18 most favorite American restaurants in New York City
In the heart of NYC, American restaurants abound, each offering a unique and delicious taste of the country's diverse culinary landscape. From classic diners to upscale eateries, American restaurants in NYC showcase the best of American comfort food and innovative cuisine. Whether you're in the mood for a juicy burger, flavorful barbecue, or gourmet seafood, these restaurants have got you covered. Come and indulge in the rich flavors and warm hospitality that define American dining in NYC.
- 1. The Smith
- 2. The Dutch
- 3. Eleven Madison Park
- 4. abc kitchen
- 5. Estela
- 6. Gramercy Tavern
- 7. STATE Grill and Bar
- 8. Marc Forgione
- 9. Gotham Restaurant
- 10. Family Meal at Blue Hill
- 11. The Modern
- 12. Tavern On the Green
- 13. Olmsted
- 14. Empire Diner
- 15. Jane Restaurant West Village
- 16. Contra
- 17. The Flatiron Room Murray Hill
- 18. American Bar - New York
1. The Smith
Perfect for any occasion, from brunch to late-night drinks.

The level of service at this establishment is consistently praised by its customers, with many using adjectives such as "great," "exceptional," and "outstanding" to describe their experiences. This suggests that the staff is highly trained, friendly, and attentive to the needs of their patrons. It also indicates that the restaurant places a high value on customer satisfaction, which is always a positive sign.
The food at this establishment is another area where it truly shines. Customers have raved about the flavor, quality, and taste of the dishes, with particular attention being paid to the steak and brunch options. The steak is often described as being cooked to perfection, with just the right amount of seasoning and doneness. Meanwhile, the brunch dishes such as omelettes and avocado toast have also received high marks for their freshness and delicious taste. Overall, the food offerings at this restaurant are sure to please even the most discerning of palates.
2. The Dutch
A SoHo institution with a seductive menu and vibrant atmosphere.

The Dutch, a renowned restaurant in SoHo, has been a hit among food enthusiasts since its inception. Chef Andrew Carmellini's culinary skills are on full display, offering a delectable menu that blends American and Seafood dishes, making it a popular destination for people with varying tastes. The restaurant is also known for being pet-friendly, adding to its welcoming and inclusive atmosphere.
The spacious and vibrant interior is complemented by a bustling and energetic ambiance, making it an ideal spot for gatherings with friends and family. The Dutch has received widespread recognition, gathering a respectable 4.0-star rating from a significant number of reviews, indicating a solid and reliable dining experience. Its diverse menu, friendly service, and ambiance make it a worthwhile destination for anyone seeking a gratifying meal in SoHo.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Lunch
- Dinner
3. Eleven Madison Park
Innovative fine dining experience with a plant-based focus.

This establishment offers a dining experience that is truly exceptional. The food is both creative and delightful, with each dish presented as a work of art that is as pleasing to the eye as it is to the palate. The restaurant's wine pairings are particularly noteworthy, showcasing a selection of wines that are not only extremely rare and hard-to-find, but also perfectly complement the flavors and textures of each dish.
Whether it's a romantic date or a special occasion, this restaurant is an excellent choice. The staff provides service that is both knowledgeable and attentive, ensuring that every guest feels welcome and well taken care of. The tasting menu offers a wide variety of dishes to choose from, allowing diners to sample a broad range of flavors and textures. Overall, this restaurant offers a dining experience that is not to be missed.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Downtown Spots
4. abc kitchen
Farm-to-table dining with fresh, local ingredients.

The culinary experience at ABC Kitchen is outstanding, featuring delectable dishes made with top-quality ingredients. The farm-to-table approach is evident in every dish, resulting in a freshness and flavor that truly impress. Paired with the impeccable service, delivered by a friendly and attentive staff, dining at ABC Kitchen is always a pleasure.
ABC Kitchen also boasts impressive capabilities for private events, offering a variety of options tailored to your needs. The event staff is dedicated to providing exceptional experiences, ensuring every detail is perfect. Guests will be wowed by the exquisite cuisine, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to organic and locally-sourced ingredients. Hosting an event at ABC Kitchen is sure to be a memorable and delightful experience.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
5. Estela
A Michelin-starred bistro with New York City classics.

Estela is a restaurant that labels itself as Modern American, which can be interpreted as a mix of various cuisines to cater to the diverse tastes of New Yorkers. The menu features classic French mother sauces, Cantonese condiments, and seaweed, all given equal importance, resulting in a fascinating fusion of flavors.
The dining experience at Estela is gratifying, with a range of dishes that cater to different preferences, from heavier options to impressive desserts. The service is noteworthy, making it an ideal place for a special night out. Whether you're looking to celebrate an occasion or merely seeking a memorable meal, Estela fits the bill.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- High-End
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
6. Gramercy Tavern
Celebrating 30 years of exceptional dining experiences.

Gramercy Tavern is known for its exceptional bar experience, offering great cocktails and delicious food throughout the week. The bartender, particularly from Monday to Thursday, is highly skilled and adds to the overall positive atmosphere. As a renowned New York institution, it is frequently at the top of many people's lists due to its unwavering confidence in delivering excellent service and quality.
The restaurant's ambiance is warm and inviting, with its open kitchen and cozy dining rooms adding to the overall experience. The menu, curated by Chef Michael Anthony, features fresh, locally sourced ingredients and changes with the seasons, resulting in a varied and delightful selection of dishes. Whether it's the excellent bar or the impressive main dining room, Gramercy Tavern consistently delivers an exceptional dining experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- High-End
- Vegan Options
- Personal Celebrations
7. STATE Grill and Bar
Modern New York-inspired fare in the Empire State Building.

Upon arrival, guests were immediately impressed with the swift and efficient delivery of their drinks. The beverages were not only visually appealing but also reported to be packed with robust and rich flavors, satisfying even the most discerning of palates.
The establishment's culinary offerings received positive feedback, with patrons praising the quality and taste of the food. The dishes were carefully curated, featuring a delightful blend of flavors and textures that left a lasting impression. Moreover, the service was consistently hailed for its excellence. The staff were attentive, providing top-notch service that made guests feel valued and well taken care of. The atmosphere was described as warm and inviting, making it an ideal spot for a night out with friends or family. Overall, the establishment's exceptional service, delicious food, and perfect ambiance made for an unforgettable dining experience.
TOPICS
- Indian Cuisine
- Dinner
- Downtown Spots
8. Marc Forgione
Signature dishes crafted by Iron Chef Marc Forgione.

A highly acclaimed restaurant has been receiving rave reviews, and it certainly lives up to the hype. Upon tasting the first dish, which consists of two spoons requiring diners to chew each ingredient for twenty seconds before consuming chips, the taste experience is nothing short of incredible. The duck and honey dish is another standout option, offering a delightful combination of flavors.
Beyond the delicious food, the atmosphere is inviting, and the service is top-notch. Begin the meal with mouthwatering buttered rolls, and end with the delectable blueberry cherry crisp. The chili lobster is also a must-try. Each course is expertly crafted, and the friendly and attentive staff members contribute to the overall great service from the hostess to the waiter to the food presenter. Diners can expect to leave thoroughly satisfied, making a return visit a certainty.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Mid-Range
9. Gotham Restaurant
A timeless NYC dining experience with a modern twist.

The culinary experience at this establishment continues to delight. With a menu that features both classic and new dishes, every item is skillfully prepared and presented. The flaky pâté en croûte, filled with earthy chestnuts and wild mushrooms, is as delicious as ever. Meats, such as the Long Island duck, are cooked to perfection with a crisp exterior and juicy interior.
The restaurant's atmosphere has been elevated with a tasteful new decor. The ambiance is elegant yet welcoming, providing the perfect setting for a special occasion or a casual night out. The service is consistently top-notch, with attentive and knowledgeable staff who make sure every guest feels well taken care of. To top it all off, the desserts are simply exquisite, offering the perfect ending to an already delightful meal. Overall, this establishment continues to provide a memorable dining experience that keeps guests coming back for more.
10. Family Meal at Blue Hill
Experience farm-to-table dining with a seasonal, shared plates menu.

Blue Hill in New York City, led by chef Dan Barber, showcases their faith in the quality of their ingredients by allowing them to take center stage with minimal interference. The result is a celebration of natural flavors that truly shines.
Family Meal at Blue Hill offers a unique dining experience, reminiscent of a restaurant's staff meal. This menu-less dinner features shared plates that showcase the restaurant's impressive selection of vegetables, grains, and meats, all presented family-style. It's a fantastic way to enjoy a variety of flavors while fostering a sense of community.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mediterranean Cuisine
11. The Modern
Refined dining experience at MoMA with award-winning cuisine

The Modern, a two Michelin-starred restaurant, offers a contemporary American dining experience at the Museum of Modern Art. Led by Executive Chef Abram Bissell, the restaurant is renowned for its creative and playful dishes that emphasize top-quality ingredients and seasonal produce.
The Modern, a Michelin-starred establishment, is located in the Museum of Modern Art and serves contemporary American cuisine under the direction of Chef Thomas Allan. The restaurant's refined dishes showcase exceptional ingredients, and the dining experience is enhanced by stunning garden views.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
12. Tavern On the Green
Iconic dining experience blending NYC's energy with Central Park's tranquility

Tavern On The Green exudes a magical atmosphere, leaving guests feeling as though they've stepped into a grand farmhouse, reminiscent of an Italian villa or a historic Hudson River Valley mansion. The decor is meticulously crafted, creating an ambiance that is nothing short of enchanting.
A recent dining experience at Tavern On The Green during the holiday season proved to be utterly delightful. The Christmas Eve luncheon offered a range of delectable dishes, each one skillfully prepared and presented. Pair this with the unbeatable setting amidst Central Park, and it's clear that Tavern On The Green knows how to create a memorable dining experience.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
13. Olmsted
Innovative dining with fresh, garden-grown ingredients.

Olmsted, a popular restaurant in Brooklyn, remains a hotspot for locals and visitors alike, with its trendy atmosphere and impressive menu drawing in crowds. Securing a reservation can be difficult due to its high demand, but those who do are rewarded with a memorable dining experience.
The menu at Olmsted features creative and sophisticated dishes that are sure to impress. The squash rings are a standout option, and the small loaf of daily prepared bread arrives at the table hot and accompanied by soft, unsalted butter. Additionally, the sweet potato pierogies and rutabaga tagliatelle are not to be missed. Each dish is carefully crafted, showcasing the chef's talent for combining unexpected ingredients and flavors.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
14. Empire Diner
So much more than just a diner. It's back and better than ever.

The diner offers a unique and upscale take on classic comfort foods. Menu highlights include the creative "pork on pork" and "steak and potatoes" dishes, as well as delicious vegetable options like chili brussel sprouts and shishito pepper poppers. The dessert menu is also worth exploring, with a selection of decadent offerings to satisfy any sweet tooth.
Regarding service, opinions seem to be divided. Some diners have reported exceptional experiences, praising the staff for their friendliness and attentiveness. However, others have been less impressed, citing issues such as rudeness, poor communication, or a lack of professionalism. While these negative experiences are certainly concerning, the majority of reviewers appear to have had a positive overall experience with the food and atmosphere.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Dinner
- Social Gatherings
15. Jane Restaurant West Village
Casual American bistro with a bustling weekend brunch.

A recent brunch experience at Jane Restaurant, located at 100 West Houston St, left a lasting impression. The establishment is known for its exceptional brunch offerings, and this reputation was well-deserved based on the quality of food and service provided.
Upon arrival, the restaurant was bustling with activity, but a reservation ensured immediate seating. The waitstaff was knowledgeable and attentive, offering excellent recommendations to enhance the meal. The menu featured a variety of options including avocado toast, omelettes, eggs Benedict, and the standout dish of French toast. The mimosas and other beverages were equally delightful. Overall, the experience at Jane Restaurant was top-notch and highly recommended for anyone looking for an unforgettable brunch.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
16. Contra
Award-winning cocktails and divine food in a chic setting.

The service at this establishment is truly commendable. The servers demonstrate a strong commitment to ensuring guests have an enjoyable dining experience. They are attentive, helpful, and go above and beyond to cater to the needs of their customers.
The dessert offerings are exceptional, offering a unique and creative take on familiar flavors. The desserts are beautifully presented and combine interesting forms and combinations, resulting in delightful and delicious creations that are sure to impress.
My wife and I recently visited for our anniversary and it was our third time dining at this establishment. We were once again impressed by the high-quality food and service. If the experience we had is any indication, it's clear that this establishment takes great care in providing an exceptional dining experience for their customers. The food, service, and overall atmosphere all come together to make this a top-notch destination for any occasion.
17. The Flatiron Room Murray Hill
Experience old New York charm with modern elegance.

This American restaurant in NYC offers a fantastic dining experience with its delectable dishes and rare spirit selection. Diners are treated to a diverse menu that showcases the best of American cuisine, along with a unique assortment of spirits that are sure to excite any connoisseur. The atmosphere is further enhanced by live music performances that add a distinctive and enjoyable element to the meal.
High-quality food, exceptional service, and live jazz music make this American restaurant a standout choice in NYC. The menu showcases mouth-watering American dishes prepared with the finest ingredients, and the restaurant's commitment to excellent service is evident in every interaction. With its regular live jazz performances, this restaurant provides a memorable dining experience that sets it apart from other establishments in the city.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Affordable Nightlife
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
18. American Bar - New York
Timeless Continental cuisine in a bright, fun setting

The culinary experience at this establishment is highly regarded by its patrons. The chopped salad and peanut avocado dishes, specifically, have garnered significant attention and acclaim from guests. The bread basket, a staple during brunch hours, is another menu item that should not be overlooked.
In addition to the salad and brunch options, the burgers served at this establishment are also highly praised. Guests have consistently noted the delicious flavor and high quality of the burger offerings, making them a popular choice for many patrons.