Top 11 banana puddings in Andersonville
Indulge in the delight of banana puddings in Andersonville, a charming neighborhood in Chicago. This delectable dessert is a local favorite, known for its rich and creamy texture, layered with fresh banana slices and vanilla wafers. From classic recipes to modern twists, banana puddings in Andersonville tantalize your taste buds and offer a sweet escape for dessert lovers.
- 1. A Taste of Heaven
- 2. First Slice Pie Cafe
- 3. Big Jones in Andersonville
- 4. Lost Larson (Andersonville)
- 5. Lady Gregory's Irish Bar & Restaurant
- 6. Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
- 7. Little Bad Wolf
- 8. Colectivo Andersonville
- 9. Ranalli's of Andersonville in Andersonville
- 10. Middle East Bakery & Grocery
- 11. Kilwins
1. A Taste of Heaven
Family-owned business with a cozy atmosphere

The banana pudding is a must-try dessert, renowned for its exceptional taste and texture. Its perfect balance of sweetness makes it a standout among other similar desserts. Many, like myself, make it a point to have some whenever they are in the area.
This delicious banana pudding never fails to impress. Its taste and texture create a memorable experience for anyone who tries it. It is not uncommon for people to go out of their way to enjoy this delectable treat, as its sweetness lingers on the taste buds, leaving a lasting impression.
TOPICS
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Downtown Spots
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link
2. First Slice Pie Cafe
Family-owned business since 2010, focuses on creating unique and delicious pies

Slice Pie Cafe offers an exceptional banana pudding that stands out for its rich flavor and comforting qualities. The dessert has a delightful texture, reminiscent of a homemade treat.
Experiencing the banana pudding firsthand, one can't help but notice its fantastic taste and texture. Its homemade taste is especially noteworthy, adding to its overall charm and appeal.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
3. Big Jones in Andersonville
Offers a variety of traditional Southern dishes with locally sourced ingredients, including gluten-free and vegetarian options.

Big Jones restaurant offers a delicious banana pudding that is truly impressive. The texture of the pudding is incredibly smooth, providing a pleasant and enjoyable experience with each bite. The flavor is also spot on, accurately capturing the taste of banana in a delightful way.
Ending a meal at Big Jones with their banana pudding is a highly recommended experience. The layering of banana and custard in the pudding is expertly done, creating a wonderful combination of flavors and textures. This dessert is a true delight that is sure to leave a lasting impression on anyone who tries it.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Vegetarian Options
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
4. Lost Larson (Andersonville)
Artisanal bakery and café using sustainable and locally-sourced ingredients

Lost Larson's banana pudding is truly a culinary delight. It boasts a lusciously creamy and rich consistency, while the sweetness is perfectly balanced, making each bite a true pleasure. This delectable dessert is a must-try for anyone looking to treat their taste buds.
The banana pudding at Lost Larson is a standout dish. It features a wonderful combination of flavors, with each element harmoniously complementing the others. The texture is also fantastic, with a smooth and velvety feel that is simply irresistible. Whether you're a banana pudding aficionado or new to the dish, this is one dessert that is sure to leave a lasting impression.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Hidden Gems
5. Lady Gregory's Irish Bar & Restaurant
Cozy and authentic Irish bar atmosphere with a friendly staff and live music on weekends.

Lady Gregory's banana pudding is a standout dessert, highly recommended for anyone looking for a delicious treat. The pudding was better than I could have ever imagined, with a creamy texture and incredible flavor.
Banana pudding isn't always a exciting dessert, but at Lady Gregory's, it's a must-try. The combination of fresh bananas, creamy pudding, and crunchy wafer cookies is simply irresistible. I wasn't expecting such a delicious dessert, but I was pleasantly surprised and thoroughly impressed.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Downtown Spots
- Mediterranean Cuisine
Relate link
6. Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams
Uses local and organic ingredients, offers vegan options, and supports sustainable farming

The banana pudding ice cream is a highly recommended dessert that stands out for its creamy texture and well-balanced taste. This delightful treat features a smooth, creamy base with the perfect amount of sweetness and a distinct banana flavor that shines through in every bite.
What makes this ice cream even more special are the generous chunks of real banana scattered throughout, adding bursts of natural sweetness and a satisfying texture. Overall, banana pudding ice cream is a must-try for anyone looking for a unique and delicious frozen treat.
TOPICS
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Happy Hours
- Downtown Spots
- Weekend Dining
7. Little Bad Wolf
The restaurant has a cozy and intimate atmosphere, with a focus on craft cocktails and local ingredients.

The banana pudding served at this location is truly delicious. It's a standout dessert that should not be missed, particularly for those who enjoy sweet treats. The quality of the desserts in general is excellent, but the banana pudding is a clear favorite.
If you're looking for a wonderful way to cap off your meal, the banana pudding is an outstanding choice. Its delicious taste and high quality make it a must-try for anyone with a sweet tooth. The dessert options are a highlight of the menu, but the banana pudding is in a league of its own.
TOPICS
- Asian Cuisine
- American Cuisine
- Dinner
- Late Night
8. Colectivo Andersonville
Featuring unique flavors and made daily in-house, Colectivo's banana puddings are a must-try!

The banana pudding served at Colectivo Andersonville is truly delightful. Its creamy and rich texture, combined with the perfect amount of sweetness, makes it a standout. This dessert is a must-try for anyone looking for a delicious treat.
I was pleasantly surprised by the banana pudding at this location. The blend of flavors and textures is expertly balanced, resulting in a truly enjoyable dessert. The creamy consistency and just the right amount of sweetness make this banana pudding a delicious choice.
TOPICS
- Breakfast
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Downtown Spots
9. Ranalli's of Andersonville in Andersonville
Kid-friendly, Local hangout, Casual setting

Ranalli's, a popular spot in Chicago, offers an exceptional banana pudding. The pudding stands out for its perfect texture and delightful flavor. This dessert provides a satisfying end to any meal at the establishment.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
10. Middle East Bakery & Grocery
Authentic Middle Eastern cuisine and grocery offerings in a welcoming environment

Middle East Bakery & Grocery offers a delightful banana pudding that should not be missed. The pudding boasts a creamy texture and a perfect balance of sweetness, making it a standout dessert.
If you find yourself at Middle East Bakery & Grocery, make sure to sample their delicious banana pudding. This dessert features a rich and creamy texture, along with a harmonious blend of sweet and fruity flavors, resulting in a highly recommended treat.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
11. Kilwins

1724 Sherman Ave., Evanston Photo courtesy of Kilwins. This Evanston outpost of Northern Michigan stalwart offers 32 flavors of ice cream, along with Mackinac fudge made in-store.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
Relate link