Top 10 toy stores in Murray Hill NYC
Toy Stores in Murray Hill NYC: A Colorful World of Playful Delights Welcome to the enchanting world of toy stores in Murray Hill, NYC! These shops offer a captivating selection of toys, games, and entertainment for children and the young at heart. From classic favorites to the latest trends, toy stores in Murray Hill NYC promise a fun-filled experience. Come and explore the vibrant aisles where imagination and creativity thrive!
1. Mary Arnold Toys in Murray Hill

Mary Arnold Toys is a fantastic toy store with knowledgeable and helpful staff who make shopping a breeze. Their speedy service and delivery options are added perks. This toy store has been a reliable neighborhood establishment for years, offering a wide range of popular toys as well as a vast selection of craft toys for children.
The staff at Mary Arnold Toys are always ready and eager to assist customers with their purchases. They make it easy to shop by being well-versed in all areas of the store. In addition to their excellent customer service, they also offer quick delivery options for those who prefer to shop from the comfort of their own homes. Overall, Mary Arnold Toys is a top-notch toy store that consistently delivers a positive shopping experience.
2. Greenpoint Toys
Brooklyn's iconic toy store for over 30 years

A visit to this toy store is sure to delight both children and adults alike. The shelves are stocked with a wide variety of toys, from classic favorites to the latest trends. The staff is incredibly friendly, adding a warm and inviting atmosphere to the store. They are knowledgeable about their products and can offer great recommendations based on age and interest.
Prices are very reasonable, making it easy to find something for every budget. The store takes care to curate its selection, ensuring that every toy is high-quality and will provide hours of entertainment. With its engaging staff and carefully selected range of toys, this store is a true gem in the world of playtime.
3. Kidding Around
Inspiring creativity and family interaction for 30 years

A cherished institution for nearly three decades, this family-owned toy store has thrived by prioritizing quality, value, and exceptional customer service. The store's large, circus-tent-like space is a hub of activity and laughter, where play and learning go hand in hand. For years, parents, educators, and discerning shoppers have looked to this independent retailer to provide engaging and educational toys for inquisitive young minds.
The owners of this beloved neighborhood toy store hold fast to the belief that play is the foundation of childhood development, with learning being the natural and joyful outcome. With a deep understanding of the importance of play, the store offers a carefully curated selection of toys that promote creativity, brain development, and problem-solving skills. From classic wooden blocks to cutting-edge tech gadgets, the store's inventory is designed to inspire imaginations and foster a love of learning.
4. West Side Kids in Murray Hill
Neighborhood toy store since 1981

The free gift wrapping service offered by this store is a convenient perk that makes birthday gift shopping an enjoyable experience. This service not only saves time but also adds a personal touch to the gift, making it even more special for the recipient.
The store showcases a well-curated selection of merchandise that appeals to a wide range of age groups. Each item has been thoughtfully chosen, ensuring a diverse offering that caters to various interests and preferences. From toys and games for children to stylish accessories for adults, this store has something for everyone, making it an ideal destination for birthday gift shopping.
5. FAO Schwarz
Iconic toy store delighting all ages since 1862

FAO Schwarz, the renowned toy store, has made a triumphant return to Rockefeller Center, offering a one-of-a-kind experience for visitors of all ages. The three-story building near the famous landmark is brimming with toys, games, and an electrifying atmosphere that is sure to delight.
FAO Schwarz provides visitors with an immersive adventure that invigorates the imagination. The moment one enters the store, they are transported into a world beyond their wildest dreams. With an extensive collection of toys, games, and interactive experiences, the story of FAO Schwarz is one that is sure to capture the hearts and minds of all who enter.
6. Disney Store
Magical shopping experience in Times Square

A visit to the Disney Store in Times Square, New York City is a must for any Disney fan. From classic characters like Mickey and Minnie to newer sensations like Elsa and Anna, the store offers a wide range of merchandise that is sure to delight. The store's lively atmosphere, combined with its impressive collections, makes for an enjoyable shopping experience.
In addition to the general Disney offerings, the store also features a nice selection of Star Wars and Marvel superhero merchandise, making it a great destination for boys and fans of those franchises. From toys and clothing to collectibles and accessories, there is something for everyone at this Disney Store. Overall, it is an excellent destination for anyone looking to add some Disney magic to their life, and is highly recommended for visitors to Times Square.
7. Toy Tokyo
A paradise for toy enthusiasts and collectors

The establishment's downstairs area boasts an extensive collection of Funko Pop figures. This is not just any ordinary collection, but rather a carefully curated assemblage of rare, collectible pop culture memorabilia. Although some may find the prices to be on the higher side, for serious collectors who have been searching far and wide for these elusive gems, the cost may well be worth it. Many of these items are sourced from overseas, making them truly unique and hard to come by elsewhere. Browsing through the collection is an enjoyable and entertaining experience, even for those who may not necessarily be looking to make a purchase.
The Funko Pop figures on display are not just common pieces, but rather, they represent some of the rarest and most sought-after collectibles in the world of pop culture. For enthusiasts who have been searching high and low for that missing piece to complete their collection, this could be the perfect place to find it. The collection features items from a wide range of genres, including movies, TV shows, music, video games, and more. Whether you're a fan of Star Wars, Marvel, Harry Potter, or any other popular franchise, you're sure to find something that catches your eye. The rare international imports make the collection especially noteworthy, offering fans the chance to own unique pieces that cannot be found anywhere else. Overall, the collection is a must-see for serious collectors and casual fans alike.
8. Playing Mantis
Celebrating creativity and sustainability with unique handmade toys

Adorable wooden toys, with their unique and rustic charm, are available for purchase. These toys may be more expensive than their plastic counterparts, but the superior quality and craftsmanship make the cost worthwhile. The attention to detail and care put into each toy is evident, making them a great investment for any parent or toy collector.
The hand-made wooden toys are particularly noteworthy. These collections bring back memories of simpler times and inspire a sense of nostalgia. The charming designs and intricate details make them a delightful addition to any playroom. Whether you're a child or an adult, these toys are sure to bring joy and wonder. The beauty and craftsmanship of these wooden toys make it easy to understand why one might be willing to spend a little extra.
9. Little Things Toy Store
Best selection of specialty toys since 1977

Little Things Toy Store offers a vast array of options for children of all ages, making it an ideal destination for parents and guardians. The store's customer service is exceptional, with knowledgeable and approachable staff who are always willing to assist in finding the perfect toy. The warm and welcoming atmosphere of the store adds to the shopping experience, creating a pleasant environment for customers.
This specialty toy store stands out with its unique and high-quality toy selection. The staff's friendliness and eagerness to help make it a delightful place to shop for gifts or treats for children. Little Things Toy Store has successfully curated an impressive collection of toys that are both educational and entertaining, making it an excellent choice for those seeking to provide children with enriching play experiences.
10. Boomerang Toys
NYC's premier specialty toy retailer since 2002

Boomerang Toys in New York City's Tribeca neighborhood is a beloved toy store that has been serving the local community since 2002. The store offers a wide variety of specialty toys, along with popular favorites such as Pokemon, LOL dolls, and Superheroes, catering to children of all ages. What sets Boomerang Toys apart is its commitment to providing high-quality, educational toys that are still incredibly entertaining.
The store is known for its friendly and knowledgeable staff who are always available to help customers select the perfect toy. The selection is impressive, given the store's manageable size. Boomerang Toys has become the go-to destination for anyone looking to buy a thoughtful and enjoyable gift for a child. Whether it's a special occasion or just a regular day, Boomerang Toys is the ideal place to find toys that are both fun and enriching for kids.