Top 11 bagels in Rochester
Discover our curated list of top-ranked bagels in Rochester, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Balsam Bagels, Cafe Sasso, Dunkin', Dunkin', Bruegger's Bagels. Let's explore together!
Toc
1. Balsam Bagels
Traditional, hand-rolled bagels made from scratch

Indulge in the ultimate bagel experience at Balsam Bagels, the unrivaled destination for bagel aficionados in Rochester! Revel in an extensive selection of fresh, expertly crafted bagels that boast a tantalizing crispiness on the outside and a delectably soft interior. Elevating your bagel game further, explore a myriad of options for house-made cream cheese that are sure to tantalize your taste buds.
Embark on a culinary journey reminiscent of the iconic bagel scene in NYC, as Balsam Bagels presents bagels with the perfect texture and delicate nuanced flavors that set them apart from the ordinary. From the impeccable service to the diverse array of choices, every visit promises a delightful experience that will leave you craving more. Bask in the excellence that defines Balsam Bagels – a true gem in the heart of Rochester.
Embark on a culinary journey reminiscent of the iconic bagel scene in NYC, as Balsam Bagels presents bagels with the perfect texture and delicate nuanced flavors that set them apart from the ordinary. From the impeccable service to the diverse array of choices, every visit promises a delightful experience that will leave you craving more. Bask in the excellence that defines Balsam Bagels – a true gem in the heart of Rochester.
2. Cafe Sasso
Cozy atmosphere, popular local spot

Nestled in the heart of the city, Cafe Sasso beckons with its tasteful decor, offering a haven for both vegans and coffee aficionados alike. From innovative vegan dishes to a simple yet enticing coffee selection, every sip and bite promises a symphony of new and fresh flavors. The walls adorned with captivating paintings by local artists add a touch of charm, with each piece inviting you to own a slice of the cafe's artistic allure.
Indulging in post-dinner "dessert drinks" at Cafe Sasso with my wife was a delightful experience that left us thoroughly impressed. The friendly staff, delectable drinks, and warm ambiance created a welcoming retreat from the bustling streets outside. As we savored our beverages, our eyes wandered across the carefully curated artworks, each corner exuding creativity and inspiration. Needless to say, we departed with content hearts, already planning our return to this enchanting cafe.
Indulging in post-dinner "dessert drinks" at Cafe Sasso with my wife was a delightful experience that left us thoroughly impressed. The friendly staff, delectable drinks, and warm ambiance created a welcoming retreat from the bustling streets outside. As we savored our beverages, our eyes wandered across the carefully curated artworks, each corner exuding creativity and inspiration. Needless to say, we departed with content hearts, already planning our return to this enchanting cafe.
3. Dunkin'
Open early for breakfast and coffee

Dunkin' Rochester offers a convenient solution for those on the go, providing a rare opportunity to enjoy a cup of coffee without leaving the comfort of their car in the bustling downtown area. Despite the challenges posed by the city's homeless population and disruptive elements, the establishment stands out as a reliable oasis for coffee lovers.
While the service at Dunkin' Rochester generally meets expectations, there is room for improvement in fulfilling orders placed through the app. Customers often find themselves waiting for accompanying pastries or snacks, dampening the overall experience and missing the mark on the quick and efficient service that patrons anticipate.
While the service at Dunkin' Rochester generally meets expectations, there is room for improvement in fulfilling orders placed through the app. Customers often find themselves waiting for accompanying pastries or snacks, dampening the overall experience and missing the mark on the quick and efficient service that patrons anticipate.
4. Dunkin'
Wide range of coffee drinks

Dunkin' Donuts holds a special place in my heart, consistently delivering on my cravings. However, during my recent visit, the confusion around the $2 cappuccino promotion left me disheartened. Despite some minor hiccups in getting my coffee order right, such as mistakenly adding cream when I ask for none, I remain hopeful that my loyalty and $5 will lead to a perfect cup of joe in the future.
5. Bruegger's Bagels
Catering services available

Bruegger's Bagels is a delightful spot for delicious bagels and creamy cream cheese, alongside a tempting array of sandwiches. Don't miss out on their decadent vanilla chai tea. While some may find the atmosphere slightly worn-down, the exceptional quality of their bagels prevails, making it a must-visit for bagel sandwich enthusiasts.
6. Dunkin'
Open early for grab-and-go breakfast options

Located in Mt. Hope near String Hospital, the Dunkin' store is overshadowed by an employee with visible hickeys, exuding discontent and reluctance. His demeanor, devoid of joy or engagement, hints at underlying job dissatisfaction. Venturing in for sourdough sandwiches sans bacon, I encountered a "supervisor" at the counter displaying blatant disrespect towards a deaf individual. Such behavior, unworthy of the Dunkin' brand known for warmth and hospitality, tarnishes the overall experience.
7. Dunkin'
Open early for commuters

Dunkin' Our recent visit to Dunkin' was delightful! The cashier was friendly and patient as we made our selections. The breakfast croissant sandwich was delicious, and the fries were perfectly fresh.
On the flip side, my Dunkin' experience couldn't have been worse. After a long wait in the drive-thru, my order of 3 drinks and 2 bagels was completely botched. Each drink was incorrect and given separately, stretching out the already frustrating experience.
On the flip side, my Dunkin' experience couldn't have been worse. After a long wait in the drive-thru, my order of 3 drinks and 2 bagels was completely botched. Each drink was incorrect and given separately, stretching out the already frustrating experience.
8. Dunkin'
Quick service and convenient location

9. Dunkin'
Quick service and grab-and-go options

10. Tim Hortons
Canadian-based multinational fast food restaurant chain

11. Dunkin'
Quick service, convenient for on-the-go
