Best of 8 banana puddings in Park Slope NYC
Banana puddings in Park Slope, NYC, are a popular dessert delight among locals and tourists alike. These puddings, a classic American dessert, are made with bananas, custard or pudding, and vanilla wafers, creating a perfect balance of flavors and textures. Indulge in the cozy and inviting atmosphere of Park Slope while enjoying this delectable treat. From traditional to innovative twists, banana puddings in Park Slope, NYC, are not to be missed.
1. Buttermilk Bakeshop
Homemade goodness in every bite

Buttermilk Bakeshop's Banana Pudding is a must-try for anyone with a sweet tooth. The dessert boasts a velvety smooth texture that is both rich and luxurious, while the level of sweetness is expertly balanced, resulting in a delightful treat that is not too sweet or cloying.
The banana flavor is the star of the show, shining through in every bite. Fresh banana pieces are neatly tucked away within the creamy concoction, adding bursts of bright, natural flavor. The pudding's smooth consistency is complemented by the slight crunch of Nilla wafer cookies, adding a satisfying textural contrast. Overall, the Banana Pudding at Buttermilk Bakeshop is a standout dessert that is sure to impress.
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
2. Goodiez in Park Slope

I must confess, I'm not particularly fond of ice cream, but let me introduce you to Uncle Louie G - an exceptional exception to my ice cream preferences. Their homemade ice cream lives up to its name, delivering a truly artisanal experience. To my delight, their banana, coconut, and maple nut flavors reign supreme, each spoonful offering a delightful explosion of taste and texture. However, I feel it is only fair to issue a word of caution - once you try Uncle Louie G's irresistible creations, you may find yourself forever loyal.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Budget-Friendly Eats
Relate link
3. Pinkberry
One of a kind taste that is truly crave-able

Pinkberry's sweet and unusual texture may not appeal to everyone, but this particular location still manages to impress. The quality of their yogurt stands out, setting them apart from other similar establishments.
The employees at this Pinkberry location are hardworking and dedicated, even when the shop is crowded and busy. Their commitment to customer service ensures a positive experience, making it easy to overlook any textural concerns with the yogurt. Overall, this location is definitely worth a visit.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
4. Häagen-Dazs
Gourmet ice-cream flavors and frozen desserts.

Ice cream aficionados will be delighted with the offerings at this establishment. The banana split, in particular, stands out as a must-try option. It features a generous helping of creamy ice cream, sliced bananas, and a variety of toppings that create a delightful combination of flavors and textures. The ice cream is made from high-quality ingredients, resulting in rich and satisfying tastes.
Furthermore, the service is consistently friendly and welcoming. Customers can enjoy customizing their shakes and take advantage of the hand-packed ice cream for a unique treat. Whether you are looking for a classic flavor or something more adventurous, this ice cream shop has something to offer. The banana split is an excellent choice for anyone seeking a decadent and satisfying dessert experience. Overall, the delicious ice cream and exceptional service make this a must-visit destination for ice cream lovers.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
Relate link
5. SkyIce Thai Food & Ice Cream
Combining authentic Thai cuisine with unique homemade ice cream.

A long-awaited addition to the neighborhood, SkyIce Sweet and Savory has not disappointed. The ice cream selection is delicious, with standout flavors like thai tea and salted caramel. The owner, Sutira, is incredibly welcoming and takes care to ensure each customer is satisfied. For those on a keto diet, don't worry - the staff at SkyIce are happy to accommodate and suggest alternatives, like fresh papaya as a substitute for noodles in the Khao Soi dish.
A recent visit to SkyIce Sweet and Savory proved to be a delightful experience. The Thai restaurant, located conveniently close to home, offers a cozy atmosphere with a knowledgeable and kind staff. Despite being on a keto diet, the server and owner were concerned with ensuring there was enough substance in the Khao Soi dish and offered fresh papaya as a noodle substitute. The northern Thai soup was rich and creamy, with the perfect amount of spice. To finish off the meal, a heavenly scoop of Thai coffee ice cream with raspberry sorbet was the cherry on top. It's clear that SkyIce takes great pride in their food and service.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
6. Malai
Unique global flavors with unexpected twists

Malai, a renowned ice cream establishment, delights customers with its imaginative and bold flavors. The company's ice cream is widely recognized for its velvety texture and wholesome taste, featuring options that are hard to find elsewhere. Among the favorites are pistachio cardamom, sea salt caramel, and sweet milks, each crafted with care and attention to detail.
In a similar vein, Nathan Harris's article showcases the ultimate banana pudding in Brooklyn, which has garnered significant praise from food enthusiasts. After thorough testing of twelve different banana pudding varieties across the borough, Harris determined the finest option is worth highlighting. This carefully curated and regularly updated selection is sure to satisfy anyone seeking the ultimate banana pudding experience in Brooklyn.
TOPICS
- Indian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
7. Miss American Pie
A delightful spot for comforting desserts and pies

The pies offered are truly a standout feature of this establishment. The signature pie, in particular, is a must-try for any fruit pie enthusiast. It boasts a delightful combination of various fruits, each bursting with flavor and perfectly balanced within a flaky, buttery crust. This dish is an excellent representation of the bakery's commitment to using high-quality ingredients and traditional baking techniques.
The staff at this establishment further elevates the experience, consistently displaying warmth and a genuine interest in customer satisfaction. They are attentive without being intrusive, striking a perfect balance in ensuring that customers feel welcome and comfortable. This attention to detail extends beyond the kitchen, with the staff's knowledge of the bakery's offerings reflecting the same dedication to quality that can be found in their pies. Overall, this bakery is an ideal destination for those with a sweet tooth seeking both delicious treats and top-notch service.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
8. Think Ice Cream in Park Slope

TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegan Options
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots