiches don't disappoint, earning their rave reviews. While seating is limited, the quick and friendly service ensures you can easily take your feast to go. From Toronto to tired travelers, this deli's double BBQ pulled pork sandwich hits the spot. Alongside a steaming bowl of soup and a refreshing soda, it's a satisfying and flavorful pitstop to refuel on your journey. And with a special touch of sharing the coveted BBQ pork recipe, Shortstop Deli goes above and beyond to leave a lasting impression.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Lunch
  • Dinner

Relate link

bread pudding in Ithaca

6. Purity Ice Cream Co.

Family-owned business since 2008, uses local ingredients

  • Time:

    7:30 AM to 10 PM

  • Rating: 4.5/5 (2480 Review by google)
  • Address:

    700 Cascadilla St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of flavors, homemade ice cream, vegan options available
  • Cons:

    Limited seating, can get crowded, cash-only policy
  • Popular Menu:

    Cookies and Cream, Mint Chocolate Chip, Salted Caramel
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website
Purity Ice Cream Co. is a fantastic local gem, offering delicious options for both lunch and breakfast. The grilled chicken sandwich with fries is a must-try, leaving you satisfied yet yearning for their renowned ice cream. Despite missing out this time, a return visit is already in the plans for a sweet treat. The breakfast menu impresses with hot and flavorful coffee, perfectly scrambled eggs, and tasty potatoes - all served in satisfying portions. Ideal for a hearty yet not overwhelming start to the day.

TOPICS

  • Holiday Celebrations
  • American Cuisine
  • Breakfast

7. Milkstand Restaurant

Small, cozy milkshake bar with unique and creative flavors

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (542 Review by google)
  • Address:

    215 N Meadow St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of milkshake flavors, friendly service, offers vegan options
  • Cons:

    Limited seating, cash-only policy, may have long wait times during peak hours
  • Popular Menu:

    Custom milkshakes, vegan milkshakes, grilled cheese sandwiches
  • Price Range:

    $5 - $10
Phone Directions Website
Milkstand Restaurant offers a vibrant atmosphere that guarantees a delightful dining experience. From their heavenly smoothies and delectable avocado toast to their flavorful pig scramble, the menu boasts an impressive array of options. Although some dishes like the pig scramble might lean towards the salty side due to the rich combination of cheddar cheese, sausage, ham, and bacon, the overall culinary journey is definitely worth embarking on. If you’re in for a unique and satisfying meal, this is the place to be.
The bustling ambiance at the restaurant may result in a wait, but the tantalizing food makes it all worthwhile. By simply leaving your number and waiting in the comfort of your car until called, the approximately 30 to 35 minutes of anticipation will fly by. Once seated, don’t miss out on trying the flavorsome Arancini salad for a refreshing and fulfilling culinary experience that perfectly encapsulates the essence of the establishment.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

quiche in Ithaca

8. Lincoln Street Diner

A local favorite for comfort food in a homey setting.

  • Time:

    6:30 AM to 1 PM

  • Rating: 4.7/5 (531 Review by google)
  • Address:

    309 E Lincoln St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of menu options, cozy and relaxed atmosphere, friendly service.
  • Cons:

    Cash-only, limited seating, hit-or-miss food quality.
  • Popular Menu:

    Omelettes, burgers, and blueberry pancakes.
  • Price Range:

    $5-$15
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Salad restaurants in Ithaca

9. Wendy's

Fresh, never frozen beef and made-to-order sandwiches

  • Rating: 3.5/5 (894 Review by google)
  • Address:

    326 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Drive-thru available, breakfast menu, offers mobile ordering
  • Cons:

    Limited vegetarian options, reports of slow service, no happy hour
  • Popular Menu:

    Dave's Single, Frosty, Baconator
  • Price Range:

    $6-$15
Phone Directions Website

4.7 American • Burgers • Fast Food Cortland's 10 best delivery spots, offering fries and sides, freshly made salads, burgers, classics and more. 157 Clinton Avenue, Cortland, New York 13045


TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots
  • Vegetarian Options

Relate link

cheesy bread in Ithaca

10. Collegetown Bagels

A local favorite for over 40 years

  • Time:

    6:30 AM to 5 PM

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (583 Review by google)
  • Address:

    301 E State St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of bagel options, good coffee, offers catering services
  • Cons:

    Can get crowded during peak hours, limited seating, prices slightly higher than other bagel shops
  • Popular Menu:

    Bagels, sandwiches, coffee
  • Price Range:

    $2-$10
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Budget-Friendly Eats

Relate link

soups in Ithaca

11. Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop

Small-batch, handcrafted ice cream

  • Time:

    3 to 9 PM

  • Rating: 4.5/5 (350 Review by google)
  • Address:

    200 W Seneca St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of unique ice cream flavors, Friendly and helpful staff, Cozy and welcoming atmosphere
  • Cons:

    Limited seating available, Cash only policy, Some customers may find the prices slightly high
  • Popular Menu:

    Seasonal fruit flavors, Vegan options, Coffee ice cream
  • Price Range:

    $3-$7
Phone Directions Website

Ice Cream Shop, Dessert Shop, Frozen Yogurt Shop · $200 W Seneca St, Ithaca, NY Closed · 3:00 p.m. - 9:00 pm. 4.5 (350 reviews)


TOPICS

  • Cheap Eats
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Dinner

Relate link

Tuna restaurants in Ithaca

12. Cayuga Lake Creamery at The Dewitt Mall

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Hidden Gems
  • Social Gatherings

13. Arby's

Offers a unique horsey sauce and classic roast beef sandwich

  • Time:

    10 AM to 12 AM

  • Rating: 3.9/5 (518 Review by google)
  • Address:

    328 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of menu options, convenient location, drive-thru available
  • Cons:

    Some customers may find it pricey, limited seating, occasional long wait times
  • Popular Menu:

    Roast beef sandwiches, curly fries, milkshakes
  • Price Range:

    $6-$15
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Dinner

Relate link

salads in Ithaca

14. U Tea Bubble Tea

Handmade tapioca pearls, fresh ingredients

  • Time:

    11:30 AM to 10:30 PM

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (156 Review by google)
  • Address:

    205 Dryden Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of tea flavors, large portions, affordable prices
  • Cons:

    Some teas can be overly sweet, limited seating, slow service during peak hours
  • Popular Menu:

    Milk tea, fruit tea, taro milk tea
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Asian Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Breakfast

15. Angelhearts Diner

Committed to sustainability and reducing food waste

  • Rating: 4.7/5 (184 Review by google)
  • Address:

    401 E State St Suite G-2, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of vegetarian and vegan options, cozy atmosphere, friendly service
  • Cons:

    Limited parking, can be crowded during peak hours, cashless payment only
  • Popular Menu:

    Vegan Reuben, Tempeh Tacos, Sweet Potato Fries
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Vegan Options
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Seafood restaurants in Ithaca

16. Rosie's Ice Cream

Phone Directions

TOPICS

  • Personal Celebrations
  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Breakfast

17. Sweet N’ Salty

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Fusion Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots
  • Lunch

Relate link

chicken roll in Ithaca

18. Loumies - Take Out & Catering

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Mexican Cuisine
  • Vegan Options
  • Budget-Friendly Eats

Relate link

kid-friendly restaurants in Ithaca

19. D.P. Dough

Known for its unique and customizable calzones

  • Time:

    11 AM to 4 AM

  • Rating: 3.9/5 (317 Review by google)
  • Address:

    408 College Ave, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Central location, variety of calzones, offers online ordering and delivery
  • Cons:

    Prices slightly higher than average, limited seating, mixed reviews on food quality
  • Popular Menu:

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone, Margherita Calzone, BBQ Chicken Calzone
  • Price Range:

    $8-$12
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Late Night

Relate link

trivia nights in Ithaca

20. komonz cafe

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Vegan Options
  • Budget-Friendly Eats

Relate link

brazilian restaurants in Ithaca

21. Mama Teresa's Pizzeria

Directions

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots
  • Cheap Eats
  • Vegetarian Options

Relate link

Tiramisu restaurants in Ithaca

22. McDonald's

Iconic fast food chain with global presence and recognition

  • Rating: 3.0/5 (1338 Review by google)
  • Address:

    372 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Drive-thru and delivery options available, Playplace for children, Wide variety of menu items
  • Cons:

    Prices may be higher than other fast food options, Limited seating capacity, Some items may contain high levels of fat and sugar
  • Popular Menu:

    Big Mac, Chicken McNuggets, French fries
  • Price Range:

    $1-$10
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Lunch

Relate link

desserts in Ithaca

23. Jack's Grill

Home of the World's Smallest Polar Bear

  • Time:

    11 AM to 11 PM

  • Rating: 3.3/5 (291 Review by google)
  • Address:

    120 Dryden Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Established in 1945, old-school atmosphere, generous portions
  • Cons:

    Cash only, limited seating, can be very busy
  • Popular Menu:

    Steak, Prime Rib, Lamb Chops
  • Price Range:

    $20-$40
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

lunch restaurants in Ithaca

24. Cold Stone Creamery

Phone Directions Website

4.6 Desserts Affordable delivery spot offering sundaes, create your own, candles, smoothies and more. 4700 Vestal Pkwy E, New York 13850


TOPICS

  • Celebrations
  • Dietary
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots