The 11 Best Italian restaurants in Jamaica New York City
Italian restaurants in Jamaica, NYC, offer a taste of Italy in the heart of New York City. These establishments serve up classic dishes like pasta and pizza, along with unique culinary creations that showcase the diversity of Italian cuisine. Whether you're in the mood for a quick slice or a multi-course meal, Italian restaurants in Jamaica NYC have something for everyone. Come and indulge in the rich flavors and warm hospitality that these restaurants have to offer.
Toc
1. Elias Corner
Astoria's first and best fish restaurant since the 80's
__NEW TEXT__
Greek salad at this establishment is highly acclaimed by patrons for its freshness and delightful flavor. The combination of ingredients, including tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, and feta cheese, creates a refreshing and tangy taste that is sure to satisfy. The freshness of the ingredients is evident in every bite, making for a truly enjoyable dining experience.
The service at this restaurant is described as friendly, professional, and consistent. Staff members are attentive to guests' needs, ensuring that their dining experience is pleasant and hassle-free. While some guests have noted that service can be slow, many understand that this is due to pandemic-related restrictions and appreciate the extra precautions taken to ensure their safety. Overall, the high-quality service further enhances the dining experience.
Greek salad at this establishment is highly acclaimed by patrons for its freshness and delightful flavor. The combination of ingredients, including tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, and feta cheese, creates a refreshing and tangy taste that is sure to satisfy. The freshness of the ingredients is evident in every bite, making for a truly enjoyable dining experience.
The service at this restaurant is described as friendly, professional, and consistent. Staff members are attentive to guests' needs, ensuring that their dining experience is pleasant and hassle-free. While some guests have noted that service can be slow, many understand that this is due to pandemic-related restrictions and appreciate the extra precautions taken to ensure their safety. Overall, the high-quality service further enhances the dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mexican Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
2. Astoria Seafood
Pick your seafood, choose your cooking style!
__NEW TEXT__
Astoria Seafood, a popular establishment known for its dual function as a market and restaurant, offers customers the unique opportunity to select their own seafood and choose from various preparation methods such as grilling, frying, or baking. The menu boasts an impressive array of fresh seafood options, including jumbo shrimp, succulent salmon, tender calamari, plump scallops, and succulent lobster tail.
Despite the high-quality and delicious food, Astoria Seafood has received some criticism for its service. Some patrons have reported slow service and a lack of attentiveness from staff. However, the freshness and taste of the food continue to attract customers, making it a well-regarded destination for seafood lovers despite its service shortcomings.
Astoria Seafood, a popular establishment known for its dual function as a market and restaurant, offers customers the unique opportunity to select their own seafood and choose from various preparation methods such as grilling, frying, or baking. The menu boasts an impressive array of fresh seafood options, including jumbo shrimp, succulent salmon, tender calamari, plump scallops, and succulent lobster tail.
Despite the high-quality and delicious food, Astoria Seafood has received some criticism for its service. Some patrons have reported slow service and a lack of attentiveness from staff. However, the freshness and taste of the food continue to attract customers, making it a well-regarded destination for seafood lovers despite its service shortcomings.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Asian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Dinner
3. Neir's Tavern
One of NYC's oldest bars, since 1829
__NEW TEXT__
This local neighborhood bar is a must-visit, thanks to its rich history and welcoming atmosphere. It's a comfortable and relaxed spot where families with young children can be seen enjoying their early dinners in the dining area. The bar's association with the classic film "Goodfellas" adds to its appeal as a bit of a landmark.
The staff at this establishment go above and beyond to provide excellent service to their patrons. The food is delicious and has earned rave reviews from visitors. In addition to the great food and drinks, they also offer high-quality merchandise at reasonable prices, making it a perfect spot for souvenirs or gifts. The reviewer's first experience at the bar was a memorable one, and they look forward to returning for more.
This local neighborhood bar is a must-visit, thanks to its rich history and welcoming atmosphere. It's a comfortable and relaxed spot where families with young children can be seen enjoying their early dinners in the dining area. The bar's association with the classic film "Goodfellas" adds to its appeal as a bit of a landmark.
The staff at this establishment go above and beyond to provide excellent service to their patrons. The food is delicious and has earned rave reviews from visitors. In addition to the great food and drinks, they also offer high-quality merchandise at reasonable prices, making it a perfect spot for souvenirs or gifts. The reviewer's first experience at the bar was a memorable one, and they look forward to returning for more.
4. Veggie Castle II
Vegan Caribbean delights in a cozy, welcoming setting.
__NEW TEXT__
Upon moving to Queens, the absence of Veggie Castle OG became a source of disappointment. However, the discovery of Veggie Castle II in the same borough brought about a welcome surprise. Despite the challenge of navigating through rush hour traffic on the Van Wyck, the venture proved worthwhile. The food was delicious, affordable and came in generous portions. The only drawback was the red velvet cake, which tasted stale, possibly due to being the last piece available.
Veggie Castle II presents a wide variety of vegan options, albeit slightly pricey, but consistently delicious. The restaurant features a hot bar with an assortment of choices and a sandwich menu. Ready-to-eat options like kale, Mac, lo mein, BBQ chicken, and po boy sandwiches are available. The restaurant also offers fresh juices and enticing vegan desserts such as chocolate peanut butter cheesecake. Caribbean vegan cuisine is also on the menu, with mouthwatering dishes such as mac and cheese, acorn squash, rice and peas, seiten, plantains, faux ox tail, and lollipop chicken. The faux ox tail stands out with its spicy, sweet and savory flavor, while the lollipop chicken delightfully surprises with its sweet taste and excellent texture. The establishment mainly caters to take-out orders, but the limited seating provided is sufficient for customers to enjoy the delectable food, making it an ideal destination for vegans and non-vegans alike.
Upon moving to Queens, the absence of Veggie Castle OG became a source of disappointment. However, the discovery of Veggie Castle II in the same borough brought about a welcome surprise. Despite the challenge of navigating through rush hour traffic on the Van Wyck, the venture proved worthwhile. The food was delicious, affordable and came in generous portions. The only drawback was the red velvet cake, which tasted stale, possibly due to being the last piece available.
Veggie Castle II presents a wide variety of vegan options, albeit slightly pricey, but consistently delicious. The restaurant features a hot bar with an assortment of choices and a sandwich menu. Ready-to-eat options like kale, Mac, lo mein, BBQ chicken, and po boy sandwiches are available. The restaurant also offers fresh juices and enticing vegan desserts such as chocolate peanut butter cheesecake. Caribbean vegan cuisine is also on the menu, with mouthwatering dishes such as mac and cheese, acorn squash, rice and peas, seiten, plantains, faux ox tail, and lollipop chicken. The faux ox tail stands out with its spicy, sweet and savory flavor, while the lollipop chicken delightfully surprises with its sweet taste and excellent texture. The establishment mainly caters to take-out orders, but the limited seating provided is sufficient for customers to enjoy the delectable food, making it an ideal destination for vegans and non-vegans alike.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
5. Comfortland
Comfort food with a twist, including vegan delights
__NEW TEXT__
Comfortland offers a welcoming and cozy environment, making it an ideal location for a satisfying meal. The staff is not only friendly but also attentive, ensuring that every customer feels valued. The Freaky Friday Chicken Burger is a standout menu item, boasting a unique combination of flavors that will leave you craving more. Pair it with their truffle fries, which are crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and generously seasoned with truffle oil.
The menu at Comfortland features creative and appetizing options that cater to a wide range of palates. For instance, the Dr Freak n' Stein burger is a popular choice, packed with a variety of ingredients that explode with flavor. To complement your meal, indulge in one of their thick and creamy milkshakes, which are the perfect blend of sweet and rich. The customer service is top-notch, with staff members who are happy to answer any questions and make recommendations. Visitors can expect a memorable dining experience at Comfortland.
Comfortland offers a welcoming and cozy environment, making it an ideal location for a satisfying meal. The staff is not only friendly but also attentive, ensuring that every customer feels valued. The Freaky Friday Chicken Burger is a standout menu item, boasting a unique combination of flavors that will leave you craving more. Pair it with their truffle fries, which are crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and generously seasoned with truffle oil.
The menu at Comfortland features creative and appetizing options that cater to a wide range of palates. For instance, the Dr Freak n' Stein burger is a popular choice, packed with a variety of ingredients that explode with flavor. To complement your meal, indulge in one of their thick and creamy milkshakes, which are the perfect blend of sweet and rich. The customer service is top-notch, with staff members who are happy to answer any questions and make recommendations. Visitors can expect a memorable dining experience at Comfortland.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
6. Sayra's Wine Bar
Perfect for a beachside date night with wine and tapas.
__NEW TEXT__
A tiny gem of a wine bar, Sayra's Wine Bar offers a cozy and intimate atmosphere for wine enthusiasts and foodies alike. Here, the wine list is extensive and well-curated, boasting a range of options from all around the world. Equally impressive is the food menu, which features delectable meals crafted with fresh ingredients and showcasing flavors from different regions.
The staff at Sayra's Wine Bar are attentive, knowledgeable, and passionate about their offerings. They take the time to engage with guests and ensure a delightful experience. Whether you're a seasoned wine connoisseur or just starting your wine journey, you'll feel right at home here. This unassuming but magnificent wine bar has succeeded in creating a loyal following of patrons who keep coming back for more of its delicious food, exceptional wines, and unparalleled hospitality. The outdoor seating, nestled within a beautiful backyard space, adds to the overall charm and is not to be missed. Sayra's Wine Bar has thoughtfully crafted an inviting space for friends and families to gather, relax, and enjoy a fine selection of wines and food.
A tiny gem of a wine bar, Sayra's Wine Bar offers a cozy and intimate atmosphere for wine enthusiasts and foodies alike. Here, the wine list is extensive and well-curated, boasting a range of options from all around the world. Equally impressive is the food menu, which features delectable meals crafted with fresh ingredients and showcasing flavors from different regions.
The staff at Sayra's Wine Bar are attentive, knowledgeable, and passionate about their offerings. They take the time to engage with guests and ensure a delightful experience. Whether you're a seasoned wine connoisseur or just starting your wine journey, you'll feel right at home here. This unassuming but magnificent wine bar has succeeded in creating a loyal following of patrons who keep coming back for more of its delicious food, exceptional wines, and unparalleled hospitality. The outdoor seating, nestled within a beautiful backyard space, adds to the overall charm and is not to be missed. Sayra's Wine Bar has thoughtfully crafted an inviting space for friends and families to gather, relax, and enjoy a fine selection of wines and food.
7. Maiella
Authentic Italian cuisine with stunning city views
__NEW TEXT__
The atmosphere of the restaurant is nothing short of exceptional. Described as beautiful, top-notch, and perfect, the ambiance is made even more appealing with its cozy and chill vibes. The overall mood is one of great energy and positivity, making it an ideal spot for any occasion.
The food served in this establishment is truly a gastronomic delight. The shrimp appetizer, bathed in a luscious cream sauce, is a must-try. The rigatoni, doused in a rich and savory sauce, is a standout among the pasta dishes, which are considered the stars of the menu. To end the meal on a high note, the tiramisu is a perfectly sweet and decadent dessert that is not to be missed. Overall, the dishes are worth every penny they cost, making for a truly satisfying dining experience.
The atmosphere of the restaurant is nothing short of exceptional. Described as beautiful, top-notch, and perfect, the ambiance is made even more appealing with its cozy and chill vibes. The overall mood is one of great energy and positivity, making it an ideal spot for any occasion.
The food served in this establishment is truly a gastronomic delight. The shrimp appetizer, bathed in a luscious cream sauce, is a must-try. The rigatoni, doused in a rich and savory sauce, is a standout among the pasta dishes, which are considered the stars of the menu. To end the meal on a high note, the tiramisu is a perfectly sweet and decadent dessert that is not to be missed. Overall, the dishes are worth every penny they cost, making for a truly satisfying dining experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Waterfront
- Social Gatherings
- Vegetarian Options
8. Rolo’s
Neighborhood gem with a wood-fired culinary experience
__NEW TEXT__
Nestled in a quiet corner of Queens, Rolo's is a charming restaurant that has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Its inviting atmosphere, complete with warm lighting and comfortable seating, makes it the perfect spot for a casual dinner or special occasion. The restaurant's menu features an impressive selection of Italian dishes, but it's the pasta offerings that truly shine. Each plate is carefully crafted, with fresh ingredients and bold flavors that transport diners straight to Italy.
In addition to its delicious pasta, Rolo's is also known for its creative take on Italian cuisine. One standout is the wood-fired pizzas, which boast crispy crusts and an array of unique toppings. From classic Margherita to more adventurous combinations, these pies are sure to please even the most discerning pizza lovers. And with a friendly and attentive staff, diners can enjoy their meal in a relaxed and enjoyable setting. Overall, Rolo's is a not-to-be-missed destination for anyone looking to experience some of the best Italian food in Queens.
Nestled in a quiet corner of Queens, Rolo's is a charming restaurant that has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Its inviting atmosphere, complete with warm lighting and comfortable seating, makes it the perfect spot for a casual dinner or special occasion. The restaurant's menu features an impressive selection of Italian dishes, but it's the pasta offerings that truly shine. Each plate is carefully crafted, with fresh ingredients and bold flavors that transport diners straight to Italy.
In addition to its delicious pasta, Rolo's is also known for its creative take on Italian cuisine. One standout is the wood-fired pizzas, which boast crispy crusts and an array of unique toppings. From classic Margherita to more adventurous combinations, these pies are sure to please even the most discerning pizza lovers. And with a friendly and attentive staff, diners can enjoy their meal in a relaxed and enjoyable setting. Overall, Rolo's is a not-to-be-missed destination for anyone looking to experience some of the best Italian food in Queens.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Dinner
- Celebrations
9. Donovan's Pub
Woodside's Landmark Gathering Place since 1966
__NEW TEXT__
Donovan's Pub is a popular spot for people looking for delicious food at reasonable prices. It's where locals and visitors alike go to enjoy a quick drink or to gather for special occasions and celebrations.
The pub's warm and inviting atmosphere, combined with its helpful and convivial staff, makes it an appealing destination for people of all ages. The food served at Donovan's is consistently high-quality, with standout menu items including their tasty burgers and perfectly cooked fries. A must-visit for anyone looking for a great meal at a great price.
Donovan's Pub is a popular spot for people looking for delicious food at reasonable prices. It's where locals and visitors alike go to enjoy a quick drink or to gather for special occasions and celebrations.
The pub's warm and inviting atmosphere, combined with its helpful and convivial staff, makes it an appealing destination for people of all ages. The food served at Donovan's is consistently high-quality, with standout menu items including their tasty burgers and perfectly cooked fries. A must-visit for anyone looking for a great meal at a great price.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
10. Sweet Afton
Astoria's best spot for craft beers and burgers.
__NEW TEXT__
Sweet Afton boasts an appealing decor, with exposed brick, velvet curtains, and charming floral table arrangements that contribute to a cozy and intimate atmosphere. This establishment is an excellent choice for a romantic date or a social gathering with friends.
The dining experience at Sweet Afton is highlighted by their delicious apple pecan flapjacks. The syrup served with these flapjacks adds a unique touch, complementing the dish exceptionally well. The fair pricing, attractive presentation, and efficient service from the waitstaff further enhance the overall positive dining experience.
Sweet Afton boasts an appealing decor, with exposed brick, velvet curtains, and charming floral table arrangements that contribute to a cozy and intimate atmosphere. This establishment is an excellent choice for a romantic date or a social gathering with friends.
The dining experience at Sweet Afton is highlighted by their delicious apple pecan flapjacks. The syrup served with these flapjacks adds a unique touch, complementing the dish exceptionally well. The fair pricing, attractive presentation, and efficient service from the waitstaff further enhance the overall positive dining experience.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Happy Hours
11. Vesta Trattoria & Wine Bar
Authentic Italian flavors inspired by local green markets.
__NEW TEXT__
Vesta Trattoria, an Italian restaurant in Astoria, offers a cozy and intimate atmosphere perfect for various occasions. Its dim lighting and comfortable seating arrangements make it an ideal spot for both casual and formal gatherings. The Margherita pizza, one of their specialties, is a must-try with its perfectly cooked crust and flavorful toppings.
Happy hour at Vesta Trattoria is an excellent opportunity to enjoy a variety of drinks and dishes at reasonable prices. The restaurant features an extensive wine list, including the Carl Graff Riesling wine, which pairs beautifully with any dish. Whether seeking a date night spot or a friendly neighborhood restaurant, Vesta Trattoria’s delicious food and inviting ambiance do not disappoint.
Vesta Trattoria, an Italian restaurant in Astoria, offers a cozy and intimate atmosphere perfect for various occasions. Its dim lighting and comfortable seating arrangements make it an ideal spot for both casual and formal gatherings. The Margherita pizza, one of their specialties, is a must-try with its perfectly cooked crust and flavorful toppings.
Happy hour at Vesta Trattoria is an excellent opportunity to enjoy a variety of drinks and dishes at reasonable prices. The restaurant features an extensive wine list, including the Carl Graff Riesling wine, which pairs beautifully with any dish. Whether seeking a date night spot or a friendly neighborhood restaurant, Vesta Trattoria’s delicious food and inviting ambiance do not disappoint.