Best of 31 bread pudding in Little Italy NYC
Tucked away in the heart of New York City, Little Italy is a cultural haven known for its vibrant atmosphere and delicious Italian-American cuisine. One standout dessert that residents and visitors alike can't get enough of is bread pudding in Little Italy NYC. This classic dish is a favorite among foodies and families alike, featuring warm, fluffy bread soaked in a sweet custard mixture and topped with a variety of tasty add-ons. Whether you're looking for a cozy café to enjoy a slice of bread pudding in Little Italy NYC or wanting to try your hand at making this comforting treat at home, there's no denying the appeal of this iconic dish.
- 1. La Bella Ferrara
- 2. Ferrara Bakery & Cafe
- 3. Caffé Palermo
- 4. Buona Notte
- 5. Zia Maria Little Italy
- 6. L’Amore Restaurant
- 7. La Mela
- 8. Paesano
- 9. Caffe Napoli
- 10. Da Gennaro
- 11. Benito One
- 12. Gelso & Grand
- 13. Casa Bella
- 14. Taiyaki NYC Japanese Ice Cream
- 15. Da Nico
- 16. Umbertos Clam House
- 17. Grotta Azzurra Restaurant
- 18. La Bella Vita restaurant
- 19. Casa D'angelo - Nyc
- 20. La Nonna in Little Italy
- 21. IL Cortile in Little Italy
- 22. Puglia
- 23. Caffe Roma in Little Italy
- 24. Sofia's of Little Italy
- 25. Original Vincent's
- 26. Lunella in Little Italy
- 27. Il Piccolo Bufalo
- 28. Spongies Cafe
- 29. Bambina Blue Gelato Wonder Room in Little Italy
- 30. Mulberry Street Bar
- 31. Caffe Venezia
1. La Bella Ferrara
Family-owned Italian bakery since 1974, using traditional recipes and techniques.

La Bella Ferrara offers a remarkable bread pudding that has won the praise of many, including myself. The texture of the pudding is excellent, with just the right amount of moistness that allows it to melt in your mouth. The flavor is also a standout feature, making it one of the best bread puddings I have ever tasted.
If you're looking for a dessert that combines texture and taste in one delicious package, La Bella Ferrara's bread pudding is a top-notch choice. Its moist and flavorful personality is sure to leave a lasting impression on anyone lucky enough to try it. I highly recommend giving it a taste for yourself.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
2. Ferrara Bakery & Cafe
Historic bakery established in 1892, serving traditional Italian pastries and desserts.

Ferrara Bakery's bread pudding is a standout dessert. Its texture is excellent, with a satisfying consistency that is not too heavy or overwhelming. The sweetness level is just right, providing a delicious taste without being overly saccharine.
If you find yourself in Little Italy, the bread pudding at Ferrara Bakery is a must-try dish. This divine dessert is sure to satisfy anyone's sweet tooth, offering a perfect balance of texture and flavor. Whether you're a local or a tourist, this bread pudding is not to be missed.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Gluten-Free
3. Caffé Palermo
Small, family-owned business with a cozy atmosphere

Caffé Palermo offers a delicious bread pudding that is widely regarded as one of the best. The texture of the pudding is perfect, with a creamy and rich consistency that melts in your mouth. It is packed with flavor, making it a delightful treat for anyone with a sweet tooth.
In particular, the bread pudding at Caffé Palermo has an excellent balance of sweetness that enhances its appeal. This dessert is a must-try for anyone visiting the café, as its indulgent and decadent taste is sure to leave a lasting impression. The bread pudding is the perfect way to satisfy your cravings and treat yourself to something special.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Celebrations
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
Relate link
4. Buona Notte
Authentic Italian cuisine in a cozy and romantic atmosphere

The bread pudding served was truly delicious. Its moist and flavorful texture made it the standout dish of the meal. The dessert had the perfect balance of moistness and taste, making it a must-try for anyone looking for a satisfying dessert.
If you're looking for a dessert recommendation, the bread pudding is highly recommended. Its delightful taste and satisfying texture make it a perfect way to end a meal. The bread pudding was the highlight of the meal, leaving a memorable and enjoyable experience for the dessert lover.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
5. Zia Maria Little Italy
Family-owned and operated for over 20 years, using recipes passed down through generations.

The bread pudding offered at this location is a highly recommended dessert. Its warmth, rich flavors, and balanced sweetness make it a standout. The combination of ingredients comes together to create a delicious and satisfying experience for anyone lucky enough to try it.
Finishing a meal on a high note, the bread pudding is a perfect choice. It is the ideal combination of a comforting and indulgent treat. With its excellent blend of flavors and textures, it is no surprise that this bread pudding is a popular menu item among diners.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
6. L’Amore Restaurant
This cozy, romantic restaurant is located in the heart of Little Italy and has a warm, welcoming atmosphere.

The bread pudding was a delightful dessert to cap off an excellent meal. Its taste and texture were incredibly satisfying, making it a standout among other dessert options.
Anyone looking for a delicious dessert should consider ordering the bread pudding. It is widely regarded as one of the best available, with a reputation that precedes it. The dessert's quality is consistently high, making it a reliable choice for those seeking a satisfying end to their meal.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
7. La Mela
Family-owned Italian restaurant in the heart of Little Italy

La Mela's bread pudding is a highly recommended dessert that provides a perfect ending to a satisfying Italian meal. This delicious dish offers a delightful combination of flavors and textures that is sure to impress.
Made from high-quality ingredients, the bread pudding features a rich and creamy custard base, accented by the sweetness of caramelized sugar and the warmth of cinnamon. The bread used in the pudding is soft and flavorful, adding a wonderful texture to each bite. Overall, La Mela's bread pudding is a standout dessert that should not be missed.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Downtown Spots
8. Paesano
Made fresh daily with high-quality ingredients, creating an unforgettable dessert experience.

The bread pudding offered at this establishment is truly remarkable. Its delightful taste and satisfying texture make it the perfect choice to conclude a meal.
Recently, we had the opportunity to try their bread pudding dessert and can attest to its excellence. Its exceptional flavor and consistency make it a standout option.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
9. Caffe Napoli
Family-owned for over 30 years with a cozy, intimate atmosphere.

The bread pudding served for dessert was an outstanding component of the meal. It stood out as the highlight, excelling in richness and deliciousness.
Remarkably, the bread pudding on offer is exceptional and highly recommended. It can be considered the best choice for a dessert lover who seeks a delectable treat, being one of the finest examples encountered in recent times.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
10. Da Gennaro
Family-owned Italian restaurant with a cozy atmosphere and friendly service

Da Gennaro's bread pudding is truly exceptional and deserves all the praise it receives. It stands out as one of the best bread puddings I have ever tasted. The dessert is an absolute must-try for anyone visiting the establishment.
The bread pudding at Da Gennaro has a heavenly taste that cannot be easily forgotten. Its delectable flavor and rich texture make it a standout dessert. Food enthusiasts should not miss the opportunity to indulge in this exquisite dish during their visit to Da Gennaro.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Dinner
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
11. Benito One
Family-owned Italian restaurant serving homemade pastas and desserts since 1968.

Benito One offers a bread pudding that is truly delicious. Warm, bursting with flavor, and possessing the perfect level of sweetness, it is a standout dessert. Food enthusiasts looking for a satisfying conclusion to an excellent meal should not pass up the opportunity to try this bread pudding.
Impressive in both taste and texture, Benito One's bread pudding is a definite crowd-pleaser. With its comforting warmth and indulgent sweetness, it serves as the perfect finale to a memorable dining experience. Diners seeking a dessert that is both scrumptious and delightful will be more than satisfied with Benito One's bread pudding.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
12. Gelso & Grand
Indoor and outdoor dining with a rustic-chic atmosphere and extensive wine list.

Magnolia Bakery's bread pudding is a standout dessert, offering indulgent flavors and a satisfying texture. The delightful combination of cinnamon and vanilla creates a comforting and warm taste, while the moist interior and crispy exterior provide a pleasant contrast.
This bread pudding is a must-try for anyone visiting Magnolia Bakery. The ideal level of moistness, crowned with a golden-brown crust, makes each portion irresistible. Furthermore, the caramel sauce drizzle adds an extra layer of decadence, elevating the dish to new heights of deliciousness.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
13. Casa Bella
Unique brick-oven pizza, cozy ambiance, and friendly service

Casa Bella is renowned for its delicious bread pudding. It is one of the standout items on their menu, known to satisfy even the most discerning of sweet tooths. The bread pudding is made to perfection, with a consistently moist and flavorful texture that leaves a lasting impression.
If you are a fan of bread pudding, Casa Bella is the place to go. Their version of this classic dessert is one of the best, boasting a delightful combination of moist and flavorful ingredients. You won't be disappointed by the quality and taste of their bread pudding, which is sure to leave you craving more.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
Relate link
14. Taiyaki NYC Japanese Ice Cream
Serving unique fish-shaped waffles with various filling options and ice cream flavors.

In New York City, there is a wide variety of bread pudding offerings, with 12 being carefully reviewed to determine the best. This guide ensures a satisfying experience, whether you prefer traditional flavors or innovative twists.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Breakfast
- Downtown Spots
15. Da Nico
Family-owned restaurant serving classic Italian dishes since 1998

The bread pudding served as dessert was a delightful end to the meal. Its delectable taste made it the perfect choice for those seeking a sweet finish to their dining experience.
Anyone who has the opportunity to try the bread pudding is highly encouraged to do so. The heavenly taste of this dessert makes it a standout choice, and will not disappoint those who decide to indulge.
TOPICS
- Holiday Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Dinner
16. Umbertos Clam House
Established in 1972, a classic Italian-American restaurant serving seafood and pasta in a lively atmosphere.

The bread pudding was a fantastic way to end the meal. Known for its rich and delicious taste, the dessert did not disappoint. It is a must-try for anyone visiting this establishment.
Although there were no high expectations for the bread pudding, it turned out to be phenomenal. The dessert was a standout dish, offering a unique and delightful end to the dining experience. It is highly recommended for all visitors.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
17. Grotta Azzurra Restaurant
Family-owned for over 30 years, Kosher-certified Italian cuisine

The bread pudding served as dessert is a must-try for anyone looking to wrap up a satisfying meal. It is widely regarded as one of the standout dishes at the establishment.
For fans of bread pudding, this version is not to be missed. It is frequently cited as one of the best examples of the dish in all of New York City.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Celebrations
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
18. La Bella Vita restaurant
Unique Italian dishes, cozy ambiance, excellent service, extensive wine list.

The meal concluded with a serving of bread pudding, which proved to be a love-hate situation for the diners. On one hand, it provided a satisfying sweet end to the meal. However, there were mixed feelings about the bread pudding's texture, with some finding it too dry to fully enjoy.
The dessert course featured bread pudding, which generated differing opinions among the group. While some praised it as an ideal sweet finale, others were not as thrilled. The main criticism was its dryness, which negatively impacted the overall experience of the bread pudding.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
19. Casa D'angelo - Nyc
Family-owned Italian restaurant serving classic dishes since 1991.

For those with a sweet tooth, the bread pudding at Casa D'Angelo is a standout choice. Its delicious taste and satisfying texture make it the perfect ending to an exceptional meal. Many satisfied customers recommend trying this dessert when visiting the restaurant.
Casa D'Angelo's bread pudding has been lauded for its divine flavor and consistency. This dessert is a must-try for anyone looking to indulge in a delectable treat. Its reputation for excellence precedes it, making it a popular choice among visitors to the establishment.
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
20. La Nonna in Little Italy
Authentic Italian cuisine, casual and cozy atmosphere, friendly service.

The bread pudding served at the restaurant is a must-try dessert. Its delicious taste and wonderful flavor make it stand out. It is highly recommended for anyone looking to end their meal on a sweet note.
La Nonna's bread pudding is a popular choice among diners for its divine flavor. This dessert is the perfect way to wrap up a satisfying meal. Its rave reviews are a testament to its exceptional taste and quality.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Celebrations
Relate link
21. IL Cortile in Little Italy
Family-owned Italian restaurant serving classic dishes since 1975

The bread pudding at IL Cortile is widely regarded as exceptional. Its moist and flavorful consistency makes it a standout dessert option. The perfect end to an excellent meal, this bread pudding is a must-try for any diner.
IL Cortile's bread pudding is renowned for its delicious taste and texture. It boasts a perfectly moist and full-flavored composition, making it a satisfying and memorable dessert choice. Diners who enjoy a fantastic meal at IL Cortile should definitely consider ending their dining experience on a high note with this exceptional bread pudding.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
- Mid-Range
22. Puglia
Warm and inviting atmosphere with a focus on Southern Italian cuisine

The bread pudding I tasted as my dessert was a true culinary delight. Its generous portion size was impressive, and it offered a delightful balance of flavors. This dessert is a must-try at Puglia, where it is prepared richly and with great flavor. It provides a satisfying and comforting end to any meal.
In summary, the bread pudding at this establishment is a standout. Its large portion size and perfect balance of flavors make it an exceptional dessert choice. Diners looking for a comforting and indulgent treat should not miss out on trying this delicious bread pudding at Puglia.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Celebrations
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
23. Caffe Roma in Little Italy
Family-owned Italian cafe with a charming patio

Caffe Roma serves a remarkable bread pudding that stands out for its texture and flavor. The consistency is just right, providing a pleasant experience with each bite. This dessert offers a great balance of sweetness that enhances its taste, making it a must-try for anyone visiting Caffe Roma.
Remarkable richness, moistness, and a well-measured degree of sweetness characterize the bread pudding at Caffe Roma. This decadent dessert is sure to captivate the senses and cater to those who appreciate a delightful blend of flavors. Food enthusiasts seeking a satisfying and delicious treat should consider indulging in this exceptional bread pudding.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Breakfast
- Social Gatherings
24. Sofia's of Little Italy
Family-owned restaurant serving Italian cuisine since 1988 with a warm and cozy atmosphere.

The bread pudding I had was truly delicious and an excellent way to end a satisfying meal. The dessert had a perfect balance of moistness and flavor that made it stand out.
At Sofia's, the bread pudding is a highly recommended dish. Its mouthwatering taste and delightful texture make it a must-try for anyone who visits the restaurant. The pudding's exceptional moistness and rich flavor make it a memorable dessert.
TOPICS
- Holiday Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Affordable Nightlife
- Downtown Spots
25. Original Vincent's
Family-owned Italian restaurant since 1904, known for homestyle cooking

Original Vincent's restaurant offers a delicious bread pudding that is sure to delight. This dessert is an excellent way to cap off a satisfying Italian meal. It is a hidden gem on the restaurant's menu that is worth trying.
The bread pudding at Original Vincent's is truly divine. It is a must-try for anyone looking for a delicious dessert. Its inclusion in the dessert menu is a welcome surprise that will not disappoint. This dessert is a great example of why Original Vincent's is a standout restaurant.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
26. Lunella in Little Italy
Small family-owned bakery with a cozy atmosphere and a wide selection of baked goods.

The bread pudding was a standout dessert, with a perfectly moist and flavorful texture that made it a must-try. It was the perfect way to end the meal, providing a satisfying and delicious experience.
The bread pudding was an impressive and tasty dessert, boasting a spot-on texture and taste. It was a delightful way to wrap up the meal, leaving a lasting impression of satisfaction and enjoyment.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
- Affordable Nightlife
27. Il Piccolo Bufalo
Family-owned Italian restaurant in the heart of Little Italy, New York

The bread pudding at this establishment is truly exceptional. It is widely considered to be one of the best examples of this dessert in all of NYC. The rich and decadent dish is a favorite among patrons, and it's not hard to see why. The bread pudding is expertly prepared, with a soft and moist interior and a crispy, caramelized exterior. It is the perfect way to cap off a satisfying meal.
The dessert selection is a standout feature of the restaurant, and the bread pudding is the star of the show. The dish is a perfect balance of flavors and textures, and it is sure to leave a lasting impression. Whether you're a bread pudding aficionado or just looking to try something new, this dessert is not to be missed. It is a true culinary delight that is sure to satisfy even the most discerning of palates.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
28. Spongies Cafe
Family-owned business with a cozy atmosphere

Spongies Cafe in NYC offers a standout bread pudding. This dessert is a top choice for those seeking a delicious and satisfying treat. The bread pudding's appeal is due to its moist and flavorful qualities, accompanied by a well-balanced sweetness that is truly delightful.
Diners looking for a must-try dessert option should indulge in Spongies Cafe's bread pudding. Its appealing moistness, rich flavors, and balanced sweetness make it a perfect choice. It is highly recommended for visitors and locals alike.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
29. Bambina Blue Gelato Wonder Room in Little Italy
Unique and artistic gelato flavors, popular local spot, cozy and intimate atmosphere

The bread pudding gelato offered at this establishment is truly a delight. Its beautiful balance of sweetness and texture makes it a standout among other dessert options. The gelato manages to capture the classic taste and comfort of bread pudding, while still offering a refreshing and unique twist.
If you find yourself at Bambina Blue, do not miss out on the opportunity to try their bread pudding gelato. This innovative dessert takes the traditional flavors of bread pudding and transforms them into a delicious and creamy gelato. The combination of a familiar favorite in a new form is sure to impress any dessert lover.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Celebrations
- Downtown Spots
30. Mulberry Street Bar
Cozy dive bar atmosphere with a friendly and welcoming staff

The bread pudding at this location is truly exceptional. Its moist and delicious texture, coupled with its rich flavor, make it a standout dessert. Whether you're a bread pudding aficionado or just looking to try something new, this is a must-try treat.
Visitors to this location rave about the bread pudding dessert. Its mouthwatering taste and indulgent texture make it a highly recommended choice. If you're in the mood for something sweet and decadent, you can't go wrong with the bread pudding.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
31. Caffe Venezia
Family-owned and operated since 1972, offering a cozy and welcoming atmosphere with excellent service.

Caffe Venezia offers a delicious bread pudding that has a wonderful texture, being neither too dry nor too wet. The level of sweetness is also just right, making it a perfect dessert to satisfy your sweet tooth without being overly indulgent.
If you're looking for a dessert that's sure to impress, Caffe Venezia's bread pudding is an excellent choice. It has a rich and flavorful taste that makes it a standout option, and its satisfying texture makes it a popular choice among diners. Whether you're looking for a sweet treat to enjoy after a meal or simply want to indulge your sweet tooth, this bread pudding is sure to hit the spot.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Dinner
- Social Gatherings
- Mid-Range