Best of 24 pumpkin desserts in Buffalo
Discover our curated list of top-ranked pumpkin desserts in Buffalo, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Hertel Avenue Poutine and Cream, Five Points Bakery, Anderson's Frozen Custard, BreadHive Bakery & Cafe, King Condrell's Candy and Ice Cream. Let's explore together!
Toc
- 1. Hertel Avenue Poutine and Cream
- 2. Five Points Bakery
- 3. Anderson's Frozen Custard
- 4. BreadHive Bakery & Cafe
- 5. King Condrell's Candy and Ice Cream
- 6. Butter Block
- 7. Dipped & Designed by Mallory
- 8. Fairy Cakes Cupcakery and Bakeshop
- 9. Cookies & Cream On Elmwood
- 10. Pam's Custard Corner
- 11. Cookies & Cream
- 12. Custard Corner & Grill
- 13. Churn Soft Serve & Coffee
- 14. Golden Hour Treats & Things
- 15. Sweet Cheeks Cake Bar
- 16. Trice's Tasty Treats LLC
- 17. Kupkates Llc
- 18. Buffalo Cake Pops Bakery
- 19. Nikki's Chocolates WNY
- 20. Watson's Chocolates
- 21. Blackbird Sweets
- 22. Frost Artisan Bakery
- 23. Two Wheels Bakery
- 24. Buffalo Delights
1. Hertel Avenue Poutine and Cream
Homemade gravy and fresh-cut fries
Indulge in the delectable delights of Hertel Avenue Poutine and Cream, a serendipitous gem that beckons you back for more. Each bite of the poutine special sends taste buds on a tantalizing journey, reaching nirvana with the first 5 to 10 savory bites. It's a paradise for the palate that leaves you craving seconds.
Nestled on vibrant Hertel Avenue, this hip spot exudes charm with its creative ice cream and shake pairings. Dive into the divine world of donut ice cream sandwiches as you soak in the lively atmosphere. Seating may be a challenge, but the mouthwatering treats more than make up for it. The amiable staff adds a warm touch to every visit, ensuring a delightful experience with each sweet treat.
Nestled on vibrant Hertel Avenue, this hip spot exudes charm with its creative ice cream and shake pairings. Dive into the divine world of donut ice cream sandwiches as you soak in the lively atmosphere. Seating may be a challenge, but the mouthwatering treats more than make up for it. The amiable staff adds a warm touch to every visit, ensuring a delightful experience with each sweet treat.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Cheap Eats
Relate link
2. Five Points Bakery
Committed to using local and organic ingredients
Step into Five Points Bakery, a charming haven where delectable treats and warm hospitality await you. The moment you walk through the door, the enticing aroma of freshly baked bread greets you, setting the stage for a culinary experience like no other. From the fluffy loaves of bread to the irresistible sweets, every bite is a taste of perfection. The cozy atmosphere, coupled with the friendly staff, makes each visit a delightful adventure. While the space may be snug, the cleanliness and accessibility add to the overall charm. Plus, the staff's patience and jovial demeanor only enhance the inviting ambiance of this bakery.
Indulge your senses at Five Points Bakery, a hidden gem that beckons with its irresistible array of baked goods and welcoming atmosphere. Stepping inside feels like entering a sweet-scented paradise, where the sight of freshly baked treats will make your mouth water. Whether you're picking up a loaf of bread or a tempting pastry, each bite is a testament to the bakery's commitment to quality and flavor. Despite the cozy layout, the friendly and efficient staff ensure a seamless experience, while the clean facilities offer convenience. Prepare to be charmed by the warm hospitality and scrumptious offerings at Five Points Bakery, where every visit promises a delectable journey for your taste buds.
Indulge your senses at Five Points Bakery, a hidden gem that beckons with its irresistible array of baked goods and welcoming atmosphere. Stepping inside feels like entering a sweet-scented paradise, where the sight of freshly baked treats will make your mouth water. Whether you're picking up a loaf of bread or a tempting pastry, each bite is a testament to the bakery's commitment to quality and flavor. Despite the cozy layout, the friendly and efficient staff ensure a seamless experience, while the clean facilities offer convenience. Prepare to be charmed by the warm hospitality and scrumptious offerings at Five Points Bakery, where every visit promises a delectable journey for your taste buds.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
Relate link
3. Anderson's Frozen Custard
Family-owned and operated since 1946, Fresh ingredients, Made-to-order custard
Indulge in a decadent experience at Anderson's Frozen Custard - a must-visit spot in Buffalo! Treat yourself to a delightful swirl of chocolate and vanilla frozen custard that is irresistibly thick and creamy, surpassing the ordinary yogurt or ice cream. It's a truly divine indulgence that promises to leave your taste buds craving for more!
Every visit to Anderson's is a delightful adventure, where exceptional service meets mouthwatering food. From delicious salmon burgers to luscious macaroni and cheese, every bite is a culinary journey worth savoring. And don't miss out on their signature double cheeseburger paired with a delectable chocolate shake - a perfect combination that will surely please every palate!
Every visit to Anderson's is a delightful adventure, where exceptional service meets mouthwatering food. From delicious salmon burgers to luscious macaroni and cheese, every bite is a culinary journey worth savoring. And don't miss out on their signature double cheeseburger paired with a delectable chocolate shake - a perfect combination that will surely please every palate!
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
4. BreadHive Bakery & Cafe
Dedicated to local and organic ingredients, focus on sustainability
BreadHive Bakery & Cafe is a delightful gem for locals that offers a charming neighborhood cafe/bakery experience. Freshly baked pretzels, bagels, and sourdough bread are just a few of the excellent items available. Upon discovering this hidden treasure through my Lexington Co-op newsletter, I found myself wishing I lived closer to indulge in their delicious offerings.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
Relate link
5. King Condrell's Candy and Ice Cream
Over 80 years of nostalgic candy and ice cream tradition
King Condrell's Candy and Ice Cream offers exceptional service, a wide range of options at reasonable prices, and knowledgeable specialists to assist in selecting the perfect peanut butter-flavored ice cream. With an extensive menu that caters to every craving, this is undoubtedly the ultimate ice cream destination for those seeking top-quality treats. High recommendations for those in search of a memorable ice cream experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
6. Butter Block
Small-batch, locally made butter and baked goods
Nestled just outside the city center, Butter Block is a charming local bakery that beckons to pastry lovers. During our recent visit, we were enchanted by the array of freshly baked croissants and cookies on display. Despite arriving late, we indulged in a simple yet divine selection including coconut croissants, salty chocolate danish cookies, and coconut cookies. Buttery goodness and decadent flavors await at this hidden gem!
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Breakfast
Relate link
7. Dipped & Designed by Mallory
Family-owned and operated with unique and creative flavors
Dipped & Designed by Mallory consistently delights with surprising creations of excellent quality. Mallory and her team showcase unmatched professionalism and kindness, making every visit a fun and tasty experience. With top-notch customer service and impeccable food presentation, this place is a must-visit for anyone seeking a unique culinary adventure. Make sure to stop by weekly to savor their outstanding offerings and warm hospitality.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mexican Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
Relate link
8. Fairy Cakes Cupcakery and Bakeshop
Indulge in a divine treat at Fairy Cakes Cupcakery and Bakeshop, where each bite is a taste of pure magic. These cupcakes transcend the ordinary, boasting rich, creamy flavors that will tantalize your taste buds. From decadent frostings to unique combinations, every bite is a delightful journey into sweetness and bliss. With an array of options to choose from, there is a cupcake for every craving waiting for you at this enchanting bakeshop.
Not to be overshadowed are the delectable cookies that grace the display at Fairy Cakes. Their Buffalo cookies are a particular standout, garnering well-deserved praise and adoration. The owners' commitment to excellence is evident in every bite, as they effortlessly blend quality ingredients with unmatched creativity. Whether you're a cupcake connoisseur or a cookie aficionado, Fairy Cakes Cupcakery and Bakeshop is a must-visit destination that comes highly recommended for a truly enchanting culinary experience.
Not to be overshadowed are the delectable cookies that grace the display at Fairy Cakes. Their Buffalo cookies are a particular standout, garnering well-deserved praise and adoration. The owners' commitment to excellence is evident in every bite, as they effortlessly blend quality ingredients with unmatched creativity. Whether you're a cupcake connoisseur or a cookie aficionado, Fairy Cakes Cupcakery and Bakeshop is a must-visit destination that comes highly recommended for a truly enchanting culinary experience.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Fusion Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
9. Cookies & Cream On Elmwood
Embark on a delightful culinary journey at Cookies & Cream On Elmwood, where every bite is a symphony of flavors that will tantalize your taste buds. With a diverse selection of cookies boasting unique twists and a whimsical array of ice cream flavors, this charming spot is a must-visit for any food enthusiast. Whether you're a local looking for a sweet treat or just passing through Buffalo on a road trip like I was, a visit to this gem promises a deliciously delightful experience that will leave you craving for more. Indulge in a delectable post-lunch ice cream fix or make it a pit stop during your travels - either way, Cookies & Cream On Elmwood is sure to satisfy your cravings and sweet tooth alike.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Gluten-Free
Relate link
10. Pam's Custard Corner
Family-owned business since 1939, Homemade custards
Nestled in the heart of town, Pam's Custard Corner is a delightful haven for ice cream enthusiasts. From the creamy custard to the renowned Perry's selection, every scoop is a harmonious blend of flavors. The waffle cones boast a perfect crunch, ensuring each bite is a moment of pure bliss. For a sweet treat on-the-go, their delectable shortbread is a must-try – ideal for a lazy Sunday takeaway. Indulge in a classic vanilla cone drizzled with blue sauce and sprinkles, or opt for the doggie size cup complete with treats for your furry companions. Pam's truly caters to every member of the family, making each visit a memorable experience.
Stepping into Pam's Custard Corner feels like a warm embrace, where friendly staff welcome you with open arms. Whether you're ordering for yourself or with your grandchildren in tow, the efficient service guarantees a seamless experience. The commitment and dedication of the team are truly commendable, ensuring that every visit leaves you feeling satisfied and content. Pam's Custard Corner is not just a place for ice cream – it's a sanctuary of sweet moments and shared joy, where each scoop is a reminder of life's simple pleasures.
Stepping into Pam's Custard Corner feels like a warm embrace, where friendly staff welcome you with open arms. Whether you're ordering for yourself or with your grandchildren in tow, the efficient service guarantees a seamless experience. The commitment and dedication of the team are truly commendable, ensuring that every visit leaves you feeling satisfied and content. Pam's Custard Corner is not just a place for ice cream – it's a sanctuary of sweet moments and shared joy, where each scoop is a reminder of life's simple pleasures.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Breakfast
11. Cookies & Cream
Family-owned ice cream parlor with unique cookies and cream flavors
Guilford's ice cream is a revelation - a symphony of flavors that dances on the taste buds. Each scoop is a lesson in decadence, with the peanut butter cookie stealing the show. The blend of the rich, nutty cookie and the velvety Reese's peanut butter cups creates a sensory explosion that lingers long after the last bite. Even the aroma of freshly baked cookies beckons you in, promising a culinary journey like no other. The homemade waffle cones offer the perfect vessel for this frozen delight, adding an extra layer of indulgence. Guilford's is not just an ice cream parlor; it's a destination for the discerning palate, with ample outdoor seating to savor every spoonful.
Who would have thought that a simple ice cream outing could be so extraordinary? Guilford's has mastered the art of crafting unforgettable treats that elevate the mundane to the sublime. The delicate balance of flavors in their offerings is a testament to their dedication to quality and innovation. Every visit is an opportunity to explore new taste sensations and revel in the joy of culinary excellence. The cozy ambiance and charming outdoor seating provide the ideal backdrop for savoring each delectable bite. Guilford's is not just a place to satisfy your sweet cravings - it's a culinary experience that will leave you longing for more.
Who would have thought that a simple ice cream outing could be so extraordinary? Guilford's has mastered the art of crafting unforgettable treats that elevate the mundane to the sublime. The delicate balance of flavors in their offerings is a testament to their dedication to quality and innovation. Every visit is an opportunity to explore new taste sensations and revel in the joy of culinary excellence. The cozy ambiance and charming outdoor seating provide the ideal backdrop for savoring each delectable bite. Guilford's is not just a place to satisfy your sweet cravings - it's a culinary experience that will leave you longing for more.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
12. Custard Corner & Grill
Family-owned restaurant serving comfort food since 1964
Custard Corner & Grill serves up Perry's ice cream scoops, a delightful refreshment under $5. The efficient staff ensures quick service, managing large volumes adeptly. Indulge in their caramel dipped cone or savory pizza rolls from their extensive food menu, all while enjoying the popular puppy cups. A must-visit for a satisfying treat!
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
- Budget-Friendly Eats
Relate link
13. Churn Soft Serve & Coffee
Small business serving handcrafted soft serve and coffee
Churn Soft Serve & Coffee remains a beloved favorite of mine even as the colder season approaches. The month's special, German chocolate ice cream, boasted delightful flavor combinations that truly impressed me. Alongside my love for churros, the treat was indulgently thick although I couldn't quite finish it. Without a doubt, I eagerly anticipate my next visit to savor more of their delectable offerings.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Breakfast
- Dinner
14. Golden Hour Treats & Things
Handcrafted comfort food and unique desserts
Discover the charm of Golden Hour Treats & Things, a hidden gem I stumbled upon during Black Restaurant Week. Recently revisiting, I was captivated by their visually appealing décor and was delighted by the delectable treats. The Biscoff/Lotus cookie shake and cookies and cream pie were pure indulgence, leaving me yearning to explore more of their enticing menu. While my personal experience was limited, witnessing the pure joy on my family's faces as they savored each bite reaffirmed the exceptional quality of this establishment. Uncover a paradise of flavors and experiences at Golden Hour Treats & Things, where every bite promises a five-star delight for the whole family.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
Relate link
15. Sweet Cheeks Cake Bar
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Breakfast
Relate link
16. Trice's Tasty Treats LLC
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
17. Kupkates Llc
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
18. Buffalo Cake Pops Bakery
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
19. Nikki's Chocolates WNY
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Dinner
- Weekend Dining
20. Watson's Chocolates
TOPICS
- Holiday Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Downtown Spots
21. Blackbird Sweets
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
22. Frost Artisan Bakery
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Dinner
Relate link
23. Two Wheels Bakery
TOPICS
- Gluten-Free
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
Relate link
24. Buffalo Delights
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
Relate link
