Top 10 pizza places in Borough Park NYC
Borough Park, a vibrant neighborhood in NYC, is home to a diverse range of pizza places. These establishments offer a variety of pizzas, from classic New York-style slices to authentic Neapolitan pies. Whether you're a local or a visitor, exploring pizza places in Borough Park NYC is a must-do for any pizza lover. Each place has its unique style and flavor, making for a delicious and exciting experience.
1. Mendelsohn's Pizza
Experience pizza perfection since 1969.

The culinary offerings at this establishment are quite impressive, with a diverse menu that offers something for everyone. The ingredients are always fresh, and the presentation is both visually appealing and appetizing. One standout dish is the onion and mushroom slice, which is bursting with flavor and sure to satisfy.
In addition to the high-quality food, this restaurant has implemented a new computerized ordering system that makes the dining experience even more seamless and enjoyable. The system is user-friendly and efficient, allowing customers to easily customize their orders and receive their food in a timely manner. Overall, the combination of delicious food and innovative technology make this restaurant a must-visit for anyone in the area.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Cheap Eats
2. Jentana's in Borough Park
Best pizza in Brooklyn with a friendly vibe

This establishment has been a long-standing favorite, with the reviewer frequently visiting since childhood. The food is consistently delicious, with the chicken parm and grilled chicken gyro being particularly recommended. The restaurant prides itself on using fresh ingredients and preparing each order promptly, ensuring a satisfying meal every time.
Jentana's Pizzeria & Restaurant offers what is arguably the best pizza in Brooklyn. The customer service is exceptional, making diners feel welcome and at home. If you find yourself in the area and in search of a high-quality pizza slice, Jentana's is the place to go. Its cozy atmosphere and delicious food make it a standout among other pizza joints in the area.
TOPICS
- Chinese Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
3. Amnon's Kosher Pizza
Best kosher pizza in Brooklyn, hands down!

The pizza offered at this establishment is quite delicious and affordably priced, making it an excellent choice for those on a budget. The staff is commendable for their friendliness and attentiveness to customers, providing a welcoming atmosphere. This restaurant is especially suitable for large families or groups looking for a satisfying and cost-effective meal.
The quality of the food served here is top-notch, with generous portions and a variety of options to suit different tastes. The speed of the service is impressive, allowing for a quick and efficient dining experience. Overall, the positive aspects of this restaurant make it a place worth revisiting, and potential patrons can expect great food and great prices.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Kosher Options
- Mid-Range
4. Yanky's Pizza
Old school Kosher pizza in Boro Park

This pizza shop offers excellent food, encouraging repeat visits. The service is efficient and the establishment is consistently clean, which adds to its appeal. The menu boasts an extensive range of options, including garlic knots, vegetable pizza, soup, and more.
The pizza stands out for its delicious taste, with a wide variety of toppings and combinations available. The crust is crispy and not overly greasy, making each bite satisfying. The team provides fantastic service, with our waitress being particularly attentive and efficient. Furthermore, the atmosphere of the restaurant is welcoming and enjoyable, enhancing the overall dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
5. Naim Kosher Pizza
Delicious kosher pizza with old-school charm

Naim Kosher Pizza in Brooklyn is renowned for its high-quality pizza slices, offering consistent excellence in taste and freshness. The establishment's old-school charm and affordability only add to its appeal. The owner goes out of his way to make sure every customer feels welcome and satisfied, creating a friendly and inviting atmosphere.
In addition to their delicious pizza, Naim Kosher Pizza also offers highly praised calzones and pita, which are made with fresh and flavorful ingredients. The garlic knots are a popular choice, earning a reputation as a must-try item. With a 4.6 Star Rating from 159 reviewers, it's clear that Naim Kosher Pizza is a top choice among pizza lovers in Brooklyn.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Kosher Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
6. Di Fara Pizza
Handcrafted pizzas with imported Italian ingredients

Pizza at DiFara's features a slight burnt taste and an exceptional crust. The crust is generously coated with olive oil, causing it to fry in the oven, resulting in a unique flavor and texture. Despite the long wait times, the quality of the pizza makes it worth the effort.
For those in search of New York's finest pizza, DiFara's is an absolute must-visit. Although located in Brooklyn, the trip to Avenue J is well worth it. While in the area, consider stopping by one of the many bakeries to pick up some challah. DiFara's is famous for its fresh pizza, with every ingredient, from the mozzarella to the herbs and sauteed artichokes, prepared to order. The tomato sauce tastes remarkably like fresh tomatoes, and the thin and chewy crusts are simply amazing. Despite the unremarkable atmosphere, DiFara's is a family-run establishment with a great deal of pride and history behind it.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- High-End
- Hidden Gems
7. Dominick's Pizza in Borough Park
Serving Brooklyn for over 25 years with passion.

It is regrettable that the delivery of the ordered item did not arrive at the expected time. Despite attempts to contact the service provider through the phone, there was no answer. This lack of communication and poor time management is certainly disappointing.
In terms of the product itself, the pizza has received mixed reviews. Some have praised its taste, noting that it is delicious and satisfying. However, others have mentioned that there is room for improvement in terms of preparation time. It appears that there have been instances where customers have found the wait time to be excessively long. This inconsistency in service may impact overall customer satisfaction.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
Relate link
8. Dagan
Delicious pizzas with a cozy, family-friendly vibe.

The Sicilian "Square" Pie at Dagan is a standout dish that should not be missed. This pizza features a thick and flavorful crust, made even more delicious with the use of fresh mozzarella and the restaurant's signature pizza sauce. The combination of these high-quality ingredients results in a pie that is both visually appealing and incredibly satisfying to taste.
Dagan has received rave reviews from numerous satisfied customers, with a 4.5-star rating based on over 200 reviews. The pizza at this establishment is consistently praised for its exceptional quality and delicious flavor. Whether you're a pizza connoisseur or simply looking for a tasty and satisfying meal, the Sicilian "Square" Pie at Dagan is sure to impress.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Gluten-Free
9. Table 40
Your go-to Breakfast, Coffee, Lunch & Pizza spot!

Table 40 serves up an exceptional dining experience, with catering and in-restaurant options available. The food is beautifully presented, bursting with flavorful combinations that appeal to a diverse range of tastes. The pizza store within Table 40 also proves to be impressive, with its crispy crusts and generous use of fresh toppings. The restaurant's staff are known for being approachable and attentive, ensuring a high level of service quality. Any food enthusiast looking for delicious dishes and excellent service will find Table 40 to be an outstanding choice.
The reviewer could not praise the food and service enough, and plans to visit the establishment again. Table 40's commitment to quality is evident in the impeccable food and hospitality they provide, leaving a lasting impression on diners. With a strong reputation for delivering delightful culinary experiences, Table 40 has earned its place as a go-to spot for those who appreciate great food and impeccable service.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
10. Crust co. Pizza

TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats