Best of 30 pizza places in Utica
Discover our curated list of top-ranked pizza places in Utica, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Swifty's Restaurant & Pub, Chesterfield's Tavolo, Babe's, Tony's Pizzeria, Nina's Pizza. Let's explore together!
Toc
- 1. Swifty's Restaurant & Pub
- 2. Chesterfield's Tavolo
- 3. Babe's
- 4. Tony's Pizzeria
- 5. Nina's Pizza
- 6. Bella Regina
- 7. THE HUB EATERY
- 8. Lukins Brick Oven Pizza
- 9. O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria
- 10. Slice
- 11. Ventura's
- 12. Parkway Pizza
- 13. North End Pizza & Tap
- 14. Pizza Classic
- 15. Pizza Box
- 16. Two Brothers Cafe and Pizzeria
- 17. Rosario's Pizzeria East Utica
- 18. Joey's @307 Restaurant
- 19. Palermo Pizzeria
- 20. Pizzeria Italia
- 21. Domino's Pizza
- 22. It's a Utica Thing! Kitchen & Bar
- 23. Savage Pizza
- 24. Hot Off The Brick Pizza South Utica
- 25. Bellagio Restaurant and Pizzeria
- 26. Little Caesars Pizza
- 27. Franco's Pizza & Italian Deli
- 28. Rosso Verde
- 29. Supreme Slice
- 30. Wood Oven Pizza
1. Swifty's Restaurant & Pub
Featuring a cozy atmosphere with a classic pub vibe
Nestled in the vibrant pulse of Utica lies Swifty's Restaurant & Pub, a culinary gem that embodies the essence of American pub fare. Step into a world where savory burgers and succulent steaks intertwine harmoniously with the lively spirit of sports and companionship. The inviting ambiance of Swifty's, complemented by a hospitable staff and spotless interiors, sets the stage for a dining experience that tantalizes the taste buds and warms the soul. Whether indulging in the hearty depths of Shepherd's Pie, savoring a berry-infused beer, or relishing the exquisite flavors of a corned beef Reuben wrap, every bite at Swifty's is a journey into culinary bliss. With a prestigious history of over a decade, marked by glowing reviews not only for its delectable offerings but also for its stellar service under the stewardship of hospitality luminaries like Danielle and Cole, Swifty's stands as a testament to the fusion of exceptional cuisine and conviviality.
A hidden lunchtime oasis in the heart of Utica, Swifty's captivates with its friendly service, swift efficiency, and mouthwatering dishes. The pub-style ambiance exudes a welcoming charm, while the impeccably clean surroundings elevate the dining experience. Delight in the delights of the Shepherd's Pie, a signature dish that embodies comfort and flavor in every bite. For the adventurous palate, the berry-flavored beer offers a refreshing twist, leaving a lasting impression that beckons for a return visit. With a staff that exudes warmth and a menu that entices with its diverse offerings, Swifty's is a culinary haven where each visit promises culinary discoveries and memorable moments alike.
A hidden lunchtime oasis in the heart of Utica, Swifty's captivates with its friendly service, swift efficiency, and mouthwatering dishes. The pub-style ambiance exudes a welcoming charm, while the impeccably clean surroundings elevate the dining experience. Delight in the delights of the Shepherd's Pie, a signature dish that embodies comfort and flavor in every bite. For the adventurous palate, the berry-flavored beer offers a refreshing twist, leaving a lasting impression that beckons for a return visit. With a staff that exudes warmth and a menu that entices with its diverse offerings, Swifty's is a culinary haven where each visit promises culinary discoveries and memorable moments alike.
2. Chesterfield's Tavolo
Authentic Italian cuisine in a family-friendly setting
Experience the unforgettable fusion of Urban Drinks and Italian Eats at Chesterfield's Tavolo, nestled in North Utica just moments away from the NYS Thruway. Featured on Travel Channel's Delicious Destinations for its renowned Original Greens, this dining gem boasts a menu that expertly marries classic flavors with a modern twist. From the delectable Artisan Pizzas baked to perfection in their exclusive oven to the tantalizing charcoal delicacies, every dish promises a culinary adventure that delights the senses. Whether you're seeking a casual meal with friends, a heartwarming family dinner, or a romantic outing, Chesterfield's Tavolo invites you to relish in a dining experience that blends exceptional cuisine with impeccable service. Be sure to savor their signature dish, the irresistible Original Greens Morelle and Chicken Riggies—the epitome of gastronomic indulgence.
Indulge in a lunchtime escapade to Tavolo's on a somber Saturday afternoon, where swift service greeted us promptly upon seating. From the flavorful chicken Melissa to the savory chicken parmesan sandwich, accompanied by perfectly crisp fries, every dish showcases a harmonious blend of ingredients. The attention to detail, such as the generous sprinkle of parmesan cheese atop the rolls, adds an extra layer of culinary finesse. However, the steep prices coupled with lackluster service left a bitter aftertaste, with our waitress fumbling drink orders. Despite the hiccups, the allure of Chesterfield's Tavolo's enticing menu and cozy ambiance beckons for a return visit, promising a chance to create lasting memories over a delightful meal.
Indulge in a lunchtime escapade to Tavolo's on a somber Saturday afternoon, where swift service greeted us promptly upon seating. From the flavorful chicken Melissa to the savory chicken parmesan sandwich, accompanied by perfectly crisp fries, every dish showcases a harmonious blend of ingredients. The attention to detail, such as the generous sprinkle of parmesan cheese atop the rolls, adds an extra layer of culinary finesse. However, the steep prices coupled with lackluster service left a bitter aftertaste, with our waitress fumbling drink orders. Despite the hiccups, the allure of Chesterfield's Tavolo's enticing menu and cozy ambiance beckons for a return visit, promising a chance to create lasting memories over a delightful meal.
3. Babe's
Over 100 beers on tap and a great selection of comfort food
Babe's restaurant offers a truly unique dining experience, featuring both indoor and outdoor seating options. The live band adds a delightful touch to the ambiance, serenading guests with beautiful music while they indulge in spirits at the indoor bar. The spacious layout of the restaurant allows for a comfortable and enjoyable dining experience, reminiscent of southern charm and hospitality.
The culinary offerings at Babe's are reminiscent of classic diners, with a focus on simplicity and delicious flavors. The cheeseburger, in particular, stands out as a star on the menu - each bite bursting with freshness and the satisfying taste of a just-grilled patty. The dining experience at Babe's is a culinary journey that promises to delight the taste buds and leave guests craving more of their delectable fare.
The culinary offerings at Babe's are reminiscent of classic diners, with a focus on simplicity and delicious flavors. The cheeseburger, in particular, stands out as a star on the menu - each bite bursting with freshness and the satisfying taste of a just-grilled patty. The dining experience at Babe's is a culinary journey that promises to delight the taste buds and leave guests craving more of their delectable fare.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Suburban
4. Tony's Pizzeria
Long-standing family-owned pizzeria, hand-tossed pizza dough
Tony's Pizzeria in Washington Mills, NY offers a decent dining experience with a cozy atmosphere and delectable crispy fries. While the large pepperoni pizza is considered good but not exceptional, their reputation for having the best pizza in the area is well-deserved. With fresh slices and a loyal customer base, Tony's is a go-to spot for delicious Italian fare.
Known for its renowned chicken wing pizza, Tony's Pizza is a must-visit establishment in Washington Mills, NY. Offering a cozy seating area and mouthwatering crispy fries, the pizzeria garners praise for its delicious menu options. Patrons frequent the eatery for a reason, as Tony's consistently delivers top-tier pizza that keeps customers coming back for more.
Known for its renowned chicken wing pizza, Tony's Pizza is a must-visit establishment in Washington Mills, NY. Offering a cozy seating area and mouthwatering crispy fries, the pizzeria garners praise for its delicious menu options. Patrons frequent the eatery for a reason, as Tony's consistently delivers top-tier pizza that keeps customers coming back for more.
5. Nina's Pizza
Homemade recipes, Family-owned business
Nina's Pizza on 100 Genesee St, Utica, New York, offers a diverse menu featuring specialty pizzas, wings, sandwiches, salads, and more. The exceptional pizza quality, top-notch service, and inviting atmosphere create a memorable dining experience. Returning after 11 years, I enjoyed introducing my son to his first authentic New York pizzeria, grateful for the community's dedication to their craft. The meticulous attention to plating surpasses typical pizzeria standards, showcasing a genuine passion for culinary excellence.
6. Bella Regina
Family-owned and operated, Uses fresh, locally sourced ingredients
At Bella Regina, prepare to be wowed by the exceptional food and top-notch service - it's a culinary experience like no other. The decadent desserts might even outshine the main courses - a delightful surprise! The vibrant atmosphere sets the stage for a perfect date night, leaving us eager to explore every tempting item on the menu. Bella Regina is now our go-to spot for a memorable dining experience.
7. THE HUB EATERY
Local favorite with a creative menu and extensive drink selection
Indulge in a culinary delight at The Hub Eatery nestled in Utica, where a plate of spaghetti unveils a mouthwatering ensemble of meatballs, garlic bread, and salad. The irresistible dishes are a testament to both quality and flavor, promising a memorable dining experience. At María's Pasta Shop, the extraordinary food is accompanied by a welcoming ambience and a team of exceptionally friendly staff. Every bite is a celebration of taste, enticing you to return for another exquisite meal. The delectable sandwiches are so captivating that stopping to snap a photo becomes a delightful afterthought, a true testament to their irresistible charm.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
8. Lukins Brick Oven Pizza
Hand-tossed dough, High-quality ingredients, Family-owned
9. O'Scugnizzo Pizzeria
Family-owned pizzeria since 1914 with unique menu items
Another customer tried to warn me when I walked in that the pizza here is not what you expect it to be.You must have noticed that I'm from out of town, but I happen to know this place and love the pies just the way they are.…
10. Slice
Family-owned pizzeria since 2007
I ordered today at Slice Pizzeria for the office staff.A great experience from order to pickup.We enjoyed trying the different things.Sorry, the pictures were taken after one or two staff members came in.
Always be sure to visit Slice Pizzeria when visiting downtown New York.The large, crispy slices of Purple Cow pizza were an absolute delight.Each bite was a perfect blend of flavors,
Always be sure to visit Slice Pizzeria when visiting downtown New York.The large, crispy slices of Purple Cow pizza were an absolute delight.Each bite was a perfect blend of flavors,
11. Ventura's
Offers a cozy and authentic Italian dining experience
Great friendly service and server.The snails were great, I prefer a sauce with more garlic.The riggies were probably the best I've had in the area.Great flavor profile in the sauce.The sausage was very good too.I'm saying tomato sauce is fine.The stuffed shells were good.
A hidden gem (at least for me) that I hope to visit again.We were on our way home after a VERY long road trip and we were starving.
A hidden gem (at least for me) that I hope to visit again.We were on our way home after a VERY long road trip and we were starving.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Hidden Gems
- Mid-Range
- Social Gatherings
12. Parkway Pizza
Locally owned and operated since 1990
13. North End Pizza & Tap
Known for their hand-tossed pizza and extensive tap list
14. Pizza Classic
Family-owned pizzeria serving the community since 1953
15. Pizza Box
Offers a loyalty program for frequent customers
16. Two Brothers Cafe and Pizzeria
Family-owned local restaurant with a warm and inviting ambiance
I must say that I was impressed with the delicious doner and burek.The food here is absolutely fantastic, with a wide variety of options to choose from.The doner and burek, in particular, are simply amazing - the flavors are rich and tasty, and the portions are very generous.
17. Rosario's Pizzeria East Utica
Family-owned and operated for over 20 years
Considering your options in the immediate area, this beats the pizza on the strip across the street.Cali pizza is very sweet, buffalo chicken was preferred.Also, I tried the special lasagna meatball and it was very good.The garlic bread was overpowering with garlic butter.I will eat again and recommend it.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mexican Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Dinner
18. Joey's @307 Restaurant
Homemade recipes with locally sourced ingredients
What a great restaurant.We went for lunch.I had pappardelle with bolognese sauce and a meatball.It also came with a great antipasto.This was a lunch special that cost 13 dollars!
Ok, I hadn't been back to Utica in a couple of decades.I was prepared for my cugino's wedding weekend.One of the items on my bucket list in Utica was to find a great Italian restaurant...Well, Joey's @307 did NOT disappoint!
Ok, I hadn't been back to Utica in a couple of decades.I was prepared for my cugino's wedding weekend.One of the items on my bucket list in Utica was to find a great Italian restaurant...Well, Joey's @307 did NOT disappoint!
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
19. Palermo Pizzeria
Family-owned pizzeria since 1988
20. Pizzeria Italia
This was our first visit.We decided to try Pizzaria Italia based on numerous Facebook reviews and some anecdotes from friends.The pizza was extremely tasty: lots of cheese, a good sauce, generous toppings, and a crispy, flavorful crust.
Delicious, we stopped by here a few days ago when I was in the area for a slice and had to return, it's the best pizza in the area.
Delicious, we stopped by here a few days ago when I was in the area for a slice and had to return, it's the best pizza in the area.
21. Domino's Pizza
Offers gluten-free and thin-crust options, participates in local community events
I go there from time to time and I like it a lot but...I think they overcharged me first thing in the morning.The girl who worked was not friendly at all.It's Domino's though, so I'll keep going there.
22. It's a Utica Thing! Kitchen & Bar
23. Savage Pizza
24. Hot Off The Brick Pizza South Utica
25. Bellagio Restaurant and Pizzeria
26. Little Caesars Pizza
27. Franco's Pizza & Italian Deli
Homemade sauces and dressings, Family-owned restaurant
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
28. Rosso Verde
The food was pretty good.The pizza and wings really hit the spot.I usually like a thinner pizza, but it felt like something thicker and based on your photos, the pizza looked perfect.I was right.It was exactly what I had in mind.
29. Supreme Slice
30. Wood Oven Pizza
