Top 9 pizza places in Brownsville NYC
Pizza places in Brownsville, NYC offer a wide variety of delicious pies for every palate. From classic cheese and pepperoni to unique specialty slices, these local pizzerias are a must-visit for any pizza lover. With a rich history and diverse community, Brownsville's pizza scene is as vibrant as the neighborhood itself. Come and taste the best pizza places in Brownsville, NYC!
1. Sal & Paul's Pizzeria
Family-owned with a secret pizza recipe.

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria has gained a reputation for serving delicious pizza that is consistently enjoyed by its customers. The pizzeria offers a range of options, including vegetarian choices, ensuring that there is something for everyone. Even kids are known to enjoy the tasty meals offered at this establishment.
One particular standout item on the menu is the plain cheese slice. Despite the reviewer's usual preference for pizza toppings such as spinach or mushrooms, the cheese slice from Sal & Paul's never fails to impress. The quality of the ingredients and the care taken in the preparation of the pizza create a truly satisfying experience for pizza lovers.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Suburban
2. BK PIZZA
Delicious pizzas at unbeatable prices!

This pizza establishment is highly recommended, particularly for those who appreciate a good stuffed crust or margarita pizza. The pricing is very reasonable, making it an excellent choice for a family night out.
The pizza here is made with care and attention, resulting in a delicious taste that is truly satisfying. Don't miss out on the wings and breadsticks, which are also made with the same love and dedication to quality as the pizzas. This place has quickly become a new favorite for families and pizza lovers alike.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
3. BK Pizza
Hand-crafted fresh to order. Served with love.

Pizza of a reliable mid-range quality is consistently delivered, making it a popular choice for many. The crust is one of the standout features, with a perfect texture that adds to the overall enjoyment of each slice.
Many reviewers have praised the pizza for its high-quality ingredients, exquisite taste, and impressive texture. The food arrives in excellent condition, and the crust is a particular highlight, with its consistently pleasant texture that enhances the overall dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
4. Pizza Hut
You can't OutPizza the Hut.

Pizza deliveries to customers have resulted in disappointment on various occasions due to inaccurate toppings and unsatisfactory temperature. The phone ordering process has also caused confusion for some individuals.
The quality of the food is mostly commendable, although a few reviewers have noted problems with pizzas that were not warm enough or topped improperly. It is clear that there have been instances of suboptimal service in both the preparation and delivery of this pizza.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
5. Tony's Pizza in Brownsville
Brooklyn's finest pizza since 1980

The local pizza shop has been a beloved establishment since childhood. Its quality and service have only improved over the years.
Tony, the owner, and his team are exceptional. They have a reputation for kindness and hard work, ensuring the food is always fresh and the pizza meets the high standards of Brooklyn. The shop has been a source of support and community, with Tony even providing a job during a tough time. The pizza is a testament to the shop's commitment to excellence, making it a beloved institution in the neighborhood.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Happy Hours
- Vegetarian Options
- Social Gatherings
6. Domino's Pizza
Contactless delivery for safety and convenience.

The pizza delivery service was commendable. Upon arrival, the delivery person notified the customer as promised, showing excellent courtesy and professionalism. This level of communication is appreciated, as it allows customers to be prepared for the delivery and ensure prompt service.
As for the pizza itself, Domino's once again delivered on its reputation for quality and speed. The pizza arrived hot and fresh, with a delicious taste that certainly satisfied the customer's cravings. Overall, Domino's continues to impress with its reliable and tasty pizza delivery service.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Late Night
7. Papa Johns Pizza in Brownsville
Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.

The restaurant offers a variety of delicious food items, with the cheesy burger pizza standing out as a must-try. Customers can expect their orders to be accurate and delivered on time. The pizza, in particular, features a perfect blend of cheese and burger toppings, making for a satisfying and flavorful meal.
Upon visiting the establishment, one is greeted with a clean and organized space. The staff can be seen regularly attending to customers and ensuring the timely delivery of orders. However, there was a slight delay in the pick-up of an order, despite the online tracking indicating that it was ready. Despite this hiccup, the staff remained respectful and the order was ultimately fulfilled correctly.
TOPICS
- Holiday Celebrations
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
8. US Fried Chicken & Pizza
Delicious pizza and fried chicken under one roof!

The pizza from US Fried Chicken & Pizza is truly a delight. Fresh ingredients are evident in every bite, and the cooking is consistently top-notch. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or just looking for a quick and tasty meal, this pizza is sure to satisfy. Ordering again is a no-brainer.
Initially, there may have been some hesitation, but after tasting the pizza from US Fried Chicken & Pizza, any doubts are quickly erased. The flavors are exceptional, and the pizza serves as a great option for those in search of a quick yet satisfying meal. With such high-quality offerings, it's not surprising that customers find themselves coming back for more.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Lunch
- Dinner
9. Domino's Pizza
Fresh hot pizza delivered quickly.

The staff at this establishment are consistently polite and hardworking, as evidenced by their attentiveness behind the counter. On this particular occasion, I ordered two vegetarian pizzas, one topped with green peppers and mushrooms, and the other with pineapple and black olives. Over the years, I've found their pizzas to be quite satisfactory. I eagerly awaited the delivery, anticipating hot and delicious pizzas.
Upon delivery, the food was indeed fresh and hot. The pizzas were carefully prepared according to my specifications, and the delivery person was both friendly and professional. The experience was a positive one, as I've come to expect from this establishment. From the quick delivery to the high-quality food, this restaurant never fails to impress.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link