Top 11 pumpkin desserts in Midtown NYC
In the heart of New York City, Midtown to be exact, pumpkin desserts are a popular fall treat. From traditional pumpkin pie to innovative twists like pumpkin spice macarons and pumpkin cheesecake, there's no shortage of delicious pumpkin desserts in Midtown NYC. Indulge in the seasonal flavor and enjoy the cozy atmosphere of the city during this festive time of year.
- 1. Buttercup BakeShop
- 2. Buttercup Bake Shop in Midtown
- 3. NY Bakery and Desserts
- 4. Little Pie Company in Midtown
- 5. Milk Bar
- 6. Patisserie Chanson
- 7. Kaylee's Creamery
- 8. Eclair bakery
- 9. Popbar -Delivery Kitchen- @ Jay Suites
- 10. Kreuther Handcrafted Chocolate (at Gabriel Kreuther restaurant)
- 11. New York Sweet Tooth
1. Buttercup BakeShop
Perfect spot for seasonal pumpkin treats

The Pumpkin Pie streusel crumb bar is a delightful treat that combines the classic flavors of pumpkin pie with a crumbly, sweet topping. The smooth pumpkin filling is rich and perfectly spiced, while the cinnamon streusel topping adds a satisfying crunch. The shortbread crust provides a sturdy base that holds the filling and topping together.
This dessert is a must-try for pumpkin pie lovers and those who appreciate a delicious, textured pastry. The Pumpkin Pie streusel crumb bar would make an excellent addition to any holiday spread, or as a satisfying snack anytime of the year. The combination of flavors and textures is sure to impress, making this dessert a standout option for any occasion. Overall, the Pumpkin Pie streusel crumb bar is a highly recommended treat for anyone with a sweet tooth.
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
2. Buttercup Bake Shop in Midtown
New York's premier destination for buttercream cupcakes and pumpkin desserts.

The pumpkin pie ordered for Thanksgiving was a resounding success among all who tasted it. Its delectable flavor and impeccable balance of spices made it a standout dish. The crust, with just the right amount of flakiness, provided a satisfying texture to every bite. Due to its popularity, it's an easy decision to order it again for future gatherings.
If you're in search of a phenomenal pumpkin pie, look no further. This particular pie boasts a divine blend of spices and a perfectly baked crust that is neither too thick nor too thin. The balance between the filling and crust is expertly executed, making each bite a true delight. Without a doubt, ordering this pie again is a must.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
- Hidden Gems
3. NY Bakery and Desserts
Perfect spot for seasonal pumpkin treats

The pumpkin cheesecake offered by this establishment is nothing short of exceptional. Its velvety texture, coupled with the ideal blend of spices, creates a symphony of flavors that is sure to delight the palate. This dessert is a standout choice for those who adore pumpkin and are in search of a truly memorable culinary experience.
Similarly, the pumpkin muffins on offer are a triumph of baked goods. Their moist interior and well-balanced sweetness make them a pleasure to consume. Any pumpkin enthusiast would be remiss not to give them a try. These muffins expertly showcase the versatility and appeal of this classic autumn ingredient.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Downtown Spots
- Dinner
Relate link
4. Little Pie Company in Midtown
Perfect spot for seasonal pumpkin treats

For those who enjoy pumpkin desserts, the offering in question is a standout. The pie's rich flavor is a testament to the high-quality ingredients used, while its smooth texture indicates a thoughtful and skilled preparation process. This pumpkin pie is sure to delight anyone who tries it, from the most devoted pumpkin pie enthusiast to the occasional dessert lover.
During the fall season, when pumpkin-flavored items are in high demand, this pumpkin pie is a must-try. Its exceptional taste and texture make it a top choice for those looking to indulge in the flavors of the season. This pumpkin pie is sure to become a customer favorite, as it has already captured the hearts and palates of those who have had the pleasure of trying it.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Mid-Range
- Downtown Spots
Relate link
5. Milk Bar
Innovative and indulgent desserts

For those who adore the taste of pumpkin, the pumpkin pie is a standout. It boasts a wonderful balance of spices, neither overpowering nor lacking, resulting in a delightful harmony of flavors. The level of sweetness is just right, allowing the natural taste of pumpkin to shine through. This delectable pie is certain to captivate the palates of pumpkin enthusiasts.
The pumpkin cheesecake is an extraordinary dessert that is sure to impress. Its creamy and rich texture is a testament to the skill of the chef. The pumpkin flavor is robust, yet not overpowering. This outstanding dessert is a must-try and is sure to be a crowd-pleaser. Impressive in both taste and presentation, it is highly recommended.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Cheap Eats
Relate link
6. Patisserie Chanson
Perfect spot for pumpkin dessert lovers

During the autumn months, the pumpkin pie offered is a standout dessert. Its carefully crafted balance of sweetness and spice, combined with a flaky, tender crust, creates a delightful eating experience. The quality of the ingredients is evident in each bite, making this pie a highly recommended choice for anyone seeking a traditional fall treat.
The pumpkin tart is another excellent option for those looking to indulge in the flavors of the season. The tart crust complements the smooth, velvety pumpkin filling for a harmonious combination of textures. The presentation of the tart is beautiful, with a consistent golden-brown color and an elegant appearance. Overall, the pumpkin tart is an exceptional dessert choice that allows the natural taste of the pumpkin to shine through.
TOPICS
- Social Gatherings
- Italian Cuisine
Relate link
7. Kaylee's Creamery
Small batch artisanal ice cream with unique flavors

Pumpkin pie ice cream is a highly recommended dessert for anyone who enjoys the classic autumn pie. The balanced blend of spices, including cinnamon and nutmeg, create a taste that is incredibly similar to actual pumpkin pie. The ice cream provides a cool and refreshing twist on the traditional dessert, while still delivering the same flavors that people love.
In addition to the pumpkin pie ice cream, the pumpkin cheesecake ice cream is also a standout seasonal option. The creamy texture and rich flavor of cheesecake are present throughout the ice cream, while the pumpkin adds a slight sweetness that enhances the overall taste. Whether you are a fan of pumpkin pie or cheesecake, these ice cream options are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. With their impressive attention to detail and commitment to delivering high-quality flavors, this brand is a top choice for anyone looking to indulge in a delicious pumpkin dessert.
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Vegetarian Options
- Happy Hours
8. Eclair bakery
Perfect spot for pumpkin dessert lovers!

The pumpkin dessert offered at this establishment is a true treat for the taste buds. It features a harmonious blend of flavors that are accurately pumpkin-like, without being overly saccharine. This allows the natural taste of the pumpkin to shine through, making for a delightful and satisfying dessert experience.
Among the various offerings, the pumpkin danish is a particularly noteworthy choice. It boasts a perfect balance of spices that complement the pumpkin flavor beautifully. Furthermore, the pastry itself is exceptionally flaky, adding a satisfying crunch to every bite. Whether you're a pumpkin purist or simply a fan of delicious baked goods, the pumpkin danish is sure to impress.
TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Gluten-Free
- Cheap Eats
- Downtown Spots
9. Popbar -Delivery Kitchen- @ Jay Suites
Perfect spot for seasonal pumpkin treats

Popbar is renowned for its innovative and delightful seasonal flavors, with pumpkin desserts being a standout favorite during the fall. The establishment is dedicated to creating treats that not only satisfy one's sweet tooth but also cater to health-conscious individuals.
The pumpkin dessert options at Popbar are plentiful, and they are all made with high-quality ingredients that are both delicious and beneficial for your health. From popsicles to gelato, customers can indulge in a satisfying pumpkin treat without any guilt. With its commitment to providing tasty and nutritious options, Popbar has become a go-to destination for those looking for a healthier dessert alternative.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
- Mid-Range
Relate link
10. Kreuther Handcrafted Chocolate (at Gabriel Kreuther restaurant)
A taste of New York's finest chocolates

Pumpkin desserts at Kreuther Handcrafted Chocolate are an extraordinary culinary experience. The establishment's expert chefs have managed to create a dessert that perfectly encapsulates the flavor and texture of pumpkin in a delightful way. This is a perfect option for anyone seeking a delectable seasonal treat.
The dessert features a velvety smooth texture that melts in your mouth and a rich pumpkin flavor that is neither too sweet nor too savory. With every bite, one can taste the quality of the ingredients and the skill of the chefs who prepared it. This combined with the overall ambiance of the establishment makes for a memorable and enjoyable experience.
TOPICS
- Personal Celebrations
- Mediterranean Cuisine
- High-End
- Dinner
11. New York Sweet Tooth

TOPICS
- Italian Cuisine
- Vegetarian Options
Relate link