Top 10 pumpkin desserts in Ithaca
Discover our curated list of top-ranked pumpkin desserts in Ithaca, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Ithaca Bakery, Purity Ice Cream Co., Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop, Rashida Sawyer Bakery, Insomnia Cookies. Let's explore together!
Toc
1. Ithaca Bakery
Uses locally milled and organic ingredients
Indulge in a culinary journey at Ithaca Bakery, where every bite tells a delicious story. The menu boasts a plethora of options to tantalize your taste buds, from savory sandwiches to decadent sweets. Sink your teeth into the iconic New Yorker sandwich while sipping on a refreshing chocolate milk, all served with a smile by the incredibly friendly staff. A visit to Ithaca Bakery is a must for anyone looking to satisfy their cravings in style.
Immerse yourself in the charm of Ithaca Bakery, a hidden gem that effortlessly combines the best of a bakery, coffee shop, and even a bar. With a unique offering that includes a range of alcoholic beverages and happy hour specials, this spot stands out as a culinary oasis. Expect nothing but the freshest and most flavorful dishes, with daily specials adding an exciting twist to your dining experience. Come discover why this bakery is a beloved favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Immerse yourself in the charm of Ithaca Bakery, a hidden gem that effortlessly combines the best of a bakery, coffee shop, and even a bar. With a unique offering that includes a range of alcoholic beverages and happy hour specials, this spot stands out as a culinary oasis. Expect nothing but the freshest and most flavorful dishes, with daily specials adding an exciting twist to your dining experience. Come discover why this bakery is a beloved favorite among locals and visitors alike.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Happy Hours
- Breakfast
2. Purity Ice Cream Co.
Small-batch, handcrafted ice cream
Indulge in a culinary delight at Purity Ice Cream Co., a beloved local establishment that promises an exceptional dining experience. From savoring the succulent grilled chicken sandwich paired with crispy fries, to tantalizing your taste buds with their renowned ice cream selection, every bite is a symphony of flavors. Make sure to save room for their acclaimed ice cream creations, hailed as the best in town - a sweet conclusion to your meal that you won't want to miss.
When the morning sun peeks through the windows of Purity Ice Cream Co., treat yourself to a delightful breakfast spread that warms both body and soul. Sip on a steaming cup of rich, flavorful coffee as you savor a perfectly prepared breakfast of fluffy scrambled eggs and hearty potatoes. Despite the modest portion sizes, each dish is crafted with care and precision, ensuring a satisfying start to your day without overwhelming your appetite. Whether you're a local looking for a great meal or a traveler seeking a taste of culinary excellence, Purity Ice Cream Co. promises a dining experience that delights at every turn.
When the morning sun peeks through the windows of Purity Ice Cream Co., treat yourself to a delightful breakfast spread that warms both body and soul. Sip on a steaming cup of rich, flavorful coffee as you savor a perfectly prepared breakfast of fluffy scrambled eggs and hearty potatoes. Despite the modest portion sizes, each dish is crafted with care and precision, ensuring a satisfying start to your day without overwhelming your appetite. Whether you're a local looking for a great meal or a traveler seeking a taste of culinary excellence, Purity Ice Cream Co. promises a dining experience that delights at every turn.
TOPICS
- Holiday Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Breakfast
3. Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop
Small-batch, locally-sourced ingredients
Indulge in the delectable offerings of Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop nestled at $200 W Seneca St, Ithaca, NY. While specializing in soft-serve treats like blizzards, this dessert haven boasts affordability and simplicity. Though I lean towards scoopable ice cream, the well-crafted soft serve at Sweet Melissa's is undoubtedly a crowd-pleaser. Despite primarily serving soft varieties, the shop does offer a few hard flavors. While the flavors may not push the boundaries of innovation, they are expertly executed, guaranteeing a satisfying experience. With reasonable prices and a range of tasty options, Sweet Melissa's is a recommended stop for any dessert enthusiast.
Swirl into Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop, a charming dessert destination in Ithaca, NY. Delight in their creamy soft-serve treats, including irresistible blizzards, all at budget-friendly prices. Although my personal preference leans towards traditional scoopable ice cream, the quality and flavors of the soft serve at Sweet Melissa's won me over. While the selection leans towards soft varieties, there are a few hard flavor options available. The flavors, while not groundbreaking, are well-crafted, ensuring a delightful taste experience. With a range of delicious offerings and affordable prices, Sweet Melissa's is a must-visit spot for those with a sweet tooth.
Swirl into Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop, a charming dessert destination in Ithaca, NY. Delight in their creamy soft-serve treats, including irresistible blizzards, all at budget-friendly prices. Although my personal preference leans towards traditional scoopable ice cream, the quality and flavors of the soft serve at Sweet Melissa's won me over. While the selection leans towards soft varieties, there are a few hard flavor options available. The flavors, while not groundbreaking, are well-crafted, ensuring a delightful taste experience. With a range of delicious offerings and affordable prices, Sweet Melissa's is a must-visit spot for those with a sweet tooth.
TOPICS
- Cheap Eats
- Vegetarian Options
- Dinner
Relate link
4. Rashida Sawyer Bakery
Rashida Sawyer Bakery is a true hidden gem, boasting the most divine desserts imaginable. Each sweet treat we sampled was a culinary masterpiece, making it nearly impossible to choose a favorite. The cheesecake and carrot cake were particularly exceptional, and the customer service was top-notch. It's truly a charming spot that delivers on all fronts.
My daughter selected a chocolate-dipped cheesecake for her birthday celebration, and it surpassed all expectations. The impeccable service, delightful presentation (including a custom cake topper), and overall experience at Rashida Sawyer Bakery left us thoroughly impressed. It's a must-visit destination for those seeking unparalleled sweet delights.
My daughter selected a chocolate-dipped cheesecake for her birthday celebration, and it surpassed all expectations. The impeccable service, delightful presentation (including a custom cake topper), and overall experience at Rashida Sawyer Bakery left us thoroughly impressed. It's a must-visit destination for those seeking unparalleled sweet delights.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
- Mid-Range
Relate link
5. Insomnia Cookies
Insomnia Cookies, a New York-based bakery founded in 2003, excels in delivering delectable cookies right to the doorstep. Their menu boasts a range of mouthwatering treats, including loaded brownies, all prepared with care to ensure a warm, fresh indulgence. The store's inviting decor and attentive staff further enhance the delightful experience, making a visit highly recommended for all those seeking a sweet delight.
Indulge in the tempting offerings at Insomnia Cookies and savor the delightfully warm, freshly baked cookies that are sure to please your taste buds. Alongside their delicious treats, the loaded brownies are a definite highlight not to be missed. The friendly and hospitable service provided by the staff adds an extra touch of warmth to the experience, ensuring that a visit to Insomnia Cookies is well worth your time and taste buds.
Indulge in the tempting offerings at Insomnia Cookies and savor the delightfully warm, freshly baked cookies that are sure to please your taste buds. Alongside their delicious treats, the loaded brownies are a definite highlight not to be missed. The friendly and hospitable service provided by the staff adds an extra touch of warmth to the experience, ensuring that a visit to Insomnia Cookies is well worth your time and taste buds.
TOPICS
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
6. Cayuga Lake Creamery at The Dewitt Mall
Indulge in delightful treats at Cayuga Lake Creamery in The Dewitt Mall. The exceptional coffee ice cream delights the senses, while the Seneca salted caramel, a partner's choice, is a true gem. While the ambiance is perfect for unwinding, a touch of background music would elevate the experience.
For a true taste of Ithaca's finest ice cream, look no further than Cornell Dairy Bar and Cayuga Lake Creamery. Purity may have left much to be desired, and Sweet Melissa's fell short of expectations, but Cayuga Lake Creamery stands out as a top favorite among locals.
For a true taste of Ithaca's finest ice cream, look no further than Cornell Dairy Bar and Cayuga Lake Creamery. Purity may have left much to be desired, and Sweet Melissa's fell short of expectations, but Cayuga Lake Creamery stands out as a top favorite among locals.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
- Social Gatherings
7. Mama Said Hand Pies-Press Bay Alley
Nestled in Press Bay Alley, Mama Said Hand Pies is a charming bakery known for its delectable handmade treats. From savory sausage rolls to flavorful Irish lamb rolls, each bite is a burst of fresh, delicious ingredients. The delightful pastries and fillings are a testament to the owners' culinary prowess, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts craving exceptional baked goods. Don't miss out on their signature salsa Verde, a perfect complement to their mouthwatering offerings.
A visit to Mama Said Hand Pies is an unforgettable experience, with every bite leaving you craving more. The quality of their offerings speaks volumes about the care and dedication put into each creation. Whether you're a local foodie or a traveler passing through, this little bakery is a gem worth supporting. Indulge in their delectable hand pies and don't forget to savor the must-have salsa Verde that adds an extra layer of flavor to their already outstanding menu.
A visit to Mama Said Hand Pies is an unforgettable experience, with every bite leaving you craving more. The quality of their offerings speaks volumes about the care and dedication put into each creation. Whether you're a local foodie or a traveler passing through, this little bakery is a gem worth supporting. Indulge in their delectable hand pies and don't forget to savor the must-have salsa Verde that adds an extra layer of flavor to their already outstanding menu.
TOPICS
- Mexican Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
8. Rosie's Ice Cream
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Breakfast
9. Sweet N’ Salty
TOPICS
- Fusion Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
Relate link
10. Cold Stone Creamery
4.6 Desserts Affordable delivery spot offering sundaes, create your own, candles, smoothies and more. 4700 Vestal Pkwy E, New York 13850
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- Dietary
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots