Top 11 milkshakes in Allentown Buffalo
Discover our curated list of top-ranked milkshakes in Allentown Buffalo, compiled from extensive research across reputable websites and blogs. Explore outstanding options like Gabriel's Gate, Allen Burger Venture, Cafe 59, Allentown Pizza, Colter Bay. Let's explore together!
Toc
1. Gabriel's Gate
Featuring a cozy fireplace and extensive beer selection

Discover Gabriel's Gate, a hidden gem nestled just moments away from the bustling city center. Indulge in their renowned pub fare, with a special highlight on their mouthwatering wings that will leave you craving for more. Immerse yourself in the cozy and dimly lit atmosphere adorned with whimsical decor, setting the perfect backdrop for an unforgettable dining experience.
Prepare to be captivated by the welcoming smiles of the staff and blown away by the delectable wings that are nothing short of perfection. Treat yourself to a feast with a generous serving of 20 wings paired with crispy onion rings and savory potato skins. In a city filled with limited options, Gabriel's Gate stands out as the ultimate destination to savor delicious food, sip on refreshing drinks, and enjoy the company of good friends. Get ready to indulge and pamper your taste buds - a culinary adventure awaits, promising a blissful food coma that is well-deserved.
Prepare to be captivated by the welcoming smiles of the staff and blown away by the delectable wings that are nothing short of perfection. Treat yourself to a feast with a generous serving of 20 wings paired with crispy onion rings and savory potato skins. In a city filled with limited options, Gabriel's Gate stands out as the ultimate destination to savor delicious food, sip on refreshing drinks, and enjoy the company of good friends. Get ready to indulge and pamper your taste buds - a culinary adventure awaits, promising a blissful food coma that is well-deserved.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
2. Allen Burger Venture
Known for their creative and high-quality burgers and craft beers

Renowned for its delectable dishes and inviting ambiance, Allen Burger Venture has quickly become a favorite dining spot for my discerning family. From the succulent calamari to the tantalizing DDD Nashville hot chicken, every bite at ABV is a culinary delight that leaves you craving for more. The flawless service provided by the attentive waitress and hospitable host added an extra layer of warmth to our dining experience, making our visit truly memorable.
During a recent visit with a friend for late-night drinks, ABV continued to exceed expectations. The impeccable service and mouthwatering menu offerings, including the irresistible calamari, perfectly complemented the vibrant atmosphere. My evening was further enhanced by an expertly crafted cocktail that perfectly encapsulated the essence of ABV's dedication to culinary excellence and exceptional hospitality.
During a recent visit with a friend for late-night drinks, ABV continued to exceed expectations. The impeccable service and mouthwatering menu offerings, including the irresistible calamari, perfectly complemented the vibrant atmosphere. My evening was further enhanced by an expertly crafted cocktail that perfectly encapsulated the essence of ABV's dedication to culinary excellence and exceptional hospitality.
TOPICS
- Corporate Events
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Downtown Spots
3. Cafe 59
Unique vintage atmosphere with a cozy and eclectic feel

Indulge in the unforgettable culinary experience at Cafe 59, where every bite is a symphony of flavors. Their signature Chicken Finger sandwich is a must-try, but don't miss the opportunity to savor the tantalizing Bourbon Chicken on your next visit. Today, I am delighting in a fiery risotto infused with roasted jalapenos, sweet corn, roasted red peppers, smoked gouda, and fresh cilantro, perfectly complemented by a refreshing San Bernardo beverage. From mouthwatering egg rolls to delectable chicken tacos and juicy burgers, my first lunch at this cafe was nothing short of exceptional.
At Cafe 59, culinary excellence takes center stage, with each dish crafted to perfection. Their renowned Chicken Finger sandwich and enticing Bourbon Chicken showcase the culinary expertise that defines this establishment. Today, I am reveling in a sensational spicy risotto bursting with roasted jalapenos, sweet corn, roasted red peppers, smoked gouda, and fragrant cilantro, paired harmoniously with a crisp San Bernardo accompaniment. From the savory egg rolls and flavorful chicken tacos to the tantalizing burgers on offer, my inaugural lunch at this cafe was a culinary journey to remember.
At Cafe 59, culinary excellence takes center stage, with each dish crafted to perfection. Their renowned Chicken Finger sandwich and enticing Bourbon Chicken showcase the culinary expertise that defines this establishment. Today, I am reveling in a sensational spicy risotto bursting with roasted jalapenos, sweet corn, roasted red peppers, smoked gouda, and fragrant cilantro, paired harmoniously with a crisp San Bernardo accompaniment. From the savory egg rolls and flavorful chicken tacos to the tantalizing burgers on offer, my inaugural lunch at this cafe was a culinary journey to remember.
TOPICS
- Affordable Nightlife
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
4. Allentown Pizza
Family-owned local favorite with dedicated customers

Allentown Pizza stands out as the ultimate vegan pizza destination in Buffalo. From the delectable BBQ seitan to the fabulous wings, the menu offers a wide array of mouthwatering options. After over a decade of meat-free dining, this pizza joint remains unparalleled in serving the best seitan pizza. A top choice in Allentown, the Hawaiian Vegan BBQ Chk'n Pizza is a true showstopper, embodying culinary excellence with every bite. A must-visit spot for all vegan food enthusiasts!
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Budget-Friendly Eats
5. Colter Bay
Featuring a large outdoor patio and a cozy interior with a fireplace

Nestled in the heart of downtown Buffalo, Colter Bay exudes a sophisticated sports bar ambiance. Renowned for its vast selection of 50 bear varieties, this modern establishment boasts an inviting outdoor space in the warmer months. The Corbet's Couloir, a decadent bison meatloaf atop Texas toast with luscious mashed potatoes and gravy, is a culinary delight priced at $14. The attentive service team enhances the overall experience, complemented by occasional live music performances and daily special offerings.
TOPICS
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
- Mid-Range
6. Falley Allen
Features local artists' work and hosts live music events

Falley Allen is an exceptional dining spot, boasting a fantastic bar and the most delicious sweet potato fries you'll ever taste. While the steak sandwich was satisfying, the standout dish was the flavorful fried rice, albeit slightly salty. The attentive service added to the impeccable dining experience.
I had the pleasure of experiencing Falley Allen during restaurant week and was blown away by the delectable offerings paired with top-notch drinks. Their impressive array of Bourbons at the bar was an unexpected delight. With summer on the horizon, I eagerly anticipate enjoying a relaxing bourbon on the charming patio.
I had the pleasure of experiencing Falley Allen during restaurant week and was blown away by the delectable offerings paired with top-notch drinks. Their impressive array of Bourbons at the bar was an unexpected delight. With summer on the horizon, I eagerly anticipate enjoying a relaxing bourbon on the charming patio.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
7. Giacobbi's Cucina Citta
Authentic Italian cuisine with a modern twist

Embark on a culinary journey at Giacobbi's Cucina Citta on Allen Street for a delightful meal. Indulge in the flavorful Chicken Milanese paired with a refreshing balsamic salad. Quench your thirst with a cold beer garnished with double oranges. The friendly waiter, accompanied by a third-year law school apprentice, ensures a pleasant dining experience. Greeted by the charming Nicole and served by the exceptional Jessie, expect top-notch customer service and tantalizing recommendations. Don't miss out on the must-try dishes like the prosciutto pizza, casino clams, and rapini pasta.
TOPICS
- Celebrations
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
8. Allentown Food Shoppe

TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Lunch
9. Allentown Eatz

TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Vegetarian Options
- Cheap Eats
10. Allentown Trading Co

11. Holley Farms Market
