Top 10 ice cream shops in Williamsburg NYC
Ice cream shops in Williamsburg, NYC, offer a delightful treat for both locals and tourists. From classic flavors to innovative creations, these shops provide a wide range of options for ice cream lovers. With a vibrant and creative atmosphere, visiting ice cream shops in Williamsburg, NYC, is a must-try experience for anyone exploring the area.
1. Van Leeuwen Ice Cream
Good ice cream that makes you feel good

This ice cream shop in Nolita is a delightful spot for a midday treat or after-dinner dessert, serving up a variety of flavors that are sure to satisfy anyone's sweet tooth. The shop boasts a cozy and clean corner space that is well-maintained, providing a pleasant atmosphere for customers. In addition to their regular flavors, they offer gluten-free and lactose-free options, making it accessible for all to enjoy.
However, the exceptional quality of their ice cream comes at a premium price. The knowledgeable and efficient staff make up for it by providing great service and recommendations on flavor pairings. A hot espresso is a popular choice to balance out the sweetness of the ice cream. Overall, this charming ice cream shop is worth the visit, whether you're looking for a unique flavor or a classic favorite.
2. Gelateria Gentile - Williamsburg
Traditional Italian gelato since 1880

Upon exploring Williamsburg's Bedford Avenue, a building with an 'ARTISAN MALL' sign and flags caught my eye. Inside, I found a typical industrial space housing various stores. My attention was immediately drawn to ANTICA Gelateria Gentile, a quaint storefront with two kind and friendly staff members serving up the best Italian gelato I've had in New York. Every item they offer is homemade and crafted with the finest ingredients imported from Italy, providing an authentic experience.
The gelato is of exceptional quality, and the long line moving quickly showcases the efficient service. Despite the wait, it is well worth it for this heavenly treat. Newcomers and returning customers alike are warmly greeted by the friendly staff, who offer quick samples to help customers make their decision. Served in their homemade Cialda, the Cioccolato Fondente and Pistacchio gelato are must-tries at this establishment. Overall, ANTICA Gelateria Gentile is not to be missed for any gelato lover.
3. Sprinkles Ice Cream - Sprinkles Confections Williamsburg
Family-owned, artisanal ice cream since 2005.

Sprinkles Ice Cream, located in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, is a popular destination for ice cream lovers. This charming establishment, known for its delicious and creative flavors, has earned an impressive 4.5 (out of 5) rating based on 63 recent reviews, with customers praising both the taste and quality of their offerings.
Aside from their exceptional ice cream, Sprinkles also provides a variety of other menu items, including personal pizzas, sushi platters, and soft sorbets, ensuring that there's something for everyone to enjoy. Whether visiting for lunch or a sweet treat, customers have come to appreciate their inviting atmosphere, affordable pricing, and friendly service. With a 4.7 rating from Google, 5 stars from Facebook and Tripadvisor, Sprinkles Ice Cream is a must-visit destination for anyone in the Brooklyn area.
4. OddFellows Ice Cream Co. Domino Park in Williamsburg
Wacky and weird flavors reimagined classics

OddFellows Ice Cream Co. has a way of converting even the most skeptical individuals into ice cream enthusiasts. Their strawberry flavor is particularly impressive, offering an intense and natural taste that is worth the visit alone. The quality of their ice cream is top-notch, making it a popular destination for those seeking a delicious dessert.
If you're looking for an ice cream shop with unique and flavorful options, OddFellows is the place to go. During a recent visit, we tried the razzle berry, passion fruit apricot pistachio, and banoff pie flavors. Each one had a distinct character and was not overly sweet. The person working at the counter was also friendly and helpful, adding to the overall positive experience. Whether you're an ice cream aficionado or just looking to satisfy your sweet tooth, OddFellows is definitely worth checking out.
5. Milk Bar
Home of the famous Compost Cookie® and Cereal Milk™

The dessert selection, including the soft serve with cereal, has received mixed reviews. Those who enjoy soft serve ice cream found the taste to be quite pleasant, with a smooth and creamy texture. The cereal topping added a satisfying crunch and sweetness that complemented the ice cream well. However, some individuals were not as impressed and compared the taste to frozen milk.
Regrettably, there have been a few negative interactions with employees that have detracted from the overall experience. A small number of reviewers have reported feeling unattended to or rushed while placing their orders. Despite these isolated incidents, the majority of customers have not reported any issues, and the establishment has maintained a positive reputation for its delectable offerings. It is always recommended to report any negative experiences to management so that they can take appropriate action to address and improve their customer service.
6. Uncle Louie G
Classic flavors with a modern twist, since 1956

The lemon icee was an ideal blend of sweet and tangy flavors. The ice had a smooth and creamy texture, making it a delightful treat. The server who provided assistance with the order was friendly and generous, not only with her service but also with recommendations for other menu items.
This lemon icee was a perfect refreshment, offering a balanced taste of sugar and sourness. Its smooth and velvety ice was reminiscent of a soft-serve ice cream. The staff member who helped us was kind and attentive, adding to the overall positive experience. She provided us with helpful suggestions for other delectable options, which was an added bonus.
7. Davey's Ice Cream in Williamsburg
Delicious homemade ice cream with unique flavors.

The "Strong Coffee" flavor at Davey's Ice Cream is a standout option. This ice cream is crafted using Birch Coffee beans, resulting in a deep and intense coffee taste that is sure to satisfy any caffeine lover. The rich and creamy texture of the ice cream only enhances the strong coffee flavor, making for a truly indulgent treat.
In addition to its delicious taste, the "Strong Coffee" ice cream is also visually appealing. Served in a generous scoop, the ice cream features a lovely dark brown color that is reminiscent of a freshly brewed cup of coffee. Overall, the "Strong Coffee" flavor is a must-try for anyone looking to satisfy their coffee and ice cream cravings in one delicious scoop.
TOPICS
- American Cuisine
- Social Gatherings
- Vegetarian Options
- Lunch
8. Tipsy Scoop
Liquor-infused ice cream for a unique treat.

A delightful and indulgent experience awaits at this establishment, where the dessert menu offers a fun twist on traditional favorites. By infusing their desserts with various liquors, they have created a unique and enjoyable offering for those looking to combine their love of alcohol and sweets. The infused treats are a great choice for any occasion, whether it be a night out with friends or a special celebration.
TOPICS
- Vegetarian Options
- Vegan Options
- Social Gatherings
- Happy Hours
9. Thick

Layer cake lovers, rejoice. This Central Park West restaurant from revered chef Jean-Georges Vongerichten has all that and more: four-layer carrot cake with cream cheese frosting, devil's food cake with layers of dark chocolate pudding, cream ice cream, and butterscotch pudding.
10. Dew Point Creamery
