Best of 29 Philly cheesesteaks in Ithaca

Discover our curated list of top-ranked Philly cheesesteaks in Ithaca, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Chili's Grill & Bar, Ithaca Ale House, Texas Roadhouse, Shortstop Deli, Simeon's American Bistro. Let's explore together!

Toc

1. Chili's Grill & Bar

Tex-Mex cuisine and American classics

  • Rating: 4.1/5 (1235 Review by google)
  • Address:

    608 S Meadow St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Spacious seating, family-friendly atmosphere, extensive menu selection
  • Cons:

    Hit-or-miss service, expensive for some diners, limited vegetarian options
  • Popular Menu:

    Baby Back Ribs, Fajitas, Guacamole
  • Price Range:

    $15-$30
Phone Directions Website
Immersed in the vibrant ambiance of Chili's Grill & Bar, my senses were tantalized by a whirlwind of flavors that danced upon my palate. Each dish was a delightful masterpiece, meticulously crafted to excite the taste buds and ignite a passion for culinary exploration. The bold and adventurous menu offerings beckon to both the connoisseur and the casual diner, promising an unforgettable dining experience that lingers long after the last bite.
As I revisited the charming haven of Chili's Grill & Bar in Ithaca, I encountered a slight hiccup in the form of a brief wait to be seated. However, once settled in, the attentive service and delectable offerings swiftly eclipsed any initial reservations. The restaurant's inviting ambiance and enticing aromas served as a prelude to a culinary journey that surpassed expectations, leaving me with a newfound appreciation for the artistry of food and the joy of shared dining experiences.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Hidden Gems
  • Social Gatherings

2. Ithaca Ale House

Extensive craft beer selection and friendly service

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (1716 Review by google)
  • Address:

    301 E State St Suite 1, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of beers on tap, delicious pub food, cozy and lively atmosphere
  • Cons:

    Can get crowded, may have long wait times, limited vegetarian options
  • Popular Menu:

    Burgers, wings, and mac and cheese
  • Price Range:

    $10-$30
Phone Directions Website
Looking to unwind with a cold, locally brewed beer in the heart of Ithaca? Located in the vibrant "Streatery" area on the east end of the Commons, Ithaca Ale House strikes the perfect balance with a wide selection of beers and a menu that promises flavorful and satisfying dishes. From the generous portions of crowd-pleasers like French Onion Soup and Buffalo Egg Rolls to their delectable salads, burgers, and pizzas, every bite is a treat. And let's not forget the irresistible Mrs. O'Leary's cookies - a heavenly finish to your meal when paired with a glass of milk. Address: 301 E State St Suite 1, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States.
During a recent visit to Ithaca Ale House, our experience was nothing short of delightful. The friendly and attentive service, combined with the impressive beer selection and outstanding appetizers, left us eager to return for a full meal on our next journey through town. For a group gathering, this venue proves to be a convenient and reasonably priced option, accommodating us swiftly and serving up a satisfying dining experience for all. Plan your visit and indulge in the culinary delights and laid-back ambiance that only Ithaca Ale House can offer.

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Spanish restaurants in Ithaca

3. Texas Roadhouse

Hand-cut steaks and famous buckets of peanuts

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (1911 Review by google)
  • Address:

    719-25 S Meadow St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Generous portions, delicious food, friendly staff, fun atmosphere with peanut shells on the floor, offers lunch specials
  • Cons:

    Can be quite noisy, may have long wait times, limited vegetarian options
  • Popular Menu:

    Ribs, steaks, and fresh-baked bread
  • Price Range:

    $15-$35
Phone Directions Website
Indulge in a carnivorous feast at Texas Roadhouse Steakhouse in Ithaca, NY, where juicy steaks reign supreme. Sink your teeth into perfectly grilled cuts of meat and savor the irresistible combination of fresh rolls slathered in soft honey butter. Start your dining experience on a high note with a crisp Caesar salad, offering a refreshing contrast of cold, crunchy greens.
Embark on a culinary journey of impeccable flavors at Texas Roadhouse, where every bite is a testament to excellence. Treat yourself to the sumptuous Porterhouse Steak, perfectly paired with a side of fragrant rice and a delightful Margarita to elevate your dining experience. With a stellar track record of consistently delicious meals, Texas Roadhouse guarantees a dining experience that will keep you coming back for more.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Social Gatherings
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Mid-Range

Relate link

quiche in Ithaca

4. Shortstop Deli

Locally sourced ingredients, homemade bread, creative sandwich options

  • Time:

    7 AM to 8 PM

  • Rating: 4.5/5 (1125 Review by google)
  • Address:

    200 W Seneca St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of sandwiches, friendly service, located in downtown Ithaca
  • Cons:

    Can get crowded during peak hours, limited seating, cash-only
  • Popular Menu:

    The Boomer, The Natural, The Godfather
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website
Shortstop Deli is an absolute gem that beckons to every passerby in town. Their sandwiches are nothing short of fantastic and a definite must-try. Despite the lack of indoor seating, the fast and friendly service ensures a seamless takeaway experience. On the menu, you'll find a mouthwatering array of options, from delicious bagels with cream cheese to hearty BBQ pulled pork sandwiches, each bursting with flavor and satisfaction. It's the perfect spot for a quick, no-fuss meal that doesn't compromise on taste or quality. Whether you're a local or just passing through, a visit to Shortstop Deli is an essential culinary adventure that promises to delight your taste buds and leave you craving more.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Lunch
  • Dinner

Relate link

fast food restaurants in Ithaca

5. Simeon's American Bistro

Creative twists on American classics in a relaxed setting

  • Rating: 4.5/5 (508 Review by google)
  • Address:

    224 E State St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide selection of American dishes, cozy and inviting atmosphere, offers outdoor seating
  • Cons:

    Some reviews mention slow service, prices on the higher side, hit-or-miss food quality
  • Popular Menu:

    Crab cakes, braised short ribs, homemade chicken pot pie
  • Price Range:

    $20-$40
Phone Directions Website
Simeon's American Bistro offers a delightful dining experience in Ithaca, striking a balance between delicious food and a charming ambiance. The location near The Commons provides a perfect setting with ample natural light during the day and vibrant activity at night. The menu, though concise, caters to all tastes and budgets, featuring both classic favorites and innovative dishes. Don't miss their nightly specials like the delectable braised halibut, paired excellently with a glass of local wine. Address: 224 E State St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States
Stepping into Simeon's American Bistro, you are greeted with a sophisticated and elegant atmosphere, highlighted by exquisite decor and attentive service. While the prices may be on the higher side, the quality of the food and the overall dining experience justifies the cost. Opt for outdoor seating if the weather permits for a side of people-watching at The Commons. The lobster mac and cheese is a standout dish, though other options like burgers may leave you craving more flavor for the price.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Salad restaurants in Ithaca

6. Lincoln Street Diner

Classic diner offering traditional American comfort food

  • Time:

    6:30 AM to 1 PM

  • Rating: 4.7/5 (531 Review by google)
  • Address:

    309 E Lincoln St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of menu options, Comfortable atmosphere, Friendly staff
  • Cons:

    Can get crowded during peak hours, Limited vegetarian options, Cash only
  • Popular Menu:

    All-day breakfast, Burgers, Milkshakes
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website
Nestled on Lincoln Street, the diner offers a delightful culinary experience. The perfectly cooked eggs and corned beef hash were a highlight, although the rust on the cutlery was a minor setback. Despite this, the cozy ambiance and friendly service made for a memorable visit. The Philadelphia omelet, served with homemade potatoes and toast, was a true delight, and the mini apple crumble tart was a delectable finish to the meal. Overall, a charming spot for delicious and affordable breakfast and lunch options.

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Pasta restaurants in Ithaca

7. Sunset Grill

Features a deck with stunning views of Cayuga Lake

  • Time:

    7 AM to 9 PM

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (812 Review by google)
  • Address:

    823 Danby Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Offers a variety of American and seafood dishes, Beautiful sunset views, Casual and family-friendly atmosphere
  • Cons:

    May have slow service during peak hours, Limited vegetarian options, Some dishes may be overpriced
  • Popular Menu:

    Lobster roll, Fish and chips, New York strip steak
  • Price Range:

    $20-$40
Phone Directions
Although Sunset Grill offers a captivating view with a rating of 2 stars, the dining experience did not meet expectations. The salmon with seafood was served with dry rice, lacking flavor. The garlic shrimp pasta was decent, but the eggplant parmesan fell short. The service was disappointing, lacking attentiveness. While not recommended for food, the restaurant is worth visiting for the view.
For a delightful meal anytime of day, this amazing spot is a must-visit. Whether it's breakfast, lunch, or dinner, the menu at this place is sure to satisfy your cravings. Indulge in classics like eggs benedict and two eggs cooked any style, paired perfectly with a hazelnut coffee that sets the tone for a truly memorable dining experience.

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

cheesy bread in Ithaca

8. Sal's Pizzeria

Hand-tossed dough, locally sourced ingredients

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (336 Review by google)
  • Address:

    220 S Fulton St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of pizzas, friendly service, delivery and takeout options
  • Cons:

    Limited seating, can get crowded during peak hours, cash-only
  • Popular Menu:

    New York style pizza, specialty pizzas, garlic knots
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website

Image 220 S Fulton St Ithaca, NY 14850 Tel: (607) 277-7257 Sal's Pizzeria bakes its pies in a stone oven and is one of the oldest pizzerias in Ithaka. Its sauce is sweet and ripe, the cheese is well melted, and the crust gives it a satisfying crunch without being too chewy. The toppings are also very well cooked and portioned. The Sal's Special is mainly what draws the masses to this place. It comes with their incredibly delicious homemade sausage, fresh mushrooms, pepperoni, green peppers, and an extra layer of mozzarella. There is also a gluten free pizza and a vegetarian option for vegetarians that taste great. Place your order anytime between 11:00 a.m. and 5:00 p.m. m. and 8:45 p.m. m. and receive your pizza. You can buy by price or as a whole.


TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

pumpkin desserts in Ithaca

9. Milkstand Restaurant

Small, family-owned business serving creative comfort food

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (542 Review by google)
  • Address:

    215 N Meadow St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of milkshake flavors, cozy atmosphere, diverse food menu
  • Cons:

    Prices slightly above average, limited seating, cash-only policy
  • Popular Menu:

    Gourmet milkshakes, grilled cheese sandwiches, tater tots
  • Price Range:

    $6 - $12
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Mid-Range
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

bread pudding in Ithaca

10. Red's Place

A popular local bar with a variety of events

  • Time:

    11:30 AM to 9 PM

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (578 Review by google)
  • Address:

    107 N Aurora St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide selection of beers, live music events, friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, outdoor seating
  • Cons:

    Limited food options, cash-only policy, can get crowded
  • Popular Menu:

    Burgers, sandwiches, wings
  • Price Range:

    $-$$
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Vegan Options
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

soups in Ithaca

11. Ooy's Cafe & Deli

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Gluten-Free
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Asian Cuisine
  • Social Gatherings

12. Uncle Joe's Grill & Sports Bar

Featuring numerous TVs for sports viewing and a relaxed patio

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (337 Review by google)
  • Address:

    302 W Green St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide selection of beers, friendly staff, lively atmosphere
  • Cons:

    Prices can be a bit high, can get crowded, limited vegetarian options
  • Popular Menu:

    Wings, burgers, sandwiches
  • Price Range:

    $15-$30
Phone Directions

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Social Gatherings
  • Vegetarian Options

Relate link

lunch restaurants in Ithaca

13. DiBella's Subs

Freshly baked bread and high-quality meats and cheeses

  • Time:

    10 AM to 9 PM

  • Rating: 4.4/5 (323 Review by google)
  • Address:

    222 Elmira Rd Suite 14, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of sandwich options, friendly service, convenient location
  • Cons:

    Limited seating, can get crowded during peak hours, prices slightly higher than some competitors
  • Popular Menu:

    Meatball parmesan sub, Italian sub, turkey and swiss sub
  • Price Range:

    $7 - $12
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Tuna restaurants in Ithaca

14. Arby's

Offers a unique alternative to traditional fast food chains

  • Time:

    10 AM to 12 AM

  • Rating: 3.9/5 (518 Review by google)
  • Address:

    328 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of menu options, convenience of drive-thru and takeout, friendly service
  • Cons:

    Soda fountain machines may have limited selection, seating may be limited during peak hours, some may find the food high in sodium
  • Popular Menu:

    Roast Beef Sandwich, Curly Fries, Jamocha Shake
  • Price Range:

    $6-$15
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Dinner

Relate link

salads in Ithaca

15. Casablanca Pizzeria

Serves authentic Sicilian-style pizza in a family-friendly environment

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (296 Review by google)
  • Address:

    111 E State St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of pizzas, cozy atmosphere, offers delivery and takeout services
  • Cons:

    Limited vegetarian options, reported long wait times during peak hours, some complaints about inconsistent food quality
  • Popular Menu:

    Margherita pizza, pepperoni pizza, lasagna
  • Price Range:

    $10-$20
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

Tiramisu restaurants in Ithaca

16. Firehouse Subs Ithaca

Supporting first responders with every purchase

  • Time:

    10:30 AM to 9 PM

  • Rating: 4.2/5 (498 Review by google)
  • Address:

    740 S Meadow St #1100, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of hot subs, Friendly service, Spacious seating area
  • Cons:

    Sandwiches can be quite salty, Limited vegetarian options, No delivery service
  • Popular Menu:

    Hook and Ladder Sandwich, Firehouse Meatball Sub, Italian Sub
  • Price Range:

    $8 - $15
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

chef salad in Ithaca

17. Gorgers

Locally sourced ingredients, sustainable business practices

  • Time:

    11 AM to 8 PM

  • Rating: 4.6/5 (495 Review by google)
  • Address:

    116 W State St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of menu options, suitable for groups, offers vegetarian and vegan dishes
  • Cons:

    Some reviews mention long waiting times and hit-or-miss service
  • Popular Menu:

    Burgers, sandwiches, and salads
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Vegan Options
  • Budget-Friendly Eats

Relate link

Seafood restaurants in Ithaca

18. Luna Inspired Street Food

Local favorite for Asian-inspired street food

  • Time:

    11 AM to 11 PM

  • Rating: 3.8/5 (701 Review by google)
  • Address:

    113 N Aurora St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of Asian-fusion street food, Fast and friendly service, Vegan and vegetarian options available
  • Cons:

    Limited seating options, Cash-only policy, May close early if sold out
  • Popular Menu:

    Bao buns, Tofu rice bowls, Korean-style tacos
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Mexican Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

persian restaurants in Ithaca

19. Pudgie's Pizza & Subs

Family-owned and operated since 1977

  • Time:

    11 AM to 8 PM

  • Rating: 3.9/5 (208 Review by google)
  • Address:

    215 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of pizzas and subs, convenient location, offers catering services
  • Cons:

    Some customers complain about slow service and high prices
  • Popular Menu:

    Specialty pizzas, hot subs, garlic knots
  • Price Range:

    $
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

brazilian restaurants in Ithaca

20. Ned's Pizza NY College Town

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Mid-Range
  • Hidden Gems

21. Lou's Street Food, Center Ithaca

Directions

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Downtown Spots
  • Lunch

Relate link

desserts in Ithaca

22. Marrakech Cuisine - Ithaca, NY

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Mediterranean Cuisine
  • Celebrations
  • Downtown Spots

23. Creola Southern Steakhouse

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Mid-Range

Relate link

Salmon restaurants in Ithaca

24. Subway

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • American Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Lunch

Relate link

burgers in Ithaca

25. Domino's Pizza

Offers a rewards program and online discounts

  • Rating: 3.4/5 (283 Review by google)
  • Address:

    311 E Green St, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Wide variety of pizzas, convenient online ordering, offers delivery and carryout services
  • Cons:

    Prices can be high for large orders, limited parking availability, some reviews mention inconsistent food quality
  • Popular Menu:

    Pepperoni pizza, Cheese pizza,breadsticks
  • Price Range:

    $10-$30
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Vegetarian Options
  • Dinner

Relate link

hidden restaurants in Ithaca

26. Dandy Mini Mart

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

kid-friendly restaurants in Ithaca

27. Mama Teresa's Pizzeria

Directions

TOPICS

  • Italian Cuisine
  • Downtown Spots
  • Cheap Eats
  • Vegetarian Options

Relate link

organic restaurant in Ithaca

28. Jack's Grill

Home of the famous 'Mile High Black Angus Sandwich', great service, and a cozy atmosphere

  • Time:

    11 AM to 11 PM

  • Rating: 3.3/5 (291 Review by google)
  • Address:

    120 Dryden Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States

  • Pros:

    Established in 1945, historic spot, old-fashioned decor, extensive menu, good for groups
  • Cons:

    Cash only, no reservations, limited seating, can be noisy and busy
  • Popular Menu:

    Steak, prime rib, burgers, seafood, milkshakes
  • Price Range:

    $20 - $40
Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Social Gatherings
  • American Cuisine
  • Cheap Eats
  • Downtown Spots

Relate link

tater tot in Ithaca

29. Ithaca Ghost Kitchen

Phone Directions Website

TOPICS

  • Fusion Cuisine
  • Budget-Friendly Eats
  • Downtown Spots
  • Dinner

Relate link

Japanese restaurants in Ithaca