Best of 21 restaurants in Bay Ridge NYC
Discover the vibrant dining scene in Bay Ridge, NYC. This charming neighborhood is home to a diverse array of restaurants, each offering unique and delicious cuisine. From authentic Italian eateries to modern fusion spots, restaurants in Bay Ridge NYC cater to every palate. Come and explore the rich flavors and warm hospitality of this dynamic community.
- 1. Sofia
- 2. Piccante in Bay Ridge
- 3. Dave's Garden
- 4. The Wicked Monk
- 5. POLONICA RESTAURANT in Bay Ridge
- 6. Peppino's
- 7. Tanoreen in Bay Ridge
- 8. Amuni
- 9. Hazar Turkish Kebab
- 10. Rocco's Pizzeria
- 11. Fresh Eats Café
- 12. Baci Ristorante of Bay Ridge
- 13. Tacos Por Favor
- 14. UBANI- Bay Ridge
- 15. South Brooklyn Foundry in Bay Ridge
- 16. Ayat
- 17. Little Athens NY
- 18. Olives & Pita
- 19. Fatta Mano
- 20. Lan Thai
- 21. Choban Pita & Grill
1. Sofia
Authentic Italian flavors in the heart of Brooklyn.

Upon entering Sofia, a quaint Italian restaurant in Bay Ridge, New York, for lunch, there was a noticeable lack of customers. However, any doubts were quickly erased as the exceptional quality of the food and service became evident. The restaurant has become a popular choice for families, with children taking a particular liking to the menu options.
Sofia boasts a range of Italian dishes, some of which stand out more than others. For instance, the rabbit cacciatore over papardelle delivers a delightful explosion of flavors, satisfying even the most discerning of palates. On the other hand, the mussels, while initially promising, may not meet the same high expectations set by other menu items. Overall, Sofia offers a cozy dining experience complete with quality Italian food, making it a great local option for families and food enthusiasts alike.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- Vegetarian Options
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
Relate link
2. Piccante in Bay Ridge
Family-owned Italian restaurant with homemade dishes.

Piccante is a charming Italian restaurant located in a residential area. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly service make it an ideal spot for a cozy dinner. The pasta dishes are a standout, featuring top-notch ingredients and creative flavor combinations. While the steak dish is decent, it doesn't quite reach the same level of excellence as the pasta. Generous portion sizes mean that you may have leftovers to take home.
This reviewer was fortunate to stumble upon Piccante in their neighborhood. The warm ambiance and gracious owner made for an enjoyable dining experience. The food was outstanding, boasting impressive flavors and fresh ingredients. The music selection was an added bonus. It's worth noting that the restaurant is small, so reservations are recommended. Overall, Piccante is a delightful spot to enjoy Italian cuisine.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
3. Dave's Garden

TOPICS
- Rooftop
- Happy Hours
- Vegetarian Options
4. The Wicked Monk
Party inside an old church with live music!

Service during the experience was described as a mix of positive and negative aspects. Some guests have praised the friendliness and attentiveness of the staff, expressing their satisfaction with the level of service provided. However, other guests have criticized the staff for lacking professionalism and not meeting their expectations.
On the other hand, the food was universally praised by guests, who described it as fantastic, delicious, and excellent. Despite the overwhelmingly positive feedback, some guests mentioned that the food has undergone changes over time and is not the same as before. Regardless, the majority of guests have expressed their appreciation for the high-quality food and dining experience.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Dinner
5. POLONICA RESTAURANT in Bay Ridge
Traditional Polish comfort food in a cozy setting

Polonica Restaurant in Bay Ridge is known for its delicious and hearty soups. Among the offerings are Borscht, Barley Soup, Stuffed Cabbage, and Ukrainian borscht. These soups are highly recommended for those looking for a filling and satisfying meal. The variety ensures there is something for everyone, whether you prefer a vegetable-based soup or one with meat.
The restaurant also receive praises for its excellent food and service. The owner is described as friendly and welcoming, always making sure that guests' needs are met. Diners recommend trying the boiled perogies, kielbasa, and stuffed cabbage, each with its unique flavor. The perogies are reportedly tender and delicious, while the kielbasa is flavorful and savory. The stuffed cabbage, meanwhile, features a delightful combination of tart sauerkraut and sweet beets.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Social Gatherings
- Gluten-Free
6. Peppino's
Experience the taste of Italy in Brooklyn.

The food at this establishment is highly acclaimed for its freshness, delectable taste, and high-quality ingredients. Pizzas are a popular choice, known for their crispy crusts and generously sized portions. Similarly, pasta dishes have received positive feedback for their flavors and presentation.
However, there have been some concerns regarding the delivery service. While some customers have reported that their orders arrived within the designated time frame, others have experienced delays. Moreover, a few customers have found their food to be cold upon arrival, and the delivery fees have been perceived as steep by some. These issues may detract from the overall dining experience for those who opt for takeout or delivery.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
7. Tanoreen in Bay Ridge
Home-style food meant for sharing

Tanoreen offers a delightful dining experience with exceptional food and welcoming staff. The restaurant's intimate size adds to its cozy and inviting atmosphere, but it can get busy during peak hours and weekends, so planning ahead is recommended. The owner, Rawia Bishara, takes the time to personally greet and engage with diners, creating a friendly and personable environment.
During a recent lunch visit, a group of friends and I were promptly seated and greeted by attentive waitstaff. We ordered a variety of appetizers to share, and the dishes that stood out were the perfectly cooked Brussels sprouts, flavorful falafel, creamy hummus, and the unique Eggplant Napoleon. The waiter also surprised us with a complimentary appetizer, Mhammara, a delicious mix of pureed red pepper, walnuts, and pomegranate molasses. This unexpected addition showcased the restaurant's commitment to providing a memorable and satisfying dining experience for its guests.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Affordable Nightlife
- Celebrations
8. Amuni
Authentic Sicilian flavors in every bite

Amuni, a popular dining destination, is renowned for its exceptional service and inviting atmosphere. The backyard area provides an ideal setting for al fresco dining during summer evenings, while the welcoming and cheerful demeanor of the staff creates a cozy and pleasant dining experience.
The culinary offerings at Amuni are equally impressive, with a focus on Sicilian cuisine that features standout dishes such as anelletti and crispy fried artichoke. The eggplant sandwich is another customer favorite, known for its rich flavor and high quality ingredients. Diners are certain to enjoy a memorable meal at Amuni, with delicious food and impeccable service that exceeds expectations.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
9. Hazar Turkish Kebab
A taste of Turkey in a casual dining setting.

This establishment is a superb choice for diners seeking authentic Turkish cuisine in a relaxed atmosphere. The service is friendly and unobtrusive, providing just the right amount of attention to make guests feel welcome without becoming overwhelming. One of the standout features is the freshly baked pita bread, which is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The restaurant's prices are very reasonable, and the quality of the ingredients used is evident in every dish.
The food at this Turkish restaurant is always fresh and prepared promptly, making it an excellent option for takeout. The eatery is known for its generosity with their homemade bread, which is a delightfully tasty addition to any meal. Whether you dine in or take out, you can be confident that the restaurant uses only fresh and high-quality ingredients in their dishes. Overall, this is an excellent choice for anyone looking for delicious and authentic Turkish cuisine.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
10. Rocco's Pizzeria
Home of the Annual Pizza Eating Contest!

Brooklyn style pizza is delightfully prepared and served at this establishment. The chicken parm is a popular choice, known for its delicious taste and generous portion. Mozzarella sticks are another favorite, with a perfect golden crust and oozing cheese.
This eatery in Bay Ridge is an excellent option for pizza and sandwiches, offering a wide variety of choices to satisfy your cravings. The neighborhood has several dining options, but the quality and service at this particular spot make it a top contender for locals and visitors alike.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
Relate link
11. Fresh Eats Café
Fresh, healthy, and delicious meals for everyone

Fresh Eats Cafe, situated in the vibrant Bay Ridge neighborhood of Brooklyn, offers a delightful dining experience. This establishment is known for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional service. The staff members are courteous, helpful, and always ready to cater to the needs of their patrons.
For those craving something savory, the Pepper Steak Sandwich with salad is a must-try. This dish features tender, freshly prepared meat seasoned with black pepper, generously nestled in a soft bun with crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes. The salad, made with freshly picked vegetables, complements the sandwich nicely. The Cafe also specializes in Halal cuisine, with delicious breakfast and lunch options, and provides delivery services to accommodate its patrons' needs.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
12. Baci Ristorante of Bay Ridge
Authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Bay Ridge.

This Italian-American restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with its delicious food and friendly service. Upon arrival for a 5 p.m. reservation on a Thursday, the establishment was beginning to fill up, but the hostess warmly greeted and seated us. The restaurant follows all COVID protocols, requiring masks until seated. With a large menu and additional offerings, the server was patient in explaining each option.
The appetizers and wine, suggested by the server, were exceptional. Entrees of pasta seafood and fish were also highly satisfying. Moreover, the restaurant presents an upscale yet classy ambiance, perfect for a special night out. Portions are generous, so it's worth considering this when ordering multiple courses. Overall, this establishment is an excellent choice for those seeking a quality Italian-American meal at a reasonable price.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
- Personal Celebrations
13. Tacos Por Favor
Authentic Mexican flavors in the heart of Brooklyn.

Tacos Por Favor is a Mexican food establishment known for its wide selection of high-quality tacos and other dishes. Two standout options are the carne asada and al pastor tacos, which are always met with rave reviews. The restaurant also prides itself on its efficient and accurate service, with a 97% rating for both on-time delivery and correct order fulfillment.
The TPF Burrito is a menu item that should not be overlooked. This generously-sized burrito features a satisfying combination of savory peppers and onions mixed with cheese, fresh avocado, rice, and cilantro. With a rating of 97 out of 100, it's clear that customers highly recommend giving this dish a try.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Happy Hours
- Late Night
14. UBANI- Bay Ridge
Authentic Georgian cuisine in a welcoming atmosphere

The Georgian restaurant in Bay Ridge provides an authentic and delightful dining experience, showcasing the rich flavors and unique dishes of Georgian cuisine. Their khinkali, a type of Georgian dumpling, are particularly noteworthy with a satisfyingly brothy and flavorful filling. The khachapuri, a traditional Georgian dish made with cheese and bread, is also a standout, especially the version with beans and cheese. The chanakhi, a slow-cooked lamb stew, is another must-try, with its perfectly cooked meat and outstanding combination of flavors.
In addition to the famous cheese boat and brothy khinkali, this restaurant offers a variety of other dishes that are worth exploring. The Georgian salad, for example, is a customer favorite, featuring a fresh mix of vegetables and a creamy walnut dressing. The restaurant's commitment to authenticity and quality is evident in every dish, making it a must-visit destination for fans of Georgian cuisine and those looking to expand their culinary horizons. Whether you're a curious foodie or a lover of Georgian food, this restaurant is sure to impress.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
15. South Brooklyn Foundry in Bay Ridge
A community hub with diverse events and hand-crafted fare.

The fried Brussels sprouts at this establishment are truly exceptional. They are prepared with great care, resulting in a quick cook time and a crispy exterior that is satisfying to bite into. The seasoning is expertly applied, providing a depth of flavor that enhances the natural taste of the Brussels sprouts. These delectable morsels come with a side of garlic aioli sauce that adds an extra layer of richness to each bite. These Brussels sprouts are certainly a must-try for any visitor.
The food at this establishment in Bay Ridge is truly something to write home about. The chef, a competitor on the hit show Chopped, showcases their culinary prowess through each dish. The mac n' cheese, made with tortellinis instead of the traditional macaroni, is an inventive and delightful take on a classic comfort food. The cauliflower dish is a standout, offering a unique combination of flavors and textures that is sure to impress. The Brussels sprouts are not to be missed - they are cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor. The beet and goat cheese salad is a delightful starter, and any meal here should be capped off with one of their delicious chocolate desserts, which are the perfect blend of rich and indulgent.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Affordable Nightlife
16. Ayat
Bringing Palestinian culture and tradition to Brooklyn

Ayat is a popular dining destination, known for its welcoming and attentive staff. Customers consistently express their satisfaction with the establishment's service, citing the team's friendly and helpful demeanor.
The food at Ayat is also highly regarded. Fresh pitas are a standout, with customers raving about their quality and freshness. Additionally, the menu offers a range of options to suit different tastes and preferences, all of which are praised for their delicious flavor and quick service.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
17. Little Athens NY
Authentic Greek cuisine with fresh ingredients.

The salad at this establishment is a popular selection among customers, and it's not hard to see why. Its freshness is immediately apparent, making for a satisfying and crisp bite every time. The quality of ingredients used is top-notch, resulting in a salad that is both delicious and nutritious. Furthermore, the portion sizes are generous, providing excellent value for money.
The food offered by this establishment is consistently fresh and of high quality. The chef takes great care in crafting each dish, resulting in a dining experience that is both enjoyable and satisfying. Customers appreciate the attention to detail in every meal, from the carefully selected ingredients to the beautifully presented plates. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty entrée or a light salad, this establishment is sure to exceed your expectations.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Celebrations
18. Olives & Pita
Authentic Greek flavors in the heart of Brooklyn

Olives & Pita in Bay Ridge is an excellent choice for anyone seeking delicious and authentic Greek cuisine. From the moment you step inside, you are greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere that immediately makes you feel at home. The staff is friendly, attentive, and creates a welcoming environment for all customers.
The menu at Olives & Pita is extensive, featuring many traditional Greek dishes prepared with the freshest ingredients. From the vibrant Greek salads with tangy feta cheese to the rich and hearty moussaka, the flavors of Greece are brought to life in every dish. The portion sizes are generous, leaving you satisfied and content without leaving any leftovers behind. Despite the high-quality ingredients and delicious taste, the prices remain affordable, making Olives & Pita an excellent choice for a night out or a casual family dinner. Whether you're a fan of Greek cuisine or looking to try something new, Olives & Pita is sure to leave a lasting impression.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
19. Fatta Mano
Traditional Italian flavors with a modern twist.

Fatta Mano, situated at 8501 3rd Avenue in New York, is a traditional Italian restaurant that prides itself on offering authentic Italian cuisine. The menu boasts a range of options, from savory pasta dishes to mouth-watering pizzas, all prepared by a dedicated chef who strives to create innovative and delicious meals. The restaurant's commitment to customer service is evident in the attentive and exceptional service provided by the staff, making for an unforgettable dining experience.
Fatta Mano is a BYOB establishment located in Bay Ridge, offering a welcoming and relaxed atmosphere, complete with warm and welcoming staff. The restaurant's menu is varied, catering to a range of tastes and preferences. In addition to the excellent food and service, Fatta Mano boasts an interior that is both clean and visually pleasing, making it an ideal location for celebrations and casual gatherings. Overall, Fatta Mano provides a memorable dining experience in a cozy and inviting setting.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Downtown Spots
20. Lan Thai

TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Asian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
21. Choban Pita & Grill
Honoring tradition with flavorsome Turkish food and exceptional service

The culinary experience at this establishment is truly exceptional. The food is consistently fresh and flavorful, providing a satisfying meal for all who dine there. It's clear that great care is taken in the preparation of each dish, resulting in a menu that is both appetizing and memorable.
The staff go above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience for all patrons. From greeting customers with a warm smile to attending to their individual needs, the team at this establishment is a true asset. Exemplary service was provided during a recent family lunch, including a considerate gesture to adjust the seating area to ensure comfort in the cooler weather. This level of dedication to customer satisfaction is truly commendable.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mexican Cuisine
- Vegan Options