13 Best seafood restaurants in West Village New York City
Seafood Restaurants in West Village NYC: A Culinary Journey West Village, NYC, is a foodie's paradise, showcasing an array of seafood restaurants that offer fresh, delectable, and sustainable seafood dishes. From upscale eateries to cozy neighborhood joints, these establishments highlight the best of sea-to-table dining, using locally-sourced and seasonal ingredients to create unforgettable culinary experiences. Join us as we explore the top Seafood Restaurants in West Village NYC.
1. Ama Raw Bar West Village
Amazing $1 oyster happy hours and craft cocktails.

A marvelous dining experience awaits at this wonderful restaurant, where every dish served is a delight. Families can share a variety of appetizers, such as the kimchi coleslaw with a unique blend of spicy and mild flavors, the refreshing salmon ceviche tacos, and the fresh oysters at an affordable price of $1 each. The sashimi salad and chicken and shrimp bao buns are other excellent options. The miso glazed salmon was cooked perfectly, leaving guests satisfied with their meals. Complimentary mochi ice cream was provided, adding a sweet touch to the dining experience. The attentive and friendly manager makes for a welcoming atmosphere, making it a definite winner.
A must-visit for seafood lovers is this restaurant in the West Village, offering a perfect spot for happy hour after work. The raw seafood offerings are particularly impressive, including fresh oysters that are a pure joy to savor. Expertly crafted cocktails complement the seafood menu, making it an ideal destination for a night out. With its high-quality seafood and cocktails at reasonable prices, this restaurant is a standout in the area. Whether for a casual evening with friends or a special occasion, this restaurant is sure to impress. Guests can expect a memorable dining experience that will leave them eager to return.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Affordable Nightlife
- Downtown Spots
2. Catch NYC
Modern renditions of classic dishes in a vibrant setting

The seafood at this establishment is of superior quality, leaving a memorable impression. The Tartare Trio, in particular, showcases a faultless blend of flavors and textures, making it a must-order. Similarly, the Hellfire Roll delivers a satisfying punch, balancing spiciness with the freshness of the seafood.
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
3. The Clam
Neighborhood gem with Atlantic seaboard flavors

The seafood at this restaurant is fresh and delectable, with a range of options that will please any seafood lover. The clam chowder is a crowd favorite, with its rich and creamy broth and tender clams. The mussels with coconut curry are another standout, with the perfect balance of spice and sweetness from the coconut milk. The Halibut with butternut risotto is a delicious and filling entree, while the oysters and codfish are also excellent choices.
The Clam is a top-notch seafood restaurant in NYC, renowned for its well-curated and thematic menu. The Chef's expertise in selecting and preparing seafood dishes is evident in every plate that comes out of the kitchen. The team's dedication to providing excellent service is also noteworthy, with a knowledgeable and attentive staff that makes every dining experience enjoyable. Overall, The Clam is a must-visit for anyone seeking fresh and delicious seafood in NYC.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Happy Hours
4. Seamore's Chelsea
Sustainable seafood with a casual beach vibe.

Seamore's, located in the heart of Chelsea, NYC, is a must-visit for seafood lovers. The restaurant, highly recommended, offers a relaxed and casual atmosphere, making it the perfect spot for a business dinner or a meal with family and friends. The manager, Bill, is commendable for his exceptional service and attention to detail.
During happy hour, Seamore's serves $1.50 oysters and delicious drinks, making it an ideal place to unwind after work. The fish selection, accompanied by tasty sides, is a popular choice for dinner. The fish and chips, in particular, are not to be missed, as they are cooked to perfection and have a delightful crunch. Overall, Seamore's is a hidden gem that should be on everyone's list when visiting NYC.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
- Budget-Friendly Eats
5. Flex Mussels
Seafood focus with creative twists and a lively atmosphere

This renowned seafood restaurant, a long-standing establishment, is a must-visit for any seafood lover. The restaurant prides itself on offering an extensive menu filled with a diverse selection of fresh shellfish and non-shellfish dishes that are equally impressive.
During a recent visit on a Thursday evening, a reservation for six was made, and despite arriving five minutes late, the food arrived promptly and was thoroughly enjoyable. One diner opted for the classic white wine and garlic dish, while another chose the version with a red sauce and calamari. Both dishes were well-prepared and satisfying, if not mind-blowingly exceptional. Overall, the meal was a positive experience, showcasing the restaurant's commitment to quality and consistency.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Asian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
6. Cull & Pistol
Michelin-acclaimed seafood in Chelsea Market

This seafood restaurant offers an exceptional dining experience, with fresh and expertly prepared dishes that are sure to impress. The oysters are a standout, with a perfect balance of brininess and sweetness. The lobster roll is another must-try, stuffed with tender, succulent meat and served on a soft, buttery bun. The shoestring fries are crispy and well-seasoned, making for a delicious side dish.
In addition to the excellent food, this restaurant also boasts a great selection of wines at reasonable prices. While it may be challenging to secure a reservation due to its popularity, I believe it is worth the effort for a top-notch seafood experience in the city. Overall, this restaurant is a must-visit for seafood lovers and a shining star in the local dining scene.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mexican Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- High-End
7. Trattoria Pesce Pasta
Authentic Northern Italian cuisine in Greenwich Village.

The seafood lasagna at this establishment is a truly exceptional dish. The flavors are expertly layered, resulting in a rich and satisfying taste. The seafood used in the lasagna is noticeably fresh, adding a depth of flavor that is not often found in this type of dish. It is highly recommended for those who visit this restaurant to give the seafood lasagna a try.
The spaghetti bolognese served at this Italian restaurant is equally delightful. As a classic Italian dish, it is often difficult to find a truly authentic version, but this establishment has succeeded in creating a dish that is both classic and modern. The spaghetti is cooked al dente, and the bolognese sauce has a deep, rich flavor that only comes from long-simmered meat. The overall experience of dining in this restaurant, with its cozy and intimate atmosphere, makes it a must-visit for any Italian food lover.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Vegetarian Options
- Affordable Nightlife
8. Dame
An English seafood haven with a playful wine list

Dame is a small yet popular seafood restaurant in England that offers a delightful dining experience. Its proximity to the Mermaid Oyster Bar adds to its charm. Despite having limited seating, consisting of 5 tables, 7 bar seats, and 4 outdoor tables, Dame manages to accommodate a good number of guests seeking to savor its delicious offerings.
The restaurant's fish and chips are renowned and a must-try. For those who prefer to start with something lighter, the whitefish salad with fried polenta and trout roe is an excellent choice, although it may have a slightly overpowering fish flavor. Additionally, the grilled oysters topped with green hollandaise are a must-order, as they are a culinary delight that showcases Dame's commitment to quality ingredients and innovative preparation. Overall, Dame is highly recommended for its delicious food, impeccable service, and cozy atmosphere.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
9. Mary's Fish Camp
Serving the best seafood in the West Village since 2001.

Mary's Fish Camp, located in the West Village, has long been considered one of the top seafood destinations in the area. The menu boasts daily specials such as three varieties of whole grilled fish, three types of oysters, whole lobster, and bouillabaisse. In addition to these offerings, the restaurant is well-known for its signature lobster roll.
However, after much time, even a beloved establishment like Mary's Fish Camp can develop some shortcomings. It's important to note that while the restaurant still offers delicious seafood options, the overall experience may not meet the high expectations that have been set in the past. The once charming beach-shack atmosphere may now feel a bit dated to some. With that said, Mary's Fish Camp remains a solid choice for seafood in the West Village, but it's worth adjusting one's expectations to fully appreciate what it has to offer.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
Relate link
10. Jeffrey's Grocery
Charming seafood haven in the heart of West Village.

The restaurant offers a welcoming and delightful atmosphere, perfect for a relaxed dining experience. The staff is friendly and attentive, providing excellent service to all patrons. The menu features a variety of dishes designed for sharing, encouraging a communal and enjoyable mealtime.
TOPICS
- Cheap Eats
- Hidden Gems
- Asian Cuisine
11. Mermaid Oyster Bar
Live jazz music on weekends, Nautical decor, Knowledgeable staff

The Mermaid Inn offers a delightful dining experience, with its relaxed New England fish shack atmosphere and exceptional seafood. The restaurant exudes a cozy and welcoming ambiance, complete with friendly hospitality that makes guests feel right at home. The menu features classic seafood fare that is sure to please, all made with the freshest ingredients.
The Mermaid Oyster Bar is a popular neighborhood destination for those seeking a casual yet sophisticated dining experience. With a focus on seafood inspired by the North Atlantic and Mediterranean, the menu offers a variety of fresh and flavorful dishes. The restaurant's warm and inviting atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for socializing over delicious food and drinks. Whether dining with friends, family, or colleagues, The Mermaid Oyster Bar is sure to provide a memorable and enjoyable experience.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Hidden Gems
- Mid-Range
12. Alice
Sophisticated Italian seafood & lobster bar in West Village.

The dining establishment offers a diverse and enticing menu, featuring a range of outstanding dishes that are sure to impress. Among the standouts are the Vongole, a delightful and flavorful clam dish, and the Tiramisu, which is a perfectly executed and delicious Italian classic. Both dishes are not to be missed and demonstrate the kitchen's expertise and commitment to quality.
The service at this establishment is exceptional, with staff who are attentive, pleasant, and dedicated to providing an outstanding dining experience. They consistently go above and beyond to ensure that customers are satisfied and well taken care of. This level of service contributes to a warm and inviting atmosphere that makes for a truly enjoyable meal. Whether dining for a special occasion or a casual night out, customers can expect to be treated with the utmost care and attention.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Fusion Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Downtown Spots
13. Crab Du Jour Xpress Cajun Seafood
Experience-driven seafood dining in a fun, communal atmosphere

Seafood lovers will not be disappointed when they dine at this establishment. The crab legs are a standout, with their freshness and perfect seasoning being particularly noteworthy. The restaurant goes out of its way to ensure that the seafood is of the highest quality, and it truly pays off in the taste.
Those looking for a generous serving of seafood will find it here. The portions are more than ample, and the flavors are expertly balanced. Crawfish is a must-try, as it is cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor. This restaurant is a top choice for anyone seeking a delicious seafood experience.
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Cheap Eats