Top 10 pizza places in Gaslamp Quarter
When it comes to satisfying your pizza cravings in downtown San Diego, the Gaslamp Quarter is the place to be. This vibrant and historic neighborhood is home to several exceptional pizza places, each offering their unique twist on the classic dish. From classic margherita to gourmet options, pizza places in Gaslamp Quarter have something for everyone. Whether you're looking for a quick slice on-the-go or a sit-down dining experience, these pizza joints are sure to hit the spot. Come and explore the delicious world of pizza places in Gaslamp Quarter!
1. Prince Street Pizza
Offers Sicilian-style pizza in a trendy atmosphere

Prince Street Pizza is a well-known establishment that offers exceptional pizza slices. If you're in town, this is the perfect spot to try some of the best pizza you'll ever have. One of their most popular options is the Sicilian slice, which is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Dinner
- Late Night
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
2. Pizza on 5th
Cozy atmosphere, family-friendly, caters to large groups

The pizza offered at this establishment is delicious, but there is often a wait due to slow service. Despite the occasional issues with the speed of service, the atmosphere is well-suited for families. However, the quality of the pizza can vary at times. There have been instances where the pizza was not served hot or did not include all of the requested toppings.
In summary, while the pizza here can be enjoyable, there are some inconsistencies in terms of service and food quality. The family-friendly atmosphere is a positive aspect, but the wait time for the pizza and the occasional missing toppings may be areas for improvement. Despite these issues, some customers have had good experiences with the pizza, suggesting that it may be worth trying again on a different occasion.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Fusion Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Downtown Spots
3. Gaslamp Pizza in Gaslamp Quarter
Spacious rooftop bar with city views and lively atmosphere

The pizza I had at this restaurant was truly exceptional. The dough was incredibly fresh, adding an unbeatable flavor and texture. The welcoming atmosphere made for an enjoyable meal.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Affordable Nightlife
- Downtown Spots
4. New Tony's Pizza
Family-owned business, hand-tossed dough, fresh ingredients

New Tony's Pizza is renowned for its delicious garlic knots, Pepperoni, and buffalo chicken. Customers rave about the perfectly cooked dishes that leave them satisfied and impressed. The pizzeria's coffee has also gained a positive reputation, with many praising its taste and quality.
Despite the numerous positive reviews, there are a few criticisms to be aware of. With a rating of 3.5 out of 5 and only 13 reviews, there may be room for improvement in some areas. However, the overall positive feedback suggests that New Tony's Pizza is a solid choice for those seeking tasty pizza and garlic knots. The quality of the coffee is another highlight, making it a great spot for pizza and coffee lovers alike.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
5. The Old Spaghetti Factory
Historic trolley car dining area, homemade garlic cheese bread, extensive wine list

Some customers have raved about the service, describing it as fast, good, great, excellent, and even spectacular. Their positive experiences highlight the dedication and proficiency of the staff in attending to customers' needs. However, other patrons have described the service as average, okay, or bad, suggesting a need for improvement in this area.
The food quality has been a topic of mixed reviews. While some have commended the dishes for being flavorful and expertly cooked, others have been disappointed by the lack of seasoning and subpar quality of certain meals. Specifically, some reviewers criticized the pasta, describing it as tinned stewed tomatoes with basil, while others found it to be cooked to perfection. These conflicting opinions suggest a need for consistency in food preparation and seasoning to ensure all customers enjoy their dining experience.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Corporate Events
6. Osteria Panevino
Handmade pasta, extensive wine list, live music

A group of three people enjoyed a two-hour dinner outside at a street-side table, filled with laugher and jokes as they dined. The meal included a Salumi pizza as a starter, which was a standout dish. The pizza's crust was crispy and complemented the fresh and flavorful toppings.
Sharing pasta dishes, the group continued to chat and enjoy their meal with the servers. The quality of the food and the enjoyable atmosphere made for a memorable dining experience. The Salumi pizza, in particular, left a lasting impression with its perfectly crispy crust and fresh ingredients.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- High-End
Relate link
7. Roma Mia
Wood-fired pizza ovens, extensive wine list, and outdoor seating

The pizza at this location is truly delicious. The crust stands out for its perfect crispiness, while the toppings are fresh and add an excellent flavor profile. Among the pizzas tried, the Margherita was a clear favorite. Its tangy sauce and well-melted cheese elevated the pizza to one of the best we have tasted.
The quality of the ingredients used in the pizza is evident. The Margherita pizza's sauce was tangy and complemented the fresh and flavorful toppings well. Furthermore, the cheese was beautifully melted, adding to the pizza's overall enjoyment. This pizza experience is definitely one to remember.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- High-End
- Hidden Gems
8. il Sogno Italiano
Hand-tossed pizza dough, wood-fired oven

While exploring the Gaslamp Quarter, I came across a pizza place offering $4 beers and outside seating, making it an ideal spot to rest. Although the Rolling Rock was unavailable, I enjoyed a Stella draft for the same price. The area was bustling with people and pizza deliveries, indicating the quality of their pizzas. However, the location also attracted many homeless individuals. They offer pizza by the slice, with a $10 combo for two slices and a beer, but I only had one beer during my visit.
During a night of bar hopping in the Gaslamp Quarter, we stumbled upon this pizza place, which caters to the late-night crowd. The establishment provides quick service and offers various ready-to-serve pizzas. Although the pizza was quite delicious, the small slice was pricey and came with a $0.50 service charge. Despite this, I would consider returning during the day to order a fresh pizza, as the quality was good.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Hidden Gems
9. Operacaffe
Family-owned and operated since 1997, serving authentic Italian cuisine

Operacaffe is a restaurant in San Diego known for its delicious pizza. The crust of their pizzas is crispy, providing a satisfying crunch with every bite. They use fresh and flavorful toppings that enhance the overall taste of the pizza. One highly recommended pizza is the Margherita, which is a classic and always a great choice.
In summary, Operacaffe is a fantastic spot for pizza in San Diego. The crispy crust and fresh toppings make for a delicious pizza experience. The Margherita pizza is a must-try and is sure to satisfy. If you're looking for a great pizza place in San Diego, Operacaffe is definitely worth checking out.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
Relate link
10. Gaslamp Eatery in Gaslamp Quarter

TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Dinner
- Late Night