Top 10 pizza places in Carroll Gardens NYC
Pizza places in Carroll Gardens, NYC, are a popular destination for both locals and tourists. These pizzerias offer a variety of styles, from classic New York slices to Neapolitan-style pies. With a rich Italian heritage, Carroll Gardens is home to some of the best pizza in Brooklyn. Whether you're looking for a quick slice or a sit-down meal, these pizza places are sure to satisfy your cravings.
Toc
1. Smith Street Pizza
Authentic New York-style pizza with a cozy atmosphere.
__NEW TEXT__
The dining experience at this establishment is truly exceptional. The traditional cheese pizza, in particular, is a standout dish that should not be missed. It boasts a perfectly cooked crust, generous amounts of cheese, and a rich, tangy sauce that blend together to create a delightful flavor profile.
The dining experience at this establishment is truly exceptional. The traditional cheese pizza, in particular, is a standout dish that should not be missed. It boasts a perfectly cooked crust, generous amounts of cheese, and a rich, tangy sauce that blend together to create a delightful flavor profile.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
2. Giardini Pizza
Unusually thin-crusted Sicilian pies and slices.
__NEW TEXT__
Located in the neighborhood for an extended period, the pizza place on Smith Street has established a reputation for serving excellent pizza. Known for its hearty toppings and consistent quality, the restaurant has become a popular spot among locals and visitors alike.
The staff at the pizza place is commended for their helpful and speedy service. This level of customer service has made the restaurant a go-to spot for those seeking a quick and satisfying meal. Additionally, the restaurant's rich history and vintage photos of the area before the elevated tracks were constructed add to its unique charm.
Located in the neighborhood for an extended period, the pizza place on Smith Street has established a reputation for serving excellent pizza. Known for its hearty toppings and consistent quality, the restaurant has become a popular spot among locals and visitors alike.
The staff at the pizza place is commended for their helpful and speedy service. This level of customer service has made the restaurant a go-to spot for those seeking a quick and satisfying meal. Additionally, the restaurant's rich history and vintage photos of the area before the elevated tracks were constructed add to its unique charm.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
3. Via Roma Pizza Bar
Fresh, delicious pizza with a friendly atmosphere.
__NEW TEXT__
A popular choice at this establishment is the margarita pizza, known for its fresh and delicious ingredients. The pizza features a perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings, all coming together to create a harmonious and satisfying flavor profile. The crust is cooked to perfection, offering a satisfying crunch with each bite.
In addition to the delicious taste, the margarita pizza is also reasonably priced. It's a great value for the high-quality ingredients and care that goes into each pizza. Whether enjoying a night out with friends or looking for a satisfying meal at a reasonable price, the margarita pizza is a reliable and enjoyable choice. The restaurant's attention to detail is evident in every slice, making it a standout option for pizza lovers.
A popular choice at this establishment is the margarita pizza, known for its fresh and delicious ingredients. The pizza features a perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings, all coming together to create a harmonious and satisfying flavor profile. The crust is cooked to perfection, offering a satisfying crunch with each bite.
In addition to the delicious taste, the margarita pizza is also reasonably priced. It's a great value for the high-quality ingredients and care that goes into each pizza. Whether enjoying a night out with friends or looking for a satisfying meal at a reasonable price, the margarita pizza is a reliable and enjoyable choice. The restaurant's attention to detail is evident in every slice, making it a standout option for pizza lovers.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Budget-Friendly Eats
4. Savelli in Carroll Gardens
Authentic Italian cuisine in a cozy, family-friendly setting.
__NEW TEXT__
Upon entering the restaurant, one cannot help but notice its spaciousness and beautiful decor. The establishment offers brick oven pizza, resulting in a perfect crust that is both delicious and satisfying. The Margherita VIP pizza is a must-try, along with their calamari, which is known for being juicy and never dry.
A group of seven celebrating a birthday had a wonderful dining experience with a reservation. Every entree was prepared with precision, from the flavorful pizza and perfectly cooked salmon to the fresh salad and unique pasta special. Even the rice balls were a hit, receiving high praise for their delicious taste. The waitstaff were friendly and professional, adding to the overall positive atmosphere of the restaurant.
Upon entering the restaurant, one cannot help but notice its spaciousness and beautiful decor. The establishment offers brick oven pizza, resulting in a perfect crust that is both delicious and satisfying. The Margherita VIP pizza is a must-try, along with their calamari, which is known for being juicy and never dry.
A group of seven celebrating a birthday had a wonderful dining experience with a reservation. Every entree was prepared with precision, from the flavorful pizza and perfectly cooked salmon to the fresh salad and unique pasta special. Even the rice balls were a hit, receiving high praise for their delicious taste. The waitstaff were friendly and professional, adding to the overall positive atmosphere of the restaurant.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
5. Aromi
Classic Italian recipes in a cozy Brooklyn spot.
__NEW TEXT__
Aromi, an Italian restaurant in Cobble Hill, is popular for its exceptional food and convenient parking. The establishment specializes in authentic pizza, cooked to perfection in a real fire oven, and a range of pasta dishes. Among the standout menu items are the succulent ribeye steak and the mouthwatering finger potatoes that accompany it. The staff and owner are friendly, attentive, and dedicated to ensuring customer satisfaction.
The atmosphere inside Aromi is warm and inviting, adding to the overall positive dining experience. Guests have raved about the Lasagna Bolognese, describing it as one of the best they have ever tasted. Similarly, the soft shell crabs appetizer and Capricciosa pizza have been met with high praise. The knowledgeable waitstaff recommend excellent wine pairings to complement each meal, demonstrating their expertise and commitment to providing exceptional service. This combination of superior food, service, and decor distinguishes Aromi as a premier dining destination.
Aromi, an Italian restaurant in Cobble Hill, is popular for its exceptional food and convenient parking. The establishment specializes in authentic pizza, cooked to perfection in a real fire oven, and a range of pasta dishes. Among the standout menu items are the succulent ribeye steak and the mouthwatering finger potatoes that accompany it. The staff and owner are friendly, attentive, and dedicated to ensuring customer satisfaction.
The atmosphere inside Aromi is warm and inviting, adding to the overall positive dining experience. Guests have raved about the Lasagna Bolognese, describing it as one of the best they have ever tasted. Similarly, the soft shell crabs appetizer and Capricciosa pizza have been met with high praise. The knowledgeable waitstaff recommend excellent wine pairings to complement each meal, demonstrating their expertise and commitment to providing exceptional service. This combination of superior food, service, and decor distinguishes Aromi as a premier dining destination.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
6. Lucali in Carroll Gardens
No reservations, first come first served.
__NEW TEXT__
Lucali, a renowned restaurant known for its exceptional pizza, presents a formidable challenge when it comes to making a reservation. The Brooklyn location, in particular, is notorious for its long waiting list. However, if you're lucky enough to secure a spot, you will not be disappointed. The restaurant's atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it the perfect place to enjoy a meal with friends or family.
To increase your chances of getting in, customers are advised to arrive before 5:00 PM and add their name to the list. While waiting, you can relax in the comfortable seating area by the counter, taking in the sights and sounds of the bustling kitchen. A selection of drinks and wine is also available, providing the perfect opportunity to unwind before your meal. Chairs are situated by the counter, allowing you to observe the chefs at work as they skillfully prepare Lucali's famous pizzas.
Lucali, a renowned restaurant known for its exceptional pizza, presents a formidable challenge when it comes to making a reservation. The Brooklyn location, in particular, is notorious for its long waiting list. However, if you're lucky enough to secure a spot, you will not be disappointed. The restaurant's atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it the perfect place to enjoy a meal with friends or family.
To increase your chances of getting in, customers are advised to arrive before 5:00 PM and add their name to the list. While waiting, you can relax in the comfortable seating area by the counter, taking in the sights and sounds of the bustling kitchen. A selection of drinks and wine is also available, providing the perfect opportunity to unwind before your meal. Chairs are situated by the counter, allowing you to observe the chefs at work as they skillfully prepare Lucali's famous pizzas.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
7. Brooklyn Pizza Market
Empowering local pizzerias with tech and services.
__NEW TEXT__
A delightful new pizzeria has opened up, serving both round and square slices with delectable sauce and toppings. Freshly grated Parmesan is available to enhance the flavor. The seating inside is limited, featuring only a few stools, but the view of the street and the basil plants on the windowsill provide a cozy atmosphere. This new pizza spot is an excellent option for takeaway, especially for those looking to enjoy a slice in the Zombie Hut backyard. Their late-night hours make it an ideal destination for a post-midnight snack.
Brooklyn Pizza Market offers a delicious, if somewhat greasy, pizza experience with vegetarian options to please all. Their garlic knots are generously sized and reasonably priced, although some may lack garlic seasoning. Although the dining area is small and cash-only, customers can still enjoy their meal in-house or opt for takeout, with quick service. While some menu items may fall short of expectations, the round pies remain a popular choice over the thinner square slices. Overall, this new addition to Smith Street brings a lively pizzeria experience to the neighborhood.
A delightful new pizzeria has opened up, serving both round and square slices with delectable sauce and toppings. Freshly grated Parmesan is available to enhance the flavor. The seating inside is limited, featuring only a few stools, but the view of the street and the basil plants on the windowsill provide a cozy atmosphere. This new pizza spot is an excellent option for takeaway, especially for those looking to enjoy a slice in the Zombie Hut backyard. Their late-night hours make it an ideal destination for a post-midnight snack.
Brooklyn Pizza Market offers a delicious, if somewhat greasy, pizza experience with vegetarian options to please all. Their garlic knots are generously sized and reasonably priced, although some may lack garlic seasoning. Although the dining area is small and cash-only, customers can still enjoy their meal in-house or opt for takeout, with quick service. While some menu items may fall short of expectations, the round pies remain a popular choice over the thinner square slices. Overall, this new addition to Smith Street brings a lively pizzeria experience to the neighborhood.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Affordable Nightlife
- Downtown Spots
8. Enoteca
Brick oven pizzas with a homemade touch.
__NEW TEXT__
Enoteca, a popular restaurant located in Brooklyn, offers an exceptional dining experience with its delicious pizza and soup selections. The inviting and cozy atmosphere, which can comfortably accommodate groups, adds to its overall appeal. One standout menu item is the inventive and mouthwatering pizzas, which feature a satisfying crust that is sure to please every palate. The salads are also notable for their freshness and flavor. Additionally, the wine flights provide an excellent opportunity to explore and savor a variety of tastes.
The soups at Enoteca are another must-try, with rich and flavorful options that will warm you up on a chilly day. The restaurant's impressive wine list, featuring a wide selection of both domestic and international wines, pairs beautifully with any dish. The knowledgeable and attentive staff are always on hand to provide recommendations and ensure an enjoyable dining experience. Overall, Enoteca is a fantastic destination for anyone seeking delicious food, an extensive wine selection, and a warm and welcoming atmosphere.
Enoteca, a popular restaurant located in Brooklyn, offers an exceptional dining experience with its delicious pizza and soup selections. The inviting and cozy atmosphere, which can comfortably accommodate groups, adds to its overall appeal. One standout menu item is the inventive and mouthwatering pizzas, which feature a satisfying crust that is sure to please every palate. The salads are also notable for their freshness and flavor. Additionally, the wine flights provide an excellent opportunity to explore and savor a variety of tastes.
The soups at Enoteca are another must-try, with rich and flavorful options that will warm you up on a chilly day. The restaurant's impressive wine list, featuring a wide selection of both domestic and international wines, pairs beautifully with any dish. The knowledgeable and attentive staff are always on hand to provide recommendations and ensure an enjoyable dining experience. Overall, Enoteca is a fantastic destination for anyone seeking delicious food, an extensive wine selection, and a warm and welcoming atmosphere.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
9. F&F Pizzeria
Classic New York slice with top-notch ingredients.
__NEW TEXT__
The pizza establishment in question generates significant buzz, and its Sicilian slice does live up to the high expectations set. However, there is room for improvement in the regular slice, which can be inconsistent in quality. This inconsistency, coupled with the high cost of the pizzas, is what keeps the establishment from receiving a perfect score.
On a positive note, the establishment's thin-crust pizza is truly remarkable. While it may be most famous for its Sicilian style, the thinner slices are where this establishment truly shines. Additionally, the service is commendable, with staff members who remain friendly and accommodating even in the face of high pressure and customer volume.
The pizza establishment in question generates significant buzz, and its Sicilian slice does live up to the high expectations set. However, there is room for improvement in the regular slice, which can be inconsistent in quality. This inconsistency, coupled with the high cost of the pizzas, is what keeps the establishment from receiving a perfect score.
On a positive note, the establishment's thin-crust pizza is truly remarkable. While it may be most famous for its Sicilian style, the thinner slices are where this establishment truly shines. Additionally, the service is commendable, with staff members who remain friendly and accommodating even in the face of high pressure and customer volume.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
10. Baby Luc's
Perfecting pizza for 16 years at Lucali
__NEW TEXT__
Baby Luc's offers a delightful pizza experience with high-quality slices and a welcoming ambiance. The outdoor patio provides an ideal spot for enjoying a slice on a sunny day, while the indoor seating is spacious and inviting. The staff at Baby Luc's are known for their kindness and patience, making customers feel valued and appreciated.
One standout amongst the menu options is the sausage and peppers slice, which boasts exquisite flavors. This particular slice is a must-try and well worth the wait. The savory sausage and tangy peppers create a perfect balance of taste, making it an exceptional choice for pizza lovers.
Baby Luc's offers a delightful pizza experience with high-quality slices and a welcoming ambiance. The outdoor patio provides an ideal spot for enjoying a slice on a sunny day, while the indoor seating is spacious and inviting. The staff at Baby Luc's are known for their kindness and patience, making customers feel valued and appreciated.
One standout amongst the menu options is the sausage and peppers slice, which boasts exquisite flavors. This particular slice is a must-try and well worth the wait. The savory sausage and tangy peppers create a perfect balance of taste, making it an exceptional choice for pizza lovers.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
