Top 11 pizza places in Theater District NYC
Pizza places in Theater District NYC are a delight for both tourists and locals alike. Among the bustling streets and Broadway shows, these pizza spots offer a taste of New York's famous cuisine. Whether you're looking for a quick slice or a sit-down meal, the pizza places in Theater District NYC cater to all preferences, making them a must-visit for any pizza lover.
Toc
1. Joe's Pizza Broadway in Theater District
Classic New York pizza experience in the heart of Broadway
__NEW TEXT__
Joe's Pizza is a well-known establishment that offers a classic pizza experience. The atmosphere is inviting, with a lively and friendly staff that contributes to the overall positive energy of the place. It is a convenient spot for a quick and easy meal, and the prices are very reasonable considering the high-quality product.
The pizza at Joe's features a chewy, slightly burnt crust that adds depth and flavor to each slice. Some customers rave about the authentic New York-style pizza, while others mention occasional issues with reheating or serving cold slices. Despite these occasional complaints, the majority of customers enjoy the fresh and hot pizza that Joe's consistently delivers.
Joe's Pizza is a well-known establishment that offers a classic pizza experience. The atmosphere is inviting, with a lively and friendly staff that contributes to the overall positive energy of the place. It is a convenient spot for a quick and easy meal, and the prices are very reasonable considering the high-quality product.
The pizza at Joe's features a chewy, slightly burnt crust that adds depth and flavor to each slice. Some customers rave about the authentic New York-style pizza, while others mention occasional issues with reheating or serving cold slices. Despite these occasional complaints, the majority of customers enjoy the fresh and hot pizza that Joe's consistently delivers.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
2. John's Pizzeria of Times Square
Enjoy pizza under a five-story stained glass cupola.
__NEW TEXT__
John's Pizzeria has gained a reputation for offering excellent pizza, considered among the finest in New York. The pizzas are made using fresh toppings and a thin, homemade-tasting crust.
The recent dining experience at this establishment was nothing short of remarkable. The atmosphere was charming, featuring a historic church building, beautiful stained glass, and unique lighting. The staff were courteous and efficient, providing great service. Particularly noteworthy was the white pizza, which was delicious, and the high-quality crust that was truly exceptional.
John's Pizzeria has gained a reputation for offering excellent pizza, considered among the finest in New York. The pizzas are made using fresh toppings and a thin, homemade-tasting crust.
The recent dining experience at this establishment was nothing short of remarkable. The atmosphere was charming, featuring a historic church building, beautiful stained glass, and unique lighting. The staff were courteous and efficient, providing great service. Particularly noteworthy was the white pizza, which was delicious, and the high-quality crust that was truly exceptional.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
3. Carnegie Pizza in Theater District
Modern pizzeria in Times Square with diverse options.
__NEW TEXT__
A recent pizza experience has resulted in a conversion to a newfound preference. The pizza in question boasted a perfect balance of thin dough and generously applied toppings, rendering it incredibly delicious. Priced between $3.50 and $5.50 per slice, with the option to add extra toppings, this pizza proved to be a truly satisfying meal.
Despite being served late at night, an extremely busy period, the service remained efficient. The pizza ordered, a spicy pepperoni slice, proved to be worth the wait. It featured a notably crunchy base, combined with a deliciously chewy center, providing a delightful contrast in texture. Ultimately, the pizza lived up to its promise of great taste, making for a highly enjoyable culinary experience.
A recent pizza experience has resulted in a conversion to a newfound preference. The pizza in question boasted a perfect balance of thin dough and generously applied toppings, rendering it incredibly delicious. Priced between $3.50 and $5.50 per slice, with the option to add extra toppings, this pizza proved to be a truly satisfying meal.
Despite being served late at night, an extremely busy period, the service remained efficient. The pizza ordered, a spicy pepperoni slice, proved to be worth the wait. It featured a notably crunchy base, combined with a deliciously chewy center, providing a delightful contrast in texture. Ultimately, the pizza lived up to its promise of great taste, making for a highly enjoyable culinary experience.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Cheap Eats
4. Little Italy Pizza
Traditional Italian-style pizzas in the heart of NYC
__NEW TEXT__
Upon placing an order at this restaurant for the first time, the delivery was swift and efficient. The food arrived hot and fresh, offering a delightful experience. The delicious flavors of the meal exceeded expectations, making it a satisfying dining experience. As a result, the decision has been made to order from this establishment again.
The restaurant's efficiency and tasty food have left a positive impression. Thanks to the delicious meal and quick delivery, this restaurant has earned a returning customer. Its excellent quality and reliable service are reasons to keep ordering from this establishment. Overall, the dining experience was amazing, and thanks are extended for the satisfaction provided.
Upon placing an order at this restaurant for the first time, the delivery was swift and efficient. The food arrived hot and fresh, offering a delightful experience. The delicious flavors of the meal exceeded expectations, making it a satisfying dining experience. As a result, the decision has been made to order from this establishment again.
The restaurant's efficiency and tasty food have left a positive impression. Thanks to the delicious meal and quick delivery, this restaurant has earned a returning customer. Its excellent quality and reliable service are reasons to keep ordering from this establishment. Overall, the dining experience was amazing, and thanks are extended for the satisfaction provided.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Budget-Friendly Eats
5. Famous Original Ray's Pizza
Home of the famous New York slice.
__NEW TEXT__
This pizza spot is an ideal resting place for a quick bite. Despite the long line, the efficient system ensured a prompt service. The spacious dining area on the upper level, equipped with TVs, added to the convenience and overall experience. The pizza had a thin and crispy crust, which is reminiscent of the classic New York City-style pizza. It certainly met the expectations!
Though the pricing seemed a bit high for fast-food pizza slices, the convenience of the location, near Times Square, may have contributed to the cost. The absence of an itemized receipt left something to be desired. However, the hot temperatures outside and hunger for a speedy lunch made this pizza place an appealing option. Although seating inside was minimal, the lack of a crowd at around 3 pm and the air-conditioned environment provided comfortable seating.
This pizza spot is an ideal resting place for a quick bite. Despite the long line, the efficient system ensured a prompt service. The spacious dining area on the upper level, equipped with TVs, added to the convenience and overall experience. The pizza had a thin and crispy crust, which is reminiscent of the classic New York City-style pizza. It certainly met the expectations!
Though the pricing seemed a bit high for fast-food pizza slices, the convenience of the location, near Times Square, may have contributed to the cost. The absence of an itemized receipt left something to be desired. However, the hot temperatures outside and hunger for a speedy lunch made this pizza place an appealing option. Although seating inside was minimal, the lack of a crowd at around 3 pm and the air-conditioned environment provided comfortable seating.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
6. Patzeria Perfect Pizza
Best Pizza on Broadway!
__NEW TEXT__
This pizzeria is an excellent spot to grab a quick and delicious slice. Its convenient location near a popular hotel in midtown makes it a regular stop for many visitors. Despite often being crowded, the staff works efficiently to ensure that customers are served in a timely manner. The prices for bottled and canned drinks are reasonably priced, making it a great place to stop by for a drink as well.
The grandma slice at this pizzeria is particularly noteworthy. Its unique toppings and perfect texture make it a must-try for any pizza lover. The other slices on the menu are also delicious and well-worth trying. The quick service, great location, and of course, the tasty pizza, make this pizzeria a standout option for anyone looking for a quick bite in the Times Square area. It's best to take your pizza to go, as there is limited seating available.
This pizzeria is an excellent spot to grab a quick and delicious slice. Its convenient location near a popular hotel in midtown makes it a regular stop for many visitors. Despite often being crowded, the staff works efficiently to ensure that customers are served in a timely manner. The prices for bottled and canned drinks are reasonably priced, making it a great place to stop by for a drink as well.
The grandma slice at this pizzeria is particularly noteworthy. Its unique toppings and perfect texture make it a must-try for any pizza lover. The other slices on the menu are also delicious and well-worth trying. The quick service, great location, and of course, the tasty pizza, make this pizzeria a standout option for anyone looking for a quick bite in the Times Square area. It's best to take your pizza to go, as there is limited seating available.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Celebrations
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
7. Famous Famiglia Pizza
Perfect pizza near Times Square.
__NEW TEXT__
Famous Famiglia Pizza, situated near Times Square in NYC, is a fantastic choice for pizza lovers. This family-owned business prides itself on providing excellent customer service, and it shows in the warm and inviting atmosphere. The pizza here features a thin crispy crust, generous amounts of flavorful sauce, and an abundance of cheese, all baked to perfection.
Compared to other popular pizza places, such as Joe's Pizza, Famous Famiglia Pizza stands out for its shorter queues and consistent food quality. In addition to their delicious pizza, customers rave about their Stromboli, which is a definite must-try. With a friendly and courteous staff, Famous Famiglia Pizza offers a cozy and welcoming experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
Famous Famiglia Pizza, situated near Times Square in NYC, is a fantastic choice for pizza lovers. This family-owned business prides itself on providing excellent customer service, and it shows in the warm and inviting atmosphere. The pizza here features a thin crispy crust, generous amounts of flavorful sauce, and an abundance of cheese, all baked to perfection.
Compared to other popular pizza places, such as Joe's Pizza, Famous Famiglia Pizza stands out for its shorter queues and consistent food quality. In addition to their delicious pizza, customers rave about their Stromboli, which is a definite must-try. With a friendly and courteous staff, Famous Famiglia Pizza offers a cozy and welcoming experience that keeps customers coming back for more.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
8. Don Antonio
Best Neapolitan pizza in Midtown Manhattan, Guy Fieri approved!
__NEW TEXT__
Pizza has been widely praised for its delicious taste and high-quality ingredients. The crust, in particular, has been singled out for its thinness and light, chewy texture. Although some reviewers have noted issues with the cooking technique, the pizza has received predominantly positive feedback.
The pizza on offer comes in a range of styles, including the traditional Neapolitan and the lesser-known Montanarra. While some pizzas boast a crispy crust, others have a more chewy or even floppy texture. Regardless of these differences, the pizza has been consistently well-received by critics and customers alike.
Pizza has been widely praised for its delicious taste and high-quality ingredients. The crust, in particular, has been singled out for its thinness and light, chewy texture. Although some reviewers have noted issues with the cooking technique, the pizza has received predominantly positive feedback.
The pizza on offer comes in a range of styles, including the traditional Neapolitan and the lesser-known Montanarra. While some pizzas boast a crispy crust, others have a more chewy or even floppy texture. Regardless of these differences, the pizza has been consistently well-received by critics and customers alike.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
9. Paul's on Times Square
Authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Times Square.
__NEW TEXT__
The pizza at Paul's on Times Square is exceptional and not to be missed. The service is commendable, with staff who are not only quick but also friendly, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. This is the perfect spot for a casual dinner, where one can enjoy excellent food in a relaxed and comfortable setting.
Paul's is a great dining destination, with a particularly impressive penne vodka al salmone. The menu offers a variety of options, from pizzas and bruschettas to start, to decadent desserts like tartufo and chocolate mousse cake. Each dish is carefully crafted, making for a truly satisfying meal. The staff's helpfulness and kindness only add to the overall positive experience. Whether looking for a casual night out or a celebratory meal, Paul's is an excellent choice.
The pizza at Paul's on Times Square is exceptional and not to be missed. The service is commendable, with staff who are not only quick but also friendly, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. This is the perfect spot for a casual dinner, where one can enjoy excellent food in a relaxed and comfortable setting.
Paul's is a great dining destination, with a particularly impressive penne vodka al salmone. The menu offers a variety of options, from pizzas and bruschettas to start, to decadent desserts like tartufo and chocolate mousse cake. Each dish is carefully crafted, making for a truly satisfying meal. The staff's helpfulness and kindness only add to the overall positive experience. Whether looking for a casual night out or a celebratory meal, Paul's is an excellent choice.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
10. Radio City Pizza
Delicious pizza in the heart of NYC.
__NEW TEXT__
A pizza place offering great options for both pizza and Stromboli was discovered by individuals during their sightseeing tour. After a tiring day of walking, they opted to take their food to their hotel for a more relaxed dining experience. Both the pepperoni and margherita pizzas received high praise, but the Stromboli, packed with various delicious ingredients, turned out to be the star of the meal. The employees were noted for their exceptional friendliness, making the experience even more enjoyable.
For those who love New York-style pizza, this establishment offers an excellent choice while visiting the city. After a walking tour, and before a Broadway show, patrons decided to try the pizza here and were thoroughly impressed. The slice with garlic was mistakenly ordered instead of parmesan, but the staff kindly replaced it without any fuss. With such great food and impeccable customer service, this place has earned a repeat visit from the enthusiastic customers.
A pizza place offering great options for both pizza and Stromboli was discovered by individuals during their sightseeing tour. After a tiring day of walking, they opted to take their food to their hotel for a more relaxed dining experience. Both the pepperoni and margherita pizzas received high praise, but the Stromboli, packed with various delicious ingredients, turned out to be the star of the meal. The employees were noted for their exceptional friendliness, making the experience even more enjoyable.
For those who love New York-style pizza, this establishment offers an excellent choice while visiting the city. After a walking tour, and before a Broadway show, patrons decided to try the pizza here and were thoroughly impressed. The slice with garlic was mistakenly ordered instead of parmesan, but the staff kindly replaced it without any fuss. With such great food and impeccable customer service, this place has earned a repeat visit from the enthusiastic customers.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Budget-Friendly Eats
- Vegetarian Options
11. Bryant Park Pizza
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots